10 Matching Annotations
  1. Jan 2021
    1. Work your way up to structured reviews As your team gets accustomed to working together and sharing feedback, “you need to do a deeper dive into how team members are doing at the individual level,” says Shapiro. Ask each person to prepare specific reviews of colleagues to be read aloud at the next meeting. “Every team member should say one thing they appreciate about the other members and one thing that would be helpful if they did differently.” The aim is to help “people understand how their behavior is impacting others,” she says. “If they hear the same kind of feedback from multiple people, that is powerful.” When it’s your turn, Schwarz recommends validating your observations with others. “Ask: ‘Are you seeing things the same way?’ Get other people’s reactions.”

      I can see how this could be useful, but I don't know. This could be tough too. In Evocative Coaching they talk about focusing on the positive. Why look for something negative to say?

    2. At the end of a project or when your team is disbanding, schedule a final check-in to discuss “what worked and what didn’t, what should we bring forward and what should we do differently next time,”

      I like this...very useful.

    1. “a rep-resentation of self, achieved in stages over time during which the characteristics, values, and norms of the medical profession are internalized, resulting in an individual thinking, acting, and feeling like a physician.”1

      This is really interesting to me. I hadn't considered the idea that an individual going through the process of forming a professional identity as being a part of professional development. I think I just always thought of that growth as being more personal, and the skills and knowledge attainment that presumably led to that identity formation as being the professional learning piece.

    2. found myself not even stopping to think about the physi-ology or the exam-I knew right away what to say and how to say it. It was a combination of a moment of teaching and patient connec-tion that I don’t think I’ll ever forget

      So insightful! I love reading these essay outtakes...great examples of a transformative learning experience!

    3. I wasn’t acting like a doctor . . . but it was one of the first times during third year that I felt I had provided a real benefit to a patient—that I wasn’t an extraneous member of the team who was burdensome, but rather somebody who fulfilled a need that would otherwise have been neglected.

      This is such a powerful reflection! In thinking about my own definition of professional learning I probably have defaulted to thinking about it as increasing skills and building knowledge and things like networking to create relationships and learn from each other. The deeply reflective process in this study, however, is definitely more about personal growth.

    4. If left on their own, students can experience a relative silence on their challenges and their PIF, and this silence is felt by

      This "silence" reminds me of a story I heard on NPR this morning that discussed this issue with first responders and how the pandemic is leaving them more isolated and less able to debrief on their difficult experiences with colleagues. I would imagine that similar challenges are being recognized in educators?

    5. When the resident dismisses the student concern as more than they can address, the student vows to find ways to address these social determinants of health during their career. This determination to live up to their own ideals represents a vital part of PIF, the integration of personal ideals with the values of the profession.

      This feels like the heart of this article to me. This describes where the professional learning helps students to stop and reflect on profound experiences that they have had, examine them closely and then connect how that experience will intentionally be used to shape their professional behavior going forward.

    6. Yet without reflection and conversation with trusted oth-ers, reframing such narratives as essential to being a physician, there is a risk that such behavior will not be, or will be delayed in being, integrated into the student’s skills repertoire.

      I think this is important in the recognition that the intentional reflective process is essential to helping students see these seemingly unrelated somewhat personal experiences through the lens of what it means to be a physician, and ultimately helping them to actually be better doctors. This approach could definitely be applied in y work with educators. Could also provide such a great framework for relationship building, which is a big part of my work.