32 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2013
    1. Gregory, Samuel

      Samuel Gregory was born in 1813 in Vermont. He graduated from medical school at Yale. He believed that it was only proper for women to be midwives. In 1848, he founded the Boston Female Medical College with Dr. Israel Talbot to produce qualified female doctors. He died in 1872.

      http://www.findagrave.com/cgi-bin/fg.cgi?page=gr&GRid=18891300

    2. Several observing moralists have remarked that the practice of employing men-midwives has increased the corruption among married women.

      While Ewell notes this observation by moralists, he does not acknowledge that the nature of a moralist is to focus on immorality, such as adultery, in society. The moralists attribute the immorality to the married women, not the doctors because social beliefs dictated that women were the weaker vessels and were not in control of themselves.

    3. female practitioners are often so ignorant---not having the opportunity or means to qualify themselves for attendance on ladies.

      Ewell attributes midwives' lack of experience to increased male domination in the field, not a lack of formal training in obstetrics.

    4. seek the employments of the vicious

      Ewell means that women without respectable jobs like midwifery to support themselves would turn to socially unacceptable professions like prostitution.

    5. several offices properly belonging to the weaker sex

      While women were considered to be be weaker in every way to men, men reserved midwifery as a woman's job because they were afraid of adultery by the male physicians, although men supposedly had better control over themselves.

    6. while the human species is the only one tormented by jealousy

      Ewell again acknowledges men's insecurity over a male physician touching their wives during childbirth and the lust midwifery could raise in the physicians.

    7. as a means of sacrificing delicacy, and consequently virtue; and as a robbery of many good women of their proper employment and support.

      Thomas Ewell recognized the insecurities of men at having their wives handled in such intimate ways during childbirth. He believes that a way to avoid possible social conflicts between men, their wives, and physicians is to encourage women to dominate the field of midwifery. Midwifery is also an important source of income for women.

    8. the testimony of some of the greatest physicians has been, and will continue to be presented---testimony which cannot be overthrown by argument, or invalidated by any counter evidence of physicians.

      In his pamphlet on man-midwifery, Samuel Gregory relies exclusively on testimonies by famous physicians. The information he presents does not include accounts by midwives or the women who were treated by the physicians. Gregory also excludes the testimonies of numerous other physicians who were not considered to be at the top of the medical social circles. While Gregory claims that no arguments or counter evidence will invalidate the claims of the "greatest physicians," realistically, there are other schools of thought on man-midwifery that were practiced.

    9. Count Buffon

      Georges-Louis Leclerc, count de Buffon lived from 1707 to 1788. He was a French naturalist who was well known for his studies in botany, geology, natural history, and anthropology.

      http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/83673/Georges-Louis-Leclerc-count-de-Buffon

    10. cuckoldom

      Definition: "The state of being a cuckold." (A cuckold is man whose wife commits adultery)

      http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/cuckold

    11. THOMAS EWELL, M.D.,

      Thomas Ewell was born in Prince William County, Virginia in 1785. He studied with Dr. George Graham, Dr. John Weems, and Dr. Benjamin Rush. Ewell received his degree from the University of Pennsylvania. After service in the Navy, he published numerous works including "Ewell's Family Medicine" and the first American chemistry text for the layman. He also became involved with the manufacturing of gunpowder and the Anacostia Bridge Company. He died in 1826.

      http://www.geni.com/people/Thomas-Ewell/6000000012251529415

    1. to lay aside all childish Baashfulness and imaginary Modesty, in order to secure their Own and their Chldrens Safety, by inviting the Assistance of both SEXES.

      Maubray draws attention to the unwillingness of the British to allow man-midwifery by lauding women from Continental Europe's acceptance of help from midwives of both genders. He believes that the European women's temporary rejection of decorum during childbirth allows them to have the best medical assistance available for themselves and their children. He implies that British society would be better off as a whole if the women accepted skilled and knowledgeable man-midwives.

    2. And indeed MEN (whom I may justly call the truest and best Boethogynists) being better versed in Anatomy, better acquainted with Physical Helps, and commonly endued with greater Presence of Mind, have been always found readier or discreeter, to devise something more new, and to give quicker Relief in Cases of difficult or preternatural BIRTHS, than common MIDWIVES generally understand

      Maubray invests in the period social beliefs of female inferiority to justify men-midwifery. He claims that men should become midwives because they have more physical and mental capabilities than women. He also references the lack of formal training among female midwives. However, he does not advocate for their education because he believes that men are superior, regardless of schooling.

    3. Boethogynists

      Male midwife

    1. What can be more conducive to the common Good, or more serviceable to any Country, than the Preservation of the Health and Lives of its multiplying WOMEN and CHILDREN?

      Maubray justifies his interests in midwifery through the belief that women's most important role in society is to increase the population.

    2. not at all by butcherly Instruments

      Maubray was part of a movement that did not believe in the use of instruments in childbirth.

      http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15257350

    3. ANTIENTS
    4. Moles

      Hydatidiform moles are a form of gestational trophoblastic disease that originate in the placenta and are a more prominent cause for elective pregnancy terminations.

      http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/254657-overview#showall

    5. false Conceptions

      An abnormal conception when a mole or fleshy mass grows in the uterus instead of a normal, organized fetus.

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superfetation

    6. Superfoetations

      Also known as superfetation. When two fetuses are conceived at different times and develop simultaneously in the uterus. This is a rare occurrence in humans, although some sets of twins that show different stages of development are thought to have been conceived at separate times.

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superfetation

    1. BIRTH, and whatever may depend of, take Rife from, or have any antecedent, concomitant, or consequent Relation to it, is the only proper Business of MIDWIFERY

      Maubray establishes a definition and a limit to the practices of midwifery, an important move for a man-midwife because midwifery was commonly a woman's job. Man-midwifes were sometimes looked upon with suspicion because social norms relegated to position to less-threatening women.

    2. rectifies and cures the other, in most (if not in all) Cases.

      Maubray believes that midwifery can cure barrenness.

    3. Maubray, John

      John Maubray was a Scottish physician who lived from 1700 to 1732. He was a leading man-midwife in Georgian London. Unusual for the time, Maubray emphasized the importance of physical examinations, theory, and practical experience in the instruction of midwifery.

      http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/15257350

    1. it leaves a mental depreciation, an easiness of soul, which shows itself in the jovial conversations among some of the merry members of the profession, in the subsequent interviews between practitioner and patient

      Gregory attributes doctor's light conversation regarding childbirth to immorality, not a shared experience. He also condemns later conversations between women and their doctors when many women most likely had similar followup sessions with their midwives, especially when there were complications.

    2. One, in this city, said he disapproved of it, and should be glad to get out of it, but he was actually 'pressed into the service, by families in which he attended.'

      Gregory unwittingly provides evidence that a number of families trust this doctor over the local midwives, reflecting that there are clients with a counterargument against Gregory, Ewell and their like-minded colleagues.

    1. The idea of it has driven some to convulsions and derangement; and every one of the least delicacy feels deeply humiliated at the exposure. Many of them, while in labor, have been so shocked by the entrance of a man into their apartment, as to have all their pains banished. Others, to the very last of their senses suffering the severest torments, have rejected the assistance of men.

      The women were indoctrinated into the social standards of privacy and propriety, which dictated that they should have a midwife instead of a doctor. Documents by women regarding their views of the privacy of a midwife versus the additional skill and knowledge of a doctor would provide stronger evidence about how women actually felt about man-midwifes.

    2. On no account submit to the interference of men in common labor; do it most readily in the uncommon cases, when a midwife under the direction of a physician cannot afford relief. I will venture to add, that there is not a physician, disinterested, of sound sense, who would not approve of the rule. The best authors on midwifery decidedly recommend it.

      While the most noted authors on midwifery believe that a physician should only attend a complicated birth, it would be difficult for the authors to deny that some of the complications have arisen from midwives lacking the knowledge and skill of physicians.

    3. In one case in my neighborhood, the husband sent for his physician to his wife in labor, yet was so strongly excited at the idea of her exposure, that he very solemnly declared to the doctor, that if he touched his wife, or looked at her, he would demolish him! No man possessed of a correct and delicate regard for his wife, would subject her to any exposure to a doctor, that could be avoided without danger.

      Ewell provides contradictory reasons for not hiring a man-midwife. His anecdote explains men's jealousy and insecurity at having another man touch his wife. However, Ewell then attributes men's unwillingness to hire a doctor to sheer concern for their wive's well being, not their fear of adultery.

    4. I was well assured that a physician in Charleston, infuriated with the sight of the woman he had just delivered, leaped into her bed before she was restored to a state of nature. The melancholy tale of the seduction of the wife of a member of congress from Carolina, by her accoucheur, is a warning that ought not to be disregarded. The beautiful organization of the lady preyed upon his mind for years; he sought her from one to the other extremity of the country, regardless of all dangers; and on acquiring his game received a premature death---leaving horror and ruin in the family he had been hired to serve.

      Ewell provides only one account of lust by a physician. More evidence is required to draw conclusions about the frequency of adultery between physicians and the women whose children they deliver.

    5. 'It is very certain, where these exposures have been most numerous, as in large cities, here adultery has been most frequent

      Ewell attributes adultery in cities to man-midwifery instead of other factors, such as lack of marital satisfaction coupled with easy access to other partners, unlike rural communities.

    6. In the submission of women to the unnecessary examinations of physicians, exposing the secrets of nature, it is forgotten that every indecency of this kind is a violent attack against chastity; that every situation which causes an internal blush is a real prostitution.

      Because of the social standards for modesty, Count Buffon believes that even a physician's examination of a woman is a rape of her privacy.

    7. accoucheur