60 Matching Annotations
  1. Apr 2022
    1. Gramsci,

      Antonio Francesco Gramsci was an Italian Marxist philosopher, journalist, linguist, writer, and politician. He wrote on philosophy, political theory, sociology, history, and linguistics. He was a founding member and one-time leader of the Communist Party of Italy.

    2. For every concept there is both a not-concept and an anti-concept.

      this is extremely interesting and completely correct. even though utopias aren't all good, they are better than current society, whereas dystopia is worse. However, not everyones utopia is the same, whereas everyones dystopia is similar

    3. This would imply that dystopia is some kind of call for revolutionary change.

      it might also be a warning against political revolution. What if the people you entrust to fix your country turns out to be like the authority figures in these dystopian books.

    4. however bad our present moment is, it’s nowhere near as bad as the ones these poor characters are suffering through.

      I feel like if we're continuously barraged with dystopias and situations that are extremely oppressive and traumatic, we will become complacent with the problems in our current society because of this mentality of "at least it's not this bad."

    5. surrealism

      (n.) cultural movement that developed in Europe in the aftermath of World War I in which artists depicted unnerving, illogical scenes and developed techniques to allow the unconscious mind to express itself

    6. fear

      this is a huge aspect of all the dystopian stories we've talked about and heard of. The people subjected to the horrors of society are usually living in a state of constant fear/paranoia. like the lower party members in 1984, the poor in The Purge, the people under Rudy in Brown Girl in the Ring.

    7. portrays some future that might actually come to pass; it’s a kind of proleptic realism. The other lens presents a metaphorical vision of our current moment,

      how are these different ? what does it mean by metaphorical vision ?

    8. Plato

      Plato was a Greek philosopher born in Athens during the Classical period in Ancient Greece. He founded the Platonist school of thought and the Academy, the first institution of higher learning in the Western world.

    9. lot of dystopias around these days,

      this reminds me of that cinematic era between 2012-2015 where every dystopian, young adult book was made into a movie and it was always about the government being corrupt like in Hunger Games or Divergent.

  2. Feb 2022
    1. In this war of every man against every man nothing canbe unjus

      why does he think this? just because you have a reason for doing something, doesn't mean you shouldn't be held responsible or that what you did was moral. also just/unjust and right/wrong are two different things, though they go hand in hand. without laws, there is no right and wrong. however, justness is based on morals, not on laws, therefore in a lawless society, there can still be justice and injustice

    2. ustice and injustice are not among the faculties [here= ‘natural capacities’] of the body or of the mind

      i agree. you aren't born with a sense of right and wrong. your morals develop from the world and people around you, therefore if you are alone, you won't have them and you don't necessarily need them

    3. Nor are actions that come from thosepassions

      i agree with him that those thoughts and desires are not inherently sinful. however, if they act on those thoughts, if they affect someone else negatively, are sinful, even if there are no laws in place.

    4. what constitutes war is not actual fighting but a knowndisposition to fight during a time when there is no assuranceto the contrary

      this connects to 1984. the war wasn't actually real. they're were a few bombs that dropped and their was some fighting on the front lines and important bases, but for the most part it was just the idea of war to keep the citizens controlled

    5. .

      this sounds like a whole lot of excuses to be violent and terrible people. Justifies destroying another person's life because of jealousy (competition), greed (distrust), and arrogance (glory).

    6. That is why men don’t get pleasure (and indeed do get muchgrief) from being in the company of other men

      i think men (whoever he is talking about) are way too focused on what others think of them. people's opinion of someone or whether they value that person or not, should not mean anything to that person at the end of the day. they're letting someone else control their life

    7. his increase in a man’s power over othersought to be allowed to him, as it is necessary to his surviva

      he only talks of conquest and violence instead of alliances and peace. he believes the only way of survival is to dominate others instead of working together

    8. Some people take pleasurein contemplating their own power in the acts of conquest

      whats this mean? like they're getting off on thinking of the power they can gain from conquest or they're getting off on the power they already have?

    9. For ordinarily there is no greater signthat something is equally distributed than that every man iscontented with his share

      i disagree with this as well. if you've had something all your life, you will be content with it if you've never known any difference, especially if you're not able to properly gauge what everyone else has.

    10. most men think they have more of than the commonherd

      its funny how many people think they're opinion matters more since they believe themselves to be smarter. they think themselves superior to others

    11. a natural faculty

      is he saying that we aren't born with the natural ability to do science? the simplest form of science is just observation, statement, and reasoning. why wouldn't we be able to do that?

    12. As for •the faculties of the mind: I find that men are evenmore equal in these than they are in bodily strength

      i disagree with this. there are some really stupid people. and just like strength can change, so can your mind.

    1. It would be so much easier, for us,if there appeared on the world scene somebody saying

      this is what a lot of people say about racism and homophobia. some prefer people using confederate flags and wearing clothes with discriminatory and offensive language because then they know who to stay away from. it's harder when they look like just another person on the street

    2. populism

      (n.) a political approach that strives to appeal to ordinary people who feel that their concerns are disregarded by established elite groups

    3. disdain for women and intolerance and condemnation of nonstandard sexual

      appearance of a contradiction. hates women but hates homosexuality. hates women but hates chastity

    4. But sucha "final solution" implies a further era of peace, a Golden Age, which contradicts theprinciple of permanent war.

      like in 1984, it's revealed that the "war" is not really a war and is just a way of keeping the citizens in each state under control. there will never be an end to the war but they encourage patriotism and hatred of the enemy to foster hope that there will be

    5. For Ur-Fascism there is no struggle for life but, rather, life is lived for struggle

      you see this a lot, actually. When something bad happens to someone or they are struggling, instead of giving help, others tell them "that's just life". instead of changing the way life is, they just accept that that is life.

    6. the only ones who can provide an identity to the nation are itsenemies

      they instill the fear of being different in people to unite everyone against a common enemy and make it easier to pick them out, killing two birds with one stone.

    7. appeal to a frustrated middle class, aclass suffering from an economic crisis or feelings of political humiliation, and frightenedby the pressure of lower social groups

      that's why you see so many states the claim to be "communist" are actually fascist. they appeal to the middle class or the working class to gain power, but once they grab that power they don't deliver

    8. No syncretistic faith can withstand analytical criticism

      just as he said before, syncretism comes with contradictions so if the faith is analyzed, the logic will break down

    9. Traditionalism

      the theory that all moral and religious truth comes from divine revelation passed on by tradition, human reason being incapable of attaining it

    10. Wittgenstein's

      Austrian-British philosopher who worked primarily in logic, the philosophy of mathematics, the philosophy of mind, and the philosophy of language. He is considered to be one of the greatest philosophers of the modern era.

    11. Gramsci was put in prison untilhis death; the opposition leaders Giacomo Matteotti and the brothers Rosselli wereassassinated; the free press was abolished, the labor unions were dismantled, and politicaldissenters were confined on remote islands

      sounds like what the ministry of love did in 1984 to keep in power

    12. It was Italian fascismthat convinced many European liberal leaders that the new regime was carrying outinteresting social reform, and that it was providing a mildly revolutionary alternative tothe Communist threat.

      ironic how leaders thought this fascism would combat communism, however a decade late, they had to ally themselves with communist russia to fight this new fascism.

    13. Mussolini did not have any philosophy: hehad only rhetoric. He was a militant atheist at the beginning and later signed theConvention with the Church and welcomed the bishops who blessed the Fascist pennants

      he did whatever he had to do to get more support and power

    14. late-Hegelian

      hegelianism (n.): the philosophy of G. W. F. Hegel, important German idealist and philosopher, in which reality has a conceptual structure

    15. Italian fascism was certainly a dictatorship, but it was not totally totalitarian

      Dictatorship concerns the source of the governing power (a single person has all the power) and totalitarianism concerns the scope of the governing power (what is the government and how extensive is its power).

    16. Why wasan expression like fascist pig used by American radicals thirty years later to refer to a copwho did not approve of their smoking habits

      people always want to emphasize their "oppression" by comparing and/or connecting it to atrocious events in the past

    17. rhetoric

      (n.) language designed to have a persuasive or impressive effect on its audience, but often regarded as lacking in sincerity or meaningful content

    18. If reconciliation means compassion and respect for all those who fought their own war ingood faith, to forgive does not mean to forget.

      I also want to put that forgiveness doesn't always mean reconciliation. just because u have forgiven someone, doesn't mean you have to restore the relationship or forget what they did

    19. moral and psychological meaning of the Resistanc

      just the act of resisting made them feel better than just doing nothing, even if they made a true impact or not. they needed to survive and this gave them a reason too

    20. realized what we were liberated from

      germany did an a amazing job at hiding the true atrocities jews face during the holocaust until after they had lost

    21. ace gave me a curious sensation. I had beentold that permanent warfare was the normal condition for a young Italian.

      this would be so disconcerting. your whole life you live a certain way and then it's changed quite suddenly

    22. And thatwas it

      what do you even say after you've lost thousands of people in a war and the future of your country is uncertain? World War II was the most devastating war to happen at that time. Everyone was just so exhausted

    23. Should we die for the glory ofMussolini and the immortal destiny of Italy?

      thats a horrifying question to be asking a 10-yr-old. Even more horrifying is what was punishment they went through if their answer wasn't positive, if they weren't smart like eco?

    24. voluntary, compulsory competition for young Italian Fascists

      Compulsory: obligatory voluntary: of your own volition the contradiction between voluntary and compulsory is similar to that of 1984. They try and make it seem like its your choice, but if you get punished for not doing it, then is it really a choice?