we must recognize the way cultural narratives circulate colonial hierarchies and how this circulation in turn perpetuates silencing, erasure, and violence toward Chicanas.
What to do
we must recognize the way cultural narratives circulate colonial hierarchies and how this circulation in turn perpetuates silencing, erasure, and violence toward Chicanas.
What to do
Reading through affect, particularly colonial affect-culture, demonstrates the way that colonial thinking structured Chicano nationalism and threatened to silence Chicanas by evicting them from the movement itself. Movement literature that cast women as vendidas further circulated colonial narratives that insisted on their devaluation.
MAIN IDEA!!!!!!
Although Chicano nationalism condemned the reification of people of color, the critique of capital it produced failed to point out how Chicano nationalism itself—and the machismo that supported it—reproduced colonial gender hierarchies.
MAIN IDEA!!!!!!
he movement's history and canon are largely recognized as dominated by male activist leaders and writers due to the lack of visibility of Chicana feminist leadership, artists, and writers.
Connection to Chicano! EP 1
In fact, one of the problems within the movement was its hostility toward feminists who voiced their concerns about the lack of women's rights in the movement agenda. Chicana feministas attempted to educate the Chicana/o/x population on the necessity of attending to women's issues and forwarding the agenda to encompass intersecting problems of racism, classism, and sexism.
MAIN IDEA!!!!
Connection to Chicano! EP 1
Access to female power and sexuality threatened patriarchal control as access to female independence left behind the colonial religious buena mujer model of female discipline and control.
Chicana feminists are viewed as as "enemies" of the Movement because they threatened "traditional" values of what is essentially Latino patriarchy
However, the idea of female independence was extremely threatening to the traditional Mexican Catholic family structure. The term agringadas is used as an insult to describe women who have assimilated into specifically Anglo-American culture. Its common association with Chicana women is tied to the myth of La Malinche as traitor and discloses the anxiety of loss of culture through intermarriage, as Chicana and Mexican women were historically tasked with the duty of cultural reproduction as mothers.
La Malinche represents the loss of culture through intermarriage (and assimilation) ----> choosing to be independent and not following traditional social roles defined by Mexican Catholicism ----> cultural betrayal
is this related to ethno-nationalism?
Chicanas who had access to white-collar jobs and single Chicanas living on their own did not fit into the working-class Chicano/a imaginary.
Exclusion of a specific group of people
highlight the intersection of gender and class in this affect of resentment to highlight the envy, shame, and betrayal felt by Chicano men when confronted by Chicanas with access to middle-class jobs.
MAIN IDEA!!!
Gendered resentment
gendered difference generally results in higher wages for men, the racialization of labor negatively impacts Chicanos and other men of color.
Women of color could access higher wages in US white-collar service jobs, but the racialization of labor made it difficult for men of color to access those jobs ----> men of color are seen as a threat and reduced to "unskilled" physical labor positions
By systemically keeping men of color in low-paying jobs, the cultural "breadwinner" is unable to provide enough income to lift a family from poverty and into the middle class. The cycle continues generation after generation by denying Chicanos the opportunities to build wealth and climb the social ladder.
While women of color gained access into the US white-collar service industry, men of color remained locked into the manual labor industry.
gendered resentment
Furthermore, the colonial affect-culture that produced macho narratives of gender inequality influenced not only the men's perspective but also that of many women. As a result, both men and women within the movement viewed feminism as an Anglo women's agenda that detracted from the Chicano nationalist cause. This caused a split among the women in the movement between what became known as the "loyalists" and the feministas.
MAIN IDEA
Connection to Chicano! EP 1
e male-centered activist environment of the movement.
Connection to Chicano! Episode 1
feminine gendering of cultural betrayal.
MAIN IDEA
Colonial affect-culture is replete with normalized patriarchal structures, and attention to their role in male-dominated activism reveals how colonial gender hierarchies were at work even in the civil rights agenda. Chicana movement feministas involved in the movement recognized these patriarchal underpinnings of the social movement. Their efforts are a response to the robotic, static, and sexist Chicano cultural nationalism that pervaded movement politics, organization, and leadership.
MAIN IDEA!!!!!
shunning women's rights as unimportant, Chicano activists sent the message that attaining equal rights for women, eliminating domestic abuse, increasing access to women's health care and family planning resources, combatting gender and sexual orientation discrimination, and more were not important. By marking these rights as secondary, macho activists imposed gendered colonial hierarchies and reacted with resentment when challenged.
MAIN IDEA!!!!
Connection to Chicano! Episode 1
reproduction of culture, they had no control or choice over how to do so and were relegated to the role of mother.
This "reproduction of culture" includes colonized notions of gender which reinforce the male hierarchy aka female subordination
enemies of the Chicano nationalist cause
excommunication of Chicana feminists from El Movimiento
Chicanas of the 1960s and 1970s had three main roles within the movement, summed up colloquially by Moraga as "the three f 's... feeding, fighting, and fucking."
Sexism in El Movimiento
How degrading. Only being valued for being motherly (providing food, shelter, and care), as a sexual being
Whereas Christianity prescribed certain ethical behavior in war, colonialism justified the violation of these ethics. That is, through the dehumanization of Indigenous and African peoples, colonialism justified and normalized violence toward them.27 Enslavement, rape, and murder thus became essential tools of colonialism that did not come under the scrutiny of the Catholic Church or Christian ethics.
How Christianity and Colonialism are intertwined; aka colonialism uses christianity for justification
Gender, in other words, was racialized through colonialism, and, in turn, labor itself became categorized according to race and racialized gender.
MAIN IDEA!!!!
Sexually marked as female ---------> used for sexual labor Indigenous women were not viewed as feminine --------> since femininity is tied to white supremacist ideals
a characteristic of la mala mujer, a marker of Indigeneity, racial inferiority, and lower class/caste.24
Racialization of class Poor ---> Brown Rich ----> white
proximity to either in terms of physical characteristics defined how society treated you and which privileges were granted.
devalued because of their racialized bloodline.
rejected for being non-white yet desired for sexual purposes
Similar to how Black enslaved women in the United States were devalued for their race, and used for their bodies in physical and sexual labor
revalued their bodies as desirable
Indigenous women became a source of sexual labor
In addition to enforcing ideals of virginity, heterosexuality, domesticity, submissiveness, and motherhood, the mujer buena ideal primarily defined the racial superiority of women of European descent over Indigenous and mestiza women in Mexico.
The mujer buena ideal promotes:
white supremacy (light skin) heteronormativity (married woman with children)
a woman's role as restricted to the standard imposed by the Catholic Church: una mujer buena (a good woman) modeled after the Virgin Mary.
Chicana female archetype -----> enforcing gender roles & expectations
"The issue of equality, freedom, and self-determination of the Chicana—like the right of self-determination, equality, and liberation of the Mexican [Chicano] community—is not negotiable. Anyone opposing the right of women to organize into their own form of organization has no place in the leadership of the movement."
So long as any group of people (women) remain oppressed, no one is truly free and the work is not over.
The male leadership of the movement cannot be successful in ensuring Chicano freedom so long as they continue oppressive structures of power against women and LGBTQ persons.
reinforced heteronormative gender roles through their machismo.
Toxic masculinity hurts men more than helps
Chicana feministas directly confronted patriarchal narratives that sought to control female behavior through the use of historic, folkloric, and religious Indigenous and mestiza female archetypes.
Example of Chicana feminism
They theorized race and gender through the lens of colonial history in order to identify the roots of patriarchal social structures of female control, such as gender hierarchy and heteronormativity.
Patriarchal social structures (male supremacy and heteronormativity) are designed to control female bodies.
endida also calls attention to the way in which brown bodies have become part of economic circulations in uneven ways that are determined by these colonial racial and gendered hierarchies.
MAIN IDEA!!!!
Objectification of women of color's bodies
Chicana feministas during the movement that attempted to contest the hegemonic narratives that fueled patriarchal hierarchies
Example of Chicana feminism
colonial affect-culture is embedded in cultural narratives that dictate gender hierarchies and heteronormativity, the racialization of class, immigration policies, and laws that police women's bodies
MAIN IDEA!!!!!!!
Affect in a colonial cultural value system fueled the lived belief that "global cultural order" revolved around "European or Western hegemony,"19 and the feelings of superiority based on relations to capital became codified in race and gender relations and justified the dismissal of all forms of non-Western knowledge, religion, and culture
White supremacy placed Europe as the center of civilization and source of all knowledge.
colonial rule imposed gender hierarchies and heteronormativity.
Colonial ideas of patriarchy and heteronormativity were replicated in the Chicano movement against Chicana leaders/feminists
Aníbal Quijano's concept of the "coloniality of power," which argues that the legacy of colonialism continues to replicate colonial hierarchies in the modern world through racial and labor hierarchies, or "coloniality." Colonial rule, Quijano explains, imposed a "systemic racial division of labor" that inevitably linked social classification with race in the global expansion of colonialism.
Colonality: the patterns of power that emerge as a result of colonialism replicate the racial and labor hierarchies
social classification ---> racial hierarchy ---> enforce global expansion of colonialism
Affects are not free-floating energies; they are felt, material responses to interactions, relationships, and encounters with people, objects, and situations.
Definition of "affects"
The theory in the flesh describes the ways that "the physical realities of our lives—our skin color, the land of concrete we grew up on, our sexual longings—all fuse to create a politic born out of necessity."
Women of Color ------> white feminist movement Feminists ---------> patriarchal societal conditions Lesbians ----------> heteronormativity
realist theory of identity: in acknowledging the reality of social categories (race, class, gender, and sexuality) and its consequences lead to one's social location.
these categories are not fixed, but social categories do have real material, systematic effects (or consequences) ------> centrality of struggle to the formation of political consciousness
coloniality and socioeconomic conditions shaped and continue to shape the lived experiences of Chicanas in the United States.
MAIN IDEA!!!!!
macho, or chauvinist, Chicanos replicated colonial hierarchies of race and gender, thereby targeting Chicanas as vendidas—in real life and in literary representations—for not falling in line with a male-centered nationalist agenda.
MAIN IDEA!!!!!!!!!!!
also, what is colonial affect-culture?
material feminist approach that utilizes affect theory in order to account for the way colonial legacies continue to be enacted and felt at the intersection of race, gender, and class.
Materialist feminism highlights capitalism and patriarchy as central in understanding women's oppression. Under materialist feminism, gender is seen as a social construct, and society forces gender roles, such as bearing children, onto women.
reappropriation of Miss Jimenez, the assimilated Mexican American vendida in Los Vendidos
ohhhh, like reappropriation of La Malinche into a chicana feminist figure
agringadas, which in itself is a betrayal of culture and ethnic roots
to white-wash
patriarchal narratives through the reclaiming of historic, folkloric, and religious Indigenous and mestiza female archetypes—such as La Malinche—as symbols of resistance and survival
Hispanic female archetypes would be a cool timeline to research.
How does La Malinche empower chicana feminists? How does La Malinche represent resistance and survival?
indictments of assimilation to a white feminist agenda
This reminds me of "The Combahee River Collective Statement" made in 1977.
Black feminists found difficulty challenging sexism within the leadership of the Civil Rights movement, and pretty much forced to choose a side (fight racism or sexism). They found it difficult to relate to white feminism which did not have an intersectional lens (and still have that issue).
The use of the terms vendida and malinche to label Chicana feministas as traitors to the movement became so prevalent that La Malinche became the "paradigmatic figure of Chicana feminism."
La Malinche can be considered the first "sell-out" for helping Hernán Cortez, literally converting to Christianity and changing her name.
Chicana feminists reclaim La Malinche as a feminist figure
a clear threat of cultural excommunication to assimilated people of Mexican descent: fall in line with Chicano nationalism, or we will run you out.
Excommunication is an institutional act of religious censure used to end or at least regulate the communion of a member of a congregation with other member.
Cultural excommunication, then, rejects any member who does not align themselves with the group's beliefs, practices, and values. If there are members who challenge "Chicano nationalism" and its leaders, rather than their critique being taken into account, they are pretty much kicked out of the group.
the Farmworker, the Pachuco, the Revolucionario, and the educated, well-spoken Mexican American.
Hispanic archetype characters
vendidos, used to describe a group of people who have "sold out," specifically, people of Mexican descent who have turned their backs on their cultural heritage and completely assimilated into US culture.
An insult for a "fake" white-washed Chicano who deny their heritage
"La Loca de la Raza Cósmica: Feminist response to 'I am Joaquín'"
It could be interesting to analyze and compare both
Chicana feminists created an activist pedagogical strategy that did not abandon middle-class assimilated Chicana/os but rather validated their lived experiences as part of the Chicana/o experience even if it was not working class.
Example of Chicana Feminism
vendidas and agringadas (assimilated or "Anglocized")
Sell-outs Assimilated
Middle-class and working-class Chicana feminists challenged the cultural norm of patriarchy (which was being reproduced in the movement's leadership) ---------> gendered resentment -------> calling those who challenge your way of thinking (male supremacy) names and accusing them of losing focus/not being active in the movement.
jeez
colonial legacies and reproduces colonial hierarchies that continue to devalue women of color.
Machismo creates gendered resentment which reinforce colonial legacies and hierarchies, AKA the patriarchy
Chicano nationalism condemned the reification of people of color, the critique of capital it produced failed to point out how Chicano nationalism itself—and the machismo that supported it—reproduced colonial gender hierarchies.
MAIN IDEA
Access to female power and sexuality threatened patriarchal control as access to female independence left behind the colonial religious buena mujer model of female discipline and control.
Chicana feminists are viewed as as "enemies" of the Movement because they threatened "traditional" values of what is essentially Latino patriarchy
However, the idea of female independence was extremely threatening to the traditional Mexican Catholic family structure. The term agringadas is used as an insult to describe women who have assimilated into specifically Anglo-American culture. Its common association with Chicana women is tied to the myth of La Malinche as traitor and discloses the anxiety of loss of culture through intermarriage,
La Malinche represents the loss of culture through intermarriage (and assimilation) ----> choosing to be independent and not following traditional social roles defined by Mexican Catholicism ----> cultural betrayal
is this related to ethno-nationalism?
affect of resentment to highlight the envy, shame, and betrayal felt by Chicano men when confronted by Chicanas with access to middle-class jobs.
Gendered class resentment
gendered difference generally results in higher wages for men, the racialization of labor negatively impacts Chicanos and other men of color.49
Women of color could access higher wages in US white-collar service jobs, but the racialization of labor made it difficult for men of color to access those jobs ----> men of color are seen as a threat and reduced to "unskilled" physical labor positions
By systemically keeping men of color in low-paying jobs, the cultural "breadwinner" is unable to provide enough income to lift a family from poverty and into the middle class. The cycle continues generation after generation by denying Chicanos the opportunities to build wealth and climb the social ladder.
Chicanas were tasked with the reproduction of culture
Chicano nationalists wanted this "reproduction of culture" to include colonized notions of gender ---> male hierarchy
"the three f 's... feeding, fighting, and fucking."
Ugh! How degrading.
Motherly figure (providing nourishment) and as a sexual being
Gender, in other words, was racialized through colonialism, and, in turn, labor itself became categorized according to race and racialized gender
Sexually marked as female ---------> used for sexual labor Indigenous women were not viewed as feminine --------> since femininity is tied to white supremacist ideals
la mala mujer, a marker of Indigeneity, racial inferiority, and lower class/caste
Racialization of class Poor ---> Brown Rich ----> white
proximity to either in terms of physical characteristics defined how society treated you and which privileges were granted.
. Simultaneously, Indigenous and mestiza women in New Spain became devalued because of their racialized bloodline
rejected for being Indigenous yet desired for sexual purposes
Similar to how Black enslaved women in the United States were devalued for their race, and used for their bodies in physical and sexual labor
the mujer buena ideal primarily defined the racial superiority of women of European descent over Indigenous and mestiza women in Mexico.
Promotes:
They theorized race and gender through the lens of colonial history in order to identify the roots of patriarchal social structures of female control, such as gender hierarchy and heteronormativity.
gender and racial hierarchies --------> effect of colonialism
vendida also calls attention to the way in which brown bodies have become part of economic circulations in uneven ways that are determined by these colonial racial and gendered hierarchies.
Objectification of women of color's bodies
European or Western hegemony,
White supremacy placed Europe as the center of civilization and source of all knowledge.
"coloniality of power," which argues that the legacy of colonialism continues to replicate colonial hierarchies in the modern world through racial and labor hierarchies, or "coloniality."
Colonality: the patterns of power that emerge as a result of colonialism replicate the racial and labor hierarchies
social classification ---> racial hierarchy ---> enforce global expansion of colonialism
Affects
felt, material responses to interactions, relationships, and encounters with people, objects, and situations.
The theory in the flesh describes the ways that "the physical realities of our lives—our skin color, the land of concrete we grew up on, our sexual longings—all fuse to create a politic born out of necessity."
Women of Color ------> white feminist movement Feminists ---------> patriarchal societal conditions Lesbians ----------> heteronormativity
realist theory of identity: in acknowledging the reality of social categories (race, class, gender, and sexuality) and its consequences lead to one's social location.
------> centrality of struggle to the formation of political consciousness
coloniality and socioeconomic conditions shaped and continue to shape the lived experiences of Chicanas in the United States.
Conclusion
macho, or chauvinist, Chicanos replicated colonial hierarchies of race and gender, thereby targeting Chicanas as vendidas—in real life and in literary representations—for not falling in line with a male-centered nationalist agenda
Main Idea
"Colonial affect-culture" ?
intersection of race and gender with class in order to draw out the way the movement identified a working-class background as the quintessential Chicano experience, marking middle-class Chicanas as sellouts to the US capitalist system.
Middle-class Chicanos are viewed as sellouts to American culture and capitalism ----------> How does that relate to classism?
what is the quintessential Chicano experience? why does poverty have to be tied to that?
material feminist approach that utilizes affect theory in order to account for the way colonial legacies continue to be enacted and felt at the intersection of race, gender, and class.
Materialist feminism highlights capitalism and patriarchy as central in understanding women's oppression. Under materialist feminism, gender is seen as a social construct, and society forces gender roles, such as bearing children, onto women.
reappropriation of Miss Jimenez, the assimilated Mexican American vendida in Los Vendidos,
ohhhh, like reappropriation of La Malinche into a chicana feminist figure
attack others for not being "Mexican enough" or for "betraying" the Chicano nationalist agenda
Like Selena's dad said...... you're either too American for the Mexicans or too Mexican for the Americans.
patriarchal narratives through the reclaiming of historic, folkloric, and religious Indigenous and mestiza female archetypes—such as La Malinche—as symbols of resistance and survival
Hispanic female archetypes would be a cool timeline to research.
How does La Malinche empower chicana feminists? How does La Malinche represent resistance and survival?
vendida and malinche to label Chicana feministas as traitors to the movement became so prevalent that La Malinche became the "paradigmatic figure of Chicana feminism."
La Malinche can be considered the first "sell-out" for helping Hernán Cortez, literally converting to Christianity and changing her name.
a clear threat of cultural excommunication to assimilated people of Mexican descent: fall in line with Chicano nationalism, or we will run you out
Excommunication is an institutional act of religious censure used to end or at least regulate the communion of a member of a congregation with other member.
Cultural excommunication, then, rejects any member who does not align themselves with the group's beliefs, practices, and values. If there are members who challenge "Chicano nationalism" and its leaders, rather than their critique being taken into account, they are pretty much kicked out of the group.
vendidos, used to describe a group of people who have "sold out," specifically, people of Mexican descent who have turned their backs on their cultural heritage and completely assimilated into US culture
Name-calling for "fake" white-washed Chicanos
vendidas and agringadas
Sell-outs Assimilated
Middle-class and working-class Chicana feminists challenged the cultural norm of patriarchy (which was being reproduced in the movement's leadership) ---------> gendered resentment -------> calling those who challenge your way of thinking (male supremacy) names and accusing them of losing focus/not being active in the movement.
jeez
colonial legacies and reproduces colonial hierarchies
Machismo creates gendered resentment which reinforce colonial legacies and hierarchies, AKA the patriarchy
bottom of the socio-economic ladder, and large numbers of them are remaining there even after several generations in the United States
Underfunded community resources and lack of access to education, job security, and legal residency complicates the American Dream. How are you supposed to build wealth if you are never handed the tools?
people who believe they are coming home
Claim to ancestral land that the United States historically has not honored or respected.
And, as rapidly increasing numbers of Latinos have gained access to the public services provided by the federal and state governments, the quality of those services has been undermined.
As more people become qualified for public assistance, the funds for social benefits are slashed.
Brown Berets of Aztlan
Is this similar to the Black Panther party?
La Raza [the Race, referring to Latino ethnicity] is a victim of the same political and economic forces
La Raza is a response to white supremacy's strict racial categorization. By combining white, indigenous, and black ancestry, there is unity in being oppressed by the same (former) empire.
MALDEF (the Mexican American Legal Defense and Education Fund)
Specific funds to serve the majority (largely ethnic Mexican) population
accommodate the presence of increasing numbers of illegal residents, such as creating day-labor hiring centers, recognizing Mexican government-issued consular identity cards for official purposes, and issuing driver’s licenses and official identity cards without regard to legal status.
Creation of "Mexican" towns on American soil that disregard US immigration policy to support undocumented immigrants against threats from Border Patrol and ICE.
This is a myth that ascribes the origin of the indigenous people who governed in Latin America before the European conquest to an area comprised of the Southwest of the United States and the Northwest of Mexico
Chicano homeland is comprised of the ceded Mexican territory (SW US states) mythically known as Aztlan.