16 Matching Annotations
  1. Aug 2023
    1. Text:"When the Board of Trustees was making the decision to start admitting women, they received many negative letters from alumni and students’ parents. Many of them outlined the biggest risk the university took when going co-ed – losing donations."

      Comment: As I delve into the history of Washington and Lee University, I find myself fascinated by the societal dynamics that once resisted the admission of women. The concern about losing donations if the university went co-ed demonstrates a remarkable snapshot of societal values during that era. It's intriguing to think that a step towards equality could be viewed as a threat to institutional identity and financial stability. Yet, I'm delighted to note that today, women constitute the majority of the student population at W&L. This prompts me to question what cultural shifts and negotiations happened to reach this point and to celebrate the courageous decisions that have allowed us to progress. These historical accounts fuel my curiosity to better understand our past while they strengthen my conviction to continually advocate for an even more inclusive future.

    1. In the beginning, the founder, Matthew Vassar, along with student accounts do not seem to mention accessibility at all. Vassar College was first and foremost a women’s college, and the construction of the buildings were meant to serve the able-bodied students that were able to attend the college. In particular, topics such as “Committee”, “Funds”, and “Office” paint a narrative in which the college was primarily focused on getting itself established within the Hudson Valley as an all-women’s institution, with not a single mention of accessibility with regards to disabled individuals.  As the timeline progresses, particularly to past the enactment of the Rehabilitation Act of ‘73, the specific mention of disabled individuals, at the time known as “handicapped”, was more prevalent, with special mention to the number 504– the section of the act that stipulated these rights given to people with disabilities. While words particular to the administration persisted, similarly to the founding period of Vassar, there is also a new focus upon the actual need for campus officials to conform to these rules and regulations, with topics like “compliance”, “accessibility”, and most importantly, the recognition of “prejudice” on campus against those who are less abled bodied.

      These historical reflections highlight a crucial issue: inclusivity and accessibility are not merely contemporary topics; they are long-standing, ongoing challenges, embedded deeply within the fabric of our societies. Tracing back the roots of institutions like Vassar and Hamilton College, we witness the evolution of accessibility dialogue, but more importantly, we're led to ponder upon the stagnant narratives that persistently sideline marginalized communities. By exploring these visualizations, I'm drawn to a curious inquiry of our past and a generous commitment towards fostering a more inclusive future. The compelling intersection of history, accessibility, and social equity poses a myriad of thought-provoking questions that deserve our earnest attention and action.

  2. Jul 2023
    1. My data cleaning first involved transcribing the texts to the greatest degree of accuracy. The texts in the Jasper Parrish Papers span the 18th and 19th centuries and bear archaic spelling and grammar conventions. Therefore, I translated these elements into modern English to create a consistent dataset.

      I agree with the decision to transform the text into modern English as part of the data cleaning process. Dealing with historical texts from the 18th and 19th centuries, which often contain archaic spelling and grammar conventions, can be quite challenging. By translating these elements into modern English, you have not only improved the accuracy and readability of the dataset but also created a consistent foundation for further analysis. This smart move ensures that the insights extracted from the Jasper Parrish Papers are more accessible and relevant to contemporary audiences, making your research all the more valuable and insightful.

    1. Then we had to convert the format of our articles before importing them to Voyant. Since the newspaper issues from my school, The Amherst Student, were in PDF format, I had to extract specific articles and save them in Word format. This was extremely time consuming because when I pasted content from PDF files into a Word document, the original formatting changed. Some words and paragraphs simply went missing, and I had to manually type them. I wonder if there is automated text extraction software designed specifically for old newspapers and/or manuscripts.

      I completely relate to the challenges of dealing with lengthy and irrelevant transcribed data. Automated text extraction software tailored for historical documents would be a game-changer, saving time and ensuring accuracy. Analyzing valuable content from old newspapers and manuscripts would become more efficient and insightful with such advancements.

    1. Methods Topic modeling: We will use Voyant to see how race has been discussed in the context of college admissions, using tools such as Scatterplot, Trends, Loom, Microsearch, Cirrus, Phrases, Collocation, and so on. Close reading: We will analyze articles or statements that address affirmative action (or more broadly, race and college admissions) Timeline: We will use tools like TimelineJS to create a timeline of major Supreme Court decisions on affirmative action and other related incidents on campus  Mapping: We would like to incorporate mapping in our project but are not sure how and will discuss this further in our next weekly meeting. Some tools we could use if we do decide to do mapping are Google Maps, Tableau, and ArcGIS.

      I find the project pitch intriguing and well-structured. The combination of topic modeling, close reading, timeline creation, and mapping holds promise for comprehensive insights into race and college admissions. I'm eager to collaborate with the team, refine our approach, and address this significant and sensitive subject thoughtfully.

    1. In Hamilton’s case, this goes to the extent in which prospective students with mobility limitations repeatedly require golf carts to complete tours, whilst injured students require campus security to attend classes.

      I'm struck by the stark portrayal of accessibility issues at these esteemed institutions. It's disheartening to see the challenge faced by students with mobility impairments due to the antiquated infrastructural setup. The text emphasizes the need for urgent reforms to foster inclusivity, making me reflect deeply on the broader implications of accessibility in our society.

    1. Very few novels, films, or other aesthetic works follow a unidirectional or linear flow. Mapping "temporality"—relational time—requires subtler tools, ones that arise from an experience-based approach to time. It would be hard to imagine charting Remembrance of Things Past on a natural history timeline meant to track the breeding cycles of fruit flies!

      Though I agree that linear timelines do not effectively represent the complex temporality in a work of literature or film. I believe the goal should never be about having perfect data analysis and visualization of a topic, subject, or concept. Rather, I believe that the goal of data analysis should be about providing the best-possible visualization and data-study rather than perfect analysis. There still should be a form of data visualization whatever the constraints may be. Benig more open about the shortcomings of a visualization tool in a particular realm, tells a richer and fuller story about the existing complexities and irregularities of the humanities sector.

    1. I looked up the word “women” in the “Contexts” tool and skimmed through the sentences that included the word. For instance, Amy says, “Women should learn to be agreeable, particularly poor ones; for they have no other way of repaying the kindnesses they receive.” In another instance, Alcott writes about how exhausted Meg is exhausted because of chores, saying “Want of exercise robs them [mothers who are oppressed under housework] of cheerfulness, and too much devotion to that idol of American women, the teapot, makes them feel as if they were all nerve and no muscle.”

      Reading through Alcott's use of "women" really hit home for me. I could see the pressures and expectations that women of her time faced, particularly those related to domestic duties. It was a stark reminder of how societal norms have shaped women's lives. Amy's advice to be agreeable and Meg's exhaustion from chores made me reflect on how some aspects of these pressures persist even today. It's a thought-provoking journey into the past that also holds a mirror to our present.

    1. digital humanists offer the jaundiced realization that computational techniques like topic modeling — long held inaccessible and unapproachable and therefore unassailable — are not an upgrade from simplistic human-driven research, but merely more tools in the ever-growing shed

      This comment challenges the notion of technological optimism in digital humanities. It emphasizes that computational techniques, including topic modeling, do not replace human-driven research but instead provide additional tools for scholarly exploration. The critical engagement of digital humanists reflects a balanced perspective on the integration of computational methods within the humanities discipline.

    1. “culture”: This column is an example of missing data – 14967 out of 17075 of them are blank, or 87.7%. Is this a good or bad thing for contextualization? Does a blank cell avoid bias or cause more confusion by leaving the interpretation open? I believe by investigating how the “culture” is determined and entered by the collections staff at the museum, we can better determine whether the blank cells are an issue of an incomplete picture or an intentional acknowledgment of uncertainty.

      I completely agree with your perspective on the blank cells in this column. The high percentage of missing data, 87.7%, is indeed significant. Whether it is a good or bad thing for contextualization depends on how the "culture" field is determined and entered by the museum's collections staff. By investigating their processes, we can gain insight into whether the blank cells indicate an incomplete picture or an intentional acknowledgment of uncertainty. This understanding will allow us to make more informed interpretations without bias and contribute to a more accurate contextualization of the data.

  3. Jun 2023
    1. For example, the Haverford 2020 Student Strike Collection provides a blurb summarizing the event. It could improve the user experience to include a paraphrased version of the League’s Letter and all other related item descriptions. Finally, the League Letters does not have a PDF version to utilize the text, further limiting access.

      I completely agree with you here. I also believe that summaries of pivotal events do not usually do a good job at explaining how impactful and how necessary such an event is. And obviously, not having the League Letters in PDF version makes it prone to unrecoverable data losses.

    1. *Race as technology is both the imposition of a grid of control and a lived social reality in which kinship with technology can be embraced. Importantly, it displaces ontological questions of race— debates of what race really is and is not, focused on separating ideol- ogy from truth—with ethical questions: what relations does race set up? As Jennifer Gonzalez has argued, race is fundamentally a ques- tion of relation, of an encounter, a recognition, that enables certain actions and bars others. The formulation of race as technology also opens up the possibility that, although the idea and the experience of race have been used for racist ends, the best way to fight racism might not be to deny the existence of race, but to make race do dif- ferent things. *

      Viewing race as technology offers a unique perspective that challenges fixed understandings of race. It shifts the focus from debates about its essence to ethical considerations of the relationships it establishes. Embracing race as a malleable construct opens up possibilities for transformative action against racism. Rather than denying its existence, this approach encourages harnessing race to achieve different outcomes. By reshaping the functions and effects of race, we can work towards dismantling systemic inequalities and fostering a more inclusive society. It invites us to explore the potential for race to be a force for positive change and social justice.

    1. There are two main advantages to the digital format of this project. Firstly, it allows for the use of video storytelling, which is integral to the project.

      I agree that the digital format of the project provides distinct advantages, notably through the integration of video storytelling. This crucial component brings the narratives to life as the authors vividly act out their experiences, establishing an intimate and profound connection to Scarborough and the overarching theme of aging. The use of personal video collages adds depth and authenticity to the project, immersing the audience in a compelling visual narration.

    1. In this book, we draw heavily from intersectionality and other concepts developed through the work of Black feminist scholars and activists because they offer some of the best ways for negotiating this multidimensional terrain

      This quotation highlights the importance of intersectionality, a concept developed by Black feminist scholars and activists, in understanding the complex dimensions of identity and oppression. By acknowledging how race, class, gender, and other intersecting factors shape individuals' experiences, it becomes clear that a one-size-fits-all approach to feminism or activism is insufficient. Incorporating intersectional perspectives allows for a more comprehensive analysis and practice that recognizes the interlocking systems of oppression and the diverse realities of women across different backgrounds.

    2. But it would be Darden herself, as a Black woman with technical expertise.d-undefined, .lh-undefined { background-color: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.2) !important; }, working at a federal agency in which sexism and racism openly prevailed.d-undefined, .lh-undefined { background-color: rgba(0, 0, 0, 0.2) !important; }2Michela Banks, ethan chang, who demonstrated that the ideological mission of the United States—as a land based on the ideals of liberty, equality, and opportunity for all—was far from accomplished

      This quotation emphasizes the significance of Christine Mann Darden's presence and achievements as a Black woman in a field and institution marked by sexism and racism. Darden's accomplishments not only advanced data science but also challenged the prevailing inequality within the United States. Her story serves as a reminder that the country's ideal of liberty, equality, and opportunity for all is still a work in progress, and individuals like Darden play a vital role in breaking barriers and pushing for change.

    1. Digital humanities thus grows specifically out of an attempt to make “humanities computing,” which sounded as though the emphasis lay on the technology, more palatable to humanists in general.

      The excerpt highlights the origin and purpose of the term "digital humanities." The term emerged from the need to reframe "humanities computing" in a way that would be more appealing to humanists by shifting the emphasis away from the technology itself. This reflects the broader aim of integrating computing technologies into traditional humanities disciplines. The term "digital humanities" serves as a unifying concept for scholars who use digital tools and methods to explore traditional humanities questions or investigate the impact of digital technologies on humanistic inquiry. By embracing the term, the field seeks to bridge the gap between technology and the humanities, creating opportunities for interdisciplinary collaborations and innovative scholarship.