- Apr 2018
-
journals.plos.org journals.plos.org
-
As those SmartFlare probes were designed for RNA targeting while using the gold core just as a carrier for the dye, successful SmartFlare binding to the Her2 gene product in the endoplasmic reticulum would mean a GNP concentration in the ER around the cell nucleus. Thus, in tumor types where certain genes are considerably upregulated, the RNA of such genes could be targeted so that the GNPs accumulate in the tumor cells only, leading to an increased radio-sensitivity compared to non-tumor cells without extra-ordinary up-regulation
See above. This is a considerable misunderstanding of the Smartflare technology: the gold is not supposed to stay where the mRNA was. In fact, to address this 'problem', Mirkin (the inventor of the SmartFlare) even developed another version where the mRNA stay bound to the mRNA (the famous stickyflare).
-
RNA targeting nanogold probes that are aiming for the Her2 gene product in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER)
The SmartFlares are supposed to enable the measurement of mRNA levels in cells. Nobody has ever claimed that they can target mRNA, even less so target specific cells on the basis of their mRNA levels. There is no reason to believe that the amount of gold in different cells should correlate with the amount of mRNA. In fact the working principle of the sensor assumes that all cells uptake the same amount of SmartFlare but the fluorescence levels are different depending on the amount of mRNA because of the release of a reporter strand from the nanoparticle. [the technology does not work, but that is another story]
-
GNPs smaller than 30 nm are leaving the cell again by passive diffusion [3, 14, 15]
Reference 3 does not include any study of passive diffusion through membranes. To the contrary, it includes a liposomal transfection agent to help oligonucleotide-capped nanoparticles go inside cells. Reference 14 does not mention passive diffusion whatsoever. It is an article about active transport (endocytosis and exocytosis). Reference 15 includes the sentence "GNPs smaller than 30 nm are leaving the cell again by passive diffusion (15)" (that's right, identical word for word)... where (15) is reference 14 above.
Tags
Annotators
URL
-