90 Matching Annotations
  1. Jul 2020
    1. ths. The increasing use of texts in education, scholarly studies, and public administration seems to have reached a critical point in the third century b.c.e., when the collections of such documents became conceived of as a thing, a library, which by the second century b.c.e. is articulated as such.

      the term library only becomes conceptualized during the second century B.C.E

    2. We can see from the wills of the Peripatetic scholarchs that at Athens there was no conception of a library during most of the third ce

      i find this widely interesting considering Athens was such a cultural and intellectual hub for Greece during this time. It had some of the greatest philosophers and writers, so for there to not have been a conception of the term library is quite astounding. I wonder if they had a word for it that got lost throughout history, but it doesn't make sense for them not to understand what a library was considering the immense amount of literature and intellectual movements that occurred.

    3. that the word was a poetic coinage; i.e., a word that was intelligible, but not in common usage

      this reminds me of the way Shakespeare used words that were not of popular usage back that but became words because of his poetic coinage.

    4. 75 Rather, a library was a thing recognized as a particular physical and social institution. And though there was no uniform meaning for a library over space and time, we can still get the general outlines of what constituted a library as a discrete concept in the Greek and Roman worlds: a space conceptually centered around the storage and use of

      this is the definition of library that Hendrickson is basing his assumptions on. As he stated before, a collection of writings can be classified as a library for some people, but he's using the word library in a larger more social scale. It implies a setting that not only is larger architecturally wise, but socially wise as well

    5. If the use (usus) of the library (as for the study) demands light, the obvious reason would be so that one could read and write there.

      this is a great observation because it's draws on logical thinking. Obviously a room that demands morning light in a library is a room for study that needs light so one can read and write there. this hints that book-related activities took place inside the library and not outside.

    6. Yet now that it is clear from recent excavations that the library did not open onto a courtyard (as Weber s plan suggested) but rather faced out to sea, the similarity falls away.58 Absent the books, the library of the Villa of the Papyri would resemble more or less closely any other room in any other luxury villa

      this also debunks the previous construction of what a typical Greek or Roman library would look like, because the libraries excavated did not open onto a courtyard or a garden, but rather faced out to the sea. the libraries looked like nothing else than any other wealthy house or villa.

    7. in the House of the Menander is open to question.

      debunks the assumption that the House of Menander was a library as well. Stating that a previous historian. Penelope Allison argues that the shelves were only used to hold small artifacts such as lamps and ceramics, but not books.

    8. int is that it was not Aristotle's Lyceum. John Lynch has pointed out that the Lyceum was a public sanctuary, where it was forbid- den for anyone to own pro

      this completely debunks the previous notion of the Lyceum being Aristotle's first library because it cannot be since it was a public sanctuary and private ownership of it is not allowed. Plenty of other philosophers and teachers came to this place to find students, therefore the credit of there being a supposed library here should not fall on Aristotle.

    9. e.30 Christian Callmer used the will of Theophrastus to outline the features of the Lyceum, but the document cannot serve as a guide.31 Theophrastus died around 287/86 b.c.e., and there is reason to suspect that the area underwent quite a few changes in the thirty- five years between Aristotles death and his o

      Basing historical recounts on previous ancient historians does not provide a completely credible source because like Hendrickson said, Theophrastus died, and obviously there had to have been reconstruction at the Lyceum between the 35 years of his death and Aristotle's

    10. In general, a gymnasium complex usually included a running track and space for wrestling, and often places for disrobing, oiling, and bathing. The open spaces of the track and the palaestra might be enclosed by a covered walkway, and the rooms for disrobing, etc., often lined the outside of the walkwa

      does not seem like the type of place where one would store books, or engage in intellectual conversations. It seems more like a place that was geared towards physical stimulation through exercise and wrestling then intellectual stimulation.

    11. lems. In fact, we have almost no information about the Lyceum in the time of Aristotle, and his books were unlikely to have been kept there in a

      the lack of historical documentation about Aristotle and his library positions historians to focus on pieces from history to put together a larger picture. The larger picture in this case was Aristotle was the first person to create a library however, there is no information to back that up so the traditional narrative cannot hold up in this sense

    12. All these libraries are typical of the "Roman library" layout: a large hall or halls with niches for bookshelves. Unlike the "Greek library," any book- related activities would have taken place in the same room as the books, and not outside in a colonnade or exedra.

      this part explains the difference between Greek and Roman libraries. Greek libraries placed book-related activities outside of the reading rooms, in a colonnade or in a garden. Whereas for the Roman libraries, any book related activities took place in the same room as the books

    13. The first public library for which we have any evidence, the Palatine Apollo library, had a similar layout: rooms off of a colo

      this goes back to the layout of the Greek libraries discussed in the beginning with the gardens and colonnades.

    14. The activity of Aratus may indicate that there was some sort of royal library there in the third century b.c.e., and likewise the report that Aemilius Paullus took books of King Perseus back to Rome with him after his victory in 168 b.c.e.

      this indicates that there probably was a rather large library there during this time. it refutes the idea that Pregamum was the first known established library because it indicates that there was a public library at Antioch during the rule of Antiochus the Great.

    15. e, who died in 322 b.c.e., a generation before the Ptolemies, could not have taught them anything, except by exa

      Hendrickson debunks the notion that Aristotle had instructed the kings in Egypt how to organize a library because he was died a generation before the Ptolemies, so he could not have physically taught them anything. It was a student of his and Theophrastus that came to Alexandria and taught them about the creation of a great library

    16. ral form: a "Greek library" was a small room or rooms off a colonnade (as it had been in gymnasia like the Lyceum), whereas a "Roman library" involved a large reading room that held both books and book-related ac

      this is the basic notion of how historians believe the evolution of libraries occurred. It started off as small rooms in a gymnasia for the Greeks, whereas the Roman libraries were a lot larger and more literature focused with book-related activities

    17. ing the "traditi

      i love the inclusion of traditional narrative in quotes, because it undermines the social census among historians when it comes to ancient libraries. It's important to challenge even the ideas that many assume are correct and factual because especially when it comes to historians, sometimes assumptions become popularized when they are not the truth

    18. a brief overview of the traditional narrative of the history and architecture of ancient libraries, followed by a demonstration why it should be set aside and how it arose in the first

      i appreciate the way he sets up the structure of the article by offering to explain the traditional narrative, why this narrative arose, and then debunking it. It sets up the stage for his assumptions about the origins and development of libraries

    19. ONE FINDS AN OVERARCHING NARRATIVE IN MOST HISTORIES OF THE ANCIENT libra

      By the way the writer says "overarching narrative", you can tell off the bat that he does not believe the mainstream conclusions historians have reached about ancient libraries. theres a sense that he feels it's a little fictionalized.

  2. Jun 2020
    1. Figure 5 is a map that depicts the Sarmatian empire, who, according to Herodotus, established themselves east of the Scythians in the 5th century BCE and were similar to their neighbors in character.

      Run on sentence?? Maybe try. Figure 5 depicts a map of the Sarmatian empire. According to Herodotus, they established themselves east of the Scythians in 5th century BCE, sharing similar characteristics with their neighbors.

    2. This map illustrates the extent of the Scythian empire’s reach. By trading with other civilizations they were able to culturally influence their neighbors.

      I love the captions under the maps cause they go into depth to explain the routes and what they were used for

    1. ons is leading classical scholars to acknowledge that some Greek beliefs about Ama-zons were influenced by women who shared the same activities as men in the nomadic cultures of Eurasia

      Q17

    2. The ancient Persians called this narrow defile Dar- e Alan, “Gate of the Alans” (Daryal Pass), after one of the nomadic tribes of Scythia. The other difficult and longer passage, some-times called the “Caspian Gates

      Q15

    3. t is easy to see how these commonsense, routine fea-tures of nomad life could lead outsiders like the Greeks— who kept fe-males dependent on males— to glamorize steppe women as mythic Amazons.

      Q10

    4. Royal Scythians” had come to reside in wagons or settlements clus-tered around the northeastern Black Sea– Don area, taking up agricul-ture and trade, facilitating exchange between Greece and points along the Silk Routes to Asia

      Q8

    5. Their common material culture, the “Scythian Triad” of distinctive weap-ons, horses, and artistic “animal- style” motifs, is evident in archaeological artifacts in burials from the Carpathian Mountains to northern China. Grave goods demonstrate far- reaching trade among these groups.

      Q7

    6. but the terms Scythia and Scythians, the names used by the ancient Greeks, are convenient catchall terms to refer to the diverse yet culturally similar nomadic and seminomadic groups of Eurasia to western China. Modern historians and archaeolo-gists use “Scythian” to refer to the vast territory characterized in antiq-uity by the horse-centered nomad warrior lifestyle marked by similar warfare and weapons, artistic motifs, gender relations, burial practices, and other cultural features.

      Q6

    7. The Greeks call them Scythians,” wrote Herodotus; the Persians called them Saka (Chinese names in-cluded Xiongnu, Yuezhi, Xianbei, and Sai). “

      Q5

    8. or the Greeks, “Scythia” stood for an extensive cultural zone of a great many loosely connected nomadic and seminomadic ethnic and language groups

      Q4

    9. In Far Scythia, nomadic prospectors braved the des-ert wilderness to reach secret gold sands guarded by fantastic beaked monsters called griffins.

      Q3

    10. Under the influence of intoxicating clouds of burn-ing hemp, they buried dead companions with their favorite horses and fabulous golden treasures under earthen mounds scattered across the featureless steppes.

      Q2

    Annotators

    1. The intense cultural exchange of the period is most impressively demonstrated at Begram, 60 kilom-eters north of Kabul. The site controls the main north – south route to Central Asia. Excavations in a small, 35 ×60 meter “ palace ” furnished a spectacular col-lection of artifacts. Ivories from India and lacquer work from China were found alongside painted and millefi ori glass from the Mediterranean as well as fi nely executed gypsum tondi representing gods, humans, and animals from Alexandria in Egypt.

      Q16

    2. The Arsacid period witnessed an enormous surge in the intensity of the trade that connected Mesopotamia and the Mediterranean with China via the steppes and with India along the coast and across the Indian Ocean. Exchange along the Central Asian caravan routes, the “ silk road, ”

      Q16

    3. On the contrary, in architecture as in tombs and burial practices, reliefs, and pottery, local traditions are clearly present and differences between strongly Hellenized city centers such as Susa and sites in the countryside are marked.

      Q12

    4. One of the most impressive Arsacid sites known is Qaleh Yazdigird, situated on a hill overlooking the main route from Babylonia to the Iranian plateau on the western fl anks of the Zagros Mountains. A huge enclosure surrounds the site. Residential units and a well - preserved palace have been partly cleared. More than 300 stucco panels, reliefs, and fi gurative capitals, dating to the late 2nd – 3rd century AD, were recovered from the walls and columns of the palace.

      Q11

    5. The large urban centers of Babylonia, Seleucia - on - the - Tigris, Babylon, Nippur, and Uruk provide ample evidence of Arsacid material culture.

      Q10

    6. References to Central Asian architecture are found in the “ Round Hall, ” part of a complex structure of several buildings grouped around a central courtyard. The walls of a circular hall (dia. 17 meters) inside a 30 meter wide square build-ing were standing to a height of 4 meters when excavated.

      Q9

    7. Arsacid - period architecture at Hatra and Nineveh, stucco and slipper - shaped glazed coffi ns at Uruk and Susa, as well as rock reliefs in Iran, were among the fi rst archaeological remains documented in the Near and Middle East

      Q8

    8. Even if there had been any specifi c nomadic residue in social practices or organization at this time, which is doubtful, it became overshadowed by the urbanized imperial setting.

      Q6

    9. But neither the title “ king ” nor the right to mint coins necessarily implied independence. Rather, they entailed submission with certain rights and duties under the aptly titled “ king of kings

      Q7

    10. Iranian character of “ the Parthians, ” this view has created a negative image of the Arsacid Empire as a loosely or rather poorly organized entity with a weak central government which, even after centuries of being based in Mesopotamian and other metropolises, still adhered to ancient nomadic traditions

      Q4

    11. Notable exceptions are the astronomical diaries from Babylon and some archives from Babylon, Nippur, and Uruk, which offer succinct information on the early years of Arsacid rule in Babylonia

      Q3

    Annotators

  3. clas3209.wordpress.com clas3209.wordpress.com
    1. Map of Bactrian Trade Routes in the 1st century BCE

      Provide links to the artifacts underneath. But overall this seems to have useful information so I suggest keeping it?

  4. clas3209.wordpress.com clas3209.wordpress.com
    1. Bactria laid at the crossroads of trade routes that went from here to Iran, India and China. Incense, spices and fabrics were brought from India, and silk, iron, nickel and furs were brought from China. Greco-Bactrian coins were in circulation far beyond the kingdom itself; they are found, in particular, in Eastern Europe.

      This paragraph was previously stated before with the same information, therefore having it here again seems pointless.

    2. Gold coin of Diodotus I king of Bactria, c. 245 BC. The Greek inscription reads: “ΒΑΣΙΛΕΩΣ ΔΙΟΔΟΤΟΥ” – “(of) King Diodotus”. Cabinet des Medailles, Paris.

      We should include a link to the source

    3. Its strategic geographic location near the crossroads of three continents had a great effect on the history of Bactria. The land was a large plain through which ran Silk Road. Anyone traveling to the Hellenistic empires from India or China would have had to cross it when going to sell their wares. Incense, spices, and fabrics were brought from India, and silk, iron, nickel, and furs were brought from China. As a consequence, Greco-Bactrian coins were in circulation far beyond the kingdom itself; they were found even in Eastern Europe. There was also gold, silver, and lapis to be found in the mountains. This location made Bactria a valuable province for rulers to capture.

      Restructure this paragraph so it flows a lot better.

  5. clas3209.wordpress.com clas3209.wordpress.com
    1. Tattoos made in Scythian style can be distinguished by the characteristic motifs easily: this wave, crosses, swastikas, composed of flowers of tridents cruciform shape. Besides, very popular in the Scythian wearable images are floral designs of leaves, buds, flowers arranged in any geometric pattern or a geometric figure.

      Restructure this whole paragraph because it doesn't seem to make much sense

    2. Fragment of mummified skin showing a Scythian tattoo. © The State Hermitage Museum, St Petersburg, 2017. Photo: V Terebenin.

      Provide a link to the source

    1. Artifacts in the Met Museum

      This page seems pretty good and doesn't need much editing, aside from the two pictures that are halfway cropped because of sizing issues.

    1. Perspectives from Greek Authors

      I don't see the point of this page because it doesn't offer us much insight on who the Scythians were, rather than very brief mentions of them for juxtaposition purposes by Greek authors. I think we could get rid of this page and use it to go more in depth about the Amazonian women

    2. This specific text outlines the amount of land Scythia covers and which other nations and peoples border them. It talks a bit about the important geographical points about the region such as what features surround them and how easily they can travel to their neighboring nations.

      It would be a good idea to read this text and then provide more information on the main page about what exactly made up the Steppes, and what lands Scythians traveled through. It gives a lot of geographical knowledge

    3. written by Herodotus, an historian in ancient Greece. He was an important historian and was said to have invented that field of study.

      Herodotus is mentioned in the main page but there is not introduction of him until now

  6. clas3209.wordpress.com clas3209.wordpress.com
    1. Arrhidaios, now calledPhilip III, was recognized as king, but provision was made for a jointkingship should Roxane bear a son, naming Perdikkas and Leonnatosas the child’s potential guardians.

      a joint kingship is not an ideal situation, and i sense it's not going to work

    2. Ptolemy suggested that the council itself should govern the empire,exercising royal authority without a king, and await the outcome ofRoxane’s pregnancy before making any other decision regarding thesuccession.

      this seems like a more democratic approach, ensuring that all the power doesn't end up on the wrong person. I don't quite understand why they allowed Perdikkas to have executive control.

    3. The only other dynastic choice was Alexan-der’s half brother, Arrhidaios, who was reputedly mentally or emotion-ally incompetent.

      i wonder if this is a reference to his mental health?? That perhaps he had a mental disability and therefore couldn't possibly be a successful successor in their eyes at that time.

    4. Over the previous year, half of the twentyprovincial governors (satraps) had either already been executed for trea-son and malfeasance or were awaiting that fate, which hamstrung thenormal machinery of government. The leading figures of the last decadewere all gone, dead from the strains and conditions of the campaignsthemselves or executed in the intrigues of court politics.

      this indicates that theres a large political unstableness within the kingdom

    5. Worse, he had failed toprovide for any succession

      this can lead to immense political and social strife because it creates uncertainty amongst the kingdom.