6 Matching Annotations
  1. Aug 2023
    1. (The question occurs to one: Do youimagine there are sightseers who see sights just as they are supposed to? a family wholive in Te rre H aute, who decide to take the canyo n tour, who go there, see it, enjo y itimmense ly, and go home co ntent? a family who are entirely innocent of all thebarriers, zones, losses of sovereignty I have been talking about? W ouldn’t most peoplebe sorry if Battleship Point fell into the canyon, carrying all one’s fellow passeng ers totheir death, leaving one alone on the South Rim? I cannot answer this. Perhaps thereare such people. Certainly a great many American families would swear they had nosuch problems, that they cam e, saw, and went away happy. Yet it is just these familieswho would be happiest if they had gotten the Inside Track and bee n among thesurviving remnant.)

      What I think Percy is getting at in this section is that people do not know how content they could be if they don't take the less beaten path. If they stick to the tours, and lookouts, they may be blindly limiting their experiences.

    2. xp osed b y what? B y the decay of thosefacilities which were designed to help the sightseer

      I see this sentence as very ironic, why can we see the canyon better when the trails and lookouts are gone? However, I think it makes perfect sense, without the trails and lodges we can see the simplicity of the canyon, the raw and natural state of it.

    3. It may be reco vered in a time o f national disaster. The Bright Angel Lodge isconverted into a rest home, a function that has nothing to do with the canyon a fewyards away. A wounded man is brought in. He regains cons ciousness; there outside hiswindow is the canyon

      The image presented in this passage, the man awakening and seeing the canyon for the first time, is a reflection of Cardenas discovering the canyon for the first time. The man, like Cardenas, is seeing the canyon without having planned to see it. He was not expecting it to look one way or another, therefore he was able to see it exactly how it was, in the moment. I think this passage is also saying that sometimes seeing something or doing something that is not planned, can be more meaningful than if it was planned.

    4. Our complexfriend stands behind his fellow tourists at the B right Angel Lodge and sees the canyonthrough them and their predicam ent, their picture taking and busy disregard. In a sense,he exploits his fellow tourists; he stands on their shoulders to see the canyon.

      In this sentence Percy is saying that "our complex friend" uses what the other tourists aren't seeing, to gain a more holistic view. He watches them snap a picture and move on. He learns from them, and takes in what they are missing. I think this also demonstrates being aware of ones surroundings. While the other tourists are only focused on the Canyon itself, the man stands back, and takes in the whole scene.

    5. How can the sightseer recover the Grand Canyon? He can recover it in any numberof ways, all sharing in common the stratagem of avoiding the approved confrontationof the tour and the Park Service

      In this section of the essay, Percy is saying that there are many ways for tourists to see the Grand Canyon for what is it, but they will not see it if they compare it to the expectation, or assumption of what they were expecting. Or if they only look at it how the tour guide tells them to look at it.

    6. Does not one see thesame sight from the Bright Angel Lodge that Cárdenas saw?

      This is an interesting question to think about and reflect on, because while the view from the lodge may be very similar to what Cardenas first encountered, even the mention of the lodge is describing how the scene is different. Where there was once only wilderness, there is now infrastructure and buildings.