The reasons that felt most compelling to me were from Care Ethics and Consequentialism. Care Ethics emphasizes responsibility in close relationships, which makes me feel that intervening is an act of love for my parents. Consequentialism reminds me that while intervention may upset them now, it prevents more serious harm later.
I especially feel this way because of my grandfather’s story. He delayed surgery, and we respected his choice. He might delay cause of fear or other conerns but we agree with his choice. Later, when his condition worsened, the chance of survival was much lower, and we regretted not intervening earlier. That experience makes me believe that sometimes respecting wishes can also mean avoiding responsibility since for me i think part of the reason that i agree with my grandfather is i am ear of losing him on surgery. Then, due to my experience, i will must intervening since i believe intervening is better for their wellbeing in long term.
The framework that best supports intervening is Care Ethics, because it emphasizes the responsibility of love and the moral duty to protect those who cannot fully protect themselves. The framework that best supports not intervening is Natural Rights, since it prioritizes respecting an individual’s freedom and decision-making, even when those decisions may carry risks.