- Oct 2024
-
human.libretexts.org human.libretexts.org
-
This piece clearly articulates the case that _____________.
This is my favorite, I like how straightforward it is, I will probably use it on my own essay.
-
Even if the argument is fatally flawed, it may still contain some valuable insight or move the conversation forward in another way. We might conclude that an argument is not valid, but still see ways in which this argument can help us get closer to the truth on a particular topic.
I agree with this point of view, it's important to be open minded and consider what we can gain, even from arguments we disagree with. This reminds me of a class discussion we had about critical thinking in my last English class, where we talked about how every argument, no matter how flawed, can teach us something.
-
Praise part of the argument
I like how the text highlights the importance of considering different perspectives. It shows a good effort to include different views which makes a better and more balanced discussion.
-
Why look for strengths if the argument is flawed?
Looking for strengths in a flawed argument helps you understand it better. Even if it's flawed, there could be good points worth considering. This balanced approach makes your critique more constructive, helps you find ways to improve the argument, and shows empathy for other perspectives.
-