struggle differently.
i think this is the key
struggle differently.
i think this is the key
she wants the difference to be embraced.
Recognition, acceptance, celebratory
please the patriarchy, and maybe, just maybe, be of enough merit to hover somewhere near the highest rank’s spot on the social pyramid
This reminds me of trying to figure out how to behave in high school so that the popular people will start inviting you to their parties and let you sit with them at lunch.
, it is easier, “[t]o believe the dangerous fantasy that if you are good enough, pretty enough, sweet enough, quiet enough, teach the children to behave, hate the right people, and marry the right men, then you will be allowed to coexist with patriarchy in relative peace…” (Rivkin & Ryan 857)
I starred this passage in the reading. Oppression can feel safe when it is the only thing you know. The unknown, even if it has the potential to be better, is scary. Failure is scary.
pretense
interested in this word choice
intention that such a declaration
In my experience, the intention has been positive, but we should not let that act as an excuse to keep saying phrases like this
real world and literature
life imitates art
What are women?
This is a super interesting question to me
Firstly, she is created from Adam
The control he seeked and did not find with Lilith
, because Lilith is aware of her value she is worth less in the eyes of both Adam and God, who are male
being aware of her value made her a threat to them
I would pull a Lilith
I'm going to use this phrase in real life
Because she considered herself his equal
Big mistake, girl. It's shocking to see that misogyny is so deeply rooted
lesser-known first woman: Lilith
Of course the first woman would be a mother to DEMONS. Really lets you know how women were first (still?) viewed
to do more than accept the compliment
Agreement would be a crime, right? "You have pretty eyes" answered with, "Thanks, I like them too!" would make a guy think you're stuck up. Annoying.
held a grudge against her mother for something she was unaware of
Helplessness of wanting someone to notice that you are not okay without telling them
she feels the need to do more than her mother did
Fixing what she can, giving the support she would have wanted. Reminds of that quote, "Be who you needed when you were younger"
repressed memories about their mother, despite its initial happy connotation.
Complexity of Raimunda's feelings for her mother. Loves/needs/misses her, but angry that she didn't do anything about Raimunda's rape/rapist
scent of her mother in her sister’s apartment.
Very interested in the role of scent in memories and the familiar/defamiliarizing
husband’s attempted rape of her daughter
I have watched the film a few times and I can't decide if Paco actually raper Paula or not, or just attempted to. I'm caught up on how Paula says, "He jumped on me". Soo he was on her, with his pants unzipped. No matter what, that's traumatizing enough
Volver—which is Spanish for the verb “to return”
I just realized that not everyone may have known this? I'm curious if those who did not know looked it up. What do people think of this title? I think it's perfect. On the surface, I'm like, "Oh yeah, it's called 'to return' because the mom comes back" but it could also definitely be a nod to the repression that Raimunda is faced to return to because of Paco's actions against her daughter
he main antagonist of the novel seems to be the privileged white people she comes in contact with
Interesting. I would not agree, I would say it was Dr. Flint
Following this, her mistress dies, and she is put into the care of the novel’s antagonist, Dr. Flint. Although she is owned by his daughter, he pursues her vehemently, and causes her to seek out an affair with a white neighbor, Mr. Sands, in the attempt to flee. She has two children with him, Benny and Ellen.
too much plot summary
Armed with only her will to survive,
Don't agree. She survived only for her children, she even stated that she did not care about her own life, only getting her kids to freedom.
To being pursued by a sadistic slave owner, to hiding in an attic for seven years, to being bought and sold like cattle, Jacobs, under the pseudonym of Linda Brent, possesses an unbreakable spirit, as she describes her hardships in the pursuit of freedom.
I want to cut up this sentence
in the year 1861
luck of being the first entry? I do not know how to avoid adding crucial information like this
didn’t comprehend her circumstances until the age of six
seems to be a large anomaly for slaves
We see something that history books can never amount to; her complete storyline allows us to feel emotionally connected to her as a character
difference between a textbook and a real life telling
published in 1861, just as the Civil War was getting underway,
repeated but important
Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl should fully count as an American novel.
yes
As she was also so white as not to be known as of colored lineage, without a critical survey, and her child was white also, it was much easier for her to pass on unsuspected.
The idea of "passing" as white
Sublime is the dominion of the mind over the body, that, for a time, can make flesh and nerve impregnable, and string the sinews like steel, so that the weak become so mighty.
Power of maternal love
paroxysm
a sudden attack or violent expression of a particular emotion or activity. "a paroxysm of weeping"
I’ll be free, or I’ll die!”
aye shoutout to NH
she turned pale and gasped for breath.
portrayed as weak again
“I always thought that I must obey my master and mistress, or I couldn’t be a Christian.”
Fear from Christianity
“My master! and who made him my master? That’s what I think of—what right has he to me? I’m a man as much as he is. I’m a better man than he is.
The frustration that comes from the unfairness
burst into tears.
depicted crying again
It’s a free country, sir; the man’s mine, and I do what I please with him,—that’s it!”
the irony
his master began to feel an uneasy consciousness of inferiority
This must be even worse than a normal case seeing as he views slaves as inhuman
as if it was white folks, that’s brought up in the way of ‘spectin’ to keep their children and wives
As every human should
Wilberforce
"William Wilberforce (24 August 1759 – 29 July 1833) was an English politician, philanthropist, and a leader of the movement to stop the slave trade"
Clear waste, sir, of a thousand dollars
Like livestock
These critters ain’t like white folks, you know; they gets over things,
Why?
quadroon
"a person who is one-quarter black by descent."
throwing him a quarter of an orange.
like an animal - dehumanization
“Hulloa, Jim Crow!” said Mr. Shelby, whistling, and snapping a bunch of raisins towards him, “pick that up, now!”
vomit worthy
hooplah
nice
A work shouldn’t be considered worthy of canonization in American Literature because of its ambiguity or complexity, but for the magnitude of impact that it made on America as a whole.
It "shouldn't be" ? Does that mean that those are the current parameters?
a beach-read
offensive?
sheer impact on a society
Message vs. craft
arguably more important than them to the American story.
Bold claim. I like the use of the phrase "American story" regarding American literature.
support
I don't like the use of the word "support" here
Let that sink in, there’s a kind of selfishness to it
Odd way to look at it
We get inklings of this sense of unease.
Definitely felt that
I’m going to be honest, I don’t really understand this blog post
appreciate this honesty
The colonial encounter is romanticized
This makes me think propaganda
story meant for European or colonialist eyes.
I agreed with this on the initial reading but now I am not so sure. It is bold to assume the author's intentions
white woman was hurt by a group of non-white people
the only thing that seems to cause alarm
she—and society as a whole—deemed the context of her captivity unimportant
CONTEXT
By elevating tragic, white-authored colonial encounters, the image of indigenous savagery is maintained and with it spreads the toxicity of imperialism and systemic racism
love this
One hour I have been in health, and wealthy, wanting nothing. But the next hour in sickness and wounds, and death, having nothing but sorrow and affliction.
how quickly life can change
“I watered my Couch with my tears”
what
our son Joseph was come in to Major Waldron’s, and another with him, which was my sister’s son
Honestly what are the odds of this?
They mourned (with their black faces) for their own losses, yet triumphed and rejoiced in their inhumane, and many times devilish cruelty to the English. They would boast much of their victories; saying that in two hours time they had destroyed such a captain and his company at such a place; and boast how many towns they had destroyed, and then scoff, and say they had done them a good turn to send them to Heaven so soon
This sounds more like what we have read about the Europeans doing to the Native Americans
I can but stand in admiration to see the wonderful power of God in providing for such a vast number of our enemies in the wilderness, where there was nothing to be seen, but from hand to mouth.
She believes that God is guiding and providing for them although they are not Christian
preserving the heathen
here is the word preserving, as she uses to describe how God keeps her going. Also, she is back to calling them heathens. It is interesting to see these two words together
Then I took it of the child
a new low
but I found no comfort here neither
i think this is the first time she has not been comforted by the bible
But the Lord upheld my Spirit,
why the heck isn't she more upset ?????
fortnight
two weeks? that seems long
and lie somewhere else
where do they expect her to go? why did they demand she travel back and then not let her stay with them?
preserving us
evidence of religion keeping her alive
invited my master and mistress to dinner
sharing food/breaking bread
me to make a shirt for his boy, which I did, for which he gave me a shilling
trade, currency
my son Joseph unexpectedly came to me
how did he suddenly appear? is she hallucinating?
passed this river
Rivers are repeatedly large obstacles
my wound
why is this back and what happened in the first place?
stoutest men
why their "stoutest men" ?
oaken leaves
healing properties?
I then remembered how careless I had been of God’s holy time; how many Sabbaths I had lost and misspent, and how evilly I had walked in God’s sight; which lay so close unto my spirit, that it was easy for me to see how righteous it was with God to cut off the thread of my life and cast me out of His presence forever.
Guilt, realizing that she took her life for granted before this time.
viz.
?
But the Lord renewed my strength still
religion = coping mechanism
“What, will you love English men still?”
such an odd question
we
who is in this group?
Glooskap
does this have a cultural meaning?
Since that time white men have come to America.
Legends = explanations for things
stone
repetition of stone. Stone canoe, stone pipe
water and fly up to the sky
biblical allusion to Jesus
point this stick at it.”
magic?
The beaver had a stick in his mouth; he gave it to her, and said
talking animal
stranger
repetition of the word stranger
Once there came to her a strange boy; he called her mother.
a type of adoption
House Made of Dawn is thus firmly rooted in a generalized "Indian" context, but it translates and interprets that experience for a non-Native audience. Abel is not "every Indian"-or maybe even "anylndian."
This reminds me of Sherman Alexie's The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Idian
forty-thousand-year history of Native people on this continent
I had no idea that there were people on this continent for this long. This isn't taught properly and I think it's because it makes the Europeans who took this land look even worse.
By far the greatest volume of fiction pertaining to Native Americans has been written about them by non-Natives.
My immediate reaction to this was that it should never count as Native American Literature and I found that interesting because in my definition of American Literature I included "works about America"
Told in the right context by the appropriate teller and to a cued audience, this little story has great impact.
A cautionary tale
explorers' first reaction was one of irrational denial.
This paints the Europeans as so high and mighty that they cannot even fathom the fact that there could be other different people on the planet. It reminds me of the argument that it is selfish and ignorant to believe that Earth contains the only life in the universe.