The Book That Started the Civil War
This title isn't fully relevant to the topic of the essay
The Book That Started the Civil War
This title isn't fully relevant to the topic of the essay
Good Read/Source
Thank you for adding more sources to read! Great idea!
Abraham Lincoln
Interesting how this is hyperlinked, the link is broken though
A work shouldn’t be considered worthy of canonization in American Literature because of its ambiguity or complexity, but for the magnitude of impact that it made on America as a whole.
I feel like this is taking a shot at the film/Oscars community and I love it
Some literature is canonized not because of its symbolism, elegance or style, but because of its sheer impact on a society.
This should be how many things are "canonized"
arguably more important than them to the American story.
Then why don't we read the entire book?
Yes, all that self-important pandering could be reduced to seven crude words- sorry Emerson.
I'm not too positive how Self-Reliance relates to the topic at hand right now
homoerotic freestyle (“Song of Myself”).
That's... Very true
JUST KIDDING.
Stand your ground, Make your argument!
Seriously, Madison, cut your losses and stay in Canada
Interesting take on it all, I can see where you're coming from but it's almost the more "selfish" stance on his part. This seems like it's playing a very "Devil's Advocate" stance just so it can say that it did
selfishness
In a way due to it supporting the trade financially, but it was something necessary. It's like someone buying all of the expired milk to keep people from drinking it. It keeps people from drinking it, but you still condoned it by telling the store it'll sell if they put it out.
none
Key word here
abolitionist narrative.
I believe it itself states something like this in the second section
dramatic irony
I noticed this a bit!
a ride down confusion lane, shall we?
I'm excited
(in class reading) Article Three: Happening Yesterday, Happened Tomorrow URL
This one!
All the story does is reiterate the societal bounds that women and minority groups have been trying to break.
Is it "reiterating" if it's one of the first times this has been seriously brought up?
I think the best and most female empowering part of the entire courtship between Winkfield and Princess Unca is when she forgoes her entire belief system and religion to conform to Winkfield’s with about the same amount of resistance that her sister had when she decided to murder the both of them. Or how about when Winkfield “persuaded his wife to conform to European dress”
I love the sarcasm in this, while still being very truthful
It doesn’t even pass the bechdel test!
This is super interesting to notice just how many works don't pass this test
This over-romanticized tale of star-crossed lovers from opposite sides of the world could not reek more of predictability and cliche.
I get this, It is very Romeo and Juliet, but there's somewhat of an unspoken power imbalance which isn't fully present in most other pieces that use this cliche
I know we all love Pocahontas, but let’s imagine authentic Princess Unca barbie dolls
I'm not too sure how Pocahontas comes into this. Is it implying Pocahontas barbie dolls?
Nor did it matter that her captors did what many U.S. citizens proudly claim they would do should an invasion happen today
Interesting to think about this happening in real life, because this is something people would gloat about
misery and heartache
To who exactly? Is it to only one character or multiple?
overdose of sorrow, disillusionment and hypocrisy to the unsuspecting reader.
I love the description being an "Overdose". It's very true
“Stand still and see the salvation of the Lord” (Exodus 14.13).
Of course, She ends it on a bible verse
One hour I have been in health, and wealthy, wanting nothing. But the next hour in sickness and wounds, and death, having nothing but sorrow and affliction.
Putting her own life in perspective
Oh! the wonderful power of God that mine eyes have seen
Annnnnd back to the religion
My sister’s son was redeemed for four pounds,
Huge price difference between her and her nephew
The twenty pounds, the price of my redemption,
"redemption" is an interesting term for her to use
how to admiration did the Lord preserve them for His holy ends, and the destruction of many still amongst the English! s
"Wow, thanks god for not killing us even though it was so easy for you to!"
God seemed to leave his People to themselves, and order all things for His own holy ends. Shall there be evil in the City and the Lord hath not done it?
Questioning again
I would take leave to mention a few remarkable passages of providence
Return back to the religion after a quick distrust in it
God did not leave me to have my impatience work towards Himself, as if His ways were unrighteous. But I knew that He laid upon me less than I deserved.
Questioning her religion?
but I found no comfort here neither
The first time she hasn't found comfort in her religion
But the Lord upheld my Spirit, under this discouragement;
Again, puts everything on god, both good times and hardships
I went with a good load at my back (for they when they went, though but a little way, would carry all their trumpery with them).
She seems to be proud of what she can carry now
and never let her see it afterward.
the first time she tries to hide her religion
surely there are many who may be better employed than to lie sucking a stinking tobacco-pipe.
wow
Psalm 137.1
She quotes so many bible verses
God
I wonder how many time she says this word in this story.
“your master will quickly knock your child in the head.”
That don't seem too good
your master
God?
Psalm 38.5-6 “My wounds stink and are corrupt, I am troubled, I am bowed down greatly, I go mourning all the day long.”
Recites bible verses from memory
I then remembered how careless I had been of God’s holy time; how many Sabbaths I had lost and misspent, and how evilly I had walked in God’s sight; which lay so close unto my spirit, that it was easy for me to see how righteous it was with God to cut off the thread of my life and cast me out of His presence forever. Yet the Lord still showed mercy to me, and upheld me; and as He wounded me with one hand, so he healed me with the other.
Chastises herself when she messes up her allegiance to god
But the Lord renewed my strength still, and carried me along, that I might see more of His power; yea, so much that I could never have thought of, had I not experienced it.
Heavily focused on God, all thoughts are of him and how he helps her
(except my life)
Interesting that her "Life" is counted as the one thing that stood, seeing that everything else she was claiming had made her life was gone.
All was gone, my husband gone (at least separated from me, he being in the Bay; and to add to my grief, the Indians told me they would kill him as he came homeward)
While this does give some context to her gloom, but doesn't excuse the hatred for all around her
a lively resemblance of hell
Others having fun is hell?
black creatures
the negative connotations to this is extremely prevalent.
It seems imperative that scholars continue to question what truly characterizes American literature within and beyond national boundaries.
What reasons are there for defining something as "American" Literature other than for us to say its something that belongs to us, going back to the "Black Hole" idea that we discussed in class.
whittled early American literature
How do you describe what American Literature is just by the examples? How is it set in stone that the texts chosen in this anthology is "American Literature"?
important works of American literature
What defines "Important"?
revisited.
Were they ever truly "Visited" in the first place?
Who determines what counts as American literature?
Is it just a singular group, or is it people as a whole who decide over time where to place the literature?
American literature and American history?
Can an American Author only produce American literature? What makes an American author "American" as well?
white gull
Does this symbolize anything as well?
thunder rolled heavily and the lightning had split a great oak near the wigwam from the top to the base
Is this metaphoric for something in their culture?
she cut the vine and let her drop down, down, down, not stopping to see what became of her.
Are all the stories this violent?
they hoped that he would win a nobler name some day,
What would define a "Noble Name"?
ordinary human,
How would this term be defined?
tribal members could not even speak grammatically in their own "tongues"
Is it grammatically correct for them though? Does grammar matter if all speakers of the language use the same "Mistakes" as their every-day speaking?
He is not the product of his background
This shows the clear distinction of being part of your heritage and recognizing how you could grow and evolve your heritage.
and confirm to the white reader that contact with Euro-Americans was the most significant event in the forty-thousand-year history of Native people on this continent-indeed, their citizens seem unable to think or talk of anything else.
Very similar to the thought of how labeling something "American Literature" boils it down to the "Black Hole" of being just about America.
"I'll take you across one time, two at most," or "I'm at your disposal for the next fifteen minutes, no more." But he gave a basically open-ended agreement-made a contract-and hence the porcupine woman was per- fectly within her rights in both demanding that he return three times and in quilling him to death when he reneged.
I'm very curious as to when this story was written, if it is possibly about the Europeans.
t does not mean that Tanaina-speaking people literally believe that beavers and porcupines talk to each other, nor does it suggest that the anthropomorphic quality of the protagonists is more than a stylistic convention.
It's interesting that the author has to explain this to the reader, as if we think so differently of the native Americans that we need to have stuff like this explained
When she had caught her breath, she turned on the beaver and quilled him to death.
Very Aesop Fable-esque with a sharp, jarring twist at the end
almost 85% of the aggregate Native American population during the contact period
Wow, that is so many people
f) these all-the-same people must of course be INDIANS! T
It's really interesting to think about how the innapropriate term to describe Native-Americans is "Indian" but never "Ethiopes" as they were originally mislabeled, yet still some call them "Indians"
b) none of them were Euro- peans, then therefore c) they must all be the same.
These ideologies hold true multiple times through all of history
was
The use of past-tense implies the fact that the author no longer believes that these ideals no longer hold true
was
Is this stating that this is no longer the case?
English literature is expected to be in English, and to be therefore accessi- ble first and foremost to English-speaking clients.
How can you define something to be "In English?" What if the initial novel was released in a different language, but is primarily sold as English copies to the point that it is seen as the "Initial" copy.
On the other hand, there is no such thing as "Native American litera- ture," though it may yet, someday, come into being.
It is very interesting to think about how difficult it is to define where a piece of literature lies, There is no one true definition, just the ideas of where specific people define other's work as.
a le af fa ll s
A Leaf Falls