7 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2019
    1. to refuse romanticized creation stories

      This is very prevalent. In American literature especially, the viewing of America as this beautiful unexplored land that was waiting to be discovered by these "first settlers". Even now, from what I remember, in schools the romanticism of Canada being discovered for the "first time" inspires dreams and the adventurous spirit in children, without really acknowledging in depth the violence that was committed against the true first inhabitants. They are erased and pushed aside in the founding of a "new" land narrative.

    2. . We wonder who will notice when the Natty Bumppos of the field will both praise and dismiss, remove and replace, take what is necessary and position themselves, once again, as the true “native,” the true inheritors of a post-post-reconceptualized re-occupation. The most cynical view is that refusals will always be replaced as long as the vestiges of settler colonialism in curriculum studies go unobserved. Refusers will be erased, subtly written off the page as remnants of the past in a settler colonial future

      This helps summarize most of the article; the idea that white people have been and are erasing Indigenous people from history, from our current lives, and placing themselves in their place, placing their views and cultures in the place of Indigenous views and cultures. Despite the different interventions, people who stand up against these white systems are quickly silenced and brushed aside.

    3. There isn’t an easy ending.

      I appreciate the author being blunt and honest about this, about there not being any easy solution to the whiteness that has overtaken our schools, there is no "comfortable" solution. It's hard, and will take hard work and holding each other accountable to keep from perpetuating settler colonialism in our education systems. This is part of why this class will be valuable in our future, if we can foster an attitude of holding ourselves and each other accountable and asking the hard questions.

    1. t schooling as a system rations kinds of knowledge to class and ethnically-stratified student populations has been empirically confirmed by a number of studies

      This reminds me of that video that we saw in Wednesday's class. It's so important that we see each student as an important contributor and part of the classroom, otherwise we're in danger of falling into this trap of distinguishing who is helpful or worth effort, "ration(ing) kind of knowledge to class".

    2. hese men and women forge new domestic alliances as whites, protecting "their communities" from African Americans and "Arabs" (W

      I'd be interested to see a similar study performed in the 2020's; have people grown more accepting of a diverse community, or is there still lots of racism and fear among middle class families? What are the domestic situations of the more recent years like?

    3. they find a lockstep pattern of teacher and parental beliefs, classroom practices, and state performance cri teria that "reinforce the differential class struc ture in preparing the young for future occupa tional roles"

      I'd be interested in knowing how they do that; what is it exactly in the curriculum or in the beliefs held by teachers and parents that keep kids in the class structures they are currently in? Maybe it's simple discrimination and there isn't much to explain? I'm sure we'll touch on this in class in the future.

    4. They disrupt the logic of schooling, but their group and practice-based insights are limited "pene trations" (Willis 1977, chapters 5 and 6) because their class expressions also reinforce ethnora cial antagonism, gender oppression, and edu cational failure.

      This idea seems a little dated to me. Children are no longer outcast for displaying behavior that is disruptive. They are talked to, they are assessed for underlying disorders that may be keeping them from engaging fully, and teachers teach differently, as to engage a variety of learners. Also, this "educational failure" isn't just a school issue; are parents helping or supporting their children in their education? It's hard to always know, especially since teacher/parent relations seem to be very tricky and sensitive in today's day and age.