62 Matching Annotations
  1. May 2025
    1. While the Asian American girls struggled with navigating displacement in the uS, including isolation at home and alienation in classes and mainstream spaces at school, they had sufficient creativity and improvisational skills to invent their own community.

      Tokunaga highlights the agency of Asian American girls in responding to their experiences of ioslation by emphasizing their creativity and improvisational skills in forming their own community. The girls are positioned as active agents such as community builders and cultural producers when they actively share cultural experiences as part of creating their own safe space at school.

    2. The girls rejected many social groups at school, specifically those they thought were racially segregated with exclusive and homogeneous memberships.

      Tokunaga highlights the girls' rejection of school social groups perceived as 'racially segregated with exclusive and homogeneous memberships.' This rejection stemmed from a perceived lack of openness to 'diversity' in various aspects of social life and still persisted until these days as you will ee most Asians will group together and create their safe space.

    3. rather, it was a community ‘where people of different races occupy the same territory, where under, lower, middle and upper classes touch, where the space between two individuals shrinks with intimacy’

      Tokunaga contrasts the Basement Group with typical school-based social groups, which are often characterized by segregation based on 'race, ethnicity, class, and/or gender,' and reflect the power dynamics among students base on those traits. In contrast, the Basement Group is presented as a community that fosters inclusivity, bringing together individuals from diverse backgrounds and creating a sense of intimacy.

    4. Studies have revealed family pressures, such as strict gender roles and expectations (dasGupta & dasgupta, 1998; Espiritu, 2003), body images created by media and popular culture (Lee & Vaught, 2003), and model minority stereotypes (Lee, 2009), as primary forces in these girls’ lives.

      Tokunaga suggests that existing scholarship on Asian American girls and young women has predominantly focused on negative influences. Among these influences, she highlights images created by media and popular culture. This emphasis on the impact of media and popular culture suggests a need to consider the role of these forces in shaping the identities and experiences of these girls, alongside more traditional factors like family pressures and stereotypes.

    5. They face a world of multiple, often contradictory, messages about who they are, what they should become, and how to navigate the world. Their parents expect them to follow and inherit their homeland traditions, beliefs, and values

      Tokunaga highlights the complex social context in which these girls develop their identities. They are confronted with 'multiple, often contradictory, messages' concerning self-perception, aspirations, and social navigation. Parental expectations to follow and inherit their homeland traditions, beliefs, and values are presented as a key influence in this process.

    1. If educators would only enter the translanguaging space in which bilingual read-ers act, it is possible that Latinx bilingual students could become educationally repositioned as success-ful readers. This, in turn, has the potential to also reposition them socially and politically.

      The author affirms that bilingual readers engage with texts by integrating their 'entire selves,' encompassing their whole life experiences. She emphasizes again that educators' adoption of a 'translanguaging space' could lead to the 'educational repositioning' of Latinx bilingual students as successful readers with further potential positive social and political effects.

    2. They realize that he has been lacking opportunities to leverage all his translanguaging to make mean-ing when he reads. The lack is not Arturo’s; it is the school’s, and the educators’ misunderstanding about the language of bilinguals, about translanguaging.

      Garcaa argues that Arturo's reading difficulties stem not from his own deficiencies but from the school's failure to provide opportunities for him to use his full linguistic abilities. The 'lack' is attributed to educators' 'misunderstanding' of bilingual language use and translanguaging practices, highlighting a systemic issue rather than an individual student problem.

    3. I start with Paco, the 3-year-old bilingual child whose mother is a U.S.-born Latina woman and whose father is a U.S.-born white man. The mother grew up in a bilingual home, the father in a monolingual one, but he studied Spanish in high school. The family is comfortable in a translanguaging space, where their use of English and Spanish is unbounded, dynamic, and fluid and adapts to meet the communicative expectations of the many different people who enter the home.

      Garcia introduces a representative example of a child raised in a 'translanguaging space,' a concept that likely resonates with my own upbringing. Just as Paco's family exhibits a mix of linguistic backgrounds, with one parent having grown up bilingual and the other acquiring the second language later, my own family also involve diverse language experiences. The description of the family's language use as 'unbounded, dynamic, and fluid' mirrors the reality of many bilingual households, where languages are not rigidly separated but rather interwoven to facilitate communication between the members.

    4. Most teachers in U.S. schools see their instruc-tion as being in English, and sometimes in Spanish or a language other than English. In this, most teach-ers reveal their monolingual view of literacy, insist-ing that the acts of literacy need to be performed in either one language or the other.

      Garcia critiques the prevailing monolingual and monoglossic perspective of literacy among U.S. teachers and argues that teachers often limit instruction to English, demonstrating a view that literacy must occur in a single language. Furthermore, she identifies a 'monoglossic view' where the language of the text is considered fixed and the only legitimate form of language.

    5. In this article, I argue that the act of reading does not depend on the language of the written text or even on the concept of a named language such as English or Spanish. Rather, the act of reading is about readers assembling all their meaning-making resources and acting on them to read themselves.

      García challenges the traditional view of reading as being solely dependent on the language of the written text or 'named language' categories like English or Spanish. Instead, she suggests that this article will explore on the fact that reading is a process of readers drawing upon their entire repertoire of 'meaning-making resources' to construct personal meaning from the text.

    1. We see this coun-ter-narrative as a crucial element in the development of a systematic analysis of the racism, classism, and linguicism that permeate much of urban educa-tion as well as in the development of culturally relevant curricula

      The authors again position their research as a 'counter-narrative' intended to challenge negative stereotypes of Latino families and their urban neighborhoods.They argue that this counter-narrative is essential for an analysis of the pervasive 'racism, classism, and linguicism' within urban education, and for the development of the relevant curricula.

    2. Although we entered this study assuming that the families had knowledge, skills, and resources, we underestimated the skillful use of multiple elec-tronic devices by the children and their families. Due to our unexamined assumptions about limited access to new technologies in low-income Latino families, we were surprised to see the number of them in the homes, the time spent using them, and the children’s expertise.

      The authors again acknowledge an initial underestimation of the technological proficiency within the studied families. Their prior assumptions of 'limited access to new technologies' among low-income Latino families were proved wrong by the observed usage, and skillful handling of 'multiple electronic devices.' This finding prompts a reconsideration of prevalent assumptions about technology access in these communities, and its implications for literacy practices.

    3. He watched cartoons, listened to Justin Bieber songs and traditional coritos (hymns), and, once he had discovered the karaoke function, was able to sing along, following the written texts. A discussion of maps in school led him to question his grandmother about Puerto Rico and she purchased a towel map of the island that she pinned to his wall.

      This passage provides a compelling example of the 'syncretic literacies' described by the authors above, where Benny actively integrates diverse literacy practices from various sources. His engagement with pop cultures like cartoons and Justin Bieber songs, traditional coritos, and the karaoke function demonstrates a blending of media and cultural forms. This illustrates how children like Benny don't experience literacy as confined to distinct settings but rather explore practices across home, school, and popular culture.

    4. And fourth, children create syncretic literacies when they draw on literacies from school, home, popular culture, the Internet, and religious and other community settings to create new forms and practices.

      They authors suggest the concept of 'syncretic literacies,' emphasizing that children actively synthesize literacy practices from diverse sources, including the often-underestimated domains of 'popular culture' and 'the Internet.' This is a crucial observation, as I think it acknowledges the multimodal and dynamic nature of literacy development.

    5. strengths and resources of the children and their families, rather than their needs and alleged deficits as often described in the dominant discourse

      They choose to explicitly prioritizing the 'strengths and resources' of Latino children and families here. This is not merely a descriptive statement but a critical intervention in a field often characterized by a 'dominant discourse' of 'needs and alleged deficits.' By actively rejecting this deficit-based framework, the authors position their research as a counter-narrative. This is important because it shifts the focus from what these children lack to what they possess, potentially leading to more empowering educational practices.

  2. Apr 2025
  3. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. The worst news of all, however, is this: enrolling in college is one thing, but getting a degree is quite another. The class gap in college com-pletion, which was already substantial 30 to 40 years ago, has steadily ex-panded. This matters hugely, because completing college is much more important than entering college on all sorts of levels

      This highlights a crucial point: the biggest disparity isn't just in who gets into college, but who finishes. The class gap in college completion has grown significantly and matters immensely for future success, showing that the educational hurdles for lower-income students extend well beyond high school graduation.

    2. Yet even in today's America the provision of extracurricular oppor-tunities through public schools remains less discriminatory than wholly private provision-piano lessons, club soccer, and the like.

      This passage makes the point that despite increasing costs and disparities, public school extracurricular activities are still more accessible to children from low-income families than purely private lessons or clubs, suggesting they retain some, though limited, role in leveling the playing field.

    3. That gap corresponds, roughly speaking, to the high-income kids getting several more years of schooling than their low-income coun-terparts. Moreover, this class gap has been growing within each racial group, while the gaps between racial groups have been narrowing

      This is a striking statistic highlighting that the gap in achievement based on family income is already a lot larger than the gap based on race, underscoring the powerful influence of wealth status on early childhood development and school readiness. Some kids are able to attend better schools just because they can afford the tuition.

    4. "I think ic comes from the lack of family cohesion," she says, "Many families in the community were dysfunctional."

      Clara, reflecting on her own youth, offers her perspective on why gang culture was prevalent in her schools, attributing it to a perceived lack of family cohesion and dysfunction within the community. This highlights a view on the social challenges impacting schools in disadvantaged areas.

  4. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. arents have to be an integral part of the mentoring process.

      This suggests Smith's recommendation for strong parent-teacher partnerships, emphasizing that teachers can play a vital role in helping low-income parents access information about crucial opportunities like scholarships and summer programs that parents might otherwise miss, thus helping to level the playing field for their children.

    2. We should incorporate into our teaching the assets low-income students bring to school.

      This highlights Smith's recommendation to shift from a deficit view of low-income students to recognizing and valuing their strengths, such as resilience and persistence. Affirming these "assets" and integrating them into the school culture, she argues, is crucial for supporting these students and potentially reducing dropout rates.

    3. Suddenly a short, stout, White woman approached me, introduced herself as Ms. Hill, and stated she was happy I was in her class. She introduced me to the class, directing their attention my way, and asked the students to introduce themselves to me.

      This passage highlights a positive intervention by a teacher, Ms. Hill, who proactively welcomed her into the honors class. This is significant because Smith describes feeling like an outsider among her wealthier white peers, and Ms. Hill's action helped bridge that social distance, illustrating the impact teachers can have in fostering inclusion.

    4. They talk about the social distance they feel from their peers who have money. They tell me they often hang out with other poor students to avoid being reminded of what they simply don't have.

      This passage reveals the social and emotional toll of the differences on low-income college students, particularly first-generation ones. It highlights how they feel distanced from wealthier peers and may self-segregate to avoid uncomfortable reminders of their financial limitations, illustrating a less visible aspect of inequality within the educational environment.

  5. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Such srudcnts, who arc mainly white and from middle-and upper-middle-class backgrounds, tend to be perceived as smart, skilled, and highly motivated, and they are generally treated with dignity and respect.

      This passage reveals how students from privileged backgrounds, often white and in higher social classes, are frequently perceived positively and treated with respect within the school system, regardless of their academic performance or behavior. This highlights how subjective perceptions, influenced by cultural capital, can contribute to the reproduction of inequality.

    2. For many students of color, however, "freedom of choice" too often h1-s meant freedom to fail or to barely get by. The high school allows students to pick an "easy" reacher or to "choose" to retake a failed class in summer school and fall further and further heh ind.

      This highlights Noguera's critique that for many students of color, the school's system of "freedom of choice" in scheduling doesn't equate to opportunity but can instead lead to choices that result in falling behind or failing, underscoring how seemingly neutral structures can have unequal outcomes depending on student background.

    3. Easy to Jump Down, Hard to Jump Up lt is difficult, though not impossible, to "jutT1p track" upward (Harklau, 1994). Very few students try, and even fewer succeed.

      This section highlights the significant difficulty students face in moving up to a higher academic track once placed, particularly for students of color. It's much easier to move down, illustrating how the tracking structure can limit upward mobility and reinforce initial placements, perpetuating inequality.

    4. Chanrelle's experience illustrates why students who lack eco-nomic, social, and cultural capital ace more vulnerable to the i_inpersonal and ineffective structures at the school. Without an adult to encourage her to cake algebra, the gateway to college preparatory math and science courses, or to advise her on where she might seek academic support, Chantelle made a decision that is likely to affect her preparation for college and therefore will have bearing in the long term on her opportunities after high school.

      This passage uses Chantelle's experience to show how students who lack economic, social, and cultural capital are more susceptible to failing. Her misinformed decision about a math class, made without adequate adult guidance, highlights how these vulnerabilities can lead to choices that negatively impact college readiness and future opportunities.

  6. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. The differences in spending between the two groups had almost tripled in the intervening years. Activities such as music les-sons, travel, and summer camps accounted for the largest difference.

      This passage powerfully illustrates the growing financial disparity in "child enrichment expenditures" between high- and low-income families. The significant increase in spending by wealthier families on things like lessons, travel, and camps highlights how income inequality translates into vastly different opportunities for children outside of school.

    2. His family did not have a reliable car and his mother worried about crime in the neighborhood.

      This sentence where Anthony Mears's mother worried "about crime in the neighborhood", points to a significant stressor and potential barrier faced by families in lower-income areas. This worry isn't just an abstract fear; as the readings suggest, it reflects the reality of living in environments with higher rates of violence and gang activity. Exposure to such unsafe conditions can have negative effects on a child's early development, including their ability to focus and their overall well-being, making it harder for them to succeed in school.

    3. According to economic theory, families with higher incomes are better able to purchase or produce important "inputs" into their young chil-dren's development-for example, nutritious meals, enriched home learn-ing environments and child-care settings outside the home, and safe and stimulating neighborhood environments.

      The reading highlights that nutritious meals are one of the crucial "inputs" into a child's development that families with higher incomes are better able to provide. It explicitly states that poor nutrition and inadequate health care have long-term negative effects on children's intellectual development, linking these income-related factors to disparities in school readiness and success.

    4. The study first assessed the children shortly after they began kinder-garten, providing a picture of their skills at the starting line of their for-mal schooling. It shows that children from families in the top 20 percent of the income distribution already outscore children from the bottom 20 percent by 106 points in early literacy.

      This passage uses specific statistics from a national study to show the concrete impact of income on early educational readiness. The 106-point difference in early literacy scores between children from the richest and poorest families, evident before kindergarten, is a powerful statistic. The authors emphasize its significance by noting it's nearly double the size of racial gaps at that age and equivalent to a full year of typical kindergarten learning.

    5. With an income of more than $300,000, Alexander's family was able to spend far more money on Alexander's education, lessons, and other enrichment activities than Anthony's parents could devote to their son's needs. Both of Alexander's parents had professional degrees, so they knew all about what Alexander needed to do to prepare himself for college.

      This sentence clearly illustrates how higher family income allows for significant financial investment in a child's education and enrichment, and how parents' own educational backgrounds provide crucial knowledge and guidance for navigating the path to college, creating a distinct advantage.

    1. It forces us all to recognize our complicity in accepting and perpetuating biases of any kind. Students are eager to break through barriers to knowing. They are willing to surrender to the wonder of re-learning and learning ways of knowing that go against the grain.

      This passage emphasizes that embracing multiculturalism demands confronting our own biases and complicity in perpetuating them. It also highlights the potential of students, suggesting they are often ready and willing to moves beyond traditional ways of learning.

    2. Despite the focus on diversity, our desires for inclusion, many professors still teach in classrooms that are predominant-ly white. Often a spirit of tokenism prevails in those settings.

      Here, the author points out that even with intentions toward diversity, many classrooms remain predominantly white, and in these settings, efforts at inclusion often fall into tokenism rather than creating truly transformed, multicultural learning environments.

    3. Students taught me, too, that it is necessary to practice com-passion in these new learning settings. I bave not forgotten the day a student came to class and told me: 'We take your class. We learn to look at the world from a critica! standpoint, one that considers race, sex, and class. And we can't enjoy life anymore."

      This quote from a student highlights the potential discomfort and even pain that can come with developing a critical understanding of how race, sex, and class shape the world, underscoring the author point about the emotional work involved in learning and the need for compassion in school.

    4. Students of color and some white women express fear that they will be judged as intellectually inadequate by these peers.

      This highlights how existing social hierarchies and biases can play out in the classroom, leading students from marginalized groups to fear being seen as less capable, sometimes resulting in their voices being silenced despite their intellectual ability.

    5. Arnong educators there has to be an acknowledgment that any effort to transform institutions so that they reflect a multi-cultural standpoint must take inta consideration the t'cars teachers have when asked to shift their paradigms

      This highlights her point that transforming education to be truly multicultural requires acknowledging and addressing the fears educators may have about changing their teaching methods and perspectives, emphasizing the need for support and training in this process.

  7. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. If I had any hope of being as successful as my well-connected peers, many of whom outclassed me, I would need to know some people.

      This is a powerful personal reflection that underscores how social connections and networks, not just individual merit, play a significant role in achieving success, particularly in elite environments, challenging the pure meritocracy often implied by the American Dream. Legacy admissions in college are also mentioned as an example of how family affiliation, often tied to wealth, provides an advantage.

    2. Does every middle school have the capacity to facilitate PSAT testing for its students in the lower grades? Does every middle school in economically blighted districts have highly qualified teachers who can teach college prepara-tory courses? Does every middle school employ counselors who can set each student on a trajectory toward college? No.

      These questions, immediately followed by a resounding "No," powerfully illustrate Jackson's point that access to critical resources and guidance for college preparation is not universal, especially in poor middle schools, demonstrating how the system creates unequal pathways for students.

    3. The middle grades are where the rubber meets the road.

      This sentence highlights Jackson's argument that middle school is a crucial, often overlooked, stage where students are effectively sorted onto different academic paths, significantly impacting their future opportunities, particularly their potential for college and upward mobility.

    4. Why Are People Poor? An Introduction to Reproduction

      This section title signals a move to understand the causes of persistent poverty, introducing the concept of "reproduction." In this context, "reproduction" refers to how social and economic inequalities, including poverty, are passed down from one generation to the next.

    5. Many of us choose to address the equity gap by struggling to supply universal access to high-quality, free, and appropriate public education. Nearly two centuries later, "the great equalizer" cannot equalize soon enough.

      This highlights the author's central critique. While public education was envisioned as "the great equalizer," it has not lived up to this promise and the significant class divides persist, suggesting the system itself may not be effectively countering inequality.

  8. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. he fact that class and race or ethnicity are so intertwined and so embedded in the structure of schooling may provide the greatest barrier of all to the achieve-ment of the dream for all Americans, and helps explain much of the contention, confusion, and irrationality in public education.

      This highlights an argument of the text where the deep entanglement of class, race, and ethnicity within the U.S. education system is the most significant obstacle to realizing the American Dream's promise of equal opportunity for everyone, leading to much of the conflicts in educational policies.

    2. An honest attempt to secure a good education for poor children therefore leaves policymakers with two difficult choices. They can send them to schools with wealthier children, or they can, as a reasonable second best, seek to give them an education in their own neighborhood that has the features of school-ing for well-off students.

      This points to the difficult, often avoided, choices policymakers face when trying to address educational inequality. The text highlights that truly equalizing opportunities would involve either integrating schools across social classes or providing equally resourced schools in disadvantaged neighborhoods.

    3. Because education is so im-portant to the way the American dream works, people care about it intensely and can strongly disagree about definitions, methods, and priorities.

      This sentence underscores the vital link between education and the American Dream. Because education is viewed as the primary pathway to achieving success in the U.S., debates over how schools operate become highly contentious, reflecting deeply held beliefs about opportunity and fairness for American citizens.

    4. Despite this consensus Americans disagree intensely about the education policies that will best help us achieve this dual goal

      While there's broad agreement on the goals of education (promoting individual success and the common good), there's intense conflict over the policies to achieve this, often due to competing interests between individual advantage and collective benefit.

    5. T HE AMERICAN DREAM IS A POWERFUL CONCEPT. It encourages each person who lives in the United States to pursue success, and it cre-ates the framework within which everyone can do it.

      This sentence lays out the foundational, aspirational view of the American Dream and how it's a powerful force providing opportunity for everyone to succeed through individual effort. My experience as an international student somewhat showed me how institutions succeed or fail at true inclusion and equity beyond domestic categories of race and class.

  9. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. We observed a similar pattern in school interactions. Overall, the working-class and poor adults had much more distance or sepa-ration from the school than their middle-class counterparts.

      Lareau notes a trend of 'distance or separation' between working-class and poor adults and school institutions, contrasting with the greater engagement of middle-class parents. This observation reminds me of another reading this week indicating that the demanding schedules and lack of flexibility often experienced by working-class families can limit their ability to engage in with their children school.

    2. "You know, you learn so much from television." Working-class and poor parents did monitor the content of pro-grams and made some shows off-limits for children. The television itself, however, was left on almost continuously

      Working-class and poor parents, in contrast to middle-class parents, did not typically restrict children's access, with some even emphasizing its educational potential. This suggests differing perspectives on the role of media in children's lives and its management across social classes.

    3. At the same time, however, compared to their middle-class counterparts, white and black working-class and poor family mem-bers are more distrustful of professionals.

      Lareau observes a behavioral duality among working-class and poor families: while they exhibit 'deferential and outwardly accepting' conduct towards professionals, they simultaneously demonstrate a greater 'distrust' compared to middle-class families. Further analysis could explore the reasons for this distrust, such as past negative experiences.

    4. little is known about the degree to which children adopt and enact their parents' beliefs.

      I think this one is interesting because it seems like a gap in sociological understanding regarding the transmission of parental beliefs to children. She emphasizes the need for research exploring the extent to which children internalize the beliefs held by their parents.

    5. Middle-class children gained individually insignificant but cumulatively important advantages. Working-class and poor children did not display the same sense of en-titlement or advantages. Some areas of family life appeared exempt from the effects of social class, however.

      Lareau highlights a key disparity in child development where middle-class children have 'cumulatively important advantages,' even if individually minor. This contrasts with working-class and poor children, who lack the same 'sense of entitlement' and associated benefits. The passage also acknowledges that social class does not uniformly determine all aspects, suggesting a nuanced impact.

  10. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. This is both a curse and a blessing.

      This is both a curse and a blessing,' introduces a crucial duality: while the lack of definitive closure can be demanding and potentially overwhelming ('curse'), it also suggests an ongoing and deeply rewarding engagement ('blessing'). This duality warrants further exploration of the complex emotional and psychological investment required of educators.

    2. The most hardened student had a beautiful and deep story full of choices, thoughts, and emotions, and once that story was told-bam!-the ste-reotype of who I thought she or he was split open like a chrysalis revealing the beautiful complex person inside.

      Ungemah argues against the validity of racism and classism, asserting that individual narratives contradict stereotypical assumptions. She uses the 'chrysalis' metaphor to illustrate the transformative power of understanding students' personal 'stories.'

    3. that student population?"

      Ungemah recounts a colleague's question about her conclusions regarding 'that student population,' noting her objection to the depersonalizing language. This prompts her reflection on her transition to community college teaching and the lessons learned from working with students labeled 'at risk' due to poverty and race.

    4. knee-deep in the muck of life and its challenges in low-income communities, and to grow with the students.

      The phrase 'knee-deep in the muck of life' emphasizes the challenging realities of teaching in low-income areas. This stance implicitly critiques colleagues who avoid such settings. Ungemah frames her experience as mutually beneficial, highlighting her own development alongside that of her students.

  11. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Some parents don't come to school because of a hectic work or personal schedule that leaves little room for even small changes in routine.

      While it's definitely hard when the parents are already struggling, I think helping the parents understand how important it is to get involved in their children academic life might be a way to improve the situation. However, I think nowadays, technology made it somewhat easier to maintain communication between the school and the parents. In addition, getting school items signed can be a lot easier than what it had been in the past with digital signing.

    2. still living week to week and check to check

      I think this goes deeper than just living week to week and check to check because there are many underlying problems when you are poor. The person is likely in debt for their whole life as well and that debt will keep accumulate over time, locking the person in that same state forever. It creates a sense of powerlessness that make it hard for the person to have motivation for anything except the minimum to survive.

  12. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Deepen staff understanding

      While this seems straightforward, I think it's easier said than done because the teachers mainly need understand that they have a massive impact on the students' behaviors and have a passion for teaching from the start. Given the state that Mr. Hawkins is already in from the start of this reading, it will be difficult to change his mindset when he's only 6 years away from retirement. 6 years in a teacher's career might not be much, but for a student, that is like half their early educational career.

    2. fewer and less-supportive networks than their more affl uent counterparts do

      This point is crucial because it highlights an important need for those students. Because it's so inaccessible, the school must be one of the supportive network for such students to help offload the physical and emotional stresses from poverty. Having such support will steer the students away from other harmful ways to cope or distract themselves from their problems at home.

    3. motional and social challenges

      I think this plays a big part in how the student perform in school, academically and socially. In my opinion, these challenges can result in them being bullied in school or becoming a bully to "distract" themselves from such issues.

    4. Retirement is only six years away.”

      The teacher's apparent focus solely on retirement plans, without acknowledging students' current struggles like lack of motivation, is disheartening. He could've been more supportive by recognizing and addressing these broader challenges. When the teacher lacks motivation, I think the student would be the same, especially when they are already facing issues as an economically disadvantaged students.