not only can such freedom be granted without prejudice to the public peace, but also, that without such freedom, piety cannot flourish nor the public peace be secure.
holland an example of free speech
not only can such freedom be granted without prejudice to the public peace, but also, that without such freedom, piety cannot flourish nor the public peace be secure.
holland an example of free speech
How many evils spring from luxury, envy, avarice, drunkenness, and the like, yet these are tolerated
some things are tolerated now because they cannot be legally enforced... more would come of preventing speech
but what question was ever settled so wisely that no abuses could possibly spring therefrom?
no such thing as a solution with no problems
men would daily be thinking one thing and saying another”—a practice that will weave deceit and hypocrisy into the social fabric, thereby permitting “the avaricious, the flatterers, and other numskulls” to rise to the top.
only puts unfit in rule
disastrous results
what would disasterous result be
he “justly cedes the right of free action, though not of free reason.”
government can control action not reason/thought
Unlike many earlier defenders of toleration, he did not exclude atheists, Jews, Catholics, and the like.
so long as your conduct is good, you may believe whatevr
The sovereign’s obligation to respect the liberty of his subjects is solely a matter of self-interest; to mistreat subjects is bound to generate resentment and possibly seditious tendencies, and those sentiments, in turn, will render the sovereign’s authority less secure than it would otherwise be
mistreating subjects will make them less likely to trust you and thus give you less power?
Obedience, not knowledge, is the “sole object” of revelation, and even here revelation is needed only when dealing with the dull-witted masses.
speaking on revelation isnt actually giving it credit
he natural light of reason, for those skilled in its use, is sufficient to show us “the true way of salvation.”
reason can have the same use as religion
vulgar” popularization of freethought as a greater threat to the religious and political status quo
more accessible freethought=more chance the average person is influenced
there remains nothing of Genesis, but an anonymous book of stories, fable, and traditionary or invented absurdities, or downright lies.
but how do they know that moses is really a prophet? couldnt moses have too been someoene spreading lies and claiming to be a prophet
A miracle, if reported by a divinely inspired prophet, was deemed authentic;
Moses gave the pentetuch credibility
We should not begin with the assumption that the Bible is divinely inspired and then afford it special treatment when we encounter stories that we would reject in any other history. Rather, we should examine biblical accounts with the same rational objectivity and critical attitude that we would apply to any other book.
sort of confirmation bias that the bible has
f this rising generation latches onto a God whokeeps His promises to His covenant people, and calls every nationinto His drama, it will recover faith not only in Providence but inAmerica’s own capacity for scientific ingenuity, technological break-throughs, moral leadership, and public virtue.
this can be done with any religion that teaches positive virtues. writer is clearly a christian
John Adams thus wrote that the Jews had“done more to civilize men than any other nation
complete swtich of the view of jews
It persuaded Englishpoliticians, philosophers, and scientists to think of themselves andtheir choices in light of a much larger story
religion gives people purpose as it relates to them and their life
Eliminating disease and faminewould not eclipse Scripture; it would vindicate it, proving that Prov-idence intended human ingenuity to help reverse the Fall of Adam.
how does eliminating disease automatically mean human ingenuity was meant to reverse fall. couldn't it just as plausibly be other things
Ifound it boring ultimately. I found the process of reading the greatChristian thinkers, reflecting on the patterns of Christian history, andrecognizing that this is where I came from
shouldnt it be based on fact and logic. and has he studied all religions to know for certain that this one is hundreds is truly where he came from
The problem
if you are really christian, shouldnt denying original sin be a problem bc you are denying the truth not because having it conditions people to act the way you want
progressives
why is he targeting progressives here. wouldn't this apply to everyone
but feel that they areopposing Christian doctrine and therefore increasingly become hostileto Christianity itself. The fact is they are indebted to the Christianinheritance
?
Trans people are definedas the last. And that seems to impose a kind of instinctive assumptionthat the last should become the first
so supporting the oppressed he i defining as "christian terms". these are simply respectful terms
the idea that there is almost aninherent virtue within victimhood. To be oppressed is a source ofpower. It’s a very radical idea that Christianity weaponizes and hasweaponized again and again and again
how so
Christian ideas.Some are obvious: the ideas of charity or forgiveness or redemption.
i wouldn't really call this a christian idea. do they mean to say no one forgave before christianity???
a faith that becamepowerful by virtue of enshrining as its symbol someone utterlypowerless. It’s incredible.
but they claim he can perform miracles so the people know he is not powerless. in fact many people did not believe he was the son of god until he performed such miracles. so he did have to display power to gain power.
Who do theChristians think they are? They don’t have a land. They don’t have amother city.
lack of real identity
that the church is a kind of independententity.
how to balance church and state
third century, the Roman Empire goes through aterrible time—barbarian invasions, galloping inflation. So whenConstantine comes to power, he is looking for a religion that can bindeveryone within the empire
bring the poor and the rich together
authority that even your pagan neighbors might come torespect.
respectable authority at a heirarchical time
conclude that it has been fashioned, not mechanically, but by divine and supernatural skill
never understood this because there are so many things wrong with the human body, why would god make something imperfect
Theologians attribute what we don’t presently understand, or what science has failed to explain, to God
looking for an explanation that we cannot find because nature is so complex.
John Toland
coined pantheist
deist
god is creator but does not interfere with natural affairs
all of nature is inherently perfect
why does he think this?
reality and perfection I use as synonymous terms
why?
ompelled to undergo infinite variations.
?
God is of all things the cause immanent
God is in everything?
declined to have it published because of the outrage it would almost certainly provoke
why did he care. isn't that what a philosopher wants, or would he be punished
secularizing modern man
acceptance of atheism
position might compromise his intellectual independence
what would taking that position limit him from doing? would there be some things he cant say/do?
heretical
opposed to what is generally accepted, contrary to orthodox religious doctrine
I am wiser than this man; it is likely that neitherof us knows anything worthwhile, but he thinks he knows somethingwhen he does not, whereas when I do not know, neither do I think I know;so I am likely to be wiser than he to this small extent, that I do not thinkI know what I do not know.
?
from their two differing bloods, if it maintains a balance
reminds me of heraclitus
First of all gods she contrived Love
if what-is has to be one whole, indivisible thing, and he mentions there being multiple gods, wouldn't that mean that God is what-is-not (not real)?
bulk of a well-rounded sphere
what-is is metaphorically a sphere
what-is, since precisely this is what Fate
what-is is left to fate
what-is is ungenerated and imperishable,whole, unique, steadfast, and complete.
always existed, one thing
But gaze upon things which although absent are securely present tothe mind
?
For thinking and being are the same
then wouldn't everything that exists be what-is?
for you cannot know what is not (for it cannot be accomplished)nor can you declare it.
you don't know what-is-not
If all things share a commonquality, that quality will not have a name
but do we need to have all qualities?
To become wise we must learn to use the senses with insight or intelligence
what is the right way to use senses?
nstead of recognizing that asingle truth is present everywhere
what is it
It is death for souls to become wet.
is this why he uses fire for the universe?
To God all things are beautiful and good and just, but humans havesupposed some unjust and others just
nothing is really bad?
hey [people in general] would not have known the name of justice ifthese things [unjust things] did not exist
problem of evil argument, virtues
The most beautiful kosmos is a pile of things poured out at random
even the universe at whole is both intricate and random
is common to all
what is that?
Things taken together are whole and not whole, <something that is>being brought together and brought apart, in tune and out of tune; out ofall things there comes a unity and out of a unity all things.
opposing forces =unity
ct in accordance with nature
how
Those who seek gold dig up much earth but find little
?
all
all people or all things? do objects "think" under logos?
For the waking there is one common world, but when asleep each per-son turns away to a private one
private understanding of the universe vs. a universal principle
Theyput their trust in popular bards and take the mob for their teacher, unawarethat most people are bad, and few are good
people trust others without logic/reason
39) In Priene was born Bias, son of Teutames, whose worth (logos) is greaterthan the others
how does logos mean worth here? if it is just supposed to be the guiding principle of the universe
This Logos holds always, 3 but humans always prove unable to understandit both before hearing it and when they have first heard it
faulting human understanding of the universal logos
thank heavens you haven’t gone to yet so we can go together for the first time
share his interests with her
I would rather look at you than all the portraits in the world
her face is the only one that matters
ou look like a better happier St. Sebastian
comparing the person to a beautiful place
San Sebastian,
ive bee there.. helps me picture the scene
f the ox does not recover soon,take him to the slaughtcrhouse and dispose of him.
is he lying to make the ox work
Howfortunate youare!Jamwornoutwithtoil,while youresthereincomfort.Youcatwell-sifted barleyandJacknothing.Itisonlyoccasionallythatyour masterridesyou.Asforme,mylifeisperpetualdrudgeryattheploughandthemillstone.
jealousy
Give me in marriage to thisKing: cither I shall die and be a ransom for the daughters ofMoslems, or live and be the cause of their deliverance.’
she is trying to stop the cycle
He had expelled all criminal desires from it,and the small residue of that odious flamewhich remained in his soulrnerely made his paternal love stronger
suddenly only loves her as a father again
were blacker and even uglier,and frightened the little children
racist
grated hers like a turnip;another one cut a small piece off hers;93another one thought she could make hers smaller by pressing it down;still another, with a certain lotion,
everyone wants a chance
I am willing, as long as the womangiven to me in matrimonyis the one that this ring fits.
cinderella-esque
ccidentally slipped off her finger and fell into the dough;but those who are considered to know the secret of this storyassure us that she put it there on purpose;
adds some character to the story
but, since he thought he was viewing a goddess,three times his arm was restrained by respect
the respect that her father does not have for her
But even the least fastidious and most wretched people,seeing her so dirty and full of Hlth,refused to hear her out or to take into their housesuch a foul creature
status has changed based on appearance
The princess, marveling at that wonderful garment,was almost of a mind to consent
she is starting to be convinced
they could be assured he would hang them all
why has he gone psychotic to marry his daughter?
if you should feel tl1e desi
selfless in death
that it never deposited feces71but, instead, beautiful three-franc pieces with the sign of the sunand twenty-franc pieces of all sorts
what?
hat, at certain mornents, the nwst perfect mindcan enjoy even marionettes without blushing
the smartest, most rational people can enjoy a story
even though no mother, husband, or confessorcan find anything in it to reproach.9
does having a "pure" story make it a better one?
It is unbelievable, how avidly these innocent souls,whose inborn rectitude has not yet been corrupted in any way, take inthese concealed teachings;
young children take in stories easier
children who havedutifully obeyed their father or mother thereby become great lords,whereas other children, who were vice-ridden and disobedient, fallinto horrible misfortune.
stories teach children
helps persuade women to be patient with their husbands,showing them that there is no husband so brutal or so capricious thata respectable woman's patience cannot be a match for him
stay in abusive relationships??
The only moral to be derived from the Matron of Ephesus isthat frequently the women who seem most virtuous are really theleast and that therefore there are almost none who are truly virtuous
ancient stories teach false morals, they believe that their stories are better
peo-ple fail to see what is good for them and are more pleased to beguided by Providence than t9 have everything work out according totheir desires
morals taught through stories