119 Matching Annotations
  1. Apr 2017
    1. One concern that we have in looking at the plan as it is now, is that the clusters seem potentially limiting.

      In contrast, interdisciplinary is not limiting.

    2. For this reason, we still believe that General Education is key, since it allows us to have broader skills and knowledge that can help us as our fields evolve in new directions over the years.

      general education gives students a well rounded education.

    3. Students want the ability to control our own education rather than feel like we’re being shuffled through a system

      This is the idea that I feel like our entire program is based off of. we are given the control.

    1. Learning should be exploratory and fun, exactly what interdisciplinary studies is trying to do.

      Love this!

    2. An overarching fear of interdisciplinarity is the “10,000 hour rule,” meaning interdisciplinary students might graduate as masters of nothing. Instead of graduating with a comprehensive understanding of a single discipline like anthropology or economics, they graduate with a smattering of knowledge, spread across many fields.

      I don't view this as a negative thing. My time is a masters program is my time to become a master of something.

    3. making interdisciplinarity collaboration a challeng

      the challenge makes the results even that more worth it

    4. The five major barriers blocking interdisciplinary students from success are: attitude, communication, academic structure, funding, and career development.

      Interesting!

    5. There would be no place for interdisciplinarity if the disciplines didn’t come first

      Yes! as interdisciplinary students we understand that our programs are made up of multiple disciplines.

    6. Society needs people to be masters in specific areas because they contribute to the understanding of the world at large.

      very true! we need people who are very good at one specific thing.

    7. Why is it desirable to be a “master?”

      Everyone is always working to trying be the best at what they do, and being a master is that.. the best.

    8. If she goes to college and studies a single discipline—like biology—and doesn’t take any classes except ones that pertain to her major, she will graduate as a near-master in her field.

      This is true, but that doesn't mean she will not have a well rounded education

    9. 10,000 hours of hands-on, in-depth, focused energy in a discipline, he will be a master of it. That’s eight hours every day for nearly three and a half years.

      Ive heard this number in another class before!

    1. Everything in the world is interrelated.

      This is becoming more and more clear to me.

    2. employers like employees who know what they want, are confident in their decisions, think independently, know their strengths and weaknesses, and are curious about life.

      I feel like because of this program, I embody these characteristics.

    3. Suddenly, education is relevant again.

      !!!

    4. Students who follow this format learn more about themselves and what they want from their educational experience than students who passively accept a predetermined curriculum based on a single field of study.

      I have already experienced this. Creating your own program makes you really think about your interests.

    5. By pursuing interdisciplinary studies in college, students are able to develop important skills like solving complex problems and thinking outside the box.

      I have already experienced this in my short time in this major!

    6. The goal of interdisciplinarity is to be relevant now.

      We show this in our active education online and publishing our work for the world to see.

    7. in the hands of students.

      One of the reasons i'm so passionate about this program!

    8. Education is about more than passing a test or being accepted to the “right” school, it’s about self-discovery and personal growth as an individual.

      I think this is so true but it gets overlooked in so many situations.

    9. If students aren’t free to be curious, engaged, and invested in what they’re learning, then they may never be curious, engaged, or invested in their lives

      I feel like this is stressed in our class.

    10. If students are living their lives in preparation for life, when will they start living?

      This makes me think.

    11. College is just one step on the continual stairway of advancement,

      it is a big step, and an important one. What you do in college could determine what your next step after college is and what you do for the rest of your life

    12. Brooks shines a light on the damaging effect that order and control have had on modern classrooms. Below, he describes the “work now, play later” ideology that has permeated across college campuses since the 1980’s:

      This is really so relevant

    13. e “suffer now, succeed later”

      A quote I live by

    14. “why is the sky blue?”

      I feel like we ask questions of this nature a lot in interdisciplinary studies. Questions of why things are the way they are.

    15. Education is not a simulation preparing students for an imaginary destination.

      Love this!

    16. If students are not engaged with a subject because they believe it’s irrelevant, no amount of force will change their minds, or if they do change their minds, the decision comes from outside, not from within

      This statements makes me think of general education courses.

    17. “Why do I need to learn this? I’ll never use it in real life.”

      I have said this a countless amount of times!!

  2. Mar 2017
    1. In some cases, interdisciplinary research requires cooperation of experts with different disciplinary backgrounds and different ways of thinking--a notoriously difficult undertaking.

      This is a topic I discussed with a scholar I look up to in my interview. She told me that she never does research alone, and never limits the people involved in her research to just her diciplines.

    2. It is of course impossible, in our age, to become an expert in everything

      I agree with this, that we cannot become experts on everything, but we can become experts on some things and are not limited to one area of study.

    3. Outsider's Perspective:

      if we only look at a problem from one perspective, we will make no progress

    4. Creative Breakthroughs: The very act of creation often involves the bringing together of previously unrelated ideas

      Creative breakthroughs is one of the most relevant pieces of interdisciplinary for me personally, we need new perspectives and ideas to have breakthroughs and progress

    1. The major challenge is the elucidation of interconnections between disciplines, fiends, and sub-fields.

      Although this is a challenge, it has remarkable outcomes.

    2. Gruenwald speaks particularly on interdisciplinary sciences. He believes that remarkably, the natural sciences have turned into interdisciplinary engagement by the inner logic of discovery.

      Being a science major, I love to hear this!

    3. For example, one with a degree in education may apply for a job with over 100 other applicants; where as maybe only 2 out of the 100 are interdisciplinary studies.

      This is a huge plus for me. It makes us stand out to jobs, graduate programs, etc.

    4. Interdisciplinary research clusters and programs are being established across the United States,

      Just like here at Plymouth!

    5. First let me start of by saying, higher education is a key component to a successful life in my opinion

      I agree with this, at least for me personally. I know people who haven't attended higher ed and are totally content, but their lives do not seem as full as those who did.

  3. spinmelikearecord.wordpress.com spinmelikearecord.wordpress.com
    1. Declaring this major feels like me declaring, “I will not settle for less! I will make the most of my opportunities!”

      This is exactly how I feel about this major and all of the progress I have already made!

    2. You can be your own self and that is who you should want to be most!

      This is important! being true to yourself and not just walking the path that others have set before you is essential for growth.

    3. Just think about it, if everyone just stuck to guidelines and tradition, the world would never grow and would never have the chance to become any better.

      So true! love this.

    4. I am creating and envisioning a possibility that others may not see or may not have the confidence to direct.

      This is what a lot of people think about their own programs and it is so true. we are creating something new and from a new perspective.

    5. Engaging in Interdisciplinary studies has broadened my understanding of entrepreneurship, abstract thinking, metacognition, and love of learning.

      I love this start pf the article. This is a strong statement that really touches on a lot of the good about interdisciplinary studies and why students like us are so passionate about it.

    1. One of the clear benefits of an interdisciplinary degree is for students to learn how they learn and the way their brains work.

      I love this! I think its so true. This is something I think a lot of students learn throughout their education, but interdisciplinary studies supports it.

    2. “one of the biggest barriers to achieving true interdisciplinary study in education environments is the necessity for collaboration of educators.

      I can see this being a big issue, but it is not a problem that i have faced. Everyone I have worked with has been academically supportive

    3. The unique environment created by residential college life is an incredible experience for most young, college-aged students. It’s such a transformative experience for so many people that it seems almost irrational to expect students to know what they want from it before they arrive.

      It is a one of a kind experience that really emerges you in your education.

    4. Many students entering college for the first time are surprised by the way it changes their thinking, identity, and perspective

      I know I was, but it was in a good way.

    5. Why should anyone, educator or otherwise, tell an eighteen-year-old student what they should or should not learn?

      This is a powerful statement

    6. demonstrating that graduates need more than one kind of skill if they want to compete in today’s job market.

      I think it is essential to follow guidelines but having a well rounded education is also essential.

    7. Not everyone, however, supported the shift towards specialization at the turn of the twentieth century

      From what I have heard and seen, the people who don't support the shift are traditionalist and people stuck in doing things in a very specific way

    8. Interdisciplinary studies, as a concept, would not be possible without the foundational structure of disciplinary studies.

      This is true. For example, my program in pre-occupational therapy is a combination of psychology and health promotion, which are two disciplines

    1. We see the roots of interdisciplinary beginning to show in society,

      Now that i know about interdisciplinary, i see it everywhere

    2. lists the psychologists, school social workers, case managers, occupational therapists, physical therapists and nurses who are present in developing and preserving a child’s mental well-being.

      As my program is for Occupational Therapy, this just shows how the medical and therapeutic field is interdiciplinary

    3. interdisciplinary is just now starting to enter the discussion.

      Its cool that we get to be a part of this new discussion

    4. Without the disciplines, interdisciplinary would have nothing to build on

      very true, as my interdisciplinary program is a combination of multiple diciplines

    5. “…the disciplines are the place where we begin, but not where we end.”

      I really like this starting quote. The core of our education begins with the disciplines, but then when develop and branch off from there

    1. “These faculty members share common formative experiences…and appreciate a common canon of writings by the “founding fathers” of the disciplines” (Repko, 90).

      interesting

    2. how they interact with each other and in which ways they belong to a social community. In most disciplines such as say dentistry people within that field if they’re close together location-wise they’re in competition with each other.

      my parents talk about this a lot when speaking about their social communities and careers

    3. Looking back it makes so much more sense that they were able to make lesson plans based off each other’s knowledge and experience.

      makes sense!

    4. Many people as students observe professors and teachers in high school and middle school as being a part of individual social groups

      I was very close with my high school teachers in this way

    1. Mathematics and music were some of the first disciplines that were taught in the Greek era.

      These two disciplines make sense to be the first

    2. Of course this knowledge exchanged was not labelled. The earliest recording of an academic discipline, similar to the ones we know today, was with the Greeks in Socrates’ time.

      Interesting!

    3. Humanities, Social Sciences, Natural Sciences, Formal Sciences, and Professions and Applied Sciences. Under the main disciplines are the sub-disciplines. The sub-disciplines are considered branches off of the disciplines which encompass fields like Psychology, Visual Arts, or Physics.

      Its cool to think that my IDS program is a mix of multiple of these

    4. It is field that is taught, studied, and researched in a college or university setting.

      Like Psychology, for example

    5. continuously changing as time goes on, making the idea more difficult to define.

      I really feel that disciplines are always changing and evolving, but for the most part it is in a positive way!

    6. Although it is a widely used concept, very few undergraduates can actually define what a “discipline” is.

      Interdisciplinary students can!

    7. Both establishments started off teaching rhetoric and religion.

      All the talk of religion in this article is interesting to me because I have never taken a religion course.

    8. According to the Guiness Book of World Records, The University of Al-Karaouine in Morocco, Africa is the oldest continuously operating, degree-granting university in the world.

      Interesting!

    9. In ancient times, it was common for a youth to have a platonic relationship with an elder.

      I have had a lot of good experiences building relationships with teachers and advisors though out my educational experience, but there was never one that was designed to just me and that that really helped me though everything.

    10. eventually spreading across the world.

      Interesting, because today, we couldn't even imagine not having academy,

    11. The academy began with teachers simply preaching a topic of their interest.

      I think this is still true to some extent, teachers choose to teach the topic that they are most interested in.

    12. the idea of having a designated place to learn has been around for over a millennium.

      I like the idea of this and that it has been around for a very long time. In my experience, the designated place to learn (traditionally, a school), becomes a sort of safe place and a place of growth.

    13. The disciplines that we have been taught since the beginning of elementary school have been such a crucial part in who we are as students, and who we become in our careers after graduation.

      Very true! Since elementary school the core disciplines have really shapes our education.

    1. Third, there is the epistemology of the discipline.

      this is an interesting and new idea to me

    2. methodology. In the case of a research project, you might be expected not just to explain your findings, but also to explain your methodology, or how you reached your findings.

      I have had to use this many times.

    3. For example, your disciplines may be primarily quantitative, using numbers, measurements, and empirical research to understand its content. Or your disciplines may be primarily qualitative, using interviews, case studies, and observations of human behavior to understand its content.

      This is very interesting. For what I want to do, I have a mix of both quantitative and qualitative courses so its interesting to see the definitions in kind of a compare and contrast.

    4. Content is generally what is “covered” by coursework in the discipline. It can include facts, concepts, ideas, and texts. Content is the what of a discipline.

      this reminds me of our contracts, because they include the content of our programs, or what will be covered.

    1. That makes Plymouth sounds so much safer, but in order to know for sure, we have to set the numbers into context,

      this is a great example.

    2. Sometimes we actually don’t want to carve a problem or concept into small bits, but instead want to see how something specific fits into a larger pattern or fabric.

      Seeing a problem in a different context can shine a new light on the problem.

    3. we may need to break the question up into parts and look at study time, social life, living away from home, economic issues, mental health, oppression, and more. Studying these parts will help us get a sense of the overall reasons for the problem.

      There are really so many things that affect students so I think these things are very important.

    4. We can also think of breaking a larger whole into its parts in order to understand the whole more fully, and this is called “systems thinking.”

      I like the way of thinking about this.

    5. Sometimes we break problems down into smaller parts so that we can solve it piece by piece.

      this is something I do a lot.

    1. challenges to accreditation processes

      This has been something on my mind

    2. Academic Freedom: Freedom to study our interests, in the way we best comprehend knowledge.

      this is so important!

    3. Genuine expertise often comes with a high price that may not always be worth the time spent.

      Interesting quote

    4. . Most real problems are not simple, and they demand thinking from a variety of academic fields.

      This is very true

    5. Creative Breakthroughs: Taking a new perspective from a different angle can yield unexpected pathways that were not visible before.

      I've only been involved in Interdisciplinary studies for a short time, and I already have experienced this.

    6. There are many reasons why approaching a problem, concept, project, or educational path in an interdisciplinary way can benefit learners and the world.

      This is so true!

    1. Create a degree, major, or educational program

      Exciting that this is what i'm doing!

    2. Instrumental Interdisciplinarity: This is when you do interdisciplinary work in order to reach an outcome of some kind

      This feels very relevant to me. I aspire to be an Occupational Therapist which is extremely interdisciplinary work.

    3. transdisciplinarity builds bridges across disciplines

      this highlights the benefits of pulling form different disciplines!

    4. Both multidisciplinarity and interdisciplinarity are valid ways to bring different academic perspectives together.

      This is good to know because I was unfamiliar with the term Multidisciplinary.

    5. “Interdisciplinarity” is more like a fruit smoothie, where the disciplines are blended together–integrated– to create something new.

      I love this way of thinking about Interdisciplinary!

    6. Multidisciplinary: Drawing on information and methods from two or more disciplines.

      From my college experience so far, a lot of education is multidisciplinary.

    7. Interdisciplinarity: Incorporates several fields of study to allow collaboration among diverse disciplines to either specify or broaden students’ education, to gain understanding, and/or to problem solve.

      I really like this definition. The collaboration in different disciplines is what is allowing me to explore the career that I want!

  4. Feb 2017
    1. Promoting digital ownership is different than assigning work in publicly accessible spaces.

      Having the freedom to create something that is geared towards one's own interests, passions, and goals completely changes the game.

    2. The web is a network for conversations, and if students still see their audience as a teacher with a red pen, then nothing changes.

      I agree with this.

    3. The first type of ‘Domain’ took audience into account, considering the implications of public scholarship, representation, and student agency. The second, in many ways, mirrored the traditional pedagogical structure by assigning papers or short answer assignments to be posted online through blogs.

      It is good to understanding that there are more than just one type of domain.

    4. “To own one’s domain gives students an understanding of how Web technologies work. It puts them in a much better position to control their work, their data, their identity online.”

      This is very true, especially that it will put students in a better position in the future.

    5. It is a living portfolio, my representation in the digital world.

      This is awesome! Even though I am just learning about these ideas, I am very excited about them.

    1. To own one’s domain gives students an understanding of how Web technologies work. It puts them in a much better position to control their work, their data, their identity online.

      This is very true and I look forward to having a better understanding of these concepts after the Intro class.

    2. Education technology – and more broadly, the culture of education – does a terrible job with this sort of portability and interoperability. When a student moves to a new school, for example, they often have to request their transcript, a document that lists their courses and their grades.

      I have had to do this more than once within the past year, and having it more easily accessible would be been great.

    3. And if a student owns their own domain, as she moves from grade to grade and from school to school, all that information – their learning portfolio – can travel with them.

      Being someone who transferred schools, this would have been a positive thing for me.

    4. we talked a lot more about technical issues (backup, recovery, privacy options, hosting laws in different countries, etc). But we also talked a lot more about digital citizenship, safety, control, design, etc. The kids saw the site much more as their own and their responsibility.”

      I have online profiles, but I do not have that much knowledge about things like safety and control when speaking to this subject.

    5. One student uses her domain to showcase her artwork.

      Being able to showcase one's work makes everything we more important.

    6. Having one’s own domain means that students have much more say over what they present to the world, in terms of their public profiles, professional portfolios, and digital identities.

      This creates connections to the professional world.

    7. Fascinating and important innovations would emerge as students are able to shape their own cognition, learning, expression, and reflection in a digital age, in a digital medium.

      Important when speaking to Interdisciplinary Studies

    8. but their own domain – the dot com (or dot net, etc) of the student’s choosing.

      This is beneficial while students are in school, and will continue to be beneficial during a professional career.

    9. Today, UMW and a growing number of other schools believe that students need a proprietary online space in order to be intellectually productive.

      This is an idea I am exploring for the first time.

    10. Students have little agency when it comes to education technology – much like they have little agency in education itself.

      There are a lot of rules and guidelines that students have to follow, which leaves little room for control or creativity.

    11. These legislative efforts stress the need to protect students when they’re online, safeguarding

      This is something that has never been a concern for me, but I have been exposed to people that view this as being a huge issue for them personally and professionally which has caused me to view the subject more seriously.

    1. She thereby enriches the perspective on each subject that she brings to students with knowledge drawn from the others and offering an example of another approach: the joint appointment of faculty members to several departments.

      This is good because bringing in different perspectives can result in a better outcome.

    2. Unless we help our students acquire their own identity, they will end up at the mercy of experts — or worse, at the mercy of charlatans posing as experts

      This is so true, and before I started the path to Interdisciplinary Studies I did not feel as if I had a professional Identity.

    3. The total amount of collected information doubles every two or three years.

      Because of this, education has to be constantly evolving to keep up with the speed of collected information.

    4. "A technical problem of transportation, such as the building of a freeway, becomes a land-use problem, linked with economic, environmental, conservation, ethical, and political issues. Can we really draw a boundary? When we ask to improve a situation, particularly if it is a public one, we find ourselves facing not a problem, but a cluster of problems ... and none of these problems can be tackled using linear or sequential methods."

      All problems and solutions are linked in some way, just another reason to be educated in multiple areas. Having different perspectives on an issue can result in a better solution.

    5. the complexity of the world requires us to have a better understanding of the relationships and connections between all fields that intersect and overlap

      Having even a basic knowledge in multiple disciplines will put someone one stride ahead someone who doesn't. Its important to have a wider range of thought and understanding in the real world.

    6. In fact, mass higher education is heading toward what I call the Home Depot approach to education, where there is no differentiation between consumption and digestion, or between information and learning, and no guidance -- or even questioning — about what it means to be an educated and cultured person.

      This is so true. A lot of my higher education experience has been focused on just knowing how to get the material in a particular class to stick long enough to pass a class and get the credits. There is no questioning about what a person gained from a course or if they come out of taking a course as a more educated person.

    7. Today's students fulfill general-education requirements, take specialized courses in their majors, and fill out their schedule with some electives, but while college catalogs euphemistically describe this as a "curriculum," it is rarely more than a collection of courses, devoid of planning, context, and coherence

      This is what has defined my educational experience up until getting exposed to/getting involved in interdisciplinary studies. I have had to take multiple general education classes that have not benefited me for the real world or getting towards my career goals.

    8. For most students, college is a time for self-discovery, for developing passionate interests, and for trying to weave them into a meaningful career.

      This is the idea of college, but the development of this takes longer to figure out than one might think.