Transaction Governance:
Who controls the transaction and what are the rules?
Transaction Governance:
Who controls the transaction and what are the rules?
transaction
how the whole system of exchanges works
horizonta
These are related products offered alongside the main one, often creating a “bundle” or “one-stop shop.”
vertical
These are add-ons that support the main product, often along the value chain.
overnance modes beyond hierarchies and markets
These aren't just "buying" or "doing it yourself"—they are complex, collaborative, in-between structures.
TCE is criticized for not having enough to say about these "hybrid" structures, which are essential in today’s economy.
moral hazard
after a contract is signed. It happens because of hidden action. You cannot perfectly monitor the other party, so they act differently (usually lazily or recklessly) once they are protected by a contract
hold-up
It happens during a relationship where you have made an investment that is only useful if you stay with that specific partner. -> lock in
adverse selection,
ccurs before a contract is signed. It happens because of hidden information. One party in the deal knows something the other party doesn't, which leads the uninformed party to make a bad decision.
new economy" and the "old economy"
(1) Traditional firms go digital Banks → online banking Retailers → e-commerce
(2) Dot-coms build real-world capabilities Logistics Warehousing Customer service
compared to dot-coms adopting traditional methods
Dot-coms = digital natives
Competitive Pressure
Finally, competitive pressure has a different impact depending on the group analysed.
countries with a high level of e-commerce, it is positive but not significant
Countries with low level of e-commerce, it has a negative and significant impact. -> competitive pressure has a negative impact on the decision to use e-business.
So, H8 is rejected in both groups.
Firm Size (H5)
reject
“Firm size is a key factor that influences the level of e-business use only in countries with a low level of e-commerce adoption.”
In low e-commerce countries: Firm size does matter BUT the direction is opposite of the hypothesis
Independent Variables:
Perceived benefits: Scale 1–4 (impact of ICT)
Firm size: Categories based on employees
IT expertise/ Customer pressure/ Supplier pressure/Competitive pressure: Dummy
Control Variables
they affect all there organizational implications
long tail of preference distribution
many niche (less popular) products that individually sell little, but together make up a large share of total demand
Hard infrastructure characteristics
Think of hard infrastructure as “what the platform technically allows or restricts.”
It includes things like:
The platform’s code and architecture
What users can or cannot do
How content is structured, accessed, and shared
ose and pay auditors rather than have the supplier do s
many companies reduce costs by requiring their suppliers to pay for audits—and some even allow suppliers to choose the auditor -> “penny wise and pound foolish.”
Rotate auditors or audit firms
demonstrates the importance of fresh eyes.
Align the activities of the purchasing department and the social responsibility team.
Suppliers that failed an audit improved only after linking the future of the business relationship to the supplier’s labor standards by coordinating the activities of its own purchasing and social responsibility departments.
When those departments were siloed, as they are in many companies, failing suppliers made no improvement.
Announce audits in advance
Although companies want a full picture of what’s going on at their suppliers, they also want their suppliers to improve.
Serving once-tarnished buyers
Because such buyers are particularly worried about facing similar criticism in the future
More likely to be cautious when selecting new suppliers and to step up efforts to scrutinize them
Such suppliers should be attractive to companies with unblem- ished records, which can piggyback on the due diligence of their once-compromised counterparts.
Avoidance of piece-rate compensation.
Workers can ignore labor standards because following them can reduce productivity and earnings
Unions.
Union
enable workers to make management aware of hazards + share proposals for mitigating
Help manager communicate with workers about health and safety standards and reinforce adherence to desired procedures.
doption of lean management.
After a factory adopted the lean system
→ Managers less likely to mistreat workers, more focus on retention
-> increase workers’ skills -> better employment terms to retain workers
ertified compliance with management system standards
Require internal audits + continuous improvement systems
Promote cross-functional problem-solving + action plans
an reinforce or undermine
Countries with high NGO density + strong media freedom (greater exposure of abuses) -> more improvement
Less oversight environments (e.g., Bangladesh, China) → require closer monitoring
Higher transparency environments (e.g., Honduras, Jordan) → relatively better improvement outcomes
Factories differ in working conditions + willingness/ability to improve → Need firm-level predictors (factors inside an individual company)
Interorganizational Relationships
a global company should allocate 20 percent of its efforts to the buyer category, 30 percent to the customer category, and 50 percent to the client category in the downstream/outbound portion of the chain.
Role of Just-In-Time Inventory
Pros:
The major cost savings comes from speeding up inventory turnover (how quickly a company sells and replaces its inventory) -> reduces inventory holding costs, such as warehousing and storage costs.
The company can reduce the amount of working capital it needs to finance inventory, freeing capital for other uses and/or lowering the total capital requirements of the enterprise.
Other things being equal, this will boost the company’s profitability as measured by return on capital invested.
Improve product quality: parts enter the manufacturing process immediately -> defective inputs to be spotted right away. -> then be traced to the supply source and fixed before more defective parts are produced.
global internal purchasing
Ex: Germany plant buys parts from its own Vietnam subsidiary
➡ Internal (same company)
➡ Global (different countries)
external
from sources outside the company
Internal
from sources within the company
integrated across worldwide locations and functional groups
Full integration across:
locations
functional groups (e.g., R&D, production, logistics)
overall supply chain management strategy
Not fully integrated across all locations
Different units may act somewhat independently
3
information
2
protection
1
performance
Unit-load packaging
palletizing, shrink-wrapping, or containerization
opportunity cost
Does the firm have the capacity to produce the product at a cost that is at least no higher than the cost of buying it from an external supplier?
And if the product is made in-house, what opportunity cost would be incurred as a result (e.g., what product or item was the firm unable to produce because of limited production capacity)?
ead factory
This is where cutting-edge production should take place or at least be test for implementation in other parts of the firm’s production network
Implies that managers and employees at the site have a direct connection to and say in which suppliers to use, what designs to implement, and other issues that are of critical importance to the core competencies of the global firm
outpost factory
Selecting countries for operations based on the countries’ strategic importance (knowledge, competition, networks) rather than on the production logic (cost efficiency) of a location.
Potentially enhancing the position of the global firm in strategic countries is sometimes viewed as a practical factor.
contributor factory
Has much more of a choice in terms of which suppliers to use for raw materials and component parts
Often competes with the global firm’s home factories for testing new ideas and products
Stand-alone in terms of what it can do and how it contributes to the global firm’s supply chain efforts.
A source factory
a source factory is at the top of the standards in the global supply chain
these factories are used and treated just like any factory in the global firm’s home country
Global learning
Foreign factories that upgrade their capabilities over time are creating valuable knowledge that might benefit the whole corporation
Flexible machine cells
Machine cell:
A grouping of various types of machinery, a common materials handler, and a centralized cell controller.
Each cell normally contains four to six machines capable of performing a variety of operations.
The typical cell is dedicated to the production of a family of parts or products.
The settings on machines are computer controlled, which allows each cell to switch quickly between the production of different parts or products.
Improved capacity utilization arises from the reduction in setup times and from the computer-controlled coordination of production flow between machines, which eliminates bottlenecks.
The tight coordination between machines also reduces work-in-progress inventory.
The ability of computer-controlled machinery to identify ways to transform inputs into outputs while producing a minimum of unusable waste material.
minimum efficient scale of outpu
Example 1: Aircraft manufacturing Fixed costs: extremely high (factories, R&D, engineering) -> MES: very large
You must produce a lot to be efficient But global demand is relatively limited
=> Build only a few factories globally, centralize production
Example 2: Soft drinks (SMALLER MES) MES: relatively small
=> You don’t need huge output to be efficient Demand exists in many countries
=> Build many local factories worldwide, Produce close to customers
16.5.5 Buyback
Occidental Petroleum builds ammonia plants in Russia
Russia doesn’t fully pay in cash. Instead, Occidental receives ammonia (the product) for 20 years
👉 So the payment = real products, not just money
6.5.4 Switch trading
counterpurchase credits: used to purchase goods from that country
For example:
a U.S. firm concludes a counterpurchase agreement with Poland for which it receives some number of counterpurchase credits for purchasing Polish goods.
The U.S. firm cannot use and does not want any Polish goods, however, so it sells the credits to a third-party trading house at a discount. The trading house finds a firm that can use the credits and sells them at a profit.
Offset
gives the exporter greater flexibility to choose the goods that it wishes to purchase
Counterpurchase - Same buyer / specific firm
Offset- Any firm in that country
16.5.2 Counter purchase
China pays the U.S. firm in dollars, but in exchange, the U.S. firm agrees to spend some of its proceeds from the sale on textiles pro- duced by China. Thus, although China must draw on its foreign exchange reserves to pay the U.S. firm, it knows it will receive some of those dollars back because of the counterpur- chase agreement.
16.5.1 Barter
Barter is mainly used in special situations, such as one-time deals for trading partners are:
Not trustworthy
Not creditworthy (can’t be relied on to pay money)
👉 In these cases, companies prefer goods over risky cash promises.
6.3.3 Bill of Lading
The bill of lading can also function as collateral against which funds may be advanced to the exporter by its local bank before or during shipment and before final payment by the importer.
(The exporter can use the bill of lading (B/L) to borrow money from their bank before getting paid)
The exporter give B/L to the bank, bank will NOT release the B/L to the importer unless:
Payment is made, OR
A promise to pay (draft acceptance) is given
The first one can also be traded between banks so that the buying bank can make a profit
Exporter gets a banker’s acceptance worth $10,000 (due in 60 days)
Instead of waiting 60 days, they sell it to a bank for: $9,800 today
The bank waits 60 days and receives: $10,000 👉 Bank profit = $200
🧠 Why does this happen? Exporter wants cash now Bank is willing to wait and earn interest
banker’s acceptance can be bought and sold between banks, and the buying bank earns profit by purchasing it at a discount and receiving full payment later.
Export agents, merchants, and remarketers
Compare to Export trading company Export agents, merchants, and remarketers act as independent resellers, they own the product and control everything after purchase
Export trading companies export products for companies that contract with them.
They identify and work with companies in foreign countries that will market and sell the prod- ucts. They provide comprehensive exporting services, including export documentation, logistics, and transportation.
Compare with EMC represent your company to sell your product, export trading company act as an intermediary and buys/sells for profit on their own (You usually have less control over how products are marketed)
Customs brokers
can offer a firm a complete package of services that are essential when a firm is exporting to a large number of countries