7 Matching Annotations
  1. Feb 2022
    1. Owing to its unrivalled onomatopoeic capabilities, it provides both a medium of lifelike expression that the cleverest European raconteur could never aspire to, and offers an ever-ready means for the coining of endless new words ... Indeed, in certain respects it is probable that no living European language, if left only to its own resources and unable to borrow from other languages, could even compare with it ... The Zulu language, then, is eminently well-stocked and vividly expressive, is resourceful and plastic to all demands.74

      Considering the unique properties of the language, both in its onomatopoeic properties as well as its ability to capture complex and varied meanings, to what degree can we assume that machine translation into English would capture these characteristics?

  2. data-ethics.jonreeve.com data-ethics.jonreeve.com
    1. Consequently,researchers are much more likely to focus on something in the present orimmediate past – tracking reactions to an election, TV finale, or natural disaster– because of the sheer difficulty or impossibility of accessing older data

      How might this bias towards the current moment in Big Data research miss patterns that only emerge over long periods of time? Might this short-term approach limit our analyses and doom us to repeat history rather than learn from it?

    2. establising

      This reminds me of the Silicon Valley buzz word "disruption." Part of the mythology of Big Data is that it will disrupt (rather than value) the ways of approaching reality/challenges/communities/scholarship that have come before.

    3. This is a world where massive amounts of data and applied mathematicsreplace every other tool that might be brought to bear. Out with everytheory of human behavior, from linguistics to sociology. Forget taxonomy,ontology, and psychology. Who knows why people do what they do? Thepoint is they do it, and we can track and measure it with unprecedented fide-lity. With enough data, the numbers speak for themselves. (2008)

      Are there things which can't be measured/quantified? If so, how do the value of these things get lost within a system that prioritizes what can be measured?

    4. We are social scientists and media studies scholarswho are in regular conversation with computer scientists and informaticsexperts. The questions that we ask are hard ones without easy answers, althoughwe also describe different pitfalls that may seem obvious to social scientists but areoften surprising to those from different disciplines

      Cross-disciplinary insight is very important for thinking critically about Big Data, especially because the "mythology" of big data is very strong in the tech fields, and because the ways of critically approaching social phenomena developed in the humanities and social sciences adds a new facet of historically, culturally, and politically-grounded perspectives to these discussions.

    5. Lessig(1999) argues that social systems are regulated by four forces: market, law,social norms, and architecture – or, in the case of technology, code.

      Lawrence Lessig's "The Law of the Horse: What Cyberlaw Might Teach" is a core text regarding the role of legal measures (versus code/digital architecture) in regulating digital spaces and impacts.

    6. Mythology: the widespread belief that large data sets offer a higher form ofintelligence and knowledge that can generate insights that were previouslyimpossible, with the aura of truth, objectivity, and accuracy

      While other "standard" definitions of Big Data touch on the first two terms (technology & analysis), the mythology of Big Data is an important point brought out by this article, and a key theme in our course.