33 Matching Annotations
  1. Mar 2017
    1. the chance to fight for the championship title

      This is so interesting to me - I wonder if focusing on these lost opportunities because of racism would strengthen the connection between your slides (both boxing and overall)? Also, it would really help me follow these slides more clearly if they were grounded in more locations (especially since so many of these boxers have J names!).

    2. was murdered in 1871

      Though this may not directly relate to the topic, I am so focused on knowing why Catto was murdered that it might make sense just to state why so that I don't leave the presentation to google why?

    1. Descendents of the Harlem Renaissance

      Connecting the New Negro Movement era artists to contemporary artists works well, though I wonder if the title of your piece is a bit misleading as this slide and, i believe, brief references in two other slides make up the 'now' portion. Is there a way to integrate more 'now,' if that's important to your argument, or change some of the language to better represent your engaging work with past portraiture? Also has the portraiture, as a definition, changed a lot over the century?

    2. the viewer might not know the racial identity of the subject

      Would this sentence function better if you focus on what the painting does/appears as rather than a potential viewer?

    3. statuette actively resists

      Is Warrick or the statuette resisting the image? Also, currently this sentence gives the portrait of Turner as being made by the statuette, rather than Warrick.

    4. brushed under the rug

      This figure of speech brings my mind's eye into the house/domestic space, which works with Turner expecting a child, but a different way of saying this might work more strongly with the rest of the analysis. Is there a better way to say that the story was quieted?

    5. portraiture

      It might help if you define portraiture and set some limitations for what that means, since I assumed portraitures were portraits and so only paintings/drawings.

    6. portraiture with white Western aristocracy

      Are your artists both black and white? Are they of mixed racial heritage or neither black nor white? And, if so, how does this matter/affect the success of the portraiture in rearticulating black humanity?

    7. proved an ideal medium

      I'm a bit confused here - it later proved, but at the time was still becoming? Also the word 'ideal' makes me wonder - what are the drawbacks, if any, of portraiture?