12 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2022
    1. Inland lake systems, like the Great Lakes region of Canada and the U.S., will see a huge influx of migrants

      Depends, considering China's inland river, which was the 3rd biggest, dried up.

    2. Problematically, many of them have also struggled politically with immigration to a far greater extent than have many much poorer countries (poor countries also host by far the greatest numbers of displaced people), and with a migrant “crisis” that is far smaller than the great climate migration we will see over the next 75 years. It may be more possible to shift a political­-social mindset in the space of a few years, however, than to return the tropics to habitability. Consider that most of Europe’s nations each rely on tens of thousands of migrant workers just to harvest the crops they grow today. With better agricultural conditions across the north, the need for labour will only increase.

      This entire paragraph is a bit confusing to read, especially so that he makes the paragraph stand alone instead of connecting it to previous ideas.

    3. Happily, however, the northern latitudes are already home to wealthier nations that generally have strong institutions and stable governments that are among the best placed to build social and technological resilience to the challenges this century.

      Why make two conflicting statements? First he claims a point of view from a group with absolutely no society, and second he claims a point of view from an established society in the same place. Only adds to the confusion.

    4. Extreme events are already occurring around the world and will continue to hit “safe” places. Some places, though, will be more easily adaptable to these changes, while others will become entirely uninhabitable fairly quickly. Bear in mind that many places will be uncomfortable if not intolerable by 2050—around the lifespan of most mortgages—we need to start planning where we make our homes now

      Where, exactly? Stop providing blanket statements

    5. In other words, identify where the freshwater resources are, where the safe temperatures are, where gets the most solar or wind energy, and then plan population, food and energy production around that. The good news is, there’s plenty of room on Earth. If we allow 20 square meters of space per person—around double the minimum habitable size for a house allowed under the International Residential Code—11 billion people would need 220,000 square kilometers of land to live on. There would be plenty of room to house everyone on earth in a single country—the surface area of Canada alone is 9.9 million square kilometers.

      In so, what would be the point in proposing this? If the author, Vince's goal was not to propose this, why bother putting this in when it's completely unrelated to the issue of overpopulation? It sounds like you're making some sort of fantasy wasteland setting where everyone has to live as neighbors lest they die.

    6. Of course, I’m not proposing anything as absurd, but this is something to reflect on when it is claimed that a country is “too full” for more people.

      One, that's a preposterous claim to make against overpopulation, and two, space isn't the problem here. Overpopulation deals with socioeconomic problems, not space. If it was, then we would've handled it long ago.

    7. Our best hope lies in cooperating as never before: decoupling the political map from geography. However unrealistic it sounds, we need to look at the world afresh and develop new plans based on geology, geography, and ecology.

      While agreeable, this is completely theoretical, and therefore, without any proper evidence backing his claims up, makes this a generic and too idealistic statement.

    8. Developing a radical plan for humanity to survive a far hotter world includes building vast new cities in the more tolerable far north while abandoning huge areas of the unendurable tropics.

      Why is that the immediate course of action they proposed? Won't it be better to first find a more tolerable solution here before migration occurs? There are a lot of other factors that cause migration to another country

    9. for large portions of the world, local conditions

      large, yet local? specify where exactly, especially since you're aiming to show the urgency of the situation