7 Matching Annotations
  1. Nov 2021
    1. I think Chichen Itza is a super fascinating topic within the Middle Ages timeline as it is outside of the general scope that people think of when they think of the Middle Ages. It is a city of the Mayan and Toltec culture in the Americas and is largely separated from the rest of the world and its influence so it is really interesting to see in what ways they advanced and what inspired them in contrast to the rest of the world.

      An extremely important point, and seemingly a good source for a thesis. This city not only expands what we know about the Middle Ages, but also acts as a present day influence of the time.

    2. there is some speculation that Chichen Itza had been abandoned by the time that the league became a recognized power.

      This is one of the points that would do well will a source or two to back it up.

    3. here are a few important buildings within Chichen Itza that are usually looked at the most. The first one is El Castillo. El Castillo is a large pyramid structure with 91 steps on each side of it and then a larger step as a sort of platform at the top which totals 365 steps. This is equal to the same number of days there are in a solar year which they knew at the time. The pyramid also has some functions during the spring and fall equinoxes where it creates shapes with the shadows that are cast onto it. The other notable building is El Caracol or ‘the observatory’. This building really highlights how advanced the people who built it were as it is built with its doors and windows perfectly aligned with the movements of the Sun, stars and planets, especially Venus. The final major spot was a cenote where the Mayan people would conduct a ritual to the rain god Chaac. During this ritual, people would be thrown into the cenote along with valuables such as Gold and Jade as sacrifices. The legends of this ritual were confirmed when bones and valuables were dug up from one of the major cenotes in 1904. 

      This consists of some very helpful information that bring more life to this place. What would help in painting more details such as sources that outline and signify what these buildings bring to the city than tourist attractions. If there is more information on the legends of the city, it would be stronger with sources that not only outline their origins and practices, but as well as what the impact of these practices had on the people.

    4. Chichen Itza is an old Mesoamerican city that was built by the Mayan people in the year 600 and then was expanded upon by the Toltec people in the year 900. It is around 16 square kilometers in size. Eventually by the year 1200 Chichen Itza was slowly abandoned due to mostly unknown reasons all though there are some reasons that could be viable. Overall Chichen Itza is a larger city in south western Mexico in the Yucatan Peninsula. It was one of the greatest Mayan cities and was a large economic hub all throughout the Americas which was proven by the different forms of silks as well as currencies that have been excavated from the city.

      An insightful introduction that gives the reader an idea of Chichen Itza, as well as estimate of its size and foundation. Although the reasons for its abandonment are unknown, it would be better if there were sources that could justify them. As well as those that make it 'viable' as well.

    1. In his 1520 Prelude on the Babylonian Captivity of the Church, Luther examined the validity of the seven sacraments as they were practiced by the Roman Catholic church.[4] When one of the sacraments, the communion, was performed in the church, the priests would consume both the wine and the bread; believed to become the blood and body of Christ through a process conducted by priests called Transubstantiation. The common folk were only permitted to consume the bread, further emphasizing that the priests were closer to the divine than the rest of the Christians and should be afforded special privileges. Luther argued that all believers should be able to partake in communion of both kinds. He also countered popular belief by arguing that the bread and wine became the body and blood of Christ not due to intervention by priests but because of God’s will.4   It was these beliefs that undermined the authority of the clergy and set the stage for the Reformation to occur and spread throughout Western Europe, inciting events and changes that still impact our lives in the 21st century.

      This closes the struggle well as it underlines the very struggles that the people were facing, and in doing so, links to what Luther was outlining in his Thesis. Overall, the report is detailed and utilizes the sources appropriately. The structure would need some adjusting as Luther acts as a surrogate for us to understand both cause and effect of the Catholic church's acts.

    2. The Reformation was a movement within Western Christianity that questioned papal authority and the Catholic belief of redemption through good deeds, confession, and penance.1 The reformation began with Martin Luther’s posting of the 95 theses, a doctrine that outlined Luther’s disagreement with the Catholic practice of selling indulgences.[3] Selling indulgences was a practice in which members of the clergy would accept payment in exchange for the promise of forgiveness for sins. Martin Luther argued in his 95 theses that not only was this practice corrupting the church, it was also indicative of a larger problem.3 Luther believed that it was impossible to guarantee forgiveness from sins and that the only thing that could grant salvation was the grace of God. This was in contrast to the prevailing belief at the time. Importantly, this belief that only God himself could grant salvation took away from the papal authority that had been established in the church. If priests could not grant pardons or influence God’s will, there was less reason for reverence. Luther’s ideas continued to attack papal authority after his 95 theses.

      Incredibly detailed and defined! The description not only outlines what the Reformation was, but as well as touch on its acts and consequences. In addition, it also provides a goal that whoever questioned the Catholic church and its practices was aiming to achieve. It would be of greater detail to elaborate on who Martin Luther was and why he was detrimental to this cause to add a deeper layer to understanding his theses.

    3. The Protestant Reformation took place in the 16th century. Although it is generally agreed that the reformation officially begun when Martin Luther openly questioned the authority of the clergy by posting his 95 theses on October 31, 1517, Luther was not the first to express disagreement with the acts of the Catholic church at the time.[1] Historic opinion of what can be considered the ending of the reformation varies. The earliest possible ending can be placed in 1555 with the Peace of Augsburg that officially ended the religious struggle between Roman Catholicism and Lutheranism. The latest ending is thought to be the end of the 30 years war.[2]

      This is a really insightful introduction to the historical struggle of the Protestant Reformation. It highlights the different opinions and origins of the Protestant Reformation. However, I would suggest that the topic is introduced with what exactly the historical event is. That way, the reader can better follow along and give context to the various reasons for its origins.