41 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2020
    1. "He wrote on science like a Lord Chancellor,"

      Does this indicate a more artistic style to the science, if not I'm honestly not sure what it means.

    1. Initially skeptics had grumbled that Humboldt was so Frenchified he had probably forgotten his native German

      interesting take, kinda relevant to my current hypothesis regarding Humboldt's accessibility to the modern reader.

    2. In short, the study of nature creates and bonds the human community and gives us the strength to resist the social pathologies that would tear us apart.

      Fascinating idea, I personally find it rather accurate but I wonder if the environmental disconnect of modern society has lessened the impact of nature on human communities.

    3. Humboldt’s status as an icon was so great that for some years after his death a high-stakes game was played over how to define his legacy

      This attitude doesn't seem to have fully survived to the modern day.

    1. The quantity of heat received by a planet, and whose unequal distribution determines the meteorological variations of its atmosphere, depends alike upon the light-engendering force of the sun; that is to say, upon the condition of its gaseous coverings, and upon the relative position of the planet and the central body.

      Hmmmmmm, climate change!!!!

    2. The superficial half-knowledge, so characteristic of the present day, which leads to the introduction of vaguely comprehended scientific views into general conversation, also gives rise, under various forms, to the expression of alarm at the supposed danger of a collision between the celestial bodies, or of disturbance in the climatic relations of our globe

      Humboldt is quite focused on this topic. It is undoubtedly compelling though he does seem to tred the same ground in different words on occasion.

    3. he history of science teaches us the difficulties that have opposed the progress of this active spirit of inquiry. Inaccurate and imperfect observations have led, by false inductions, to the great number of physical views that have been perpetuated as popular prejudices among all classes of society.

      I'm begining to suspect Humboldt had some sort of future sight, either that or our current society is rather ignorant of the pattern of attitudes towards scientific study clearly present throughout human history.

    4. Recent researches have rendered it very doubtful whether the primitive seat of Hindoo civilization — one of the most remarkable phases in the progress of mankind — was actually within the tropics

      Humboldt seems to have a vested interest in a variety of sciences. This quote for instance indicates Humboldt was at least partially interested in anthropology.

    5. Mont Blanc

      I know this was, and still is, a literal mountain but it's also the name of a poem by Percy Shelly, This man should be considered a romantic poet.

    6. the magic power exercised upon our minds by the physical world, since the character of the landscape, and of every imposing scene in nature, depends so materially upon the mutual relation of the ideas and sentiments simultaneously excited in the mind of the observer.

      The reverence with which Humboldt describes nature is downright inspiring.

    7. The dogmas of former ages survive now only in the superstitions of the people and the prejudices of the ignorant, or are perpetuated in a few systems, which, conscious of their weakness, shroud themselves in a vail of mystery.

      Did Humboldt just accurately predict modern attitudes toward's climate change?

    8. He who can trace, through by-gone times, the stream of our knowledge to its primitive source, will learn from history how, for thousands of years, man has labored, amid the ever-recurring changes of form, to recognize the invariability of natural laws, and has thus, by the force of mind, gradually subdued a great portion of the physical world to his dominion

      Damn solid insight into man's relationship with nature.

    9. The subject before me is so inexhaustible and so varied, that I fear either to fall into the superficiality of the encyclopedist, or to weary the mind of my reader by aphorisms consisting of mere generalities clothed in dry and dogmatical forms

      this is genuinely pretty funny but also rather self aware. Yet, although he acknowledges it his writing is still a bit to close to an Encyclopedia for my personal enjoyment.

    1. “He keeps  coming back to the trip to the Americas time and  again,” says Kutzinski. “It is a touchstone . . . it is always there,  always on his mind.”

      hmm, studying Humboldt has honestly come as a surprise, I hadn't thought we'd be focused more on literature written by Americans, yet Humboldt work is undeniably American despite his European origins.

    2. Latin Americans and Europeans are more likely to know of Humboldt’s legacy than  people in the United States

      Anecdotal but this quote definitely rings true to my experience (or lack there of) with Humboldt and his work.

    3. we no longer consider as unworthy of our attention anything that diverges from the style that the Greeks bequeathed to us through their inimitable models”  can be seen as a direct challenge to the European sense of cultural superiority.

      kinda sad that this idea is still rather controversial in certain spheres of modern society.

    4. “The unequal distribution of animals across the globe has had  a profound impact  upon the lot of peoples and  their more or less rapid  march toward civilization.”

      Increadably progressive idea we are still grappling with. Funny in a sad way to think that some modern people still haven't grasped this concept.

    5. After pointing out that many Andean peaks are indeed higher than Mont Blanc

      Again I wonder about romantic connections, I am beginning to suspect that Romantic science has a different list of significant figures than Romantic poetry despite them both being romantic literature.

    6. “It is quite rare for this postman to lose letters or get them  wet on his way from Ingatambo to the residence of the governor of Jaén.”

      Is this fiction or biography? Because it seems to be a true account considering Humboldt's body of work yet the story is rather absurd.

    7. He proposed that profits be shared with slaves to give them an incentive to increase agricultural wealth and that public funds be set aside to buy slaves’ freedom. Humboldt’s ideas so infuriated officials in Havana that they banned his book.

      Again, Humboldt appears to have ideals in line with the great romantic authors, why is he not considered among them in literary circles?

    8. Humboldt wrote  prolifically about  the condition of slaves on the island and sought to demonstrate that slavery could not be justified even on economic grounds.

      Humboldt appears to be a man ahead of his time in a wide variety of ways.

    9. His star may rise again with the efforts of the Alexander von Humboldt in English project.

      Does English here refer to literature or the language, or both?

    10. Charles Lyell, Louis Agassiz, Franz Boas, and  Samuel  Morse.

      I may need to update my knowledge of 19th century scientists. Can't say I recognize any of these names.

    11. “If you really want  to have a notion of tropical  countries, study Humboldt,” wrote Charles  Darwin,

      Humboldt as the basis for future scholars seems to be a central idea in studying his life and work

    12. “a high-minded scientific decorum that forbade him from violating anyone’s privacy, including his own.

      Why bother writing a personal narrative at all if you don't want to include any human emotion or significant personal details?

    13. a Romantic sense of the sublime,  and  the values—though not the bloodshed—of the French  Revolution.

      Would Humboldt's writings be considered romantic literature? He fits the time period and this author claims his writings contain the sublimity of romantic work, but his focus on science seems to have removed him from the discussion of significant romance authors, at least from a literary perspective.

    14.  Personal Narrative of a Journey to the Equinoctial Regions of the New Continent,

      Seems like a text worth exploring if I wish to dive deeper into Humboldt

    15. the preeminent scientist of his day

      I'm curious about this claim, while it could be true among more learned circles in the modern day, the general public seems to have little knowledge of Humboldt even if exposed to his concepts.