- Aug 2020
-
via3.hypothes.is via3.hypothes.is
-
student-teacher parity gap is not due to a failure to recruit minority teachers. The gap has persisted in recent years largely because the number of nonminority students has decreased, while thenumber of minority students has increased –leading to an increase in the proportion of all students that are minority.
inflation of one side of schooling without the other
-
-
Local file Local file
-
they typically tend to blame students’ families, cultures, and communities as primary causes of unequal educational outcomes
situational vs inherent
-
-
Local file Local file
-
Low-income communities in California draw disproportionately on the global market to ensure an adequate supply of teachers to meet the highly qualified teacher policy require-ments (Bartlett, 2009). Schools in these communities have traded a historic reliance on underqualified teachers (emergency credentialed, out of field, intern, etc.) for professionally qualified teachers recruited from overseas. Yet by comparison with the high visibility of “alternative routes” into education, the hiring of overseas-trained teachers remains what Bartlett describes as a “hidden phenomenon” (Bartlett, 2009), as districts and schools are not required to report on the country of origin, education, or visa status of their workforce.
lack of transparency
-
for experienced, professionally certified teachers
so are international teachers cost-effective?
-
o see the use of cursive writing in French first-grade classrooms, judging 6-year-olds not “ready” for cursive; French teachers were surprised to see American 6-year-olds grouped together on a rug for reading time, viewing that as a practice to be left behind when children entered the “real work” of first grade
cultural differences lead to difference in education style
-
However, as a set, the studies do little to relieve concern for attrition or to settle debates about the worth of the “teach for the short term” remedy.
evidence for both sides
-
“Compared to what?
voluntary vs involuntary high turnover rates
-
Programs recruit candidates from highly regarded colleges and universities, selecting and placing a relatively small proportion of those who apply. The programs appeal to the graduates’ political and social idealism while also positioning them to ben-efit socially and materially from their short-term experience in challenging schools
social justice as a tool of teaching?
-
is that young, highly educated individuals will stimulate achievement and motivation in low-performing schools, even if they remain only a short period; a corollary but more implicit premise is that high turnover of such teachers will do no harm to students or schools, presuming that programs and schools are able to recruit a steady supply
consistent stream - lack of individuality in teachers?
-
appear to be shaped heavily by working condi-tions.
still has to do with resources of schools
-
less than 4%, as against more than 10% in countries such as Sweden and the United States, where salaries (relative to GDP per capita) are low”
teaching as a profession can compete
-
Unlike other nations with more developed social welfare or youth minis-tries, the United States traditionally has relied on school-based measures to ameliorate the effects of poverty
placing the onus of systematic poverty on teachers as opposed to governmental intervention
-
lower student test scores, schools with lower income students, or schools that have higher proportions of minority students”
allocation of funds based on student performance creates a cycle of disadvantaged students
-
eachers elect to teach in schools with rela-tively advantaged student enrollment and profiles of high achievement and to avoid schools in poverty-stricken areas, especially those with high minority enrollments
what societal stigmas play a role in this
-
the teaching of subject matter, teaching diverse students, managing classrooms, and assessing learning
more things go into teaching than expertise on the field being taught
-
each group is divided as to the special preparation for teaching that teach-ers should require prior to taking on the responsibilities of a classroom.
whether theory education or practical experience is more valued
-
acquire scientific and mathematical knowledge germane to the field of engineering, but only recently have engineering schools begun to consider various practical contingencies of successful engineering work
education on theory instead of practicality
-
emphasize academic background versus other dimensions of teacher quality and to concentrate attention on individual qualifications and incen-tives rather than on employing organizations and the organizational conditions asso-ciated with teacher effectiveness and retention.
onus on individual teachers
-
remain concentrated in urban and poor communities, one issue is where new and practicing teachers seek or accept employment
more incentive to join communities that provide more resources as opposed to already disadvantaged schools
-
most have focused on the experience of White teachers in preparing to teach students of color; only recently have studies begun to emerge that chronicle the challenges that may confront teachers of color as well
still centers white experiences
-
Some progress appears evident, if hard-won, in cases where admission procedures screen candidates on the basis of demonstrated cultural sensitivity and commitments to social justice; where a multicultural, intercultural, or antiracist perspective per-vades the program
this requires antiracism and multiculturalism to be a value held by the institution at large
-
designated courses that may be elective rather than compulsory and that encapsulate issues of diversity rather than integrating them as a fundamen-tal feature of professional preparation
made to seem as optional as opposed to necessary devalues them in the eyes of the community
-
increased workforce diversity will demand more in the way of both pol-icy formulation and research than a singular focus on recruiting teachers of color.
recruitment is one part of a much larger necessary issue
-
he experience of being a “token” minor-ity forced the teachers to consider their personal and professional identity and their relationships with students and colleagues in ways unlikely to confront their White colleagues
creates the conception of a monolithic experience where there is none
-
(many Black teachers lost their jobs)
integration didn't result in a proportional hiring/firing of teachers across racial and ethnic lines
-
minority teacher turnover in the United States had become significantly greater than turnover among White teachers—although minority teachers were less likely than White teachers to exit schools in high-poverty areas or with large populations of minority students
representation goes both ways
-
impediments such as the reli-ance on standardized testing as a requirement of licensure
not always an accurate representation of qualifications
-
she observes that the percentage of high school students who become teachers from schools enrolling a large share of low-income and minority students is signifi-cantly less than the percentage of high school students who become teachers from more advantaged schools.
experience with quality of schools incentivizes or disincentivizes those who attend high school to continue into the field of teaching
-
is also to join the shape of the prospective teacher workforce to the dynamics of higher education access.
unaccessible to many
-
In countries where teaching has high social status—such as Finland, Ireland and Korea—there is strong competition for entry into teacher education
we as a society value education but not teaching
-
women and minorities
when other occupations become available, competition for teaching workforce increases
-
more than half held a master’s degree
teaching then becomes accessible to those with economic means to attend multiple higher institutions of learning
-
boasting the highest levels of academic achievement
teaching then becomes inaccessible to portions of the population to whom prestigious schooling/valued schooling was not available despite quality of education otherwhere
-
homogeneous
lack of representation leads to reluctance in underrepresented groups to engage in the field of teaching
-
ith a few exceptions, teaching is an occupation of women, especially in elementary schools; it employs the young and the graying, a bimodal age distribution that may reflect a reluctance of “Generation X” (born in the 1960s and 1970s), “Generation Y” (born after 1980), or the current “Millennium Generation” to commit to long-term careers in teaching;
what would prompt this?
-
last of them that appears most prominent in current discussions and debates regarding qualifications to teach and teaching effectiveness.
in a monetary-driven society, schooling that would lead to the most economic success is deemed most valuable
-
presumably emphasize the substantive knowledge, skills, and dispositions valued by labor markets.
economic incentives for education
-
Thus, different perspectives on the purposes of schooling orient one to different qualities, qualifications, practices, and accomplishments of teachers.
what we value determines who we deem valuable
-
constructs education as a commodity or “private good”
education as personal capital
-
he former two constitute goals focused on the “public good” of education
communalistic as opposed to individual based - for good of society as opposed to personal gain
-
a mood of “hard-edged efficiency” dominated American education as well as a “growing emphasis on the schools as a direct instrument of social control”
control the education, control the people
-
global economic competitiveness.
we value education for what economic success it may bring us
-
what those desired outcomes might be.
what value do we place on education as a society and for what use?
-
obscure or overlook the role of institutional and organizational processes
places the onus on individual teachers as opposed to administration/institutions
-
nearly exclusive focus on teachers’ academic background and subject specialization as warrants of professional qualification and as anticipated predictors of student achievement and attainment
teacher's perceived quality of education/qualifications seen as a predictor of student success
-
escalat-ing stakes attached to educational achievement and attainment.
knowledge as a tool of power and capital
-
-
learningpolicyinstitute.org learningpolicyinstitute.org
-
which have come to appear inevitable in the United States, are not the norm in developed nations around the world
why do we accept it as a fact of life?
-
experience school spending about 10 times greater than our most poorly supported students.
those who already possess resources are then disproportionately allocated more resources where those who need more aid are not given what they need
-
we systematically under-resource those schools significantly
is this an intentional choice from those in power?
-
where universal health care, housing subsidies, and high-quality, universally available child care are the norm.
increase in good federal programs leads to greater education overall
-
were reduced or eliminated, and federal aid to schools was cut from 12% to 6% of a shrinking total. Meanwhile, childhood poverty rates, homelessness, and lack of access to health care grew with cuts in other federal programs supporting housing subsidies, health care, and child welfare.
what prompted the cutes to federal programs?
-
No society can thrive in a technological, knowledge-based economy by starving large segments of its population of learning
only allows for one portion of the population to possess knowledge as capital
-
noticeable reduction in educational inequality in the decade after its release, due to desegregation and school finance reform efforts, along with increased investments in urban and poor rural schools through the Great Society’s War on Poverty
what caused educational inequality to surge again?
-
locking millions of students of color from low-income families out of today’s knowledge-based economy
using knowledge as a tool of power in keeping significant influence out of the hands of the historically disenfranchised
-
faced a “system of apartheid” in its major cities.
private schools have high proportions of white and high income students even in diverse cities ex. NYC has a large population of minorities but segregation remains high in neighborhoods and in schools
-
moving toward two societies, one black, one white—separate and unequal.
sustained segregation in the school system combined with high turnover rates in low-income, high-minority schools divides out education equity
-
-
Local file Local file
-
shortages persist
high turnover and lack of stability
-
has obvious cost and recruitment implications, given that teacher salaries are the largest item in school district budgets. How will districts sustain this growth?
economic incentives to leave - lower salaries as the workforce grows
-
45 percent of all public school teacher turnover takes place in just one-fourth of public schools, with high-poverty, high-minority, urban, and rural schools experiencing the highest rates of turnover.
leads to increased inequity in education
-
have gone back up as the recession receded
lack of economic stability incentivizes teachers to stay but as prospects open up, teachers leave. what jobs do they leave to join?
-
40 to 50 percent of those who enter teaching leave teaching altogether within five years
is there increased competition amongst teaching positions?
-
increase in overall teacher turnover
does this have anything to do with the changing modal ages of teachers?
-
by the turnover rates of minority teachers, which our research shows are much higher than those of white, non-Hispanic teachers, and have also increased in recent years
recruitment efforts don't equate to retainment efforts - why are minority teachers being incentivized to join the workforce but not incentivized to stay? what is the state-by-state breakdown of these numbers?
-
minority teacher recruitment efforts
what do these recruitment efforts entail?
-
that number has grown by 31 percent since 1987–88
overall ballooning of the teaching force
-
raditionally been female-dominated,
does having larger representations of female teachers prompt more female students to join the teaching force or deter male students from becoming teachers? what societally accepted female vs. male roles creates the proportion of female to male teachers? where do gender nonconforming people fall on this map?
-
a growing number of older career switchers)
what prompts career switches?
-
has also become less experience
what would the ideal age for teachers be?
-
But by 2015–16 that number had decreased to about 1.1 million
are there modern incentives to join the teaching force younger?
-
public school teacher retirements increased
how does this compare to private school teachers? how would this impact resources/quality of education for private vs public schools? would this make for a less stable teaching environment?
-
increasing demand for teachers in special education, math and science, and ESL/bilingual education
does this possibly have to do with increasing globalization? - more emphasis on equitable learning (special ed etc.)
-