Question of cruelty is bad but how can you counteract cruelty when it is part of the legal/societal system?
- Apr 2017
-
rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com
-
-
While there is a love story Kathy does not allow herself to see the situation in that way
-
Ishiguro asking the reader to think about the future in real life
-
What is being told to the children is also being told to the reader about society
-
- Mar 2017
-
rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com
-
Pg 88- need to connect evidence with values. This reminds me of my work this semester-- I have had ideas/thoughts about dystopias and I had to remember to back everything up with evidence
-
Pg. 17 -- I have had problems writing on a text and starting with certain expectations about how women are treated in the world but when I look deeper at the diction, I realize I was not completely right
-
Transformation also includes personal, subjective viewpoints such as what type of person is behind the writing
-
Having to figure out how the writer answers the question -- how is that known?
-
reworking is not novel
-
- Feb 2017
-
rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com
-
The more confi dence your readers have in your descriptions of such texts, the more they are also likely to credit your uses and interpreta-tions of them.
A way of establishing ethos almost?
-
extracting such materials is only part of the job
Using to build your own ideas
-
As I write this book, for instance, I am sitting in a small room, before a laptop computer, surrounded by books, papers, and magazines—all of which I am, in some metaphorical sense, “in conversation with” (in much the same way I am also in conversation with you, my imagined reader).
Everything involved in the writing process becomes a sort of conversation
-
third reader
Someone else who has thoughts/would want to have a conversation about a piece of text
-
conversation are subtler than those of debate;
Conversation is different than debate
-
But you rarely win over a person you are speaking with by fi rst refuting what she or he has just said.
If people think you are attacking them they arent going to listen
-
A dialogue is not a debate. You don’t win a con-versation, you add to it, push it ahead, keep it going, “put your oar in,” and maybe even sometimes redirect or divert the fl ow of talk.
Goal is to continue the dialogue
-
In this view, to be-come a lawyer, a historian, a biologist, or a social worker, you need to learn to think and talk like a lawyer, a historian, a biologist, or a social
And be able to identify as one of those roles as well
-
-
www.theatlantic.com www.theatlantic.com
-
Twitter, unmediated by the press, has proved an extremely effective communication tool for Trump.
A way for Trump to get around the press
-
“And then they said, ‘You know he’s killed reporters,’ ” Trump told the audience. “And I don’t like that. I’m totally against that.
Ironic because of his relationship with the media now
-
Calculated outrage
His platform as a whole was built on anger and resentment for the current status of the US
-
Glimpses of his family’s wealth-seeking activities will likely emerge during his presidency,
Shifted from talking about the future as if it is going on right now to predictions of what Trump will do in his presidency
-
Presidents from Jimmy Carter onward have balanced this unique exemption with a unique act of disclosure: the voluntary publication of their income-tax returns. At a press conference on January 11, Trump made clear that he will not follow that tradition.
Providing an example of Trump already going against the grain
-
how difficult it will be to enforce laws against an uncooperative president.
Difficult for the American people to stand up for themselves ta all
-
What about Trump’s conflicts of interest? “This is not what I’m concerned about in Congress,” Ryan said on CNBC. Trump should handle his conflicts “however he wants to.”
Autocracy - Americans taking a very passive stance
-
“I don’t know. I’m not really focused on these things.”
Then what is he even focused on?
-
Trump has scant interest in congressional Republicans’ ideas, does not share their ideology, and cares little for their fate.
Trump does not even identify with his own party. This article isolates Trump from the American system today as a whole.
-
“Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.
No one is being ambitious. No one challenging Trump and what is happening
-
“democratic recession.”
Connotations of the word "recession"
-
guaranteed a successful future.
Almost a warning
-
If this were happening in Honduras, we’d know what to call it.
Saying it without saying it
-
Other paths remain open. It is up to Americans to decide which one the country will follow.
call to action
-
Wise business leaders take care to credit Trump’s personal leadership for any good news, and to avoid saying anything that might displease the president or his family.
People trying to appease the president
-
t’s 2021, and President Donald Trump will shortly be sworn in for his second term. The 45th president has visibly aged over the past four years. He rests heavily on his daughter Ivanka’s arm during his infrequent public appearances.Fortunately for him, he did not need to campaign hard for reelection. His has been a popular presidency: Big tax cuts, big spending, and big deficits have worked their familiar expansive magic. Wages have grown strongly in the Trump years, especially for men without a college degree, even if rising inflation is beginning to bite into the gains. The president’s supporters credit his restrictive immigration policies and his TrumpWorks infrastructure program.
Setting up a time frame and a futuristic world -- Trump is well likes, people like what he has done so far
-
-
rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com
-
Bush looked at who he wanted to appeal and almost mimicked them
-
Burke: identification
-
People will be more likely to listen if they believe they are talking to someone similar to them
-
You audience needs to believe these three things in order to be receptive to your rhetoric
-
- Jan 2017
-
history.hanover.edu history.hanover.edu
-
The feminine opinion of your mother, however, who wished to keep you busy with spinning and silly girlishness, following the common custom of women, was the major obstacle to your being more involved in the sciences.
So now not just men that are getting in the way of women -- so are other women
-
but in the perfection of conduct and virtues.
New ranking system
-
where no one will reside except all ladies of fame and women worthy of praise, for the walls of the city will be closed to those women who lack virtue.
Doesn't this seem hypocritical? Or actually only further playing into views/stereotypes about women?
-
in fact we have come to vanquish from the world the same error into which you had fallen
Believed women were bad/unworthy because how they were portrayed
-
realize how their claims could be true when compared to the natural behavior and character of women.
rhetoric of women does not match how women actually are
-
Because the subject seemed to me not very pleasant for people who do not enjoy lies,
Such a foreign concept
-
-
rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com
-
s always a product of the culture from which it springs.
Audience is able to understand because the world is created in respect to the real world that the author & audience is from
-
eliberative rhetoric about reform: The future imagined as a utopia can be used in argu-ments for shaping the future.
Utopia can be used as an example -- allows the reader to juxtapose the utopian world with the real world
-
canons of memory (memoria) and inven-tion (inventio) are perhaps most remarkable for their systematized handling of imagined places and imagined temporal realities.
In the mind -- need to be able to visualize the place but do not need an exact location
-
appeals to broad cultural ideals and organizing principles.
Must be recognizable by the audience.
-
define a utopian rhetoric as the use of symbolic communication in an attempt to move the actual state of human affairs into alignment with an imagined, better state of affairs
Utopian world aided in the use of symbols and communication that can be identified by people.
-
-
rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com rhetofwomenindystopia.files.wordpress.com
-
Group 2- In order to understand the text, we first have to understand the writer and argument/piece as a whole. The main ideas of the argument are based on the writer's motive.
-