3 Matching Annotations
  1. Mar 2019
    1. What has praise and fame to do withpoetry? What has seven editions (the book had already gone into no less)got to do with the value of it? Was not writing poetry a secrettransaction, a voice answering a voice? So that all this chatter andpraise and blame and meeting people who admired one and meeting peoplewho did not admire one was as ill suited as could be to the thingitself--a voice answering a voice. What could have been more secret

      I think that this is a very important moment of realization for Orlando. She wants to bury the book as a sort of celebration for how far she has come as a writer. However, she is reminded of all the fame and praise that come with being a writer. She questions the fame that comes with writing, whether it is necessary and whether it should be a reason for writing. She also mocks the literary critics, who believe that they are in the position to determine whether a work is good or not, when that piece of work is "a voice answering a voice", a subjective piece of art. Her writing is just her thoughts on paper, which are the most secretive things a person has, unless shared with others. Her writing is hers. This also ties into the theme of biography, in which the narrator's goal is to pour out a person's life and meaning onto paper, but these things are inherently secretive and open to interpretation and bias. Even with Orlando's life, it has first gone through the voice of the narrator of this novel, and then to us, the readers, who will also look at it from a different perspective. Both the narrator and the readers are critics in a sense.

    1. The change of clothes had, some philosophers will say, muchto do with it. Vain trifles as they seem, clothes have, they say, moreimportant offices than merely to keep us warm. They change our view ofthe world and the world's view of us. For example, when Captain Bartolussaw Orlando's skirt, he had an awning stretched for her immediately,pressed her to take another slice of beef, and invited her to go ashorewith him in the long-boat. These compliments would certainly not havebeen paid her had her skirts, instead of flowing, been cut tight to herlegs in the fashion of breeches. And when we are paid compliments, itbehoves us to make some return. Orlando curtseyed; she complied; sheflattered the good man's humours as she would not have done had his neatbreeches been a woman's skirts, and his braided coat a woman's satinbodice. Thus, there is much to support the view that it is clothes thatwear us and not we them; we may make them take the mould of arm orbreast, but they mould our hearts, our brains, our tongues to theirliking.

      The narrator suggests that much of Orlando's change in character had to do with the change in her clothes, which affect how other perceive Orlando, and also how Orlando perceives herself. This ties into something I learned in sociology called the looking glass self, which is the idea that our sense of self develops as a reflection of the way we think others view us. Orlando did not consiously decide to act more feminine, but as others see her, in her dress and with her appearances, as a woman, she subconsciously changes her manners to reflect that. What does this show about how appearances and the physical aspects of a person affect how other people received him/her? In addition, although she had previously not felt very changed, in becoming a woman from man, as she meets more and more people, and socializes, she realizes that she does act more as a woman. I think this has something to do with the expectations that the society has of women, and how despite Orlando's mindset, she feels compelled to conform to it. The opinions of others and societal norms also influence how people act.

  2. Feb 2019
  3. engl22001.commons.gc.cuny.edu engl22001.commons.gc.cuny.edu
    1. Here comes the Countess. Now heaven walks onEarth!

      This is a metaphor, comparing Olivia to heaven. As Olivia enters the scene, he is saying that heaven, originally though of being in the sky, has come down to the Earth. This shows how highly Orsino thinks of Olivia, comparing her to heaven, synonymous with purity and goodness. He is very much in love with Olivia. Heaven can also be seen by some as a final destination in life, and I think this also shows that his goal is being with Olivia.