Unsure — I'd want to discuss this further
Initial feedback is closer to $200K as pilot but open to discuss
28 Matching Annotations
- Last 7 days
-
next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev
-
-
What's the single biggest risk or concern you see with this concept?
Need for guardrails
-
What's the single biggest opportunity you see with this concept?
Civic participation and a connectivity between the region and it's youth; research potential
-
Yes
Yes but would want more definition to confirm diversity of the cohort
-
Are there specific aspects you want to see changed?
More detail about selection criteria; more guidelines for grantmaking authority
-
5
5
-
FYI This is labeled as We Can be in the hypothesis list.
-
-
next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev
-
1
Other ideas have more optimism and potential
-
What's the single biggest risk or concern you see with this concept?
Concept is built around identification of problems vs. opportunities and has risk of being confrontational
-
-
next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev
-
Unsure — I'd want to discuss this further
Needs further discussion
-
What's the single biggest risk or concern you see with this concept?
Time commitment and uncertainty of commitment of public officials
-
What's the single biggest opportunity you see with this concept?
Cohort of new leaders coming from less likely corners of the community
-
Partially — the intent is right but the mechanism may not reach them
Possibly but not certain
-
Are there specific aspects you want to see changed?
Exploration of expanding existing regional leadership programs vs. launching something new
-
2
Concerned about the length of time and commitment needed by participants and civic leaders
-
-
next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev
-
Who are the prospective funders and program partners that come to mind for this concept?
All funders
-
Recommended ($225K) - 250 dinners, 2,500 participants
Agree
-
What's the single biggest risk or concern you see with this concept?
Lack of diverse participation; challenging to facilitate; clarity about what happens after the meal.
-
What's the single biggest opportunity you see with this concept
Aspirational to show opportunity to bridge divides.
Good storytelling with opportunity to gain regional interest and participation from people who may not typically have opportunity for involvement.
-
Yes — the design puts the right people at the center
Appears that the intent is there
-
Highlight this text and annotate with your answer. A sentence or two is plenty — what is missing that needs to be addressed during revisions?
Add focus on youth; more detail about diversity of participation
-
5
Priority
-
Is there or could there be a youth component?
-
-
next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev
-
We think this is one of the lower value ideas when looking at the stated ROI. If this is an idea you think has higher potential, consider how to talk about the outcomes and deliverables to the group.
-
Would be helpful to have some detail on the 21st to validate the likelihood that this campaign can be in place before the 4th? What decisions would need to be made and by when to provide you with enough time to activate.
-
Change title so that would not be tied to a Heinz program
-
-
next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev
-
Remove from 21st presentation
-
-
next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev next250.matt-hannigan.workers.dev
-
Remove this brief from presentation for the 21st but work with Matt Barron to bring this as an idea to the Press Forward SWPA chapter.
-