4 Matching Annotations
  1. Jan 2023
    1. Data can be poisoned intentionally as well. For example, in 2021, workers at Kellogg’s were upset at their working conditions, so they agreed to go on strike, and not work until Kellogg’s agreed to improve their work conditions. Kellogg’s announced that they would hire new workers to replace the striking workers:

      Intentional data poisoning does seem reasonable in some cases- for example the Kellogg's strike that was not taken into account (on the company), was taken into account of the public. This reminds me of Tuesday's lecture on who wold benefit given a trolling situation. In this case, I think the employees would benefit, the company would get bad press because of their refusal to worker rights. So in some cases data poisioning is good.

    1. Social media platforms then use “data mining” to search through all this data to try to learn more about their users, find patterns of behavior, and in the end make more money.

      Data mining seems to work very effectively and efficiently because, ads, profiles, videos are all catered to what you seem to like. I think this might be different but data mining also reminds me of how you might be talking about something and then you see ads on google about that exact thing. This does also make me question how third parties work and how can social media sites recommmend outside sources without the consent of the user knowing their personal information is going somewhere else?

    1. Feeling Smart: Going with the gatekeeping role above, trolling can make a troll or observer feel smarter than others, since they are able to see that it is trolling while others don’t realize it. Feeling Powerful: Trolling sometimes gives trolls a feeling of empowerment when they successfully cause disruption or cause pain.** Advance and argument / make a point: Trolling is sometimes done in order to advance an argument or make a point. For example, proving that supposedly reliable news sources are gullible by getting them to repeat an absurd gross story.

      Trolling and authenticity I feel are similar but not the same, I think trolling is probably one of the many reasons why the internet can be kind of a horrible place because when people do things like be a troll, they don't face as much repercussions and if they do get backlash thats what makes them feel more better so it's almost like the best thing to do is ignore/not give attention.

    1. While trolling can be done for many reasons, some trolling communities take on a sort of nihilistic philosophy: it doesn’t matter if something is true or not, it doesn’t matter if people get hurt, the only thing that might matters is if you can provoke a reaction.

      While reading this chapter I did think that some of the ethics frameworks would not see a huge ethical issue with trolling, I think that most troll accounts do view what they are doing as nilihism- that it doesn't matter and if you evoke a large negative reaction its good. I also found it not surprising that with this framework people (who troll) will only defend their group which is often all very bad social groups (misogynists, racist groups, violence etc.)