Home Alone demonstrates another feature of the contradictory “democracy” of the Oprah Winfrey Show. The show characteristically likens situations that are fundamentally dissimilar and unequal. In Home Alone, as we have noted, gross neglect and abuse were equated with the actions of the guest who had left her children for 20 minutes. Underpinning the Oprah Winfrey Show (and, indeed chat shows as a genre) there seems to be a general assumption that apparently similar actions mean the same thing, regardless of who carries them out and the situation in which events occur. This kind of failure to make distinctions can be seen to constitute what Susan Bordo calls “plastic pluralism.” As she suggests in relation to the Donahue Show:
explains that the show, along with chat shows as a genre, operates under the assumption that seemingly similar actions hold the same meaning, irrespective of the context or the individuals involved. This lack of discernment is likened to "plastic pluralism," a concept Susan Bordo discusses in relation to the Donahue Show, suggesting a superficial treatment of complex issues that fails to recognize meaningful distinctions.