91 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2018
    1. As in our native Language can I find That solace? All our Law and Story strew'd With Hymns, our Psalms with artful terms inscrib'd, [ 335 ] Our Hebrew Songs and Harps in Babylon, That pleas'd so well our Victors ear, declare That rather Greece from us these Arts deriv'd; Ill imitated, while they loudest sing The vices of thir Deities, and thir own [ 340 ] In Fable, Hymn, or Song, so personating Thir Gods ridiculous, and themselves past shame.

      Greece derives it art from the Hebrew. What is the implication of this judgment, for Milton chose to express salvation in the form of heroic epic. Ironic?

    2. Thus they the Son of God our Saviour meek Sung Victor, and, from Heavenly Feast refresht Brought on his way with joy; hee unobserv'd Home to his Mothers house private return'd.

      The whole mystery of salvation has been won by means of an argument? And Jesus goes back home to his mother. These seems to end strangely, certain underplaying the subsequent drama of the narrative.

    3. And now the Tempter thus his silence broke. The City which thou seest no other deem Then great and glorious Rome, Queen of the Earth [ 45

      The last Temptation is set in Rome, not Jerusalem

    1. So spake the Son of God; and here again [ 145 ] Satan had not to answer, but stood struck With guilt of his own sin, for he himself Insatiable of glory had lost all, Yet of another Plea bethought him soon.

      is this the end of the second temptation,

    1. Besides to give a Kingdom hath been thought Greater and nobler done, and to lay down Far more magnanimous, then to assume. Riches are needless then, both for themselves, And for thy reason why they should be sought, [ 485 ] To gain a Scepter, oftest better miss't.

      rejects the offer of a kingdom, a Scepter.

    2. In ample space under the broadest shade A Table richly spred, in regal mode, [ 340 ] With dishes pil'd, and meats of noblest sort And savour

      Satan sets a table in the wilderness. Jesus rebuttal, I don't need your table I could command my own.

    3. To whom thus Jesus; What conclud'st thou hence? They all had need, I as thou seest, have none.

      Like the child that did play, here Jesus does not have physical needs as Hagar, the children in the wilderness, of Elijah. This is a docetic Christ..

    4. When suddenly a man before him stood, Not rustic as before, but seemlier clad, As one in City, or Court, or Palace bred, [ 300 ] And with fair speech these words to him address'd.

      Satan 2nd appearance disguised this them as a courtier.

    5. When suddenly a man before him stood, Not rustic as before, but seemlier clad, As one in City, or Court, or Palace bred, [ 300 ] And with fair speech these words to him address'd.

      Satan appears a second time clad as on of city court or place, with fair speech,

    6. Thus we rejoyc'd, but soon our joy is turn'd Into perplexity and new amaze: For whither is he gone, what accident Hath rapt him from us?

      Apparently Andrew and Simon (Simon in the Gospel only learns of Jesus later from Andrew) who accept from the witness John that he is the messiah, are puzzled because he has disappeared. He is in the wilderness to engage in the cosmic battle for salvation in a contest with Satan.

    1. this the argument. Victory and triumph to the Son of God Now entring his great duel, not of arms, But to vanquish by wisdom hellish wiles. [ 175 ]

      The battle for salvation is debate that pits wisdom against hellish wiles.

  2. Aug 2018
    1. my Mother soon perceiving By words at times cast forth inly rejoyc'd, And said to me apart, high are thy thoughts O Son, but nourish them and let them soar

      So it was Mary that put all these thoughts in Jesus head!

    2. To which my Spirit aspir'd; victorious deeds [ 215 ] Flam'd in my heart, heroic acts; one while To rescue Israel from the Roman yoke, Then to subdue and quell o're all the earth Brute violence and proud Tyrannick pow'r, Till truth were freed, and equity restor'

      Jesus imagines a political agenda.

    3. How many Ages, as the years of men, This Universe we have possest, and rul'd In manner at our will th' affairs of Earth, [ 50 ]

      Milton implies that all past human history has been ruled by Satan.

    4. Recover'd Paradise to all mankind,

      Luke 23:43, II Cor 12:4, Rev. 2:7 Curiously, Paradise is not a Biblical idea, but an apocryphal one surfacing 2 century BCE and note in three isolated references in the NT. It makes the Biblical view cyclical, a return to a past, were its general thrust is to a future state unlike anything the past. Jesus, Mk 12:25 in the resurrection they are not given in marriage!

    1. To leave this Paradise, but shalt possess A Paradise within thee, happier farr.

      The Kingdom of God is with in you. A kind of realized eschatology? It is curious that the Calvinist doctrine of election is missing. This again raises the question about Milton's "orthodoxy." Is universal salvation possible for Milton. At the end he say of Adam and Eve and all the world was before them. This strikes me as optimistic.

    2. To leave them to thir own polluted wayes; [ 110 ] And one peculiar Nation to select From all the rest, of whom to be invok'd, A Nation from one faithful man to spring: Him on this side Euphrates yet residing,

      Call of Abraham and the creation of a chosen people.

    3. Since thy original lapse, true Libertie Is lost, which alwayes with right Reason dwells Twinn'd, and from her hath no dividual being: [ 85 ] Reason in man obscur'd, or not obeyd, Immediately inordinate desires And upstart Passions catch the Government From Reason, and to servitude reduce Man till then free. Therefore since hee permits [ 90 ] Within himself unworthie Powers to reign Over free Reason, God in Judgement just Subjects him from without to violent Lords;

      Milton's political theory: Interior tyranny, means the exterior tyrannies will follow.

    4. The Angel Michael continues from the Flood to relate what shall succeed; then, in the mention of Abraham, comes by degrees to explain, who that Seed of the Woman shall be, which was promised Adam and Eve in the Fall

      This deductive history, it happen in a accordance to an inherent logic. That why the story can be told ahead of it happening! Don't expect any surprises. In reality this is not history which require free choices and is replete with surprises, even for God! In I Peter 1:12 speaking of the prophets say that predicted "things into which angels longed to look."

    1. So willingly doth God remit his Ire, [ 885 ] Though late repenting him of Man deprav'd, Griev'd at his heart, when looking down he saw The whole Earth fill'd with violence, and all flesh Corrupting each thir way; yet those remoov'd, Such grace shall one just Man find in his sight, [ 890 ] That he relents, not to blot out mankind, And makes a Covenant never to destroy The Earth again by flood,

      The vision extends down to Noah Arc, which is glossed with the explanation that is shows how "willingly God remits his Ire.

    2. Our second Adam in the Wilderness, To shew him all Earths Kingdomes and thir Glory. His Eye might there command wherever stood [ 385 ] City of old or modern Fame

      A fanciful aside filled with exotic names. lines 385-410 It is to no apparent purpose to the task of showing Adam the future

    3. This Hill; let Eve (for I have drencht her eyes) Here sleep below while thou to foresight wak'st, As once thou slepst, while Shee to life was formd

      Eve is set aside for the time so Adam can be shown the future. Hence Eve will know the future through Adam. Again a kind of sexist parameter which Milton extend into his own time.

    4. And reverence thee thir great Progenitor. But this præeminence thou hast lost, brought down To dwell on eeven ground now with thy Sons: Yet doubt not but in Vallie and in Plaine God is as here, and will be found alike

      Adam is on the level as his sons, yet outside of Paradise God is present.

    5. Michael, this my behest have thou in charge, Take to thee from among the Cherubim [ 100 ] Thy choice of flaming Warriours, least the Fiend Or in behalf of Man, or to invade Vacant possession som new trouble raise:

      Michael is dispatch to expel Adam and Eve from the garden to soil from which Adam clay was taken.

    6. This other serv'd but to eternize woe; [ 60 ] Till I provided Death; so Death becomes His final remedie, and after Life Tri'd in sharp tribulation, and refin'd By Faith and faithful works, to second Life,

      Milton's doctrine of redemption: That death is a cure, stand well in the tradition. The condition of Faith and Faithful works, stand in the Catholic/Anglican Tradition, but parts from the Luther/Calvinist, faith alone. He appears to be an Arminian.

    1. So spake our Father penitent, nor Eve Felt less remorse: they forthwith to the place Repairing where he judg'd them prostrate fell Before him reverent, and both confess'd

      Milton's poetry often seems to go off and drag on, and then as with 1013f, Adam final speech addressed to Eve it soars. One can imagine this part by itself coming across on stage splendidly. Love it.

    2. The Race unblest, to being yet unbegot. Childless thou art, Childless remaine:

      Eve's despair leads her to the conviction that they should remain childless. Adam argues that they should rise to better hopes. This hope he pins on the part of their sentence which say thy seed shall bruise the serpents head" often in the tradition called the proto-evangelicum.

    3. More miserable; both have sin'd, but thou [ 930 ] Against God onely, I against God and thee, And to the place of judgment will return, There with my cries importune Heaven, that all The sentence from thy head remov'd may light On me, sole cause to thee of all this woe, [ 935 ] Mee mee onely just object of his ire.

      Milton's logic leads him naming Eve the sole cause and doubly guilty, since Adam just sins against God.

    4. Met who to meet him came, his Ofspring dear. Great joy was at thir meeting, and at sight [ 350 ] Of that stupendious Bridge his joy encreas'd. Long hee admiring stood, till Sin, his faire Inchanting Daughter, thus the silence broke.

      The Son Satan, a corrupt mimic of the son of God, who is born of Sin, Satan's daughter, the result of incest.

    5. Came the mild Judge and Intercessor both To sentence Man: the voice of God they heard Now walking in the Garden, by soft windes Brought to thir Ears, while day declin'd, they heard, And from his presence hid themselves among [ 100 ] The thickest Trees, both Man and Wife, till God Approaching, thus to Adam call'd aloud

      In Genesis it is God, who walks in the Garden, and not God's Son. The God man relationship up to this point is by visions and the mediation of Angels. In Milton's view this mediation is now raised to a higher level with the advent of the son.

    1. In Femal Sex, the more to draw his Love, And render me more equal, and perhaps, A thing not undesireable, somtime Superior: for inferior who is free? [ 825 ] This may be well: but what if God have seen And Death ensue? then I shall be no more, And Adam wedded to another Eve, Shall live with her enjoying, I extinct; A death to think. Confirm'd then I resolve, [ 830 ] Adam shall share with me in bliss or woe: So dear I love him, that with him all deaths I could endure, without him live no life.

      Eve tempted to keep this ill gained knowledge for herself to level the playing field with Adam. But if the death sentence did occur Adam would be wed to another Eve. Better they both be dead!

    2. he wish'd, but not with hope Of what so seldom chanc'd, when to his wish, Beyond his hope, Eve separate he spies,

      Satan see Eve separated an occasion for which he wished.

    3. Betook her to the Groves, but Delia's self In gate surpass'd and Goddess-like deport, Though not as shee with Bow and Quiver armd, [ 390 ] But with such Gardning Tools as Art yet rude,

      The stage is now set for action: Eve has separated herself from Adam making her vulnerable to Satan. She will be back by noon for lunch.

    4. Thus it shall befall Him who to worth in Women overtrusting Lets her Will rule; restraint she will not brook, And left to her self, if evil thence ensue, [ 1185 ] Shee first his weak indulgence will accuse.

      From 200 to 388 is a husband and wife routine, Fiber McGee and Molly, Michael and May, George and Gracie which quite entertaining. The moral of which is comes in line 1180 "Thus it shall befall Him who to worth in Women overtrusting let her Will rule." In the end this is, as much comedy, offensive.

    5. The season, prime for sweetest Sents and Aires: [ 200 ] Then commune how that day they best may ply Thir growing work: for much thir work outgrew The hands dispatch of two Gardning so wide. And Eve first to her Husband thus began.

      This seems to translate life in paradise into an idealized life of an English swain. Man and his Wife and their common labor in their garden. What could go wrong? Except for those dam vines that keep growing at night.

    6. In every Bush and Brake, where hap may finde [ 160 ] The Serpent sleeping, in whose mazie foulds To hide me, and the dark intent I bring.

      Always love the phrase "mazie foulds," excites the imagination! then in quick order "bestial slime" This essence to incarnate and imbrute. How fun to read this passage orally.

    7. The Serpent suttlest Beast of all the Field. Him after long debate, irresolute Of thoughts revolv'd, his final sentence chose Fit Vessel, fittest Imp of fraud, in whom To enter, and his dark suggestions hide [ 90 ] From sharpest sight:

      a kind of satanic incarnation

    8. Of my Celestial Patroness, who deignes Her nightly visitation unimplor'd, And dictates to me slumb'ring, or inspires Easie my unpremeditated Verse: Since first this Subject for Heroic Song [ 25 ] Pleas'd me long choosing, and beginning late;

      Milton's Muse: It is typical at the beginning of each book to evoke a muse, as in the classic canon. How consistent is he in the way he names his muse. It would make an interesting study to identify each form it takes in the 12 books. There is also in this selection an interesting description of his poetic. He calls it "unpremeditated Verse." What does he actually mean by this.

    1. I follow'd her, she what was Honour knew, And with obsequious Majestie approv'd My pleaded reason. To the Nuptial Bowre [ 510 ] I led her blushing like the Morn: all Heav'n, And happie Constellations on that houre Shed thir selectest influence; the Earth Gave sign of gratulation,

      Something like the God problem, the physical laisson,/experience precedes the spiritual communication.

    2. ; I, ere thou spak'st, Knew it not good for Man to be alone, [ 445 ] And no such companie as then thou saw'st Intended thee, for trial onely brought, To see how thou could'st judge of fit and meet:

      Typical of Milton's use of foreknowledge, God replies to Adam it true that you had to bring up the point that you were alone, but I already knew this, and just put you through this little exercise of self discovery for your own good! There is a God issue with this. I am tempted to ask, how many more of these little exercise am I going have to go through?

    3. My question is about the initiative in the God man dialogue. "thus presum'd" is this the beginning of a dialogue with a God who up to this point is a rational conclusion/vision? This is a rationalistic God, not the revealed God the Biblical Tradition.

    4. As new wak't from soundest sleep Soft on the flourie herb I found me laid In Balmie Sweat, which with his Beames the Sun [ 255 ] Soon dri'd, and on the reaking moisture fed. Strait toward Heav'n my wondring Eyes I turnd, And gaz'd a while the ample Skie, till rais'd By quick instinctive motion up I sprung, As thitherward endevoring, and upright [ 260 ] Stood on my feet;

      Adam movement to self awareness is through an encounter with nature. His experience with nature tells him who he is and leads him to his Maker. Or so it seem. He is wide eyed innocent.

    5. For I that Day was absent, as befell, Bound on a voyage uncouth and obscure, [ 230 ]

      Raphael missed witness the creation of man, because he was else where. The matter of what and how angels know is a fairly esoteric inquiry. But Milton raises the point, so it should be said that the classic understanding of angels as "pure intellect," means that angelic knowing is not bound by time and space. Milton angels are mythic, not theological.

    6. Thee I have heard relating what was don Ere my remembrance: now hear mee relate My Storie, which perhaps thou hast not heard; [ 205 ] And Day is yet not spent; till then thou seest How suttly to detaine thee I devise, Inviting thee to hear while I relate,

      The only thing that is missing is a pint. If Eve is curious, Adam is garrulous. Swapping yarns with angels.

    7. Yet went she not, as not with such discourse Delighted, or not capable her eare Of what was high: such pleasure she reserv'd, [ 50 ] Adam relating, she sole Auditress; Her Husband the Relater she preferr'd

      Eve does not share Adam's curiosity or his desire to listen to Angels! She preferr'd to listen to Adam, because she could divert him when it got to heavy! Clearly sexist, Much beyond the Biblical text Milton is interpreting.

    1. All things proceed, and up to him return, [ 470 ] If not deprav'd from good, created all Such to perfection, one first matter all, Indu'd with various forms, various degrees Of substance, and in things that live, of life; But more refin'd, more spiritous, and pure, [ 475 ] As neerer to him plac't or neerer tending Each in thir several active Sphears assignd, Till body up to spirit work, in bounds Proportiond to each kind.

      This idea of things proceeding first matter is a form of monism which is problematic because existence is not a creation, but a emanation. This is the view of Neoplatonism which influenced Augustine, but he rejected, in favor of creation ex nihilo. What is at stake is creation ex nihilo produces an other which means the spirituality is relational. Full weight is given to the otherness of God, which it seems to me is something that Milton undercuts.

    2. In favour and præeminence, yet fraught With envie against the Son of God, that day Honourd by his great Father, and proclaimd Messiah King anointed, could not beare Through pride that sight, & thought himself impaird.

      The act of anointing a messiah, of creating a Son of God on might Zion here serves as the motivation of the Angel of Light, Satan's, rebellion.

    3. The grosser feeds the purer, Earth the Sea, Earth and the Sea feed Air, the Air those Fires Ethereal, and as lowest first the Moon; Whence in her visage round those spots, unpurg'd Vapours not yet into her substance turnd. [ 420 ] Nor doth the Moon no nourishment exhale From her moist Continent to higher Orbes. The Sun that light imparts to all, receives From all his alimental recompence In humid exhalations, and at Even [ 425 ] Sups with the Ocean: though in Heav'n the Trees Of life ambrosial frutage bear, and vines Yield Nectar, though from off the boughs each Morn We brush mellifluous Dewes, and find the ground Cover'd with pearly grain: yet God hath here [ 430 ] Varied his bounty so with new delights, As may compare with Heaven; and to taste Think not I shall be nice. So down they sat, And to thir viands fell,

      Where does this concept of hierarchical feed come from? Is it pure Milton invention?

    4. And on, methought, alone I pass'd through ways [ 50 ] That brought me on a sudden to the Tree Of interdicted Knowledge: fair it seem'd, Much fairer to my Fancie then by day: And as I wondring lookt, beside it stood One shap'd and wing'd like one of those from Heav'n [ 55 ] By us oft seen;

      Eve's dream is already a preview of the temptation. If she can dream it before it happens, does it need to be acted out? Isn't she already "fallen."

    5. nly Abdiel a Seraph,

      The note explain the origin of Abdiel, seem to confirm my impress that name of individual and location commend themselves to Milton because of their obscurity and sound.

    1. DEscend from Heav'n Urania, by that name If rightly thou art call'd, whose Voice divine Following, above th' Olympian Hill I soare, Above the flight of Pegasean wing. The meaning, not the Name I call: for thou [ 5 ] Nor of the Muses nine, nor on the top Of old Olympus dwell'st, but Heav'nlie borne, Before the Hills appeerd, or Fountain flow'd, Thou with Eternal Wisdom

      The ref. to Urania to Salluste du Bartas the Huguenot 16th century poet is an interesting lead as what were Milton's sources. It would be an interesting study to compare Salluste's The Semenies with the treatment here. Salluste seems to stick closer to the text of Genesis, holds to the doctrine Creation ex nihilo, and is expository rather than fanciful.

    1. But list'n not to his Temptations, warne Thy weaker; let it profit thee to have heard By terrible Example the reward [ 910 ] Of disobedience; firm they might have stood, Yet fell; remember, and fear to transgress.

      Thus end Raphael sermon, which suggest that Book Six is modeled on the homiletic enterprise common in Milton day and religious circle in particular.

    2. Two dayes are therefore past, the third is thine; For thee I have ordain'd it, and thus farr [ 700 ] Have sufferd, that the Glorie may be thine Of ending this great Warr, since none but Thou Can end

      The third day is the Resurrection, so Milton has cast "the war in Heaven, as the three days quickly sped. The stalemate/wounding of the angelic host is a preview, or perhaps an allegory of the Crucifixion. Sending the Son out mount for battle follows closely 19:11 of the Book of Revelation, but the sword there is the word, not a weapon of "puissant" strapped to ones thigh. Milton's reading of Rev. is common in the militant use of the Book of Revelations.

    3. Yet soon he heal'd; for Spirits that live throughout Vital in every part, not as frail man [ 345 ] In Entrailes, Heart or Head, Liver or Reines; Cannot but by annihilating die; Nor in thir liquid texture mortal wound Receive, no more then can the fluid Aire: All Heart they live, all Head, all Eye, all Eare, [ 350 ] All Intellect, all Sense, and as they please, They Limb themselves, and colour, shape or size Assume, as likes them best, condense or rare.

      Milton invents a physiology of Angel, where in an angel can feel pain, but which is spontaneous healed. He is equal to later day sci fi invention of alien physiology. The problem however is that it is that it does not make angel's spiritual beings, But quasi-physical beings. In other words, he cheating! Calvin's theology especially draws a sharp line between spiritual operation and physical operation. This apples to the above comment "then Satan first knew pain."

    4. two dayes are past, Two dayes, as we compute the dayes of Heav'n, [ 685 ] Since Michael and his Powers went forth to tame These disobedient; sore hath been thir fight,

      The Heavenly wars has gone on for two days. Not two earthly days, but days as heaven computes them. The problem is divine action is eternity, even as human action is in time. The idea of heavenly time, is like quasi physical. This is metaphysical cheating. It does work.

    5. to subdue [ 40 ] By force, who reason for thir Law refuse, Right reason for thir Law, and for thir King Messiah, who by right of merit Reigns.

      The law to which obedience is owed is equated with "right reason. Right reason is assumed to be self evident. Both of these propositions are questionable, and even more problematic Those who have right reason are authorized to subdue by force those who reason for their law refuse!

    1. From thir own mouths; all is not theirs it seems: One fatal Tree there stands of Knowledge call'd, Forbidden them to taste: Knowledge forbidd'n? [ 515 ] Suspicious, reasonless. Why should thir Lord Envie them that? can it be sin to know, Can it be death? and do they onely stand By Ignorance, is that thir happie state, The proof of thir obedience and thir faith?

      Satan argues that "Knowledge forbidd'n is suspicious reasonless. can it be sin to know. How does Milton rebut this? Editor's note argue the sin is in disobedience, but this does not answer the point makes. Why does God makes this a criterion for obedience. Perhaps the issue turns on the way and timing.

    2. O Hell! what doe mine eyes with grief behold, Into our room of bliss thus high advanc't

      O Hell, God has done it again. Humans are beyond his angelic expectation. Even if the remain a little lower than the angels.

    3. Thence up he flew, and on the Tree of Life, The middle Tree and highest there that grew, [ 195 ] Sat like a Cormorant; yet not true Life Thereby regaind, but sat devising Death

      Wonderfully grotesque image, Even Poe like.

    4. The way he went, and on th' Assyrian mount

      This another the 3rd? journey motif which is a favorite of Milton's. It begins, with the Assyria Mount, line 126 and is complete line 180. Cape Horn, Mozambic, Sabean, Arabie, Asmodeus, Media, Aegypt! Then over the wall into Eden. The list seems to have more to do with sound than geography.

    5. O had his powerful Destiny ordaind Me some inferiour Angel, I had stood Then happie; no unbounded hope had rais'd [ 60 ] Ambition.

      Satan is arguing that his plight is God's fault .

    6. Of what he was, what is, and what must be [

      parody of God, He who was and is and is to come. Note in the divine formula is to come implies an open future, where the demonic future is not free, it is determined.

    1. I yielded, and unlock'd her all my heart, Who with a grain of manhood well resolv'd Might easily have shook off all her snares: But foul effeminacy held me yok't [ 410 ] Her Bond-slave; O indignity, O blot To Honour and Religion!

      I just so happens that in the course of reading from Morning Prayer the Sampson story came up. and recall thinking that he might have been strong and courage, but clearly not very bright. Does it occur to Milton that his hero blaming foul effeminacy is not very bright either?

    2. Had Judah that day join'd, or one whole Tribe, [ 265 ] They had by this possess'd the Towers of Gath, And lorded over them whom now they serve; But what more oft in Nations grown corrupt, And by thir vices brought to servitude, Then to love Bondage more then Liberty, [ 270 ] Bondage with ease then strenuous liberty; And to despise, or envy, or suspect Whom God hath of his special Favour rais'd As thir Deliverer; if he aught begin, How frequent to desert him, and at last [ 275 ] To heap ingratitude on worthiest deeds?

      Judah's fault in not backing

      Judah is to fault in not appreciating him and following his leadership. This blame is not in the Biblical text, so it is clear a theory of Milton, a mirror to his own sense of political betrayal.

    3. nd buried; but O yet more miserable! My self, my Sepulcher, a moving Grave, Buried, yet not exempt By priviledge of death and burial From worst of other evils, pains and wrongs, [ 105 ] But made hereby obnoxious more To all the miseries of life, Life in captivity Among inhuman foes.

      Reflection on his own blindness. If the grave language is stark it is not out of line with Puritan expectations of this life.

    4. The Sun to me is dark And silent as the Moon, When she deserts the night Hid in her vacant interlunar cave.

      What science is this? Does Milton pretend an archaic science for the sake of his poetic?

    5. Under the Seal of silence could not keep, But weakly to a woman must reveal it, [ 50 ] O'recome with importunity and tears. O impotence of mind, in body strong! But what is strength without a double share Of wisdom, vast, unwieldy, burdensom, Proudly secure, yet liable to fall [ 55 ] By weakest subtleties, not made to rule, But to subserve where wisdom bears command.

      clear expression of Milton's sense of the woman person

    6. Divine Prediction;

      Clue to Milton's sense of Providence: Prediction implies a specific design/outcome. Not a general embracing will for things to turn out right.

    1. Took leave, and toward the coast of Earth beneath, Down from th' Ecliptic, sped with hop'd success, [ 740 ] Throws his steep flight in many an Aerie wheele, Nor staid, till on Niphates top he lights.

      as in the end of the Book 2, there is an astronomy that seems not engaged with the science that was unfolding around him. He can reference Galileo telescopic lens, but his has not reoriented himself to the modern universe, and lives in a geography of his own contruction.

    2. s if predestination over-rul'd Thir will, dispos'd by absolute Decree [ 115 ] Or high foreknowledge; they themselves decreed Thir own revolt, not I: if I foreknew, Foreknowledge had no influence on their fault, Which had no less prov'd certain unforeknown.

      Milton assertion that predestination/foreknowledge has no influence human action, can only work if predestination/foreknowledge works on totally difference frames of reference. This would require remodeling what is meant by those term, something that Milton will not do. In the terms he explains it they necessarily control the actions.

    3. When Will and Reason (Reason also is choice) Useless and vain, of freedom both despoild, Made passive both, had servd necessitie, [ 110 ] Not mee.

      By in large Milton has reduced Reason to an act of will, thus will defines being human. Something is missing in being human when this is done. Life is reduced to obey or disobey.

    4. inds a place since call'd The Lymbo of Vanity; what persons and things fly up thither;

      A contrivance which allows Milton to fudge on the problem how and angel condemned to Hell and find his way into to earth.

    1. O Progeny of Heav'n, Empyreal Thrones, [ 430 ] With reason hath deep silence and demurr Seis'd us, though undismaid: long is the way And hard, that out of Hell leads up to light; Our prison strong, this huge convex of Fire, Outrageous to devour, immures us round [ 435 ] Ninefold, and gates of burning Adamant Barr'd over us prohibit all egress.

      With the decision to go after God by means of corruption the new created humanity, Milton faces a perplexing problem, how to get Satan out of hell and into the world. Given the premises thus far there does seem to a way to accomplish this and I don't think Milton ever attempts a clear answer, instead with line 430 begins a long and convoluted recapitulation of all the heroic journey's of ancient lore. Now clearly, Satan is the classic hero! But does this elevate Satan, or denigrate the classic hero. In Christian tradition there are two takes on the ancient world, Origin's which sees a pre-revelation, and Turtellian who see it corruption. It takes no less than 600 lines for him to come upon "this pendant world." Certainly not some of the most memorial lines of Milton's poetry!

    2. n circuit, undetermind square or round, With Opal Towrs and Battlements adorn'd Of living Saphire, once his native Seat; [ 1050 ] And fast by hanging in a golden Chain This pendant world, in bigness as a Starr Of smallest Magnitude close by the Moon.

      Alas the goal is in sight! What a wonderful. "The pendant world.

    3. Suppose he should relent And publish Grace to all, on promise made Of new Subjection; with what eyes could we Stand in his presence humble, and receive [ 240 ] Strict Laws impos'd, to celebrate his Throne With warbl'd Hymns, and to his Godhead sing Forc't Halleluiah's; while he Lordly sits Our envied Sovran, and his Altar breathes Ambrosial Odours and Ambrosial Flowers, [ 245 ] Our servile offerings.

      Does Mammon anticipate the Christian dispensation and the resulting worship, warbl'd hymns" and they make fun of it? Mammon the demon of worldly materialism would at the time of Milton, as now, be in on this scorn. Where is Milton in this? Does he suggest as Augustine that the devil could be saved

    4. Love this line! It is an example Milton's rhetorical brilliance, joining adjective and nouns that seem to roll off the tongue and at the same time utterly nail it.

    5. Satan's argument is that Divine Law has created first the angels of light, namely himself, and second created free will. Free will is a key theological idea which is hotly debated and Milton seems to come down strongly on side that free will cannot be lost. Not even Satan lost it! So there is always a question of what to do with it now.

    1. There went a fame in Heav'n that he ere longIntended to create, and therein plantA generation, whom his choice regardShould favour equal to the Sons of Heaven:

      The creation of humankind was not known by the angels as something God would do and in making equal to angels, was jealousy created which added to the rebellion on some part of them?

    2. In Fable or Romance of Uthers Son [ 580 ]Begirt with British and Armoric Knights;And all who since, Baptiz'd or InfidelJousted in Aspramont or Montalban,Damasco, or Marocco, or Trebisond,Or whom Biserta sent from Afric shore [ 585 ]

      Uther's Son is King Arthur, so what does Milton think of king Arthur and how does his poetic fit with the romantic poetic, Walter Scott and Tennyson's Idylls of the King, which will fallow in the next century.

    3. Long before human parliaments invented closed sessions to do the "public's business" the demonic crew were masters of it. My favorite line of Book One is "The great consult began."

    4. Consult how we may henceforth most offendOur Enemy, our own loss how repair,How overcome this dire Calamity,What reinforcement we may gain from Hope, [ 190 ]If not what resolution from despare.

      Ironic, I think. The Fallen Angel has just rejected Satan's proposal of out right war as a bad idea. It would end in a disaster all over again. So he calls for a consultation of the fallen demons, one might say that he is call for a Parliament, which can come up with a better idea! I would rather suspect that Milton has in mind the "success" of resent English Parliament, as I might have of the US Congress, as he will unfold this grand consult. Love it!

    5. Long after known in Palestine, and nam'd [ 80 ]Beelzebub. To whom th' Arch-Enemy,And thence in Heav'n call'd Satan, with bold wordsBreaking the horrid silence thus began.

      Satan breaks silence and counsels the "fallen angel" that he with them should return to war outright against heaven.

      Call this possibility number 1

    6. If then his ProvidenceOut of our evil seek to bring forth good,Our labour must be to pervert that end,And out of good still to find means of evil;

      The common solution to theodicy is to argue that God/Providence sought to use evil to do good. The argument is rather lame since good should not require evil to be good. Moreover the poet is convinced that the Fallen Angel is smart enough not to let his get by with that.

    7. the unconquerable Will,

      Is an assertion the what constitutes being is will. Hence will is a beings soul, its immortality. . This a serious narrowing of the tradition where knowing/illumination was at least coordinate with will.

    8. Such place Eternal Justice had prepar'd [ 70 ]For those rebellious, here thir Prison ordain'dIn utter darkness, and thir portion setAs far remov'd from God and light of Heav'n

      The bite of position is that darkness, sulphuric Prison is ordain, prior to the act of rebellion and not in reaction to it. Does such a preordained punishment, preordain the act of rebellion? A dreadful thought.

    9. I may assert Eternal Providence, [ 25 ] And justifie the wayes of God to men.

      This what is called Theodicy something many attempt with difficulty. What seem unique here is he is answering the question, before he explores the subject matter. The answer is Eternal Providence, that everything was foreknown and had to happen just the way that it did. No surprises. Hence there is no narrative.