11 Matching Annotations
  1. Feb 2020
    1. When they entered the city of Jerusalem celebrating the superstitious idolatry of the Holy Fire, they reflected on Jesus' lament over the city for killing its prophets and continuing in ignorance and squalor. Thus, they reflected that the New Israel of God's chosen people was needed to breathe new life into the land and its people. For the ancient prom-ises of salvation and light had come full circle, where the citizens of the New Zion had come to rescue the ancient Zion and its people. American cultural and religious perspectives supported the belief that American Christians had a specific role to play in God's story.

      Because Christianity has at its core a sort of anti-authoritarian sentiment (Jesus always being portrayed as at odds with the religious and political authorities of His day), I wonder whether American evangelicals, themselves possessing significant political and religious authority, had to cast the the Near East as "Bible Lands" so as to infuse them with the notion of Biblical Authority, and give to Evangelical missionaries a "false" religious authority to define themselves against.

  2. Jan 2020
    1. er, the presumed equiva- lence of Eastern homosexuality and occidental personal liberation may disguise the specter of colo- nial privilege and exploitation encoded in the hier- archy white man/brown

      The exploitation of underage boys for the "personal liberation" of Europeans which Boone describes mirrors the way Said describes the West using the Orient to construct its own identity.

    1. umph of the imperial gaze, its life is also stamped by sadness. Its exis-tence is cruelly brief. It is devalued, disposable, unimportant, and kitsch. It is frequently indistinguishable from its siblings on the rack. Its pro-ducers prefer not to be associated with its production. It is neither a real gift nor a full letter. It is quick, "abundant, systematic and cheap," and it has a marginal standing within the archive.38

      It's interesting that culture deemed "feminine" is so readily dismissed as "low" culture.

    2. een European and Indian notions of womanhood, which are defined in part through their relation to each other and through their gendered interaction with the patriarchal public sphere.

      Like Mohanty's article from last week, Mathur lifts up the importance of attending to the way in which colonialism adds different dimensions to gendered relations.

    1. Beginning from the lives and interests of marginalized communities ofwomen, I am able to access and make the workings of power visible—toread up the ladder of privilege. It is more necessary to look up-ward—colonized peoples must know themselves and the colonizer. Thisparticular marginalized location makes the politics of knowledge and thepower investments that go along with it visible so that we can then engagein work to transform the use and abuse of power.

      Mohanty argues that knowledge of the "workings of power" can only be gained from a specific epistemic viewpoint- that of the marginalized.

    2. n other words, this discussion allows me to reemphasizethe way that differences are never just “differences.” In knowing differencesand particularities, we can better see the connections and commonalitiesbecause no border or boundary is ever complete or rigidly determining.The challenge is to see how differences allow us to explain the connectionsand border crossings better and more accurately, how specifying differenceallows us to theorize universal concerns more fully. It is this intellectualmove that allows for my concern for women of different communities andidentities to build coalitions and solidarities across borders.

      Summarizes what Mohanty hopes to accomplish in this "revisiting"

    1. ch scholarship on Christianity in a global context asserts that women's status in society improves over the course of Christianization; although that may be true in India in a qualified way, I have observed as well a tendency toward a restrictive form of femininity

      Might this assertion about the improvements in women's status be a result of orientalist constructions of the "average third world woman" (Under Western Eyes, 65)?

    2. ow-caste Indian women had long been discouraged or prohibited from adopting the practices that connoted modesty and femininity in the hegemonic gender discourse of the region. Upwardly mobile Indian Christian commu-nities tended to appropriate practices from both elite Indian and Western sources related to marriage, labor, clothing, child rearing, and so forth that privileged women's enclosure over mobility, self-restraint over spontaneity, and self-denial over self-indulgence, producing a form of femininity that, from a present-day feminist outlook, appears more restrictive than liberating.

      This seems to be a good example of paying attention to the varieties of political contexts that Mohanty encourages.

    1. philosophical life in which the critique of what we are is at one and the same time the historical analysis of the limits imposed on us and an experiment with the possibility of going beyond them [ de leur franchissement possible]

      While Foucault suggests that we are shaped by the limits that our social-political context impose on us, he remains optimistic about the possibility of transcending them by experimenting within them. This reminds me of the interplay of habitus and improvisation in Pierre Bourdieu's thought, where habitus is the set of rules inscribed in a person by their social location, and improvisation is the use of those rules in a way that at once obeys and restructures them.

    2. Hegel

      Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831), a German philosopher belonging to the continental tradition, is a key figure in German idealism. He is best known for his articulation of absolute idealism, which seeks to overcome dualisms (such as that between subject and object) to gain knowledge of absolute being, which Hegel calls Geist (spirit). This process of overcoming dualisms is called sublation, and is credited by many as the origin of the thesis/antithesis/synthesis triad. Hegel is also well known for the master-slave dialectic, a passage from Phenomenology of Spirit which narrates the emergence of self-consciousness between two distinct beings. This dialectic, and the concept of sublation, would later influence Karl Marx's development of dialectical materialism.