Elliott recalls the effect of this “lesson” on the way students behaved: “It was just horrifying how quickly they became what I told them they were.” Within half an hour, Elliott continued, a blue-eyed girl named Carol had changed from a “brilliant, carefree, excited little girl to a frightened, timid, uncertain, almost-person.” Not surprisingly, in the hours that followed, the brown-eyed students came to life, speaking up more and performing better than they had before. The prophecy had been fulfilled: Because the brown-eyed children thought they were superior, they became superior in their classroom performance; they also became “arrogant, ugly, and domineering” toward the blue-eyed children. For their part, the blue-eyed children began underperforming, becoming the inferior people they believed themselves to be.
This entire experiment was so interesting to me because I have seen this prophecy firsthand when teaching. Many children, if told they are doing amazing and have had tremendous growth actuallly end up with those results and vice versa for the negative side. This is something that I truly believe is important to understand. Have you ever seen the self-fulfilling prophecy play out in front of you, like in this expirement?