aboriginal, or subaltern, or preliterate, or non‐Western women made sense of their gendered pasts when they had not shared Western categories for organizing experience
relate to postcolonial movement as a subsection of intersectionality
aboriginal, or subaltern, or preliterate, or non‐Western women made sense of their gendered pasts when they had not shared Western categories for organizing experience
relate to postcolonial movement as a subsection of intersectionality
Judith Butler wondered if being female constituted a ‘natural fact’ or ‘cultural performance’.
reference while talking about diff ideas of masculinity and femininity - this shows questioning of WHY associations are perpetuated
enabling of relational analysis and its applicability to discourses, institutions, and abstractions,
add to definition of gender history
making women relevant to historians of other subjects.
purpose of gender history
women assumed responsibilities ‘outside’ the home as breadwinners, house builders, skilled artisans, spiritual leaders, and heads of state
therefore separate spheres idea too rigid, western centric
The presumption that men and women occupied dichotomous spheres was helpful for organizing women’s experience and explaining their perpetually lower status. But the model was rigid, leaving little room to imagine women as anything but victims of patriarchal forces.
example of difference between women and gender histories = patriarchal equilibriums still show women as victims rather than agents
no theoretical accounting for why more women appeared in some realms of activity than others, and why those realms continued to relegate women to secondary status. How were gender hierarchies constructed in the first place, and how did they change over time? It was not enough to trace women’s subjection in the past.
relate to patriarchal equilibriums
masculinist prescriptions of historical practice
this is an issue of women's history that gender history sought to correct
Rigorous history
use this phrasing somewhere
Literate women of the middle and upper classes had long written diaries, journals, and personal correspondence and maintained family relics and keepsakes. Monarchs, professionals, and social reformers revealed themselves readily, while illiterate and labouring women proved to have little time or inclination to save papers.
use this as criticism of women's history - link to history from below
‘contribution history’
cite this
The first British women’s history courses emerged through History Workshop—a vehicle of new social history growing steadily feminist in its aims.13
acknowledge this in history workshop section
anti‐war, civil rights, black power, New Left, Maoist, and countercultural movements, they were inspired to reorient their research both in content and perspective
add to history from below section
official, written documents; but few of these sources provided insight into the agency of women, since most women, as yet, had no legal status as property holders or political beings
link to history from below
bscured women’s longstanding relationship to the historical enterprise—not just as historians but also as subjects of history.
left out of history writing since it became professionalised in the 19th/20th
unscholarly, unhistorical, and off limits to legitimate scholars.
misogyny
rise of gender history cannot be extricated from the story of women’s history
helpful for end of first section