129 Matching Annotations
  1. Jan 2018
    1. Son of the Church

      Throughout a lot of these he seems to hit really hard on hypocrisy between words and actions, or in this case between actions and intentions.

    2. Upon the whole we must not judge of one another by their best Actions; since the worst Men do some Good, and all Men make fine Professions: But we must judge of Men by the whole of their Conduct, and the Effects of it. Thorough Honesty requires great and long Proof, since many a Man, long thought honest, has at length proved a Knave. And it is from judging without Proof, or false Proof, that Mankind continue Unhappy

      This just sounds like a Ben Franklin quote, do we know where he took this from?

    3. and if he have not enough, you may borrow some to make up a sufficient Quantity

      This whole section reminds me of the gothic recipe from Walker's Hibernian Magazine for January 1798 ("take an old castle, half of it ruinous")

    4. N.B. Mrs. Dogood has lately left her Seat in the Country, and come to Boston, where she intends to tarry for the Summer Season, in order to compleat her Observations of the present reigning Vices of the Town.

      This is such a great addition.

    5. after much meditation on the Eighteenth verse of the Second Chapter of Genesis

      "Then the LORD God said, 'It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him a helper as his partner.'"

    6. our Sex, and deny’d me no Accomplishment that could possibly be attained in a Country Place; such as all Sorts of Needle-Work, Writing, Arithmetick, &c. and observing that I took a more than ordinary Delight in reading ingenious Books, he gave me the free Use of his Library, which tho’ it was but small, yet it was well chose, to inform the Understanding rightly, and enable the Mind to frame great and noble Ideas.

      This is the first time I could guess at the gender.

    7. I shall never be able to forget; for as he, poor Man, stood upon the Deck rejoycing at my Birth, a merciless Wave entred the Ship, and in one Moment carry’d him beyond Reprieve. Thus, was the first Day which I saw, the last that was seen by my Father; and thus was my disconsolate Mother at once made both a Parent and aWidow.

      This sounds like a scene from Romances of the period.

    8. So much so that the colonial government in Massachusetts frequently attempted to censor the newspaper and jailed James Franklin several times when he published articles that were thought to defame public officials (Cotton Mather, for example)

      Political and publishing coming into more direct contact again.

    9. it is testimony to how widely influential the Spectator was that even in colonial America, teenaged boys reading it and taking it as a model for their own writing

      Would Franklin count as an outlier? I assume he would be much more well read than most teens a the time.

  2. Feb 2016
    1. GEORGE Lord Lansdown

      George Granville, 1st Baron Lansdowne of Bideford, was an English poet, playwright, and politician, who served in the House of Lords and was the British Secretary of War from 1710-1712. He was also an early patron of Pope, hence the dedication.

    2. Exil’d by thee from earth to deepest hell,

      The following segment is a reference to Milton's Paradise Lost where various evil things are personified and placed in hell, such as Sin and Death.

    3. Red Iber’s sands, or Ister’s foaming flood

      The Iber is an old Roman name for the Ebro river in Spain, while the Ister is the Danube river, which flows through several countries in central Europe.

    4. The winding Isis and the fruitful Tame:

      The Thames was personified as the offspring of two other rivers, the Thame and the Isis. This idea would later become popular in Victorian London.

    5. purple deaths

      Purple deaths referring to the Plague of 1665, the Great fire of London, and all the civil wars that followed. Many believed that these events were God's revenge for the beheading of Charles I.

    6. Henry

      Henry VI was the ruler that saw England through the end of the Hundred Years War, and also the king at the start of the War of the Roses. He was eventually deposed and murdered in the tower of London.

    7. Edward’s acts

      Probably reffering to King Edward III of England (ruled 1327-1377) who started the Hundred Years War and was known for his remarkable military feats.

    8. Fair Geraldine, bright object of his vow, [295] Then fill’d the groves, as heav’nly Myra now.

      Geraldine and Myra were fictitious women to whom both Surrey and Granville addressed their love poetry.

    9. Surrey

      Henry Howard, Earl of Surrey, was one of the founders of rennaisance poetry and was a first cousin of both Anne Boleyn and Catherine Howard, the second and fifth wives of King Henry VIII.

    10. To sing those honours you deserve to wear, And add new lustre to her silver star.

      "Honours" and "silver star" are references to the Order of the Garter, though Granville was never admitted to it.

    11. Cowley’s

      Abraham Cowley was another mid 17th century poet, and is considered a poetic prodigy, with his first great work being published when he was only 10 years old.

    12. Cooper’s hill.

      Cooper's hill overlooks London and Windsor Castle, and was the focus of John Denham's poem of the same name, which is of the same kind as Windsor Forest.

    13. Such was the life great Scipio once admir’d, [255] Thus Atticus, and Trumbal thus retir’d.

      Scipio - Scipio Africanus was the Roman General who defeated Hannibal. </p>

      Atticus - Quintus Caecilius Pomponianus was a Roman editor and banker who is best known as being a good friend of Cicero, to whom he wrote under the cognomen Atticus.

      Trumbal - Sir William Trumbull was an English ambassador and secretary of state who was close friends with both John Dryden and Pope.

      All three of these men are connected by the fact that they retired peacefully from public life.

    14. Po

      The Po, Eridanus in Latin, is a large river which flows across northern Italy. It is also connected with the Eridanus constellation, which was said to be caused by Phaethon as he careened across the sky in his father Apollo's chariot, hence its winding appearance.

    15. Thro’ the fair scene rowl slow the ling’ring streams, [215] Then foaming pour along, and rush into the Thames.

      This is another allusion to Ovid, this time to the myth of Io, which starts by describing several rivers and streams flowing down to the sea from the mountains. This description serves as a means of transitioning from the myth of Dapne to the myth of Io, as the rivers are unsure of whether or congratulate or console Daphne's father for her transformation, with only Io's father being absent, thus setting up the story explaining his absence.

    16. laves

      To bathe or wash, in the 13th century it also referred to being covered in blood or sweat, creating a slightly dated irony in this line as Diana is actually bathing in Lodona's body (of water).

    17. Lodona

      Pope is creating a myth about a nymph named Lodona, whose father is the Thames. The river Loddon is a tributary of the Thames, hence the distinction. This myth is derived from the story of Apollo and Daphne told in Ovid's Metamorphoses, as the daughter of a river god is chased by a lustful god. Even the language itself is copied directly from Ovid, with only the names changed. This happens most obviously in lines 186-194 which is a direct copy of the Ovidian myth, with Thames supstituted in for Peneus.

    18. spirits

      At the time, there was a belief that the organs of the body produced subtle spirits that helped it to function properly, in this line Pope is saying that in this golden age a combination of youth and purer spirits caused men to roam the hills more freely. The idea of spirits comes up in Pope's other works as well, such as An Essay on Criticism lines 77 and 208.

    19. swain

      A country or farm laborer, originally an old English word for a young man who attends to a knight, the late 16th century saw a change in meaning towards rustic workers such as shepherds and foresters.

    20. Granville commands; your aid O Muses bring! [5] What Muse for Granville can refuse to sing?

      George Granville, Pope's patron for this piece, is commanding the muses to help Pope write. These two lines parody the lines from Virgil shown above.

    21. Nimrod

      In Hebrew and Christian tradition Nimrod was the king who built the tower of Babel to usurp God. It should be noted that this may be a reference to Milton's Paradise Lost, XII 24-44, where he also draws parallels between the English monarchy and the biblical story.

    22. vain; The swain with tears his frustrate labour yields

      Game from royal hunting grounds would often ravage nearby farms, thus rendering the farmer's efforts "in vain."

    23. savage laws

      Trespassers on royal hunting grounds were tried in special forest courts, often cruelly. Examples include bowmen having fingers cut off and poachers being blinded.

    24. Pan

      Pan was the Greek god of wildlife, shepherds, and, in many tales, a companion of the nymphs. He takes the form of a satyr and therefore has the upper body of a human and the legs and torso of a goat.

    25. Let India boast her plants

      Many spices and other rare plants were imported from the Indies during this time period. Pope makes a reference in the next line to the power of the English navy at the time by bringing up the oak cargo ships that transfer these Indian plants.

    26. harmoniously confus’d

      Traditional European gardens were incredibly neat and logically arranged, but the introduction of the sharawadgi aesthetic led to many gardens becoming more "organic" in appearance. In this line Pope is furthering the idea of Windsor Forest being the ideal garden by moving from the idea of Eden to more modern gardening techniques.

    27. Muse’s

      The nine muses of Greek and Roman mythology were said to bring inspiration in the fields of literature, science, and art. Many classical writers begin their works with an invocation to the muses, as does Pope here when he asks the Muses to "invite my lays."

    28. Non injussa cano: Te nostræ Vare myricæ Te Nemus omne canet; nec Phoebo gratior ulla est Quam sibi quæ Vari præscripsit pagina nomen. Virg.

      "I do not sing unbidden: of you, Varus, our tamarisks (shrubs) and our groves all sing; there is not a any page more pleasing to Apollo himself than those which the name Varus is prescribed" from Virgil's Eclogues book VI lines 9-12. (rough translation)

    29. Windsor

      Windsor Forest is a royal preserve to the west of London. Historically a royal hunting ground, the park began to change into more of a garden and retreat during the 18th century due to the efforts of Charles II and others.