43 Matching Annotations
  1. Nov 2020
    1. Washington made two concerted attempts to re-enslave Ona. First, while still in office, he sent a letter through Secretary of the Treasury Oliver Wolcott, Jr. to Joseph Whipple, Portsmouth’s collector of customs.

      Why did Washington try so hard to capture Ona again? Couldn't he have just bought another one? Does he feel like his precious material object has run away and in order to ensure the safety of his product (and possibly the products of everyone else) then he would feel accomplished? What I am trying to say here is, if the president can't get his slave back then who can? People might see this and think slavery is a dangerous investment. Which could explain Washingtons response to getting Ona back.

    2. “As there was no suspicion of her going off nor no provocation to do so, it is not easy to conjecture whither she has gone, or fully, what her design is.”12“Runaway Advertisement,” Frederick Kitt, Philadelphia, 24 May 1796. Of course, it never occurred to the Washingtons that enslavement served as plenty of provocation for Ona to escape. They believed they had treated her like a daughter and felt betrayed by her departure.

      It is interesting what giving a slave some level of respect can do to that slaves character. Even in this instance you can see that their treatment of Ona is likely what facilitated her idea of freedom because of her greater understanding of the world than other slaves who are restricted. I again, connect this to Fredrick douglas who had the world opened to him when he first learned to read through his only "nice" slave owners who happened to have children who also read. Through this he manifested the knowledge to fight his way to freedom similar to Ona.

    3. Her friends in the free black community had already carried her belongings to the port and they were waiting for her when she arrived at the docks.

      All those people in this community likely risked their lives in a very scary way in order to secure Ona's safety,

    4. At some point during the spring of 1796, Ona made contact with members of the free black community that would facilitate her escape. There are no records of how she was introduced to this community or who helped her, and Ona kept this information secret to protect everyone’s safety.

      These free slaves still had to keep their recruitment of their community a secret. Even though it was significantly less criminalized to be a slave in the North.

    5. Ona said “she was determined never to be her slave,” referring to Eliza Custis.8“Washington’s Runaway Slave,” Granite Freeman, T.H.A., May 1845. Eliza had earned a reputation among the enslaved women for being highly volatile and erratic—dangerous qualities in a slave owner. Finally, Ona may have worried about Law’s questionable reputation. When Law arrived in Philadelphia, he brought his two illegitimate children that he had fathered while in India and he was plagued by rumors about his character. Given Ona’s enslaved status, any white man could sexually assault her without punishment and she may have feared for her safety in a new household with a disreputable owner.9Erica Armstrong Dunbar, Never Caught: The Washingtons' Relentless Pursuit of Their Runaway Slave, Ona Judge (New York: 37INK, 2017), 95-97. Show Me More

      This section of the paragraph highlights how Ona anticipates how she'll be treated with the changes in masters. It is clear that from merely hearing a rumor and her suspicion being confirmed. Tells us how brutal those times were towards slaves where if you are to hear a rumor about someones character it is likely true, especially in regards to slavery where there are no bounds.

    6. wore out her shoes while accompanying Martha on her visits. Moll, the enslaved nanny for Martha’s grandchildren, did not usually join them out of the house, so she likely needed fewer pairs of new shoes.

      This might be insight into how Ona was able to secure her freedom. From this bit it is implied she travels more frequently out of the home, letting her plan her escape.

    7. Ona also accompanied Martha on her social visits and attended to the first lady’s needs at home. Ona’s status as Martha’s preferred lady’s maid meant that she received a fancier wardrobe than most enslaved people because she visited homes and buildings normally off-limits to enslaved people. Much like George’s enslaved manservant, coachmen, and postilions, these individuals wore fancy livery because their uniforms needed to reflect the president’s wealth and status; Ona’s clothing was an extension of Martha’s status.

      I believe there is something to unpack here. The fact is, Ona was being treated better than most other slaves. Yet despite this, she still felt her need to become free. This highlights how much change and dire magnitude for freedom slaves encompass once seeing the north, that even being given a "nice" life in comparison to other slaves is not satisfactory. Which of course makes sense.

    8. When Martha brought Ona to the President’s House, Ona left her family for the first time. It must have been incredibly scary for sixteen-year-old Ona to travel to New York City, a place she had never visited before. But New York City, and then Philadelphia, offered new opportunities.4In 1789, the new federal government was located in New York City. Washington, his family, and his enslaved workers lived in two different homes in New York City until the summer of 1790. In November 1790, they moved into a new house in Philadelphia when the government relocated. After his election, John Adams resided in the same house in Philadelphia, before moving into the White House in Washington, D.C. on November 1, 1800. Ona encountered a sizable free African-American community for the first time, saw interesting sights, tasted different foods, and met new people. For example, in June 1792, she attended the theater;

      Once slaves are exposed to the lives of other free slaves, their need to become free is extenuated. I connect this to Fredrick Douglas who went through a similar path to becoming free. I believe he saw how life was like for a black man in the north and was immediately compelled by it.

    9. While the newspapers did not print the interviews verbatim, the quotes are rare examples of a formerly enslaved person describing their experiences in their own words. Few enslaved workers left written records, let alone participated in interviews with reporters. Whenever possible, this article uses Ona’s words to tell her remarkable story.

      The quotes are likely to be one of the few primary sources other than slave trade ship logs that we can use to assess slavery. If only the newspaper printed the interview verbatim.

    10. lived with Betty in a small cabin near the mansion house, completing simple chores, helping her mother with easy tasks in their cabin, or playing unsupervised with other enslaved children.2Mary V. Thompson, “The Only Unavoidable Subject of Regret”: George Washington, Slavery, and the Enslaved Community at Mount Vernon (Charlottesville: The University of Virginia Press, 2019), 158-67. When Ona was twelve, Martha brought her into the mansion house to begin her official training as a housemaid.

      This answers the question of at what age are slaves bound to brutal work? This bit tells us that at least in this case scenario, the proper age is 12. While their lives prior to that consist of smaller household chores and playing unsupervised with other enslaved children.

    11. Betty, gave birth at Mount Vernon to a daughter named Ona Judge.1Ona was often called Oney by the Washingtons, but later in life introduced herself as Ona, so we have followed her preference. It was common practice for slave owners to give their enslaved workers nicknames that ended in”y” to subtly infantilize adult men and women. Ona’s father was Andrew Judge, a white indentured servant who was employed on the estate.

      Interestingly, this is how most of the slaves in America grew in rapid growth. It wasn't because they were sent here, but because of the generational growth slavery had in America. Ona judge is one of the results of this phenomenon.

    1. Allen, an abolitionist who was born enslaved, had moved to Philadelphia after purchasing his freedom. There he joined St. George’s, where he initially preached to integrated congregations. It quickly became clear that integration went only so far: He was directed to preach a separate service designated for black parishioners. Dismayed that black people were still treated as inferiors in what was meant to be a holy space, Allen founded the African Methodist Episcopal denomination and started the Mother Bethel A.M.E. Church.

      It is especially interesting that during the second great awakening people started to see how brutal slavery was even though prior the Church directly profited from it somehow. How was did this realization not come sooner? People (espicially masters) used slaves as preachers to preach to the other slaves, opening their eyes to the shared religion where they understand in essence that Slavery (even by these white men words) was wrong. Thus starting the true route towards freedom.

    2. Sugar cane was a brutal crop that required constant work six days a week, and it maimed, burned and killed those involved in its cultivation. The life span of an enslaved person on a sugar plantation could be as little as seven years

      Before the industrial revolution the labor required to produce and sell such products was very brutal fo many people. Thus could this be the main reasoning behind slavery to begin with. The difficulty of cultivating these crops associated with the high death rate turned Europeans off to cultivating it themselevs so they forcibly used another's population to conduct such orders. It makes me wonder why sovereignty wasn't something that Africa argued for, because it was something the Portuguese were clearly defying. By this time I would imagine Sovereignty had already become a enacted international law between European states. Maybe this shows how those rules ONLY pertain to European states, and open to elsewhere.

    3. through the creation of a Virginia law in 1662 that decreed that the status of the child followed the status of the mother, which meant that enslaved women gave birth to generations of children of African descent who were now seen as commodities. This natural increase allowed the colonies — and then the United States — to become a slave nation.

      What made the slave trade even more profitable is almost as because it truly is a degree of farming. From cultivating flowers to make offspring, or to have cattle make offspring for more products, the slave trade was the same. And a large factor in why America ended up having such a large population of slaves in the coming futures.

    4. allowing them to secure political positions and determine the fate of the nation.

      Slavery was used as a means of hegemony for many of these countries. Which is very interesting, not just because of the securing of political positions through very unpolitical means, but also because of how the slave trade skyrocketed the economies of many of the countries that took part in it.

    5. The slave trade provided political power, social standing and wealth for the church, European nation-states, New World colonies and individuals.

      I'm somewhat curious as to how the slave trade profitted the church. How would that be so? I thought it was through the labor market slavery truly made the profit from. How did the church profit? If anything with more thorough understanding you would think slavery worked severely against the church. Even though the pope affirmed it.

    6. Enslaved people did not meekly accept their fate. Approximately one out of 10 slave ships experienced resistance, ranging from individual defiance (like refusing to eat or jumping overboard) to full-blown mutiny.

      This bit shows that the slaves did not go without swinging. One out of 10 is a rather strong ratio for resistance in my opinion. Makes me wonder whether or not if other slaves knew of some of the successful revolts whether or not they would be more willing to revolt themseleves. (although the conditions of these slaves were so dire they were probably to weak to carry out the attacks for most of them.)

    7. Suicide attempts were so common that many captains placed netting around their ships to prevent loss of human cargo and therefore profit; working-class white crew members, too, committed suicide or ran away at port to escape the brutality.

      To understand that life had become so difficult it would be better to end it all than to persist through really highlights the brutality of it all. Espicially since the captains main concern was the lives of these slaves, so the prevention of their deaths while seemingly justified is really to ensure their profits. Adds to the really disgust of the trade in general.

    8. “The iron entered into our souls,” lamented a formerly enslaved man named Caesar, as he remembered the shackles he had to wear during his forced passage from his home in Africa to the New World. Used as restraints around the arms and legs, the coarse metal cut into captive Africans’ skin for the many months they spent at sea. Children made up about 26 percent of the captives.

      This bit I feel was included to truly show the analogy of slavery to cattle as we've seen before. Which is unsurprising because the slave trade is best compared to the selling and shipping of cattle. The forced restraints of the products.

    9. Njinga was forced to flee in the face of Portuguese attack. Eventually, however, she conquered a nearby kingdom called Matamba. Njinga continued to fight fiercely against Portuguese forces in the region for many years, and she later provided shelter for runaway slaves.

      As my general understanding, I thought that most of the African kings and queens allowed for their people to be taken from them for monetary purposes. However this bit was interesting for me for two reasons. It attacks my assumption that most kings and queens were okay with the slave trade, this shows some of them strongly resisted and even helped subvert the trade. And secondly how there were women queens who ruled in Africa at the time.

    10. Eventually other European nation-states — the Netherlands, France, Denmark and England — seeking similar economic and geopolitical power joined in the trade, exchanging goods and people with leaders along the West African coast, who ran self-sustaining societies known for their mineral-rich land and wealth in gold and other trade goods.

      This bit illustrates the massive profitability from the slave trade itself.

    11. It granted the right to invade, plunder and “reduce their persons to perpetual slavery.”

      The first time slavery was enacted to be legalized. While this might not be worth something mentioning, the legalization by the pope for slavery was something impactful for every country dictated by Catholicism then.

    12. In the 15th century, the Roman Catholic Church divided the world in half, granting Portugal a monopoly on trade in West Africa and Spain the right to colonize the New World in its quest for land and gold.

      This was the first instance of the initial startings of the slave trade. First started by the Portuguese and affirmed by the Pope.

    1. Slavery, rather than symbolic religious conict, may have provided the deepunderpinning of the southwestern events. Legal enslavement of AmericanIndians by Spaniards had been forbidden by royal decree since the mid-sixteenth century, but that did not stop the actual practice. So-called "justwars" provided one loophole, and on that basis Apaches, Utes, and otherswho refused to acknowledge Spanish authority were fair game for enslavers

      This is how the spainarids supposedlky enslaved the natives.

  2. Oct 2020
    1. I went up and down mourning and lamenting; and my spirit was ready to sink with the thoughts of my poor children. My son was ill, and I could not but think of his mournful looks, and no Christian friend was near him, to do any office of love for him, either for soul or body. And my poor girl, I knew not where she was, nor whether she was sick, or well, or alive, or dead.

      I believe the one thing that pains Mary the most is the thought of her children. She knows nothing about how they are doing and whether they are okay or not. I'm sure she constantly prays for them even though it hasn't been mentioned much. I believe that while she mentions she misses her old life, I feel the main component of her life she misses so much is her family and children. No mother can bear the though of not knowing whether or not their children are safe. Even if they are the ones who are in danger.

    2. yet not one of them offered the least imaginable miscarriage to me.

      What keeps Mary going is not only her religion but also her gratefulness. She constantly is reminding herself of how everything could be much worse and attributes that to God looking out for her.

    3. He answered me that he was not asleep, but at prayer; and lay so, that they might not observe what he was doing. I pray God he may remember these things now he is returned in safety.

      I would hope that Mary find some sort of thing to relate to in regards to the fondness of praying from this Native. Showing that they are not all that different in some regards.

    4. I offered the money to my master, but he bade me keep it; and with it I bought a piece of horse flesh. Afterwards he asked me to make a cap for his boy, for which he invited me to dinner. I went, and he gave me a pancake, about as big as two fingers. It was made of parched wheat, beaten, and fried in bear's grease, but I thought I never tasted pleasanter meat in my life. There was a squaw who spake to me to make a shirt for her sannup, for which she gave me a piece of bear. Another asked me to knit a pair of stockings, for which she gave me a quart of peas.

      The Natives here, treat her well in response to her doing some of their bidding. It is clear here that while there are natives that are subject to brutalizing her and starving her, there are many who feel sympathy for her. While this generally is very opposite to the conquests we studied prior of native captives.

    5. I was presently ready for another, such a bewitching thing it is.

      She uses her religion as a means of not getting addicted to Tobacco. Unfortunately not everyone in America shared this view or else the tobacco slave market wouldn't have been such a big hit. :/ Very unrelated, just a random point.

    6. "No," said he, "none will hurt you." Then came one of them and gave me two spoonfuls of meal to comfort me, and another gave me half a pint of peas; which was more worth than many bushels at another time.

      Another instance of Native sympathy.

    7. preserving us in the wilderness, while under the enemy's hand, and returning of us in safety again.

      Mary uses her religion to keep her spirit up even when all else seems to be against her.

    8. The cause of this rout was, as I thought, their espying some English scouts, who were thereabout.

      I'm curious as to why the Natives thought it would be a good idea to bring her to what sounds like an English stakeout to me.

    9. But before it was half ready they got half of it away from me, so that I was fain to take the rest and eat it as it was, with the blood about my mouth, and yet a savory bit it was to me: "For to the hungry soul every bitter thing is sweet."

      This in connection to another statement she made earlier, shows how the bar for what kinds of things she's willing to eat has changed now. To such a degree she truly doesn't care what it is. For any form of meat is likely to lead her to a happy day. The natives truly starved her. Mentally and physically.

    10. English cattle had been. That was comfort to me,

      Just the remnants of her English life brings her comfort and joy. It is clear that she hasn't been in normal life for a very long time and is beginning to be worn out by it.

    11. no Christian soul near me, and yet how hath the Lord preserved me in safety?

      For me, this illustrated that Mary believes anyone who hasn't submitted to Christianity is likely what she calls a "heathen".

    12. I went along that day mourning and lamenting, leaving farther my own country, and traveling into a vast and howling wilderness,

      As her time in captivity increases, Mary's morale has a decline. You can see it in this excerpt right here which to me illustrates her tiredness, her frustration, and her loneliness, She hasn't been back to her normal life in what probably feels like forever right now.

    13. And here I cannot but take notice of the strange providence of God in preserving the heathen.

      I'm not too sure what she means by this but I interpret it as her confusion as to why God has kept these natives alive when they are torturing her like this.

    14. I could think how formerly my stomach would turn against this or that, and I could starve and die before I could eat such things, yet they were sweet and savory to my taste.

      Being in captivity for so long, Mary has found her taste in things starting to change. In my perspective, her expirience has set the bar very low for the things she enjoys eating. While before her stomach might turn at eating a horse, now and with time in captivity, it is probably one of the more enjoyable foods she can eat. Example of how beggars can't be choosers.

    15. "When thou passeth through the waters I will be with thee, and through the rivers they shall not overflow thee" (Isaiah 43.2).

      Mary frequently relates portions of her life during this time to any form of a Bible excerpt she finds relatable. It makes me wonder if she is usually this religious or if having her life threatened is what pulls out this frequent religiosity. Like does she normally relate everyday events to Bible excerpts? Is this something many people did then?

    16. The occasion (as I thought) of their moving at this time was the English army, it being near and following them. For they went as if they had gone for their lives, for some considerable way, and then they made a stop, and chose some of their stoutest men, and sent them back to hold the English army in play whilst the rest escaped.

      This bit illustrates the Natives fear and alertness regarding the English army. From this excerpt alone you can tell the Natives are paranoid.

    1. In 2016, months of national polls confidently showed Hillary Clinton ahead, and set many Americans up for a shock on Election Night, when the Electoral College tilted decisively in Trump’s favor

      This was in regards to the unforseen future to the linkage of the past.