29 Matching Annotations
  1. May 2024
    1. hen teachers talk to girls about their appearance, the conversations are usually longer, and the focus stays on how pretty the girl looks. Sometimes the emphasis moves from personal appearance to papers and work. When boys are praised, it is most often for the intellectual quality of their ideas. Girls are twice as likely to be praised for following the rules of form. "I love your margins" or "What perfect handwriting" are the messages.

      This interaction was really interesting because of I know that girls are more often commented on their appearance. Meanwhile boys are not praised on appearance as much. However the difference was how appearance is even judged on their school work like handwriting or formatting. While I knew this to be true in physical appearance, the way in which their intellectual work is judged was surprising.

    2. Teachers praise students only 10 percent of the time. Criticism is even rarer-only 5 percent of comments. In many classrooms teachers do not use any praise or criticism at all. About one-third of teacher inter-actions are comprised of remediation, a dynamic and beneficial form of feedback.

      This is interesting because students would likely benefit from receiving support and discussion from their teachers. It makes me wonder if teachers maybe scared from sharing their criticism of their students work. And if they are scared, how has and can it affect her students work. In other words, how is it impacting their ability to improve or understand material in the long term if they are not given criticism or little praise from their teachers.

    3. watched as girls typi-cally raised their hands, arms bent at the elbow in a cautious, tentative, almost passive gesture. At other times they pause or stop to think before raising their arms straight and high. Educator Diana Meehan calls this phenomenon the "girl pa use": If a teacher asks a question, a girl pa uses to think, Do I know this? Meanwhile, a boy blurts out an answer, and the class moves on. 2 In contrast, when boys raise their hands, they fling them wildly in the air, up and down, up and down, again and again.

      It is interesting to know how girls approach certain classroom behaviors, and how the Sadkers defined these interactions as "girl pause". In other words, this form of acting sis on the basis of ones gender and impacts ones own identity on being able to create their identity. But these means that for educators they would be tasked with creating a certain environment that asks for collective contribution from students.

    4. The gendered nature of the classroom compromise can be subtle and is often ignored. Male students frequently control classroom conversa-tion. They ask and answer more questions. They receive more praise for the intellectual quality of their ideas. They get criticized more publicly and harshly when they break a rule. They get help when they are con-fused. They are the heart and center of interaction. Watch how boys dominate the discussion about presidents in this upper elementary class.

      This point makes me think about how teachers and educators are working to try to improve the level of comfort in this class, and ensure how girls, minorities, and new English speakers are able to participate in a class. While this is a significant role for teachers to tackle, but is necessary for them to address issues that could determine a students ability to develop confidence and academic skills.

    1. Whereas “fag discourse” is overt and a form of public shaming that draws attention to students to squelch dissent, silencing any reference to “gayness” also privileges and reinforces heterosexuality.

      It was important for the author to include this portion of the implications of immortalizing homosexuality, especially in schools because that is where students begin to foster their own ideas and identities. But what is important to point to is how ethnicity or race effects gender and sexuality identity. For communities of color, it is more difficult for young adults to share their identity with their family because of their histories where anything but being heterosexual would cost ones life. This is not to say that it is not prevalent in white populations, however people of color are increasingly at risk of night finding the right resources or support because they are historically underserved.

    2. Students’ testimonials reveal how exclusionary beliefs interact with school practices such as dress codes, curriculum tracking, and narrow course cur-riculum to maintain raced-gendered inequality and sexualized policing that typecasts, limits, and recreates hierarchies.

      One experience that dissimilar to the sexualize policing girls in high school both Latinas and Black girls were instantly impacted by this in school. During the hottest days of the year, where our school was located would be in 90s to 110s, and many girls would wear tank tops, shorts, skirts, and other pieces. But many of us would be dress coded because it was "showing too much skin". Our school had bad air conditioning and old classrooms, and with little ventilation being in class would be uncomfortable. However the same was not said to our male counterparts who had shorts. This demonstrated how the dress coding was because we were being sexualized and therefore targeted. The only time were we supported was when a few teachers posted on their doors they would not be taking part in dress code because it was targeting and sexualizing girls.

    3. Meanwhile, unequal access to resources persist, and sex edu-cation remains absent in schools such as SCHS, thereby limiting students’ opportunities to learn more about their bodies, relationships, health, and sexual identities. Such absence persists in part because “lessons about sexual pleasure upset the balance of gendered power in our society by introducing women’s capacity for self-determination”

      This becomes even more true once in middle or high school as girls of color are affected by discriminations of their bodies. But the persistence of these practices are created to uplift male and/or white dominated spaces. In other words, aptriahcal systems commonly target girls and women of color as uncontrollable and can only be stopped by a white man. As a result, the controlling of Latina, Black, Asian, and Indigenous bodies are learned by men who teach one another to stereotype girls and women.

    4. They are historically rooted and permeate all aspects of our society, including attitudes and dynamics at schools. At SCHS, there are several recurring myths categorizing Latina/o students as uncaring about education, hypersexual, and potentially preg-nant teenagers. These beliefs impact experiences and material conditions

      The study's focus of Latinas at SCHS to understand their schooling and mechanisms throughout high school is interesting because of the growing popualtion of Latinx students across the country. By focusing on Latinas, it targets both gender, ethnicity, and at time immigration status. More importantly, the focus on gender helps identify how gender roles and forms of oppression begin in public schooling that continue into adulthood. As explained by the author, commonly are sexualized. This creates danger for Latinas, and of course Black, Asian, and Indigenous girls who are sexualized on the basis os stereotypes because of their skin color and connotations.

    5. Emerging in the context of “tough on crime” policies and fueled by a culture of fear and the demonizing of youth of color, schools are increasingly using prisonlike tactics, including zero tolerance policies where students caught violating school rules face stricter penalties, including suspensions, expulsions, and maybe even police interventions

      These tactics are common in schools with predominantly Black and Latino schools in low income communities. As result, many of these students are constrained to the life to prison like schools. This is because of attempts to control crime however, this socializes students who are commonly targeted as being guilty of crimes to be socialized into that role. Instead of providing the right and sufficient resources to improve attendance, or completion of k-12 the they are targeted.

    1. "Boys are definitely punished more often and publicly," a veteran math teacher told us. "Boys are boys. They talk loudly, interrupt, and push each other around to prove they matter," professed a second-year English teacher. For girls, teachers worried most about sexual harassment. A social studies teacher offered this insight, "Sexual harassment is an unspoken threat to female students. Sadly, I think young males see the verbal and physical harassment of girls as a rite of passage."

      The teachers insights into the interactions between boys and girls, and how gender is practiced in classrooms can be troubling. This is because interactions could either be addressed or need to be retaught in order to change see harassment as rites of passage. This is because students would likely replicate these interactions and learned behaviors once older. If unlearned, it would increase and continue normalized behavior of intimate partner violence and aggressiveness.

    2. As a teenager, I find myself obsessed with achieving the "white girl" look: slim hips, perky breasts, flat stomach. I hate that I don't look like white models in magazines. ....

      In addition to the obsession of achieving a perfect image is the culture within communities of color but also white supremacy in media and in institutions like schools. Within Latino households, girls are commonly affected by colorism that promoting dangers and unhealthy expectations for young women and girls. As result, Latinas are raised to perform under whiteness only because of learned behavior and beliefs that families place pressure on girls.

    3. She took her most important step toward status when she stopped raising her hand so that classmates wouldn't realize she knew the answers. She told Keyes: "It made a tremendous difference." "You were asked out more?" "Oh, yeah. Instantly." She grimaced. "I realize the kind of patheticism of it-(a) that I stopped raising my hand, (b) that I felt I had to, and (c) that it worked.

      This was interesting observation from Ephron as she reflects on her own interactions with other students at a young age. When we discuss the gender roles in schools, because of socialization and peer pressure it is explains certain behaviors. But even more astonishing was the way in which Ephron held herself back academically because of her social environment and interests. For Ephron, she provides an interesting insight into the way she understood her interactions at 15 and how she either fit herself into a role.

    1. While Japanese provided them a tool for creating a pan-Asian language that they felt connected to, their use of Japanese cannot be romanticized. They had access to Japanese language through the global dissemination and popularity of Japanese popular culture, which was based on Japan’s strong economic and cultural power (Iwabuchi, 2002). They did not have the similar contact with other Asian popular culture, besides that of Korea, which may have limited their adoption of other Asian languages. Additionally, they seemed to be aware that using Japanese gave them some form of power, given its popularity in the uS and Japan’s high status within the hierarchy of Asia

      This was interesting obersvation among the girls, while they each were apart of their own Asian community they managed to find one language to share amongst themselves. But what I found even more interesting is how English was not the pan-language that they highlighted. It seemed as though they wanted to ensure that they had their culture highlighted through common interests. This demonstrates how they are able to celebrate their similar, but still different, in an American school. While still thriving despite the racial segregation that is amongst students. But I believe this to be the same for other ethnic and racial groups of students like the ESOL group, because they likely are comfortable with others of similar backgrounds and even experiences.

    2. My various identities – a Japanese citizen, an Asian woman, a non-native English speaker, and a doc-toral student (at the time of my fieldwork), with a middle-class background, among other aspects of my identity and experiences – impacted the ways I understood phenomena and how I built relation-ships with the girls. I am aware of my positionality in representing the lives of the girls and producing this ethnography

      The researcher's comment on their positionality and how her immersion into the world of the girls was interesting but necessary. Similar to another study, this helps the students to be comfortable and have that relatability to the researcher. Otherwise, students would perform in front of them and not provide an accurate obersvations of the students.

    3. nderstanding the constraints these girls experience is important to disrupt this pattern. However, it is equally important that scholars explore the girls’ agency, capacity ‘for desiring, for forming intentions, and for acting creatively’ (Sewell, 1992, p. 20) in navigating these constraints. While the girls are not ‘free agents’ (Ortner, 2006, p. 152) with complete control over their lives, they are ‘capable of exerting some degree of control over the social relations in which one is (they are) enmeshed’ (

      The author does well in highlighting how young Asian American students with their limited freedom and amongst themselves they are able to find their own self identify to access their desires and creatively think. But it does well in identifying that just as being limited to their parents's supervision, they are also limited to their own culture. However their own socialization and learning amongst one another, they manage to develop these agencies.

    1. bilingual readers who bring their entire selves—their language, with its multilingualism and multi-modalities; their emotions; their bodies; and their lives—into the text.

      What I really like about this conclusion is highlighting how bilingual specifically Latinxs, have managed to use their cultural and social surroundings to improve their education. This helps promote bilingual education to be apart of the curriculum especially for students from diverse populations. For districts with a significant amount of students speaking another language would be supported to get the resources to improve both their English and native language.

    2. Ms. López respects Yamaira’s translanguaging space and acknowledges that even though the class is officially in English, Yamaira has opened a trans-languaging space that has transformed the class. Latinx bilinguals, who make up 75% of this middle school, have begun to understand that their trans-languaging is a resource, not a hindrance, for read-ing deeply about history and other content.

      When we consider the historical consideration of speaking another language where Spanish speaking students were unable to, even amongst themselves. This has been the same case for native students who were forced into schools to be "Americanized". This practice was ensuring that students were in some ways colonized. But since then, this section demonstrates how language has and can liberate students from white supremacy. Luckily, for Yamaira and other students are supported in being bilingual.

    3. ranslanguaging focuses on the unbounded and agentive dynamic actions of bilinguals as they use their entire linguistic/multimodal repertoire. Bilingual readers leverage all of their meaning-making resources and all of themselves as they engage with text.

      Before this reading I had not heard of this from of being bilingual before, but they us of translanguaging seems to be more accurate of defining both the cultural and social experiences of student speaking more than one language. The author describes this as bilingual readers being able to leverage all forms resources and meaning from texts to engage with bodies of writing. This reminds me of how when speaking, bilingual speakers commonly switch in and out of language in order to express certain emotions and/or expressions. Similarly, it seems when they read bilingual readers look to be able to be able engage with readings and formats to effectively make their own connections.

    1. The agency of the boys, their families, and community members was evident as they generated that flow by transporting, transforming, and syncretizing literacies “aggressively and persistently” (Neuman & Celano, 2001, p. 15). Looking at the places alone as “access points” as we originally intended would have masked the activity and creativity of the participants and the flow they generated between spaces

      The author does well in pointing out the differences among the two children and how they are exposed to different spaces where they can still get educate. What this points to is how either informal or formal practices for different families, they are able to adapt to what resources they have at hand. As well as using their environments to help their children. This is necessary to note because it helps support students to not be limited in formal education such as paid tutoring sessions, but successfully adapt to what they have around.

  2. Apr 2024
    1. A discussion of maps in school led him to question his grandmother about Puerto Rico and she purchased a towel map of the island that she pinned to his wall. Kenny, the teenage son of the family living with them temporarily, taught Benny to use Google Maps and he explored Puerto Rico—copying the spelling of cities from the towel map—as well as his neighborhood, sites in the city he had seen on a school field trip, and a water park he had visited with his family.

      This interaction between Benny, his grandmother, and brother Kenny demonstrates how these literacy spaces are different from a common American one, and how this family adapted to the resources they had. But they also maximized the roeusrces such as the Google Maps in order for Benny to know about Puerto Rico. While it not may have the intention of Benny to learn, he used what his family gave him and likely learned something.

    2. To complete the homework, Gina and Miguel sat at the dining room table, using pencils, crayons, paper, or scissors stored in the cabinet there. First, either Miguel read the instructions on his own or Gina read them in English, asking whether he understood. Then, Miguel proceeded to complete the tasks while Gina provided prompts if he hesitated, scaffolding the sounding out of words and rarely providing them. They moved through the tasks without interruption and without words of praise from Gina.

      This reminds me of a personal experience, being apart of what is known as the first germination, my mom growing up would ensure that I was learning something at all times. Either that be math, geography, or reading she would be given materials that would teach me a new skill. One particular experience was when she had me learn multiplication on my own, as my mom only uses English a little and was not able to finish school. But in that instance I was not wanting to learn, but she would make sure I could not leave until I had everything right. But similar to Gina, there was no praise instead moving onto the next one.

    3. this investigation found that the boys and their families had created rich literacy spaces that reflected their lives and interests. In addition to workbooks, worksheets, and books brought from school for homework, the families had books of their own, library books, newspapers, folders of student awards and report cards, school and city notices and questionnaires, advertising flyers, lists, cook-books and recipes, games with instructions, photo albums, Bibles and reli-gious books, televisions and TV schedules, soccer magazines, computers, videotapes, electronic games, CD players and CDs, iPods, and global posi-tioning system (GPS) devices among other

      I wonder on what claim and support that Benny and Miguel's community had few "reading materials". While there seemed o be no mention about how researchers came to this conclusion, I assume that the definition of reading materials is written by common materials by those with he capital and/or are white Americans, This is because is did not consider the various forms of reading materials that could be used and actually be an advantage for students. This would also support how immigrant students without common resources are in fact able to access different tools.

    4. “culture in the middle” (Cole, 1996, p. 116) by exploring the complex “webs of signifi-cance” (Geertz, 1973, p. 5) among the social and cultural understandings and practices constructed by human actors.

      What is interesting about this piece is their emphasis of culture being in the middle and playing a significant role in the construction of a person. For us, immigrant students are the focus and a major actor because they soak up any and all information they are given that support their academic journey. By using their cultural experiences as a major player in their research, one can understand how students are processing their experiences as being undocumented but also growing up among native born peers.

    1. hus leaving them vulnerable to the consequences of their “illegality”. As undocumented immigrant students reach these important American milestones, they must learn the hard lessons of what it means to be undocumented. Equally important, they must deal with the stress and stigma that accompanies their new status. Negotiating separation among their community of peers, friends, and classmates is all the more diffi cult, as undocumented immigrant youth must make decisions about whether to reveal or conceal their status.

      The author wrote that undocumented students have to negotiate the separation of their community, and this is effective in describing how they are essentially left on their after public schooling. Without the presence and cotibkutions from an educator, students will not know what opproetunies are out there in order to receive support. Overtime the change into illegality is mentally and emotionally tolling on students no matter if high or lower achieving. Simply because the opportunity was never there and are unable to support themselves.

    2. t is important to note that school success or failure often hinges upon whether school offi cials create a culture that facilitates positive interactions among students, teachers, and staff

      This is especially true for undocumented students because of the fact that they commonly require ESL courses and possibly need to catch up to an average performance if they had yet too. This goes back to the building of social capital with teachers, especially through encouragement and postive support. Since immigrant students are easily influenced, what I mean by this is that because of cultural and social differences, interactions with educators determine a students development.

    3. suggest that students’ ability to access these relationships is shaped by their position within the school curriculum hier-archy. There are many reasons why undocumented immigrant students do not make successful transitions to college: exclusion from fi nancial aid, resource-challenged families, frustration, and disillusionment, to name a few. But we fi nd that many students are also disadvantaged by school structures that fail to illuminate pathways to resources critical to successful

      This highlights how the limitations posed on undocumented students is not singular to legal difficulties, but also due to the public resources that they can access. Teacher's commonly lack the right resources to address their students needs especially when located in a population with a population. Native born students already have a difficulty having support for secondary schooling, we already know how this is intensified for students who need extra support and direction.

    4. ery little, however, is known about lesser aca-demically achieving young adults like Flor, who, because of legal, fi nan-cial, and educational barriers, make up a larger share of this population.

      While the author attempts to make a distinction between "higher" and "lesser" achieving young adults, it is important to know that this lesser achievement is very likely due to limited chances to continue school. Similar to Flor who out of necessity needed to start working, the differences is not in their academic capability but their opportunity among their families. I mention this because without no change in documentation, no matter if high or low achieving they remain in the same place without documentation and limited opportunities.

  3. docdrop.org docdrop.org
    1. Further, all second-generation children are U.S. citizens, whereas many first-generation children must contend with the realities of undocumented status. There are well over 11 million unauthorized immigrants in the United States

      The author's distinction to readers of what makes certain the first and second generation different, alludes to pointing out the difficulties of having an undocumented status. Second generation still share a set of struggles when it comes to education, however the first germination and parents are forced to deal with legal processes in order to stay in the country. This helps provide context as to how social and even political factors create difficulties in as students academic achievement.

    2. Immigrant students, new to the Ameri-can system, will be heavily reliant on school personnel-teachers, counsel-ors, coaches, and others-to guide them in the steps necessary to success-fully complete their schooling and, perhaps, go on to colleg

      Similar to students who are native born or 2nd generation, immigrant students too depend on the system of public schooling especially that of educators and administrators. As the most accessible authoritative and fusing figures, educators who are willing and can provide insight into schooling and opportunities after are necessary. But a major difference for immigrant students is that the social partial that is respective to American schooling and social life is limited or can not be found in their household. This is simply because their parents similar have had to navigate a new county and need support developing their social capital. Which why the support of quality teachers is necessary to their educational development.