124 Matching Annotations
  1. Jun 2022
    1. This student path is almost always individualistic in nature and requires a level of sacrifice that most teach-ers themselves are loath to make.

      I see some of the older generation saying how they feel bad for the younger people because their generation messed things up and now it's up to us to deal with the repercussions. This reminds me of that. People give us advice that they haven't or wouldn't even do themselves. It's unfair and unrealistic, and if we can't meet their expectations we end up feeling really bad about ourselves.

    2. McCain’s insinuation that this election signifies the “end of racism” (D’Souza, 1995) is mythmaking

      Absolutely! This was just one step but there is still such a long way to go for racism to truly ever end. Especially with the hate crimes as of recently and the election of Trump that brought out white supremacists from hiding.

    3. It is akin to what Martin Luther King Jr. (1963) referred to as “the tranquilizing drug of gradualism” (para. 5): an individualistic up-by-your-bootstraps hyperbole that suggests if urban youth just work hard, pay attention, and play by the rules, then they will go to college and live out the “American dream.” I

      Sometimes I feel like this hope is what we are reading and writing about in these college courses. We talk about all these "if we can just get all teachers to do this and all students to do that, we will have a peaceful and happy world." But the reality is much harsher than this and I feel like sometimes these classes can be a little too idealistic.

  2. May 2022
    1. NCLB’s definition also only recognizes the teacher as the main educator of students, but MPS understands that students have other teachers in their lives. Family members like my grandfather teach us life lessons all the time, so shouldn’t they be recognized as educators too? Should academic excellence and credentials weigh more than personal connections?

      I agree with MPS's sentiment that school teachers are not the only people students learn from. Nowadays, kids spend a majority of their time online, over going to school and spending time with their family. Good or bad, students learn so much from their favorite youtubers and celebrities.

    2. When you ask them to think about their greatest teachers, they tell you not about degrees or credentials, but about teachers who pushed them to think critically, held them to high expectations with challenging work, knew their family members, and acknowledged and valued their identities, com-munities, and histories by making classroom lessons relevant to their ever y-day lives

      This goes back to my first question that asks what determines if a teacher can be considered "high quality." Sure, credentials and numbers are important, but people who lack actual experience working with kids will struggle with teaching no matter how well they personally did in school or on tests. It is true that when you meet people you focus more on the things they do and their personal qualities instead of what their gpa was in high school.

    3. process allowed the students to name the key qualities present or ab-sent in the teachers who had taught them significant lessons in their lives. They then had to consider what teacher qualities would allow replication of these positive learning experiences for other young people

      This is an interesting activity. I like how it goes a step further and asks the students to think about what the teacher can do to support their learning as opposed to just stopping at what you have learned. It would be interesting to see what students consider important and impactful. I would predict that it would be more related to life lessons than academics but I am unsure.

    4. NCLB also focuses on highly qualified teachers and how to prepare, train, recruit, and support them. But the media and legal dis-course concerning NCLB does little to further the public’s understanding of how teacher quality affects students.

      I would like to know what the government and NCLB considers to be "highly qualified teachers." Is it a subjective score like a number on a test or is it based on experiences where they helped children. Is there a list of standards and how was that list made?

    1. Teachers and students co-created unitsthat simultaneously enhanced students’ writing skills andengaged students and teachers in a collaborative effort toaddress the threat of the construction of a waste transferstation in their community.

      This is a really cool project that I wish my school implemented. I did not have a lot of opportunities to work with my teachers on a project but I think it would have been great to create a closer relationship with the teacher. You also become more motivated and interested in the topic. What you learn from it sticks with you and what they did holds a lot of value.

    2. Based on their workwith youth in these settings, Ginwright and Cammarota(2007) conclude that neighborhood organizations arevital in helping urban youth develop what they refer toas critical civic praxis—“ a process that develops criticalconsciousness and builds the capacity for young peopleto respond and change oppressive conditions in theirenvironment”

      What happens when the child's neighborhood is not racially or philosophically diverse? Nowadays, people are very untrusting of others and do not really get to know their neighbors. In my personal experience, there were not a lot of opportunities for community based work.

    3. Multicultural education is a process of comprehensiveschool reform and basic education for all students. It chal-lenges and rejects racism and other forms of discrimina-tion in schools and society and accepts and affirms the plu-ralism (ethnic, racial, linguistic, religious, economic, andgender, among others) that students, their communities,and teachers reflect. Multicultural education permeatesschools’ curriculum and instructional strategies as wellas the interactions among teachers, students, and familiesand the very way that schools conceptualize the natureof teaching and learning. Because it uses critical peda-gogy as its underlying philosophy and focuses on knowl-edge, reflection and action (praxis) as the basis for socialchange, multicultural education promotes the democraticprinciples of social justice (Nieto & Bode, 2008; p. 44)

      I wonder if multicultural education is interchangeable with the term "critical race theory" that encourages students to learn about systemic racism and how it could affect their present lives. Similarly, critical race theory should be taught in schools because otherwise, history would repeat itself.

    4. de juresegregation,resulting in a two-tiered system with stark contrastsin resources and opportunities for White students andstudents of color.

      This is the first time I've heard of "de jure segregation." I found that it is intentional segregation enforced through discriminatory laws and policies. This is different from de facto segregation because it is unintentional discrimination that comes from the states.

    1. One middle school teacher in a New York public school described "good faith" assignments that enable students to be the expert by having them write narratives about themselves

      This is a really cool idea. I wish some of my teachers did this in high school. I always preferred teachers who would ask to learn more about us than the ones that just started with the school work right away.

    2. a culturally relevant pedagogy-one that resear es the individual growth of students, celebrates their culture honors engag . ' culture of others, and analyzes real-world issues-produces significantly tbe t r outcomes for students of color.5

      This is a really cool concept but I wonder how do we incorporate this in really diverse schools with multiple cultures. For example, the video we watched in class had students from a Black community that had strong ties to hip hop culture. What do we do for schools where there are some black students, asian students, latinx, native american etc. How do we find one specific similarity in all cultures to center all of our curriculum around that?

    3. If I don't like school now, why would I go to more school? If school is boring and I don't see myself reflected in what I'm learning and its relevance to my life, then why_ go for more?

      This question is hard for adults to answer for children. I would respond with "it will help you in the future" but children don't really have the foresight neither the purpose to think about the future. I try saying things like Learning is fun or it will make you smarter! I think the answer should depend on the child and what they value. Some kids want to look smarter than others so you could say, "you go to school so you can answer questions and not look dumb" (i know this is kind of blunt but i think we should be a little more blunt and straightforward with kids instead of sugarcoating everything)

    4. The idea that students of color from disadvantaged backgrounds cannot compete at the same level is erroneous. Although individual experiences and home environments influence student achievement, research shows that school environments play an increasingly vital role in preparedness for college and career attainment.

      This is interesting because I often heard in high school that your skin color can make you more or less likely to be accepted into a college. I was told that students of color, specifically Latinx or Black, may have a higher chance of acceptance to increase the school's percentages of diverse ethnicities. This study is saying this is not the case, but rather how a school prepares students for college. This makes sense. Some schools do a good job at prepping students while others rarely take the time to explain.

    1. Finley and Diversi make an important point: ~any believe people are home1ess due to an ethos of irresponsibility or bad choices. This inaccu-rate view also applies to many people who live in poverty. Unfortunately, this perception leads some to believe that people deserve to be in the situ-ations they are.

      This is so important! We tend to make judgements without ever talking or trying to understand a person's situation. I personally believe that everything happens for a reason and that people do not just make bad choices to make bad choices, rather something happened to them or they experienced something that misshaped they world view. We need more compassion and empathy.

    2. fight against poverty in education requires dis-trict-and school-level leaders who are committed to several fundamental principles in serving children who are living in poverty and their families.

      It is interesting to see how much of an impact poverty has on one's quality of life including something so specific as their performance in school. It affects how well they listen to their teachers, how much they study outside of school, their control and focus because of nutrition, etc.

    3. I have concluded that some district leaders and even some principals are not really committed to reforming their policies and practices for the sake of students living in poverty, primarily because they believe what I once did: that if individual ' teas:hers teach more effectively, student learning will improve

      There is a lot of pressure for teachers to be these amazing role models, highly intelligent beings who are also aware of cultural, social, environment, and political issues, all the while practicing and modeling kindness, open discussion, anti-bullying policies etc. Perhaps we should focus more on how to improve the children's live to make them more agreeable and open to learning. How do we approach that?

    4. N1any of them want and expect teachers to be excellent in their individual classrooms without thinking seriously about what is essential from them, as leaders, to promote, ensure, and sustain teacher effectiveness.

      There is a heavy focus on the logistics of the structure of education as opposed to thinking realistically what the classrooms are like on the inside. We can say things like classroom sizes, diversity, and inclusivity but it's much easier said than done. More emphasis should be placed on how teachers are actually teaching classrooms.

    1. final assignments for these units usually consisted of some sort of performance or presentation that allowed students to take ownership of the knowledge production process. There was also some form of interrogation built into these presentations, usually from the students who were not pre-senting

      Presentations are better in tests as it's more similar to how in the real word we have to work together in a group, collaborate, communicate, and present our ideas to one another. Tests may be a good measure of how much you remember about certain concepts, but a presentation shows that you understand it well enough it explain it to someone else.

    2. Nothing promotes border crossing or tolerance more than helping students to arrive at an implicit understanding of what they have in common with those they have been taught to perceive as differ-ent.

      I agree with this. Connection is more important than memorization which is often more emphasized in education due to standardized testing. Memorization questions are easier to grade and score than bigger picture questions but bigger picture questions lead to greater mastery.

    3. firmly committed to freedom and social change that we were able to motivate students to develop sophisticated academic literacies.

      The autonomy to choose what social issues are important to you would increase a student's interest and therefore their dedication to academic work. Choice is important.

    4. it became important to include critical literary theories and multicultural readings of canonical texts that empowered stu-dents as readers and did not defer to the authority of the texts

      I agree with this sentiment because the U.S. is so diverse and many want to know more about their home countries and how it relates to America. Growing up Asian American, it was hard to actualize U.S. history information because I couldn't relate to any of the figures I was reading about. I wasn't interested in it either. But I think introducing multicultural texts can help ethnic students be more interested and engaged in their courses.

    1. If the student population was unique, so was the school’s physical space. Operating in a repurposed supermarket, the building was primarily one large open room, where classes were separated with blackboards and partitions; one teacher estimates that there were 20 to 25 quasi-cubicles throughout the building that would be organically arranged by students and teachers each day (Campbell, 2015)

      It is kind of crazy to see that oppression was so prevalent that educators has to resort to using an old supermarket to teach black students or students who did not agree with the racist teachings of Euro-centric schools. It is inspiring to see people go to whatever lengths they have to to fight for the right cause.

    2. “Even the person with the most contrasting point of view is my friend—better yet, my brother,” wrote James Rogers, class of 1969 (Bey-Grecia, 2015; Stan-dard Oil of New Jersey, 1970

      This is a great sentiment. Being met with different opinions is a good thing, not a bad thing. You want to challenge your own thoughts and you want to hear new perspectives because there is always another side to a situation that you may not consider. I like surrounding myself with different people with different outlooks because it helps me stay aware that I am not always right.

    3. Still other students had con-sciously left school because they felt marginalized for being interested in Black culture and politics, feeling unwelcome in Eurocentric-focused class-rooms where “they were continually forced to conform to a system of values which they had no part in forming”

      This is a very valid reason to want to drop out of school. It takes a lot of bravery to speak up and take action and actually drop out. Some people continue to conform to avoid confrontation and fighting. But real change starts with real action. It is very courageous that these students knew with confidence that what they were learning was nonsense and that they did not want to tolerate it any longer.

    4. Upon hearing about discussions of a new school in Harlem, Bayard Rus-tin, renowned civil rights leader and chief organizer of the 1963 March on Washington, declared his support for starting this “new enterprise,” mak-ing clear that Harlem Prep would “demonstrate that the dropout—and the black youth—have the same capacity as the white youth”

      It still shocks me how people used to think this way. How they used to think that skin color somehow determined how smart or dumb you were. That is the most illogical and unreasonable belief to ever exist yet it remained prevalent for centuries and some people still hold this belief today. Skin color has nothing to do with one's level of intelligence.

  3. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Rather than viewing the world through rose-colored glasses, antiracist multicultural education forces teachers and students to take a long, hard look at everything as it was and is, instead of just how we wish it were.

      Our education system should encourage vulnerability and open discussions about heavy topics such as racism and prejudice. Only this way do we actually make change instead of tiptoeing about real issues.

    2. Antiracism, indeed antidiscrimination in general, is at the very core of a multi-cultural perspective. It is essential to keep the antiracist nature of multicultur~ education in mind because, in many schools, even some that espouse a multi-cultural philosophy, only superficial aspects of multicultural education are apparent.

      Considering the recent horrible mass shooting in Boston, I think multicultural education is more important than ever. Social media is dangerous and in the wrong hands it can be used to give someone very harmful and wrong messages. That is why schools should implement antiracist education so that tragedies such as this one does not occur again.

    3. We don't need multicultural education here; most of our students are White." "I don't see color. All my students are the same to me." "We shouldn't talk about racism in school because it has nothing to do with learning. Besides, it'll just make the kids feel bad." "Let's not focus on negative things. Can't we all just get along?"

      I can see why people would say these things and want to keep educational topics light hearted. But this isn't the reality of the world. When we ignore all the violence and discrimination in the past, we hurt more people than we heal. I acknowledge that it can feel uncomfortable for white students who might feel attacked when they learn about these topics. But to be ignorant and then encounter people of color in the future and know nothing about their history will have them feeling even more uncomfortable.

  4. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. o know, to care, and to act in ways that will develop and foster a democratic and just society in which all groups experience cultural democracy and cultural empowerment.

      I really like that "to care" is included in the goals of transformative curriculum. We are often fed information from textbooks and lectures only caring about memorizing the highlights and not really internalizing the real difficulties and hardships people have faced. It is important for us to care about these different social issues because it can affect someone you meet or someone around you.

    2. Another frequently used approach to integrate cultural content into the curriculum is the additive approach. In this approach, cultural content, concepts, and themes are added to the curriculum without changing its basic structure, pur-poses, and characteristics. The additive approach is often accomplished by the addition of a book, a unit, or a course to the curriculum without changing its framework.

      I like this approach. I am a fan of progressivism and would like to see schools try to make history a more interactive experience for students to really empathize and understand what they are reading in their textbooks. Sometimes it is hard to believe that the people we are reading about are real.

    3. Feminists will continue to challenge the mainstream curriculum because many of them view it as malecentric, patriarchal, and sexist (Andersen & Collins, 2016). Much of the new research in women's studies deals with the cultures of women of color (Guy-Sheftall, 2012). Women's studies and ethnic studies will continue to interconnect and challenge the dominant curriculum in the nation's schools, colleges, and universities. Gay and lesbian groups will continue to demand that their voices, experi-ences, hopes, and dreams be reflected in a transformed curriculum

      This is really great change that I do hope to see will happen in the future. America is very diverse and more people deserve to have their stories heard and related to.

    4. ut also with White main-stream students.

      Multicultural education is so important, especially for this group that will encounter many people from many different ethnic backgrounds. It is good to know a little bit about different cultures and to not stay somewhat ignorant or blind to these differences. The hope is to spread knowledge and compassion so that people are not viewed as outsiders.

  5. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Standardization has negative effects on students, teachers, and schools because it leads to bureaucratization and to a focus on low-level knowledge and skills that can be easily measured by norm-referenced tests.

      This is true. It is good to hold your students to specific expectations and to want them to meet those standards. However, standardization makes these expectations toxic and have the opposite effect of making students not learn. Instead teachers and students focus more on achieving higher test scores to be competitive with other schools.

    2. A study by Roderick, Jacob, and Bryk (2002) indicates that performance improved in low-performing schools after the implementation of standards-based reform.

      This is interesting because usually NCLB gets a lot of backlash. It is nice to know that there were some benefits of having same standards for all schools regardless of income, ethnicity, disability, and English proficiency. This shows that anyone, regardless of these outer differences, are capable of achieving if they are given the right and equal treatment.

    3. Providing content related to these issues and to the cultural communities in which students live is significant and meaningful to stu-dents.

      I wish my high school classes talked more about current events at the time. During my time in high school, there were foreign invaders going to Vietnam and trashing the streets and country to retaliate. I remember this really stressing my family out and it would have been nice to talk about in school.

    1. Involving students’ families is also essential. Information sessions and parent workshops can be

      I support the idea of having parents involved in their child's education. Especially because many parents from low-income communities do not have higher education but want to understand it for their children.

    2. persistent and substantial overrepresentation of Black students in special education has lasted for forty years

      Placing students who do not need special education in special education has a number of negative effects. For one, they are limited in what they learn compared to normal groups. They may also experience lower self-efficacy by being put in a class with students they are not at the same level at.

    3. . To reduce this problem, teachers can be trained to be culturally responsive and the public-school system can be improved so that students from low-income households receive better services.

      So much pressure for teachers. I agree that teachers should be trained to recognize the signs of special education needs, but again they need to be paid a lot more bc of all the other hundreds of responsibilities they have with the children of our future.

    1. What would it take for U.S. society and schools to stop labeling, to stop positioning Lydia in ways that attend primarily to her differences, her perceived deficits, and that negate her full personhood?

      I can see why this parent is upset at the labeling, but I personally think sometimes it is necessary. Without some labels, we cannot give a person the kind of help they specifically need. We know that every person is extremely unique and requires different things. Labels help us group and efficiently help a specific group. What we really need to do is remove the negative connotations surrounding labels and just recognize them simply as a label.

    2. Despite my efforts, because most of the other children with special needs have been removed ("so their needs can be better met," I have been told more than once) and because, in my opinion, her school doesn't really believe in inclusion, as in the question asked by a parent representative to the CSE, "Wouldn't she be happier in a class where all the children are different?"

      While I understand the author's intentions and reasons for wanting her child to be placed in normal classes, I have to disagree with making this exception or change. As someone who works with elementary school students with learning disorders such as ADD, just having one student with a disorder in a class with typical students makes a huge difference in learning progression. On top of normal disruptive student behavior, students who are developmentally delayed will cause the whole class to pause. I also think the student may experience more bullying or teasing in a normal classroom especially if they are really disruptive.

    3. Being defined in school settings as an Other limits Lydia's ability to construct her own identity. This positioning also causes feelings of shame and pain for Lydia, and pain, loss, and grief for me as her mother, as some of the incidents above suggest.

      I never realized how dehumanizing this label could be. While it may not have any direct effect on Lydia's feelings right now, as she grows up she may start to question her "Other" label.

    4. Situations like this are reminders that no matter how much I might want it to be so, Lydia will never be able to do what children who are typically developing can do. Grieving is an ongoing experience when you have a child who has disabilities

      I can only imagine how frustrating this can be for someone to watch her own child grow up, unable to develop like the other kids. What is horrible is that it is not her fault or anyone's fault, but she probably blames herself for not being able to be this "super mom" that can support her child on top of working and enjoying her own life. Not only that, but she must deal with the negative stereotyping

    1. Because I want to go inside a classroom and stand there andbe openly queer and openly Asian.

      This is a very powerful statement. This is a sentiment that I hope comes true for all students.

    2. A lot of the times when people label things to be age-appropriate or age-inappropriate, it’s not because of their genuine concern for their child. It’s because of their belief that, ‘I don’t want my kids to learn about things that I personally do not understand, or things that I do not wish to understand.’

      I never made this connection but this makes sense. Often, people will raise issues with certain topics without fully acknowledging their personal flaws or the potential part they play in reinforcing such harm.

    3. Until schools provide support groups that educate parents about such issues, LGBTQ+ students must navigate their way through a heteronormative, and possibly homophobic, school environment.

      I would like to see this kind of support group in schools. What is hard is getting parents to attend them because of work and stubborn values. But putting this kind of support for parents can be huge for those who actually do come and learn from it.

    1. The pressure on straight allies of LGBTQ students to not express their opposition to homophobia may indicate that not supporting gay people is an integral part of indicating one's own heterosexuality.

      I have seen some students in my high school who took on this kind of mentality. To prove that they were not gay, they would be mean toward gay students or talk poorly about the LGBTQ+ community as a whole. This just creates more unnecessary hatred and creates a greater divide. We are so afraid of outside perceptions.

    2. hools, like the rest of the social world, are structured by heterosexism-the assumption that everyone is and should be heterosexual

      This can be a very tricky topic to speak on when you are teaching students. Sometimes you subconsciously reinforce gender norms because that is what you grew up with and what society has instilled with you.

    1. Whether because of pressure to conform to this problematic notion of male power or out of concern that they will be thought to be weak or gay if they don't harass, young men are the group most likely to harass LGBTQ youth and young cisgender women as well.

      This is very true. Society paints this image that men are supposed to be tough and strong, and to never shed a single tear. As such, whenever they see another guy show some form of "weakness" they call them slurs probably out of the insecurity that they cannot do that themselves.

    2. and career advancement, older ideas about male-female relationships have changed; for instance, the necessity for feminine submissiveness to male power has waned significantly.

      This is very true and starts as young as second grade. I hear me students talk about how girls can do any sport too, girls can be faster than boys, and girls can be smarter than boys. Boys also accept this and say similar messages too.

    3. How do genders become understood as having particular qualities, actions, appearances, and so on? How do gen-der identity and sexual orientation, stabilized as normative, then become the foundation for the normative and normal communities and personal re-lationships?

      There needs to be a book that has all the standards and outlines for how gender should be taught in schools that all teachers use so that all the information is cohesive.

    4. gender or organizing teams of boys against girls,

      During my senior year of high school, students from the LGBTQ+ club raised their concerns with how the school was for holding their battle of the sexes assembly. They argued that it wasn't inclusive to people who were non-binary and that it was simply outdated. Initially the school hesitated to change the assembly because it was an annual tradition but eventually they changed it to battle of the teachers.

    1. Many teachers do not want to emphasize appearance. "They pull you in," a preschool teacher says. "The little girls come up to you with their frilly dresses and hair ribbons and jewelry. 'Look what I have,' they say and wait for you to respond. What are you supposed to do? Ignore them? Insult them? They look so happy when you tell them they're pretty. It's a way of connecting. I think it's what they're used to hearing, the way they are rewarded at home."

      This is so true! I try not to make comments on any student's appearance but then I think about how insecure I was as a kid and how getting compliments would make me feel better. But now I recognize that it would actually make me feel worse when I did not get these compliments and it would make me even more insecure. For example, it one teacher compliments my dress, I feel good but when someone else doesn't, I question, am I not pretty enough? But if no one ever commented on my appearance, I wouldn't even care about this.

    2. I think the reason it is so hard to treat everyone the exact same is because teachers are just human, we get stressed out and we have lesson plans that need to be taught, so we will do what needs to be done to get everything taught in time which may include choosing the same students who always raise their hands to keep the class moving.

    3. The teacher in the social studies class about presidents was completely unaware that she gave male students more attention.

      I am guilty of this. I let the males just say whatever and have to remind myself to tell everyone needs to raise their hands to get called on. I have to work on being more consistent and fair to all my students even if I think it will hurt student's feelings. Doing so benefits them in the long run even if in the short term their feelings may be hurt.

    4. metimes these hand signals are accompanied by strange noises, "Ooh! Ooh! Me! Me! Ooooh!" Occasionally they even stand beside or on top of their seats and wave one or both arms to get attention. "Ooh! Me! Mrs. Smith, call on me." In the social studies class about presidents, we saw boys as a group grabbing attention while girls as a group were left out of the action.

      Picking on students in class can be kind of tough because it is fast and sometimes you choose people unconsciously. Also when you see a student who normally doesn't raise their hand, you want to pick on them to encourage them to raise their hand more but then you think about all the other kids you didn't choose who you think might not raise their hand again.

    5. They get criticized more publicly and harshly when they break a rule. They get help when they are con-fused. They are the heart and center of interaction.

      This is true because 1) boys are expected to tolerate punishment better than females. They are supposed to be strong and less affected by harsh words. 2) They get more help because there are lower expectations for boys to be engaged in school, so when they are they get more help and attention.

    6. Male students frequently control classroom conversa-tion. They ask and answer more questions.

      I wonder which age group they are referring to here. From my personal experience of being a student myself and also working with 1st to 4th graders, I have noticed that female students tend to participate more. Males only dominated conversations by being disruptive.

    1. Morbidly afraid of being fat, high school and college students suffer from bulimia, episodes of binge eating, vomiting, or abusing laxatives to prevent absorbing food. The self-starvation syndrome of anorexia nervosa plagues adolescents whose images of their bodies are so disturbed that they adamantly refuse to maintain a healthy weight. Anorexia is a lethal disease: one i

      These eating disorders are extremely stressful and debilitating. It makes focusing in school hard when all you can think of as you sit in class is how you look to others. We need to work on changing peoples views on body thinness and food by implementing nutritional and mindfulness classes at this age group.

    2. The obsession with being thin takes many forms: girls who skip breakfast or lunch or dinner, or all three; girls who exist on diet drinks and popcorn;

      Sadly, I knew a lot of girls like this in high school. They were overly stressed about their appearance. They spent all of their money on makeup, some girls would steal makeup. They are constantly checking themselves in the mirror and editing their social media pictures.

    3. Beautiful, feminine, popular with the boys, popular with the girls .... The one thing I would like to get across about my whole feeling regarding high school is how I was when I was fifteen: gawky, always a hem hanging down, or a strap loose, or a pimple on my chin. I never knew what to do with my hair. I was a mess. And I still carry that fifteen-year-old girl around now. A piece of me still believes I'm the girl nobody dances with.

      This is what I hate about movies, books, and other forms of media that portray unrealistic depictions of what high school looks like. Adolescents are very susceptible to outside information so the kind of images and roles they are being told hold strong. It creates insecurity when you can't look like the popular girl in the movies.

    4. It appears that the courses in school aren't really the hardest part about it. And the material taught in classes is probably the least of what is learned within these walls. But what kids learn, is it helping them or pulling them apart? School is more of a war zone-a place to survive.

      If I had to put a number to it, my high school experience was caring 40% about my grades and academics and 60% worried about my friend group, how I appear to my peers, and whether or not I was liked by others. High school truly is a war zone.

    1. By stigmatizing students and associating pregnancy with immorality and disrespect, sentiment by teachers such as Saldana pits students against one another, limits pregnant students’ sources of support, and pushes them away from certain classes and maybe even out of school.

      Being a teenager is already difficult because you are dealing with all these insecurities, anxieties, and pressure. To add on the weight of being judge for being a teen mom is very challenging. Women who decide to continue pursuing their education should be supported because they need to provide support for their new life.

    2. Given sexualized media representations where girls and women are evaluated by their bodies and clothes, some may support dress codes as a way to combat sexist and consumerist media pressures. 3

      But doesn't this also promote sexism or at least deeming it okay. Sexism is the unequal treatment of men and women. To make women cover up because men find their bodies sexual again places all the responsibility onto women to fix this issue when men are also at fault.

    3. e Latina/o culture or value, and research indicates that having a child as a teenager is linked to class resources, not culture (Blum et al. 2000, as referenced in Denner and Guzmán 2006, 4)

      This makes sense. Any young teen could get pregnant without access to quality sex education on preventative measures. It is not fair or correct to attribute teen pregnancy to cultural values.

    4. The Asians seem to be motivated and driven. The Latinos don’t seem to value education in the same way.

      As horrible as this view is, I think my school also had this horrible sweeping generalization. It is obviously not true because everyone is capable of greatness but self-efficacy gets lowered because of this stereotype.

    5. Underlying these practices and imperatives are prevailing ideologies that blame young women for their experiences and cast Latinas as hyper-sexual and potentially pregnant teenagers.

      An ongoing issue that women continue to face is how often women are blamed for wearing "exposing" clothing but men are not corrected at all for their tendencies to sexualize the female body.

  6. Apr 2022
    1. As community builders and cultural producers, they constructed the Basement Group, a borderland community that embraced and affirmed characteristics they thought were meaningful, desirable, and valuable. In this youth-created space, the girls were encouraged to foster cultural hybridity, nurture flexible belonging, develop ambivalent identities (ngo, 2009), and create new cultural scripts that expressed their own and their friends’ border-crossing lives.

      This sounds like how clubs are formed in high school. It is often how high schoolers find people with similar interests and create a small, close community.

    2. they did not feel comfortable in the main hallway, partially due to the type of students they perceived sat there. Z

      I could relate to wanting to find a private space in school because you don't feel like you fit in with others. I often did this in high school to avoid being around other groups.

    3. ’ They happily explained to me that they enjoyed their time with their friends in the school basement, specifically during lunch.

      This supports the research that says social support is really important for students' attitudes and motivation for school. Having a space to connect and talk with friends by sharing similar interests will make the students like going to school more.

    1. Yamaira has opened a trans-languaging space that has transformed the class. Latinx bilinguals, who make up 75% of this middle school, have begun to understand that their trans-languaging is a resource, not a hindrance, for read-ing deeply about history and other content.

      I like this teacher's approach to teaching where she understands that knowing a second language is a good thing not a bad thing. It's not good to make students feel bad for not being able to speak English. It ruins their self-esteem and self-efficacy.

    2. She also assures Yamaira that she will not be evalu-ated on her knowledge of English, but on her knowl-edge of history

      I think this is a really good idea for non English speaking students because at the end of the day comprehension is more important than ability to write grammatically correct sentences in English.

    3. Arturo’s Spanish teacher, believes that he does not have suf-ficient Spanish-language vocabulary to make sense of the Spanish-language chapter books.

      I have a student in a similar situation where he only knows how to speak Spanish and that impacts his English reading capabilities. He can accurately pronounce tough words but has no comprehension of what the words mean.

    4. He is in a dual-language bilingual classroom, where he is expected to read texts in English as well as in Spanish. Y

      There are elementary schools like this in Socal where the students learn in English learn both English and Spanish. And the students are all ethnicities. I think it is to take advantage of that language acquisition stage

    1. Although both provided formal and informal learning activities at home, Miguel’s family tended to construct spaces throughout the city while Benny’s spent much of their time in their church in an adjacent neighborhood. The families also created spaces where there were no places, such as the secondhand stores used as book stores by Benny and his grandmother and the representation of Central America in this Midwestern city created by Miguel, his family, and their community of com-patriots.

      Basically demonstrating the point that just because a familiy is low-income, it does not mean they are incapable of providing their kids with resources to enrich their learning at home.

    2. Gina and Miguel sat at the dining room table, using pencils, crayons, paper, or scissors stored in the cabinet there. First, either Miguel read the instructions on his own or Gina read them in English

      Really good at home social support. Completing homework and school related material is much easier when there is someone willing to work with you or at least hold you accountable for getting your work done. It also teaches collaboration and communication skills.

    3. , this investigation found that the boys and their families had created rich literacy spaces that reflected their lives and interests. In addition to workbooks, worksheets, and books brought from school for homework, the families had books of their own, library books, newspapers, folders of student awards and report cards, school and city notices and questionnaires, advertising flyers, lists, cook-books and recipes, games with instructions, photo albums,

      In another class, I learned how important access to such resources is extremely advantageous for children's learning. Psychology courses have also made it obvious how important having a separate space specifically for studying is good for getting into the correct mindset and mood. As opposed to using you sleeping space to eat, study, do work, and sleep.

  7. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. The pro-spective participants were told that their participation would last for five years, until the summer of 2002, and that we were interested in investigat-ing the experience of immigration for newly arrived immigrant y<»-1th, 1

      I predict that the participants experienced a lot of difficulty with learning the language, making friends, and following certain rules/policies. Because schools have to move progressively it is hard to stay on one topic for a few students bc you have to keep moving on. I would hope there are after school programs. But attitudes toward education are very different now. Not many people value college or school and might not be motivated to go to after school programs

    2. Our study focuses exclusively on the experiences of recently arrived foreign-born youth and their families. It does not confound that experience with the realities of the second generation or of those who arrive as babies or as very young children (the so-called 1.5 generation).

      This is a very interesting population to focus on. I think the results could be generalized to how foreigners feel supported in the American education system.

    3. ndeed, babies born to immi-grant mothers tend to be healthier than second-generation babies, and im-migrant children are less likely to be obese, to experiment with drugs and alcohol, or to engage in a host of other risky behaviors. T

      I wonder why this is the case? If second-gen is better academically, they should be more educated and have more money to then support the kid with the right nutrition and prenatal care? Maybe the second-generation is more open to harmful substances like drugs and alcohol compared to the first generation which affects the health of their children

    1. It’s just that I didn’t relate to any of my teachers and I didn’t know anyone else [at school]

      I also did not have strong relationships with teachers but sometimes it can be the fault of the student. I personally was too shy to speak to them and I had very low self-esteem. Also if we force teachers to care about each and every student, will that care be genuine and how are they meant to form relationships with every single student on top of know every single student's particular background on top of knowing each child's preferred learning style. There needs to be some other sort of intervention.

    2. I have been spending my whole school career trying to do something that I am really not going to end up doing.

      This is such a common experience for college students. We randomly choose something we find not to be boring, take the classes for it and by the time we realize we don't actually like it, well, we're already in too deep. I think this is due to the lack of exposure to different types of job opportunities. But also how are we just supposed to know what we want at 18?

    3. uch teacher-based forms of social capital reduce the probability of students dropping out and help stu-dents who come from socially disadvantaged backgrounds or who have had academic diffi culties in the past.

      Again, this article places the pressure on teachers which if that is the case, they should be paid a lot more than they actually are.

    4. Undocumented immigrant students are particularly vulnerable and have arguably greater needs than their citizen peers.

      While I agree that this is an important issue, I wonder how schools could realistically fund more support for undocumented students considering how severely underfunded schools currently are. Of course, all students should be given equal opportunities, but how can that come about realistically? And why do we put so much pressure on teachers

    5. I don’t think it would have changed anything.

      Our society pushes education and college onto students without understanding that not everyone is going to succeed with a degree. High schools should also take into account how some students might not want the college route because sometimes it really doesn't guarantee financial stability

  8. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. chronic tardiness, lack of motivation, and inappropriate behavior.

      One way to tackle lack of motivation could be to increase interest and hope/self-efficacy.

    2. Children who experience poverty during their pre-school and early school years experience lower rates of school completion than children and adolescents who experience poverty only in later years.

      Proper nutrition and quality care is so important for child development and not having the means to provide that for children is devastating. It creates more hate, sadness, and misfortune. I hope that policymakers can work to provide these means.

    3. Teachers don’t need to come from their students’ cultures to be able to teach them, but empathy and cultural knowledge are essential

      I agree with this sentiment. Learning about students' cultures and backgrounds isn't something educators should be interested in, rather it should be something they are responsible for. It helps a lot with figuring how to approach the students' learning and being sensitive to their identities.

  9. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. It is what we have to say that matters, not how much money our parents make or where we come from.

      I think it is also important to acknowledge the challenges and difference each kid goes through instead of pretending there aren't any differences. If you pretend that all students are equal and have the same resources that each student wouldn't get the right kind of care.

    2. However, I think that if a teacher had made some small attempt to communicate with my mother in a positive manner, perhaps a letter inviting her to come to the school or just an invitation for a letter in reply, it would have been a great step toward earning my mother's respect and trust.

      Parent-teacher communication is critical in supporting a child's learning. It is really helpful to know more about a child's home life to assess what extra help they may need.

  10. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. snide remarks from peers

      Many of these articles attack how the education system approaches students in poverty but few talk about how to address this with students because they are often the perpetuators of the negative comments.

    2. And then I noticed my classmates' response to my sad homemade flag. It was pity, pure and simple. It's the first time I remember feeling shame.

      It is possible that this person already felt insecure about their financial situation and perceived everyone's reactions as pity because the child feels so indifferent.

    1. by not writing off their students.

      There is so much teachers have to be aware of that makes me not want to be a teacher. Not that I do not think this isn't important because it definitely is. But this article and the many we've seen in the past show how hard it is to be a really good teacher.

    2. Teachers can further exacerbate poor students’ feelings of inadequacy through the tasks they assign and experiences they provide

      This was the case at my high school where teachers assigned us online homework, assuming that every had good wifi and access to a computer at home. There were also projects that required us to buy supplies that were expensive. Clubs also required money to join.

    1. “Oh, of course Ann knows the answer to that question,” or “Ann wants to answer this question.”

      I saw this a lot in my high school where my teachers would purposefully only call on the Asian smart students because they knew they would know the answers and it would keep the class moving. But as a result, other students don't get a chance and their internal belief that they aren't smart enough gets reinforced.

  11. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. daily basis to subtle, negative messages that undermine the worth of their unique culture and history.

      This reminds me of how when I was a child my mom didn't want me to speak Vietnamese because she didn't want me to be teased for not being able to speak English. It sucks because now I cannot speak Vietnamese and I grew up to be somewhat ashamed of my heritage.

    2. School~ng involves either adding on a second culture and language or subtracting one's original culture and language.

      This is a really interesting way to view schooling. It is true that American schools do in a way diminish the importance of individuals' cultural backgrounds by forcing assimilation.

  12. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Yet, in this case, a child's culturally influenced, nondisruptive classroom behavior, along with the teacher's stereotype of "good Asian students," led to her not receiving appropriate instruction.

      Many articles make this same point of how we are not teaching children with the appropriate instruction because of their race. Our personal attitudes and the common stereotypes can make teaching the child hard because there are so many factors to consider. As such, I feel that teachers should be played a lot more seeing how that are literally responsible for creating the adults who help the functionality of society,

    2. ey will often defer to boys, displaying their knowledge only when in the company of other girls.

      I wonder what age group of girls are referring to here because I work with a lot of Latino 1st-5th graders and at each grade level I have never really observed this. At this age the girls are pretty confident and have no problem correcting or calling out boys. I think after puberty, however, this might change as you begin to think more about how you are perceived by others.

    1. It’s not such a diffi cult process . . . to start with. . . . If they [Latinos] really wanted to do it, they would just go out and fi ll out the application and ask the teacher for details. . .

      I don't think it is as easy as she makes it sound. As we learned in last week's article, there are some kids who don't even understand the order of taking pre-algebra before algebra simply because they don't have people in their lives to explain that to them. It may seem easy to her because it is a path a lot of people in her family have taken or that her family holds strong values to school so she knows more about it.

    2. His father “was very encouraging about what [grades] I got. If I tried my best, that would be fi ne.” But his mother was more demanding: “If I came home with all As and a B, she’d question me. ‘What’s the problem?’” However, Lee- Sung asserted that while his parents “communicated in diff erent ways,” “they both valued education.

      This example goes to show how different cultures have different attitudes toward education/grades.

    3. lthough of course we can’t real-ly know the motivations of Alan’s teacher, the mere fact of her anger— the oddity of it, under the ostensibly heartening circumstances of a student making extra eff orts to be placed in a more challenging class— suggests that she perceived his eff orts as a transgression of accepted boundaries, perhaps rupturing her sense of (racial) order.

      This reminds me of the discussion we had in class on Tuesday and last week's discussion on implicit biases teachers may carry into the classroom. I wonder if in the hiring process, schools ask teachers about their comfortability with diversity and how they personally understand racism.

    4. nie’s comment that Alhambra was a place in which new immigrants could be comfortable, where they wouldn’t feel “outcasted,” and furthermore where they constitut-ed the “norm,” expressed a regional ethos in which immigrants and people of color were neither marginal or exceptional

      I had a similar high school experience as my high school was predominantly Vietnamese Americans. As such, I never felt outcasted and in fact the reverse happened where the few white people at my school felt left out.

    1. She received some notoriety from the racist incident and was asked to appear on MTV.

      I think it is really sad how her hurtful words became a joke for people to laugh at. This issue should have been taken more seriously but I think because other races may feel "this doesn't personally affect me" it was not condemned or handled with as much severity as it should have been

    2. On the outside, R. W. appeared to be a model student at her historically white educational institutions. Her demeanor was quiet, which likely suggested to white outsiders only a stereotyped Asian passivity. Thus, even with numerous warning signs of mental illness, she was never seen as a concern. The white-created “suc-cessful model minority” stereotype made it difficult for non-Asians around her to see her illness and encouraged silence among the Asian Americans who knew her.

      I could really relate to this sentiment as an Asian American growing up in a dominantly white area. Even though I was young and only in elementary and middle school, I subconsciously already knew all the stereotypes people had of asians such as "they're quiet," "they are good at math," and "they're good at everything and don't have mental health issues." I felt I had to fit into these stereotypes but by doing so I really pushed away my own signs of bad mental health and depression.

    3. I often encourage my students to feel when we learn about inequality, because oppression works in a way so that we no longer feel empathy for target groups.

      This is so important because the over saturation of terrible devastating news desensitizes people to the reality that the person dying had a whole life, a personality, a family, friends, etc. and now that is just gone. But because we see so much death and tragedy all the time it just feels like "another story"

  13. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. At seven, race was not yet salient for David because it was not yet salient for society. But later it would be

      This is why the phrase "I don't see color" is upsetting. Not acknowledging someone's race and the difficulties the experience due to their skin color is being ignorant and making the problem worse. We should be aware of the stereotypes and challenges people of color face instead of pretending they don't exist.

    2. If you walk into racially mixed elementary schools, you will often see young children of diverse racial backgrounds playing with one another, sitting at the snack table together, crossing racial boundaries with an ease uncommon in adoles-cence.

      In elementary school, friendships are less about sharing similar values or philosophies and more about doing the same activities together such as playing a similar sport. As time goes on, we start to think about our personal values and struggles and yearn to meet people who can relate which could be a possible factor as to why we start to stick with our same races.

  14. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. As light-skinned Hispanics they stood out, and Clara has vivid memories of being chased home by black kids from school through a darkened freeway underpass.

      When kids experience something traumatic in their childhood, it drastically affects their performance in school. What is more difficult is that kids often don't have the vocabulary or ability to express what happened to them so they don't reach out for help and become more closed off in school.

    2. Troy offers a richer menu of extracurricular activities than Santa Ana, but, as we shall see, private fund-raising explains chat differ-ence, not unequal investment by the school districts.

      How do we fix this problem? At first, I thought funding Santa Ana high school so that they can add more extracurricular activities and provide more resources for the students, but I wonder if you have to fix the community first. That could be by helping their parents getting jobs and educating them on finance.

  15. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. build social capital with teachers, guidance counselors, and other professional staff.

      This is very true but very unfair for students who are shy and scared to talk to older adults. That was the case for me where I did not know if it was okay to ask my teachers or other staff to help me because it did not seem like they cared about me outside of the classroom.

    2. The next day, Ms. Hill did not warmly greet me at the beginning of class. I raised my hand, and she called on me last.

      Teacher bias and attitudes play a huge role in student's outcomes. If a teacher does not believe a student can perform well, they are likely to not give that student as much help or attention. Implicit biases should be checked before hiring teachers.

    3. Their teachers and college professors rarely reward them for their diversity of attitudes, preferences, tastes, mannerisms, and abilities or encourage them to draw on their own experiences to achieve in school.

      I do not know when this article was written, but I think this aspect has changed in both K-12 education and college. Many of my professors are understanding that some students work multiple jobs, may not have reliable means of transportation, or do not have access to certain technologies. These professors try to make accommodations and acknowledge students' efforts. As for K-12, the elementary school I work at is in a low SES community and all the staff is aware and takes important care of not making students feel bad for not having certain supplies.

    4. They get tired of being reminded of these differences when they are with wealthier students.

      I could relate to this experience when I started working in Irvine when I grew up and still live in Santa Ana. A lot of my coworkers are more wealthy and could not relate to my financial struggles which made it an awkward topic to bring up. Whenever I do hang out with my Irvine friends, I tend to try not to bring up money

  16. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Pierre Bou:r<lieu (1977) argues that cultural knowledge, srnrus, and distinctions mcdi;:ice the rclarionship between economic structures, schooling, ;ind people's lives.

      This is very true when we consider that in some cultures school is not as heavily stressed compared to others. Parents attitudes toward the importance of getting a degree can dramatically change how much they care to put in additional money to their child's education. For example, they may not see the need to spend extra time at night reading to them or buy them new school supplies because they might expect their kid to just get through high school and then start working with them.

    2. Given that so much is at stake, it must be recognized that a system of course assignment that allows students to choose which classes to take will invariably work better for some than others.

      I think the real problem is that a lot of freshman coming into high school and even sophomores have no idea about what colleges are and why they have to take certain classes. At least from my personal experience as a first-generation student who didn't have any older siblings or relatives who went to college, I did not get any advice on what to do in high school. Perhaps, even in middle school, schools should begin introducing career options so that students can have an idea of what they want to be in the future.

    3. Without an adult to encourage her to cake algebra, the gateway to college preparatory math and science courses, or to advise her on where she might seek academic support, Chantelle made a decision that is likely to affect her preparation for college and therefore will have bearing in the long term on her opportunities after high school.

      In my personal high school experience, my counselors, because they see so many students, did not take the time to talk deeply about which school courses to take based on what careers you were interested in. In my high school, we would just receive our schedules and the only time counselors would make changes is if there was a time conflict rather than personal preferences. This negatively affected me in my junior year when I wanted to AP Bio but my counselor told me I had to take physics. I later learned after I graduated that it was perfectly fine to take AP Bio and that it would even be more beneficial for me when applying to colleges.

    4. That she reached the point of enrolling in prealgebra without having these notions corrected is a reflection of the limita-tions of the school counseling process.

      I never realized how even the knowledge of the differences between a prealgebra and algebra can show class differences and the importance of knowing people who went through the education system.

    5. However, it is possible to address school conditions that contribute to disparities in achievement, such as school size, the student-to-counselor ratio, procedures that are used to track stu-dents into higher-an<l lower-level courses, and processes used to provide academic support co students who are struggling.

      Other possible strategies that could benefit schools where achievement is low is creating non-profit after school learning programs dedicated to subjects such as reading or math. Nonprofits can get free volunteers from local college students who want to see what the field is really like. This is idea benefits both parties greatly.

  17. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Why might growing gaps in family income cause an increasing gap between the school success of low-income and higher-income children?

      Culture may play a part in the increasing gap in that different cultures have different attitudes toward the importance of school, learning, and earning a degree

    2. fifth grade.

      I wonder if the reason 5th grade in particular shows a larger gap is because that is when most children start puberty. Puberty can add more stress onto the child and affect their abilities to focus in school

    3. This difference is nearly twice the size of the gap between the average reading skills of white and both black and Hispanic children at that age, and nearly equal to the amount that the typical child learns during kindergarten.

      This is consistent with another research study that found students from lower SES backgrounds had 30% less the vocabulary as students from a high SES backgroun