Very interesting and well-controlled study on the roles of different Golgi-localized vesicle-tethering proteins. I believe the discussion of GARP function in Golgi trafficking would benefit from consideration of two recent papers from our laboratory characterizing the mammalian GARP complex (PMID: 36578782; PMID: 40100055). These studies, together with another paper already cited in the manuscript (PMID: 34161137), demonstrated that both GARP knockout cells and cells subjected to acute GARP depletion exhibit significant glycosylation defects, as well as mislocalization of a subset of Golgi enzymes and SNAREs. These findings strongly support a role for GARP in intra-Golgi trafficking in mammalian cells. We believe that these mammalian data further support the proposed intra-Golgi trafficking function of GARP in yeast cells.