11 Matching Annotations
  1. Apr 2024
    1. VIAF: The Virtual International Authority File is an OCLC-run database that contains structured records–called “name authority files”–for individual authors and creators. We used VIAF to gather information on authors whose novels were included on the list, including their birth and death dates, nationalities, genders, and occupations.

      It would be cool to link to Toni Morrison's actual VIAF record

    2. Comparing the average points of movement between the top 500 and 3 other ranking lists, we can see that the novels moved the least when compared to the number of holdings ranking (45 pts). Novels were 2x more likely to move positions when compared to the number of editions ranking (82 pts) and 3x more likely to move when compared to GoodReads rankings (137 pts).

      Maybe do a quick deep dive on one or two novels that changed a lot?

    3. Above are the top 10 authors and the number of times they appear. John Grisham appears a stunning 19 times!

      It would probably be good to have the text before the output

    4. author gender and name.

      Maybe good to re-emphasize that gender info comes from VIAF?

    5. Itt

      typo

    6. may have been released in hundreds or thousands of editions since its initial publication.

      Maybe include how many editions are reported by OCLC according to your data here? Or is that too complicated at this point?

    7. A key issue in literary studies is which

      Should there be a verb or something here?

    8. To start, what is a novel?

      Seems really useful for students

    9. We wondered about the implications of this claim and more broadly about what it means to base ideas of “literary greatness” on the number of libraries that hold a particular work. How do historical biases in systems of literary production, preservation, and circulation figure into these kinds of claims? And how do we even define what counts as a novel?

      So great! I love this framing

    10. most widely held in libraries

      as of 2019? might be good to root to a time period since the list changes

  2. Mar 2024