I know we're focused on early in the college educational process here, but I worry about what this means for later. My stats final project has a "rubric" that looks roughly like "do something awesome related in some way to what we've learnt". I don't want to tie students into more structure than that.
As they struggle with it (and most do to some extent) I offer more examples of what they might do or how they might think about it, but I want this to come /after/ they've done some thinking for themselves. They may well a have ideas that are much better than anything I could come up for them.
And life isn't especially scaffolded in this way. If we want students to thrive beyond college, we need to let them work without as much direct, explicit, frequent support.