2 Matching Annotations
  1. Mar 2024
    1. Raskolnikov would have sworn to God that he winkedat him, devil knew why.

      This moment also stuck out to me. Part of Dostoevsky's genius here is to extend the uncertainty of the situation as long as humanly possible, and Porfiry Petrovich is his conduit for doing so. Just before the supposed wink, the narrator recounts that Petrovich "suddenly looked at (Raskolnikov) somehow with obvious mockery." The word "somehow" implies the anguish Raskolnikov is experiencing for lack of knowing for certain what Porfiry is actually aware of with regard to the crime. This contributes to the ever tightening grip of suspense which is built up simultaneiously as Raskolnikov descends into madness.

  2. Feb 2024
    1. Don Quixote's moral code arises from a narcissistic pursuit kleos based on the outdated notion of chivalry. Here, Don Quixote assumes that the farmer will abide by his orders because of an outdated notion of knightly chivalry. However, as soon as Don Quixote leaves, the farmer continues abusing Andres–even intensifying it to spite Don Quixote. This shows that simply abiding by a moral system, individually, doesn't mean that others follow that system which makes Don Quixote's pursuit of justice futile seeing as people will just continue their previous behavior as soon as Don Quixote leaves. This is an example of Don Quixote's narcissism since he believes that everyone abides by knightly chivalry just because he does, and he assumes that his influence is so strong that others will automatically abide by his instructions out of fear. However, that moral system is not compatible with the society Don Quixote lives in, and his reputation is simply not large enough to force compliance with his orders, as shown with this farmer.

      I totally agree. My reading of DQ so far is that his misunderstanding of the situations he finds himself in, be they hallucinations or poor judgement, reflect a greater personification of attitudes toward shifts in European societal structures and the almost melancholy undertones of change. Don Quixote is at once an individualist and someone seeking public recognition. However nuclear his views, he propounds a far simpler perspective that is no doubt appealing to men who feel their only outlet of power is to gain kleos through physical prowess and courtly love.