75 Matching Annotations
  1. Dec 2016
  2. codkashacabka.files.wordpress.com codkashacabka.files.wordpress.com
    Myles_Horton_Paulo_Freire_We_Make_the_Road_Chapter_4.pdf
    73
    1. Start with what they know. Build with what they have. But the best of leaders when the job is done, when the task is accomplished, the people will all say we have done it ourselves.
      #hortonfreire
    2. It's necessary to laugh with the people because if we don't do that, we cannot learn from the people, and in not learning from the people we cannot teach them.
      #hortonfreire
    3. I remember that my mother used to say to me, after the death of my father, that my father always said to her, "This boy will become a subversive." He didn't say revolutionary. He used to say subversive. I liked it.
      #hortonfreire
    4. I learned when I was a child that a loving space is indispensable for development of the children.
      #hortonfreire
    5. The more we get this kind of alive love among parents, the more it's possible to help kids to grow up in good shape.
      #hortonfreire
    6. I'm much better at working out ideas in action than I am in theorizing about it and then transferring my

      thinking to action.

      #hortonfreire
    7. Those who refuse to share their knowledge with other people are making a great mistake, because we need it all.
      #hortonfreire
    8. being a pro­gressive on one hand does not mean to be naive, but to make some decisions and then to risk the preservation of the revolution. On the other hand, being a progres­sive means to deepen the connection with the masses of people, means to respect the beliefs of the people, means to consult the people, means to start from the letters and words with which the people are starting the process of education.
      #hortonfreire
    9. Then, through this kind of very strong serious work, through a work that is at the same time tender and heavy and serious and rigorous, we need to shape, to reshape, to form permanently the teachers without manipulating them.
      #hortonfreire
    10. But understanding formation not as some­thing that we do in some weekends or some semesters, but formation as a permanent process, and formation as being an exercise, a critical understanding of what we do.
      #hortonfreire
    11. I don't like the word training in English. Maybe it's a prejudice of mine, but I prefer formation, formation in French and foT1Tta(iio in Portuguese.
      #hortonfreire
    12. We must be free; we must be free to believe in freedom. Do you see this paradox? Without freedom it's difficult to understand freedom. On the other hand, we fight for freedom to the extent that we don't have freedom, but in fighting for freedom we discover how freedom is beautiful and difficult to be created, but we have to believe that it's possible.
      #hortonfreire
    13. We are afraid of risking. And it's impossible, just impossible, to create without risk­ing. It's absolutely impossible, but it takes time to begin to risk
      #hortonfreire
    14. When I talked with the presi­dent, he used to say to me, "Paulo, it's not easy to put into practice the things we think about." Yes, it is not easy, but it's not impossible. This is my conviction.
      #hortonfreire
    15. There are many ghosts in society fighting against the dream of a much more open society
      #hortonfreire
    16. if we could do something over­night, it's not worth doing because if it's that simple and that easy, it'll take care of itself.
      #hortonfreire
    17. the deepened transformation in society never arrived on a second Monday morning. Never. No, the radical transformation of society is a process, really, and it comes like this.
      #hortonfreire
    18. It means to be patient, or the words I prefer, to be impatiently patient, in the process of struggling to change.
      #hortonfreire
    19. It is a center that wants to be a theoretical context inside of which the workers can make a critical reflection about what they do outside of the theoretical context.
      #hortonfreire
    20. The people in Nicara­gua are helping us in Brazil, are helping us as Latin Americans, and are helping you to the extent that you are also helping them. This is kind of a struggle here; on the one hand, you gave support to Nicaragua. On the other hand, you made an impression in the space inside of the country, do you see, and this is history.
      #hortonfreire
    21. Trying to co-opt is a kind of a struggle on behalf of those who have power to do so. It's a tac­tic; it's a moment of the struggle.
      #hortonfreire
    22. Does success mean that we're no longer subver­sive enough?
      #hortonfreire
    23. So the phrase I've always used when I talk is, "You have to bootleg education." You have to find a way to bootleg it. It's illegal, really, because it's not proper, but you do it any­way.
      #hortonfreire
    24. We have more space outside the system, but we also can create the space in­side of the subsystem or the schooling system in order to occupy the space. That is, I think politically, every time we can occupy some position inside of the subsystem, we should do so.
      #hortonfreire
    25. if you worked outside the system, you couldn't influence the system. The argument was that you could change the system. We concluded that reform within the sys­tem reinforced the system, or was co-opted by the system. Reformers didn't change the system, they made it more palatable and justified it, made it more humane, more intelligent
      #hortonfreire
    26. the dialecticity between patience and impatience.

      A secondary source with more info on this.

      <script src="&lt;a href=" https:="" <a="" href="http://hackpad.com" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">hackpad.com="" hPVh1arzwDa.js?format="html"" target="_blank" rel="nofollow noopener">https://hackpad.com/hPVh1arzwDa.js?format=html"></script><noscript>

      <div>View Reading Paulo Freire: His Life and Work on Hackpad.</div></noscript>

      #hortonfreire action plan
    27. My system is to make him thirsty, so he'll volunteer to drink.
      #hortonfreire
    28. the delicate relationship between teaching, giving knowl­edge, and learning knowledge
      #hortonfreire
    29. I think it's my responsi­bility to share what I believe in, not only in discussions but in the way I live and in the way the workshops run and in the way Highlander's run, the way life is.
      #hortonfreire
    30. The central meeting room at Highlander is circular in shape. Rock­ing chairs, a fireplace, and a spectacular view of the Smoky Mountains provide a comfortable atmosphere for workshops.
      #hortonfreire
    31. Starting from people's experiences, and not from our understanding of the world, does not mean that we don't want the people to come with us in order to go beyond us afterward
      #hortonfreire
    32. the quality of becoming more and more open to feel the feelings of others, to become so sensitive that we can guess what the group or one person is thinking at that moment.
      #hortonfreire
    33. they come absolutely convinced that the teacher has to give a class to them
      #hortonfreire
    34. You set the stage for doing something that they're uncomfortable with. You know they're uncomfortable with it, and you have to work through that business of getting them to be comfortable with trusting them­selves a little bit, trusting their peers a little bit
      #hortonfreire
    35. then they begin to see that you aren't going to play the role of an expert, except in the sense that you are the expert in how they're going to learn, not in what they're going to learn.
      #hortonfreire
    36. close enough to their expectation
      #hortonfreire
    37. You do have to make concessions like that
      #hortonfreire
    38. The more people partici­pate in the process of their own education, the more the people participate in the process of defining what kind of production to produce, and for what and why, the more the people participate in the development of their selves.
      #hortonfreire
    39. That was what they wanted. Now what we wanted in addition to that was to help them understand that they should work with a larger community. They should work with farmers, they should deal with integration, they should be part of the world. We had our own agenda.
      #hortonfreire
    40. They had to learn to think, make decisions-not learn gimmicks, not learn techniques, but learn how to think.
      #hortonfreire
    41. You've gotta have a structure that participants can feel comfortable with until they begin to have something to deviate from or add to
      #hortonfreire
    42. So we turned it all over to them, and they were in complete control. I mean they exercised that control.
      #hortonfreire
    43. of everyone united to get a grievance settled.
      #hortonfreire
    44. No matter where this kind of educator works, the great difficulty­or the great adventure!-is how to make education something which, in being serious, rigorous, methodi­cal, and having a process, also creates happiness and joy.
      #hortonfreire
    45. This transforms the practice of education into a kind of entertainment.
      #hortonfreire
    46. it's impossible for me in this kind of education to teach how to think unless. we are teaching something, some content to the students.
      #hortonfreire
    47. What Myles did was to touch their memory about a subject and to remake the road. I think that it's really impossible to teach how to think more critically by just making a speech about criti­cal thought
      #hortonfreire
    48. I mean what I'm doing with the mind is the same as nature does with the body. It's no different. I think you should stretch people to their limits and our limits
      #hortonfreire
    49. Money has to come from the system, and people that we identify with produce that wealth.
      #hortonfreire
    50. If I believe in social equality and don't practice it, then what I say is hollow. You have to have that kind of consis­tency.
      #hortonfreire
    51. You have to tie the practical with the visionary.
      #hortonfreire
    52. next is respect for people's abilities to learn and to act and to shape their own lives.
      #hortonfreire
    53. The third thing grows out of caring for people and having respect for people's ability to do things, and that is that you value their experiences.
      #hortonfreire
    54. Highlander can't be described as an organization because it isn't departmen­talized and mechanistically conceived. It's more of an organism, therefore it's hard to describe. It's a mosaic or a piece of weaving.
      #hortonfreire
    55. Highlander is a kind of a weaving of many colors, some blend and some clash, but you know it's alive.
      #hortonfreire
    56. Movements change what goes on and how things are organized.
      #hortonfreire
    57. We were part of the world but we had to start locally.
      #hortonfreire
    58. Authority is necessary to the educational process as well as necessary to the freedom of the stu­dents and my own. The teacher is absolutely necessary. What is bad, what is not necessary, is authoritarianism, but not authority.
      #hortonfreire
    59. The teacher is of course an artist, but being an artist does not mean that he or she can make the profile, can shape the students. What the educator does in teaching is to make it possible for the students to be­come themselves.
      #hortonfreire
    60. The people who use that label are people who unknowingly, for the most part, are dedicated to the support of the status quo.
      #hortonfreire
    61. I'm just saying that we understand that the people who claim to be neutral, and call us propagandists because we are not neutral, are not neutral either. They're just ignorant. They don't know that they're supporters of the status quo. They don't know that that's their job. They don't know that the institution is dedicated to per­petuating a system and they're serving an institution. They have influence nevertheless.
      #hortonfreire
    62. Conflicts are the midwife of consciousness.
      #hortonfreire
    63. Those who come tomor­row will start acting, precisely taking what we did as the starting point.
      #hortonfreire
    64. I think it is abso­lutely indispensable that educators be secure, capable, and have a capacity for loving and for curiosity.
      #hortonfreire
    65. I have noth­ing against teaching. But I have many things against teaching in an authoritarian way.
      #hortonfreire
    66. knowledge never is static. It's always in the process.
      #hortonfreire
    67. I am humble because I am incomplete
      #hortonfreire
    68. one of the virtues we have to create in ourselves as progressive educators is the virtue of humility.
      #hortonfreire
    69. I try to find ways to expose them to learning processes that would finally lead them to take a look at my conclusion.
      #hortonfreire
    70. MYLES: Well I think you have to divide that into principles. When I say what I believe, I'm talking about prin­ciples such as love and democracy, where people control their Jives. THIRD PARTY: Your vision. MYLES: My vision. Now the strategy for my vision, the ap­proaches and processes, I've learned from other people.
      #hortonfreire
    71. any kind of prob­lem has five or six good solutions and five or six bad solutions.
      #hortonfreire
    72. If you have a convic­tion, you have a responsibility to act on that conviction where you can, and if you're doing education, you act on it in an educational context.
      #hortonfreire
    73. For me it has always been a political question, not exclusively an edu­cational question, at what levels students take part in the process of organizing the curriculum.
      #hortonfreire
    klown.cogdogblog.com klown.cogdogblog.com
    Your writing Adam, and Amy's too, is moving, and as Kate noted in twitter, its going beyond pulling the quotes from the book and postulating
    2
    1. It's hard to even see much of that spark anymore, that so many beliefs have been crushed, negated, that our society is mired with an unbearable weight of cynicism.

      I am reading Dave Gray's Liminal thinking. Two quotes that bear on this:

      1."The obvious is not obvious.It is constructed....We band together in "obvious clubs" that defend competing versions of reality." (Gray 8-13)

      1. "Your experience of reality is limited by the range of your experience...so your experiences are limited by the things you notice, or pay attention to, within those experiences..." (Gray 14-15) In other words we pay attention to what we are most primed to pay attention to.

      He compares that attention to this:

      when maybe it should be more like this:

      #hortonfreire
    2. its going beyond pulling the quotes from the book and postulating about education

      I am not sure what "beyond" means here. Feels like a judgment, a noting of a failing. I based a lot of my formative teaching years doing exactly that. I would try to find ways to make the quotes work in meatspace. Maybe that's not what you mean by this, but I find any attempt to connect across contexts (known or unknown) to be a winner.

      #hortonfreire