How unfortunate
subtle persuasive closing
How unfortunate
subtle persuasive closing
The lessons of HOPE VI provide a tantalizing clue about how social mobility can be engineered in America by building bridges between rich and poor.
policy implication, restates central metaphor being bridge.
gentrification should improve outcomes for kids, so long as it actually improves social integration
explicity states argument
The empirical evidence for this is weaker than conventionally assumed.
challeneges common belief
This process often occurs without explicit governmental intervention or cost. The problem is that it is regularly dismissed as gentrification,
reframes controversial concept
concentration of disadvantage and social isolation worsen the effects of material disadvantage.
supports integration htesis
31 percent higher incomes in adulthood (alongside improvements in college attendance and reduced rates of single parenthood).
logos-strong supporting stats
poor children living in concentrated poverty—
explains mechnism of inequality
Whatever their parents’ circumstances, the kind of neighborhood children grow up in substantially affects their life outcome, for better or for worse
generslizes argument beyond techwood example
social capital is just as important.
social capital supports thesis
built a bridge to surrounding communities
metaphor brdge equals to integration
But the new study,
refutation using research
False HOPE” argued that the new mixed-income model was “a social engineering scheme built on a number of inaccurate, irrelevant, and harmful assumptions about low income families and their neighborhoods.”
counter argument
The program was controversial from the outset.
acknowledges opposition
“Just giving people cash, just giving people education, doesn’t do as much as if you pair it with connections that then help them,”
ethos plyys key concept which is social capital
A new, rigorous study
logos-introduces empirical evidence
It was intentionally designed to reduce the isolation of the urban poor—and it’s succeeding.
Authors evaluation-positive one
Few places illustrate
casestudy
Gates and windows lay shattered; residents complained of squalid living conditions; drug trafficking and gang violence were out of control.
negative imagery of isolation-pathos
less like a villainous process and more like a heroic one.
re defines gentrification
So long as gentrification brings rich and poor together, and offers the latter greater opportunity to take part in a healthy economy, it looks less like a villainous process and more like a heroic one.
main thesis- integration improves mobility
The opposite might be true:
signals counter claim