39 Matching Annotations
  1. Oct 2017
    1. The tendency to connect with similar or like-minded individuals online as offline, what Thelwall (2009) calls homophily, means that social media may not foster diverse spaces for knowledge exchange and negotiation, leading instead to “echo chambers,” a situation in which we share knowledge and perspectives with individuals who already share the same views as ourselves.

      This is becoming especially more common with "search" tools on social media that have specific algorithms that show us exactly what we want to see

    1. Or will openness go down in the history books as just another fad that couldn’t live up to its press?

      If universities are starting to take slow steps towards interdisciplinarity- totally or partially- I would assume that in some way OER would have to be a part of that conversation.

    2. However, it is almost always the case that these products are commercialized in such a way that access is restricted to those who are willing to pay for them a second time. Why should we be required to pay a second time for the thing we’ve already paid for?

      This resonates with Robins comments about the library resources we pay half a mil to use each year. We already pay for the research through taxes... now we have to pay for it again?

    3. Open educational resources provide an immediate, proven way to make education significantly more affordable and accessible for students.

      Plus, the collaboration that happens with OER (hypothes.is) allows for sharing ideas.

    4. Today, the cost of having a 250-page book transcribed by hand is about $250. The cost of printing that same book with a print-on-demand service is about $5. The cost of copying an online version of that same book (e.g., an ePub file) is about $0.0008. The cost of shipping either the handwritten or printed book is about $5. The cost of distributing an electronic copy of the book over the Internet is approximately $0.0007.

      How can we possibly call this learning when these are the additional expenses? I cannot afford to buy textbooks. I especially dislike when the only required text in the course is written by the teacher, and it's a requirement that you buy it. As if I wasn't already being robbed by the Uni, now my professors feel that they can reach into my pockets too. Learning from one book, written by one person is not comprehensive learning!

  2. Sep 2017
    1. Make the major minor.

      This idea would allow students to learn how to "think" before putting into practice what they're learning.

    2. Virtually every study of workplace advancement, such as the annual surveys conducted by the National Association of Colleges and Employers, underscores the importance of general skills in communication, collaboration and basic cultural knowledge. CEOs like to complain that the best undergrads come with specialized skills but lack these basics.

      That's because many students are trained in only ONE specific field and when they look for jobs the companies are looking for ONE person to be trained in MANY fields...

    3. How do you train a professional-managerial class at a time of accelerating automation when seemingly any profession could be “Uberized” tomorrow?

      I ask myself this question a lot in business. We call this idea "disruptions". These are trends or new methods that would outsource old ways of doing things and making them obsolete.

    1. The disciplines, where we find a wealth of specific knowledge, are the building blocks of Interdisciplinary Studies.

      It's important to remember that disciplines are not our enemies in IDS but instead our building blocks!

    2. Charles Eliot (21st president of Harvard) gave a speech stating that there is no best method or focus for learning, therefore Harvard will have them all. 

      This is an important mindset for an interdisciplinary institution.

    1. The “digital facelift” helped higher education deny both the needs and the opportunities emerging with this new medium.

      I think more educators need to understand that with a digital facelift come these emerging opportunities to help their students!

    2. The medium is the message.

      In my communications class, we learned that McLuhan also said, "the medium is that massage" as in it gives us a comforting and relaxing feeling. An "ahhhh" moment.

    1. And then – contrary to what happens at most schools, where a student’s work exists only inside a learning management system and cannot be accessed once the semester is over – the domain and all its content are the student’s to take with them. It is, after all, their education, their intellectual development, their work.

      This is truly one of my favorite parts of learning through IDS. I've tried harder on my blog posts because I know they have the potential to reach others in my field. It makes more sense for my education to put my work out there than to submit it on moodle. Another great part is that I can read my peers work and see all the cool things they're working on in their own field. #PlymouthIDS #IDSSem

  3. Nov 2016
    1. Leaders need to have vision, creativity, and perseverance. To establish a successful interdisciplinary program requires education of scientific colleagues and administrators about the potential value of interdisciplinary research. To coordinate the efforts of a diverse team requires credibility as a research scientist, skill in modulating strong personalities, the ability to draw out individual strengths, and skill in the use of group dynamics to blend individual strengths into a team.

      I feel like this is a selling point of IDS: its ability to give students the opportunity to be a leader inside the classroom while inspiring them to be natural leaders outside.

    2. Some of the comments indicated concerns: working in interdisciplinary research was not “pure”; it was “less challenging” or “high risk”; those who do collaborative work could not succeed in their own discipline; they would be lost in a team effort and “lose their professional identity.”

      I feel like this is the general feeling towards the IDS major, that it's less challenging or more "out there". But having something so custom fit heightens my professional identity.

    3. interdisciplinary science is viewed as second-rate.

      It's important that we break the mold and stop this legitimate major from seeming like a oddity

    1. Through the use of interdisciplinary education, critical thinking, creativity, collaboration and communication skills are disbursed within and across the curriculum.

      These are all valuable skills that employers look for.

    2. Students enrolled in interdisciplinaryprograms see instructorsas theymodel continued learning, have an opportunity to build upon their individual strengths and become personally invested in their work.

      Robin puts such effort into teaching us how to continue learning, no other professor has done this before! One of the many reasons I love IDS.

    3. Moreover, interdisciplinary education helps to increase student achievement by promoting positive attitudes toward subject matter, creating curricular flexibility, and integratingrapidly changing information with increased efficiency

      When given the opportunity to chose and engage with the content you learn it allows an individual to feel excited

    4. reach beyond the typical constraints of a single contentarea

      This was the reason I went to IDS as a major; I needed to reach outside what a typical major could offer me.

    5. interdisciplinary education is an important tool in creating new ways of thinking and helping toconnect fragmentedknowledge in a coherent way

      This illustrates a nice mental image that interdisciplinary studies can be the string that allows the pearls of education to be strung together.

    6. Educators areincreasinglycoming to the realization that teaching skills and vague concepts without connectionto real-world applicationsare seen by students as irrelevant andin turn, are easily forgotten[2

      If I will never get the opportunity to use what I'm learning in real life, what's the point? It's excess knowledge.

  4. Oct 2016
    1. Transferable skills of critical thinking, synthesis and research are developed and are applicable to future learning experiences

      I was able to transfer so much knowledge of non-traditional communication skills from my experience at an art school to a more traditional learning environment.

    2. when students encounter something new, they have to integrate it with previous ideas and experiences by connecting the new knowledge to something already known.

      Building off past experiences can be key.

    3. enables students to build their own interdisciplinary pathway by choosing courses which make sense to them

      This! I have never understood why I would need to take an astronomy class for a marketing degree... There are plenty of other courses that would have been a better use of my money.

    4. boundaries

      The idea that there are boundaries between what you can and cannot study in college.

    1. The major challenge is the elucidation of interconnections between disciplines, fiends, and sub-fields

      Interconnections and sub-fields could be the new "major or minor" type of program building.

    2. According to Grunewald colleges must be redesigned as completely interdisciplinary. I couldn’t even imagine my excitement if I attended a school with zero majors. If every single person build his or her degree from the bottom up, how creative and amazing would that be?

      I was thinking of this earlier. I have gotten so much out learning to build my program, more than any gened could have given me.

    3. interdisciplinary studies is proven to broaden our intellectual horizons, therefore we must fund this type of education! If one is truly to think about majoring in interdisciplinary studies, and they are hesitant all they have to do is think about the competition.

      When I was hesitant to major in IDS I sat down with Robin DeRosa who helped me understand that being interdis. is such an advantage in the job market. She had me imagine my "Marketing & Creative Services" degree compared to 90 other "Marketing" degrees when applying for a job. Not only do I have the same marketing experience the other applicants do but I have that little extra in communication and visual arts. Those things can make a big difference to an employer.

    4. According to Grunewald science and technology and communication now drive all aspects of life in the global village, this most importantly includes higher education.

      Keeping up with technical advancements in all aspects of life are key to staying up to date and current in higher ed

  5. spinmelikearecord.wordpress.com spinmelikearecord.wordpress.com
    1. I will not settle for less! I will make the most of my opportunities!”

      My thoughts exactly, I'm in control of my education and it's exciting.

    2. or may not have the confidence to direct

      I have been to two schools and this is arguably my fourth major, and it's taken me three years to figure all of this out! No school offered my perfect major, I took the initiative to build it myself.

    3. The love of learning was the most unexpected benefit of IDS. There is such an emphasis that the work done for this class wont get deleted at the end of the year, that it will be lasting and relevant.

  6. Sep 2016
    1. Traditional assignments don’t necessarily empower students when they have to post them in a public space.

      We don't live in a traditional world anymore. More educators need to get on board with utilizing technology because there's so many better ways to empower a students learning ability than through a textbook.

    2. “To own one’s domain gives students an understanding of how Web technologies work. It puts them in a much better position to control their work, their data, their identity online.”

      Although I'm intimidated by running my own website, it delights me. I have a sense of power and ownership to my knowledge and I can represent that in my own way through my online identity.

    1. By contrast, he introduced his students to open source platforms like WordPress, teaching them about Web standards like HTML and CSS.

      THIS is the "real world" stuff we should be learning!

    2. the domain and all its content are the student’s to take with them. It is, after all, their education, their intellectual development, their work.

      This touches back on last weeks conversation about how meaningless school work can be. If students know that the work they have on their domain will stay and carry them into their future than I imagine the student will go that extra mile to make the content useful. It also feels like your're creating work for you, not your professor.

    1. the complexity of the world requires us to have a better understanding of the relationships and connections between all fields that intersect and overlap

      Students with multifaceted degrees will have the upper hand in the work place. Imagine sifting through 80 "marketing" majors and then one applicants title is "marketing and creative services" (I'm using my optimistic real life example). It's important for students to take initiative and define their own degrees instead of letting school do it for them.

    2. Today's students fulfill general-education requirements, take specialized courses in their majors, and fill out their schedule with some electives, but while college catalogs euphemistically describe this as a "curriculum," it is rarely more than a collection of courses, devoid of planning, context, and coherence.

      This reminds me of last weeks class talking about how limited we are in our education system while being a consumer to our university.