Grading Contracts: Assessing TheirEffectiveness on Different Racial Formations
- The study is designed to examine the different experiences of effectiveness with grading contracts by African American, Asian and Pacific Islander, and White students, what the research questions as "effectiveness on different racial formations", which is important because it is the only study of race for scholarship in labor-based grading contracts and of a quantitative sort, and the author thinks the findings will inform their own practice as an instructor and their implementing them as a co-director of the writing program under study.
- There are a few research questions including how effective has my grading contract been for my students; does it work better for some students than others; and how are various racial formations faring on our assessments, and the primary variable of interest is three senses for effectiveness.
- The author assumes the variables of effectiveness represent quantity of work produced, its quality, and reactions to and acceptance of grading contracts, which serve as a proxy for experiences the students have of grading contracts.
- All the students are positioned through a lens of assets with writing assessment systems positioning only white students with assets, so the participants are positioned as advantanged in the case of white students and disadvantaged in the cases of African American and Asian and Pacific Islander students by effects of conventional grading, and their senses of effectiveness are framed as malleable, because contract grading is alternative to conventional grading and implies the participants have agency to earn a grade whether or not they follow standardized edited academic American English.
- The author claims to measure consequential validity of grading contracts which have either positive or negative consequences for quantity and quality of writing by the participants.
- The final sample size of the survey reflected the distribution of enrollment by the different racial formations under study, because even though it looked as if more White students responded, when student enrollment statistics are compared to students who completed the exit surveys, students of color are somewhat overrepresented in the survey... White students are underrepresented when compared to overall university enrollment figures, and the sample size, and all students portfolios were included along with their grade distributions, so the sample is big enough to make the claims about effectiveness of grading contracts on different racial formations in the writing program with limitations of the sample in this study only being for African American students which represent the lowest enrollment at the university to make claims about African American students' experiences.