67 Matching Annotations
  1. Nov 2021
    1. "Why We Should Open Our Borders"

      It appears that some citations within the "Works Cited" page are in bold font.

    2. Research-Based Proposal Arguments

      Yes, I can definitely see myself using these sample essays in my class. The sample proposal essay "Why We Should Open Our Borders" works really well here!

    3. Research-Based Evaluation Arguments

      Wonderful evaluation essays! I like that the essay "Universal Health Coverage for the United States" has a specific attribution. I wish it contained a "Works Cited" page as well.

    4. Research-Based Definition Arguments

      The three essays that are included in this section are great! I especially favor the essay with the pdf version and annotations. Students find essays, like this one, extremely helpful and see them as guides while they develop their own writing.

    5. The essay "An Image Is Worth a Thousand Calls to Arms" by Saramanda Swigart analyzes a visual argument.

      This essay is very detailed in the way that it analyzes the image included within it. I like how it can be used in one of my classes to show an example of a visual analysis essay.

    6. The essay "Argument Analysis of Cory Doctorow’s 'Why I Won’t Buy an iPad (and Think You Shouldn’t, Either)'" can serve as an example

      Absolutely! I would advocate for the inclusion of this student essay. It contains lots of very detailed and thoughtful annotations.

    7. The brief essay "Henig's Perspective on the Gender Revolution"

      This sample student argument analysis essay works well. I also like how you included the original text that is being analyzed before the essay itself.

    8. The essay "Contested Territory" compares and contrasts two arguments on immigration

      This essay works really well as a sample comparison and contrast essay!

    9. responds

      Yes, I like how you differentiate these essays by category since these short essays can be used as both sample summaries and student responses.

    10. In "Typography and Identity," Saramanda Swigart summarizes

      This is also a great summary because it could be seen as a way into an argument about racial identity and could be connected to Black Lives Matter movement as well. I like how the PDF version points out the opening of the essay as well as the thesis statement - very effective.

    11. n "Spread Feminism, Not Germs," student Gizem Gur summarizes the Atlantic Magazine article

      This summary works really well since it relates to the current pandemic. I like the marginal notes that are included within the PDF version of this sample summary. Since this is a summary written by a student, it works well as a model summary for students completing a similar assignment.

  2. Oct 2021
    1. Attributions

      Anna, here is my summary of this chapter:

      The chapter "Keeping It Concise" explores the importance of being concise in academic writing by eliminating wordiness and provides specific strategies for eliminating such wordiness.

    2. Exercise 14.2.114.2.1

      Would you consider adding to this exercise?

    3. A goddess as a child, a queen at eighteen, a celebrity soon thereafter, she was an object of speculation and veneration, gossip and legend, even in her own time.

      This is such a beautiful example!

    4. Look for words and phrases that you can cut entirely.

      Would it be helpful to remind that this is best done during the revision process?

    5. Wordiness may seem to add to our academic credibility, and it can cover over areas of uncertainty

      Would you also want to add anything about wordiness and the connection to the length of an assignment? Just an idea...

    6. everything in the final version should add something unique to the paper.

      This is such an important point to make, I am just thinking how it could be highlighted more...

    7. some significant work for the paper as a whole

      This is beautifully said!

    8. repetition

      Would it be helpful to give examples of repetition or make a case for the difference between repetition and analysis?

    9. Why is it important to be concise?

      I really like that this section is phrased as a title as a question - it works really well for students because it gives them the purpose here.

    10. Why is it important to be concise?

      Anna, I have a similar comment here: would you like to add an image? Do you already have an image in mind for this chapter?

    1. Attribution 

      Anna, here is the summary:

      This chapter "What Defines Good Style in Academic Writing?" focuses on the importance of clarity as a major component of academic style. It also advocates for focusing on style and clarity in the revision, rather than in the drafting, process.

      Feel free to change it however you see fit. Thank you for this incredible opportunity to work with you on this chapter.

    2. satisfying

      Here is another quotation: "I have rewritten–often several times–every word I have ever published. My pencils outlast their erasers." ~Vladimir Nabokov

    3. Editing for style can then be a satisfying and not overly burdensome part of the process.

      So much of our writing is rewriting? Here is a beautiful quotation about writing and rewriting that I found: "Writing is rewriting. A writer must learn to deepen characters, trim writing, intensify scenes. To fall in love with the first draft to the point where one cannot change it is to greatly enhance the prospects of never publishing." ~Richard North Patterson

    4. Once we have our ideas clear, it will be easier write effective sentences

      In this chapter, since you are writing about drafting and revision, would you like to bring in research?

    5. revision process

      Would you consider adding an exercise here to show how this could be done?

    6. separate the drafting process from the revision process

      This is a way to draft first and then to look over the draft. This reminds me of Anne Lamott!

    7. Compare the following two versions of a sentence:

      Would you consider adding more examples, like these, to show the difference between the two styles?

    8. We can develop this sense of confidence, however, without fancy vocabulary or a hyper-formal, fussy style.

      This is a great way to lead into the clarification about academic writing and style.

    9. it takes a genius to make complicated things simple.

      What a great way to put it!

    10. annoying rather than impressive

      Or even awkward and convoluted?

    11. Unnecessary jargon, fancy vocabulary, and convoluted sentences can make anything harder to understand. 

      Thus, it is important to prioritize clarity in writing.

    12. alienating readers

      Yes, I completely agree - this is the danger.

    13. elegant, graceful, and pleasing word combinations

      This is a beautiful way to describe writing style. I cannot think of anything that could be added to this description.

    14. clarity should be our first goal

      Yes, when it comes to style, and especially when it comes to style in academic writing. Would it be worth noting this?

    15. stylistic choices we make should also help our readers understand

      Would you consider mentioning audience awareness here and its importance?

    16. self-consciously scholarly style

      Well said! This often leads to awkward phrasing

    17. clothing style can shape how we see a person

      This is such a cool comparison!

    18. Prioritize clarity

      Anna, would you consider adding an image here? I can look for one we can use in an OER text.

  3. Sep 2021
    1. Ask someone you trust for feedback and constructive criticism.

      This could be a tutor?

    2. It’s most efficient to revise from “big” to “small.”

      This is such a helpful tip

    3. as help

      Yes, as just an opportunity for a different perspective

    4. and pick up only negative vibes

      Yes, that feeling of "not good enough," but a critique can be quite the opposite

    5. drafts.” 

      I am totally not sure about this, but is there a need for an in-text citation? I am so used to citing...

    6. celebrates

      Yes! She really does, and it is great for a writer to see that

    1. Drafting is the stage of the writing process in which we develop a complete first version of a piece of writing. 

      This is a very well written chapter. I am not sure if I have too much to add to it.

    2. As Anne Lamott says in her book Bird by Bird: Some Instructions on Writing and Life

      This is such a great attribution to Lamott

    1. Set a timer and write for 5-15 minutes

      This reminds me of the Pomodoro technique

    2. Choose a prompt, an idea or question that gets you started

      I like this idea of connecting freewriting to the prompt from the very beginning of the writing process

    3. Let your mind go, go with the flow,

      This is a really great way to put it

    4. connections

      This is a really great way to start creating some synthesis in argumentative/ research writing

    5. Think of ideas that connect to the big concept.

      Or branch out of it

    6. big concept

      Connecting this big concept to an assignment prompt?

    7. What I know/don’t know lists:

      I really like this one! For example, 10 things I know to be true about...

    8. Work as quickly as you can

      Can set a time limit by using a timer, for example, 10 - 15 minutes. Write without stopping and then, after the time is up, take a 5 minute break. After the break, come back to your writing so you can see it with "fresh eyes"

    1. Write notes by hand on the margins of the text

      It is almost like having a conversation with the text. You can challenge assumptions, question, agree/ disagree, etc.

    2. Underline or highlight words, sentences, and passages that stand out.

      Question the text, the author, or the ideas presented in the text/ argument

    1. first step toward coming up with our own contribution to the larger conversation

      Yes, this is truly when the writing process actually begins

    2. instructor's guidance can help

      Yes, these specific guidelines outline the criteria of the essay or assignment

    3. The instructor's guidance can help us focus our efforts from the start.

      It may also help to mention that styling the prompt will help students to make sure that they answer/ respond to the prompt directly in their writing. This way their writing should follow the prompt.

    4. murky thoughts

      Yes, or those very first, very rough drafts

    5. we almost always get to greater insight and clarity for ourselves and our readers

      Yes, and simply because writing is a different kind of thinking within itself

    6. eel discouraged and question our skill because we can't envision a fully-formed essay on the spot

      This reminds me so much of Anne Lamott's writing "First Drafts"

    7. new assignment

      Yes, and, in this case, ANY new assignment

    8. Writing can be daunting

      This statement is just so relatable! I think that anyone who writes can really relate to it.

    1. Image by pencil parker from Pixabay 

      This image relates both the idea of what writing is through generating ideas and the actual process that we go through as writers.

    2. Image by pencil parker from Pixabay 

      I actually like this image. It is very compelling and interesting. I think that it reflects on the concept of the writing process quite well. I see that it already has an attribution. Is this image going to be the image for the chapter?