5 Matching Annotations
  1. Feb 2026
    1. In the final paragraph of this essay about essays my conclusion will be…what the fuck. I don’t know. In 2008, a few months after my son was born, I wrote the words I think I need help in my journal. I was scared I might hurt him. I didn’t know there was a name for what I was feeling, that postpartum depression was a Thing, and it would take three more years for me to be able to look at those words—I need help—without crying. When I sat down to write the piece that would eventually be selected for The Best American Essays 2013, there was a single question pulling me: How do I talk about depression in a way that’s not depressing? I felt that pull throughout my entire body. It made my blood boil, was all I could talk about when I sat with my friends. In his Letters To a Young Poet, Rilke writes that “a work of art is good if it has sprung from necessity.”

      Ending the essay without a clear conclusion is important. Her story about postpartum depression shows that strong essays come from something personal and meaningful. not just an assignment. It made me wonder how writing classes might change if students were encouraged to write about what they truly need to say instead of what they’re expected to prove.

    2. In the second body paragraph of this essay about essays I will talk about reading essays. I just read an essay by Roxane Gay that challenged me to read more diversely.

      I like how she uses real examples instead of just explaining her point. By mentioning different writers and how their essays made her feel, she shows what essays can actually do. Each example shows a different purpose, like helping people heal, question privilege, or feel less alone, which makes essays important, not just school assignments.

    3. “Essays are terrifying.” “Terrifying,” I said. “Why terrifying?” “Because you have to be totally, completely certain about everything,” she said. “I’m eighteen years old—I’m not certain about anything.”

      This quote really made me stop and think. The idea that essays are scary because you have to be “certain” makes a lot of sense to me and describes why writing can feel stressful. I like how Stielstra reminds us that essays don’t have to be about having all the answers, but about exploring ideas.

    4. irony: a statement or event in which the opposite is said or the unexpected happens multiplied times 300 other words we’d be tested on and yes, fine, to this day I can still recite the definition of irony, but it wasn’t until years later, when I walked in on my boyfriend getting down with my roommate that I understood what irony actually meant.

      The irony example stood out to me. Memorizing definitions without really understanding them feels like how we often study just to pass exams. I’ve also had moments where something only made sense after I experienced it myself. This shows that repeating information isn’t the same as truly learning it.

    5. five paragraphs—introductory paragraph, three paragraphs of support, conclusion. Sound familiar? I’d wager we all learned this particular form, and yes, I think it’s vital to know how to organize our thoughts and back up an argument, however, the assumption that there’s only one way to do so is increasingly problematic, especially in light of this country’s current testing culture.

      The SAT example is really concerning. Spending only two minutes on an essay doesn’t seem like enough time to judge how deep someone’s thinking is. It feels like the system values speed and following a formula more than real thinking, which might be why many students feel stressed about essays instead of curious about them.