TheEburnean Orogeny is associated with significant gold mineralisation involcanic, volcano-sedimentary and sedimentary rocks of the BirimianSupergroup
you can see this on the map in Maya's draft
TheEburnean Orogeny is associated with significant gold mineralisation involcanic, volcano-sedimentary and sedimentary rocks of the BirimianSupergroup
you can see this on the map in Maya's draft
thousands of steps.
!!!
carbonatites and alkaline rocks
Can we get some average analyses of these rocks to compare with average rhyolite or average basalt?
Dysprosium is also critical to high performance
Why this particular metal?
saturation magnetization
what is this?
phosphors
?
La acts as a hydrogen absorber in rechargeable batteries
I'd like to understand more about how batteries work
recent advances made separation economically feasible
how are they separated from each other?
ontological
really? geographers!
mining underwriting documents and juxtaposing financial logics with actual income, expenses and tenant turnover draws our attention back to the fact of property as bricks and mortar.
"space" vs. space
mining underwriting documents of CMBS
item 3
space
using the word as a synonym for markets; somewhat inappropriate in a discussion of real estate, i.e. real physical space
Building Indicator Project and the overleveraged property database
items 1 and 2...
data-driven tactics contribute facts to “the war of ideas”.
and this is what I hope to see in your research
extractive
akin to mining, i.e. removal of finite resources
The role of critical narratives in contesting financialization speaks to how rhetorical framing strategies can work to challenge the “discursive naturalization” of market logic, and chart alternatives
Don't let your enemy control the vocabulary of discourse
tightened credit markets led to Dawnay Day’s closure amidst insolvency in 2008,
Yay!
This tactic illustrates the group’s understanding that East Harlem’s housing problems and displacement are intimately bound up in flows of global capital, and the ways financial actors can mobilize these flows in service of real estate development
this reminds me of the national recognition and participation in Native American protests against pipeline construction
7Finally, some activists reworked spaces of finance through building solidarities in the tracks of global capital flows
God, I hate this language! Reminds me of grad school!
tenant associations held press conferences in front of buildings, posted signs to investors saying “don’t buy here” and “speculators keep out” in their windows (insert figure 3 about here), and conducted guided tours of deteriorated building conditions for politicians and the press
activism at its best--making a difference where you live
Based on these data, each unit faced a discrepancy of $605 per month; across all 9876 units this makes for a shortfall of $6 million a month and $71.7 million a year (insert table 2 about here). Data on tenant turnover assumptions is less readily available, but in three major portfolios, underwriting was based on assumptions that 20-30% of units would turn over within a year of purchase—actual turnover rates in rent-stabilized apartments range from 5-10% a year
hard numbers here for concept expressed in general terms earlier
re-inscribed hidden links between property as a distressed asset and property as distressed housing
setting up the conundrum, how can housing be de-linked from financial products?
CHPC’s analysis showed that buildings within 500 feet of overleveraged properties are more likely to be physically deteriorated and have more housing code violations; those within 250 feet are more likely to have serious housing code violations requiring emergency repair intervention by the city
blight really does creep
Covering over 50,000 housing units owned by investors engaging in irresponsible real estate practices, it is the best measure of a phenomenon that is difficult to measure
always fun to measure things that are hard to measure!
A score of 800 or more “warrants examination to confirm probable physical and/or financial distress”
one example of the difference between strategic positivism and critical narratives
Speculators have been unjustifiably raising their estimates for how much rent they will take in after they buy the property and low-ball how much maintenance costs will be in order to get a larger mortgage from the bank. The larger the loan, the larger the fees the bank can take in, and then, similar to a subprime loan, the bank securitizes the mortgage on the secondary market”
puts in it everyday language
For example, the New York City Council created the Predatory Equity Task Force, describing the problem as community organizations did
political success of the narrative
Community organizations see the activist community as “extraordinarily successful in creating this term ‘predatory equity’ and really getting it out there to policymakers, the politicians and the press
"critical narrative" "alternative knowledge" overlap here?
fallout of boom time speculation on the quality and supply of affordable rental housing.
alternative narrative
private equity distressed debt market has evolved from a concept to a global investment market since the early 1990s
somewhat understated exposure of the perversity of financialization. even distressed debt becomes a product with buyers and sellers.
negative social externalities
owners are imposing social costs, e.g. dislocation, on others
ystematic harassment
disgusting
The profit expectations and debt load associated with predatory equity deals were predicated on rates of tenant turnover in the range of 20% or more a year, whereas the typical turnover rate for rent-stabilized units is 5-10% a year
people must be kicked out of their homes for the new owners to reach their investment goals
the encroachment of the financial into the non-financial: the city’s affordable rental sector has largely been a “financial backwater” (ANHD, 2009b, p. 8) because of the non-liquid nature of the assets, which return moderate profits of 7-8% a year taken as income (not capital gains). This encourages long-term ownership, making for a low-pressure market
i.e. a stable, less volatile form of investment, with clear benefits to tenants and owners
Under these terms, the deals could only succeed by displacing tenants paying affordable rents and cutting back on maintenance costs.
Of course.
uxury decontrol, without an inflation adjustment, “has morphed into an automatic deregulation machine,liberating units whenever strong demand pushes rents high enough” (
clearly, an unindexed rent cap for decontrol favors landlords
Furthermore, such high-risk lending practices intersected with older frameworks of racial inequality
as so often happens. see today's (3/17) Times article about evictions
rather than anchoring wealth in place via property, today mortgages facilitate global investment and the extraction of value from place-bound property
note "extraction of value." reminds me of "rent-seeking," described by Sitglitz and others
ith the extended reach of finance also comes the transmission of risk and volatility into the non-financial, participating in and potentially exacerbating already uneven geographies
bit obscure, along with preceding text, but clear that risk has been transferred to commodities that arguably should not be subject to it, e.g. housing, health care, at least not with the associated high volatility (instability of pricing)
hus to the production of urban space
wonder what this means. lots of urban space is already "produced," isn't it?
Countertopographies trace contour lines that analytically connect geographically distinct places (such as the dynamics of dispossession linking informal settlements of the Global South with urban neighborhoods in the U.S., “and thereby enhance struggles in the name of common interests”
the writer comes through on "countertopographies"
These narratives might serve as place frames (D. Martin, 2003) that respectively mobilize residents and make claims on elected officials, define and build community within a neighborhood and promote collective action across neighborhood boundaries.
it's important to have a story to sell a political position. see Democrats now trying to "spin" the big spending bill just enacted.
Strategic positivism recognizes that research is always political, and thus represents an important aspect of working toward urban social justice.
thanks for partially defining strategic positivism
via postmodern sensibilities of multiple meanings
the sentence would have been clearer without this phrase
understandings of community organizations as taking up multiple roles, producing alternative forms of knowledge and engaging in new spatial strategies.
3 parts to "practice"
more politicized approaches might focus on decommodifying land and housing
intriguing. how could this be done?
However this period was short-lived as federal policy shifted in the late 1960s from direct support of local political organizing to providing funding to cities and states for community economic development
the era of "block grants."
(efforts to improve living conditions and quality of life)
this sounds like work that would be accomplished at the "district" level of neighborhoods
alternative knowledge production and reimagined modes of spatial practice
very curious to hear what the latter are
how these changes have transformed the meaning and significance of mortgage capital in local communities, redrawing the relationship between housing and urban inequality
would be nice to hear what exactly the transformations are, rather than simply that they have occurred.
counter-topography
this seems to be a term coined by the author. nothing turns up in a google search.
topology
the way in which constituent parts are interrelated or arranged. this is a second, non-geometry-related meaning.
financialization
Financialization (or financialisation in British English) is a term sometimes used to describe the development of financial capitalism during the period from 1980 to present, in which debt-to-equity ratios increased and financial services accounted for an increasing share of national income relative to other sectors. Wikipedia
neoliberal
Neoliberalism or neo-liberalism is the 20th-century resurgence of 19th-century ideas associated with economic liberalism and free-market capitalism. It is generally associated with policies of economic liberalization, including privatization, deregulation, globalization, free trade, austerity and reductions in government spending in order to increase the role of the private sector in the economy and society; Wikipedia
discursive
wonder what this is. text should illuminate. suppose it means "talking to people."
deep energy retrofi t strategies
what is this? followed up, got link to energiesprong, a European program. Retrofits existing buildings to be net zero energy consumers (they generate whatever energy they require.)
holistic energy performance,
what's this?
New York City’s per capita emissions are now 5.8 MtCO2e per person, which is just over one-third of the American average of 17 MtCO2e per capita
demonstrating the per capita efficiency of urban residence
To achieve our 80 x 50 commitment, citywide emissions from all sources will need to be reduced by 44.5 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (MtCO2e) from a 2005 baseline by 2050 – or more than the total annual GHG emissions produced by the entire state of Connecticut
Wow.
MOS works to minimize NYC's contributions to climate change from the waste, transportation, energy, and building sectors
Mayor's office of sustainability
City will study and develop implementation plan for carbon trading by Jan. 1, 2021
did this happen?
Limits from 2030-2034 are set to affect the most carbon-intensive 75 percent of buildings, with 25 percent under the cap,
can't understand. Ask Dick to explain the graph.
FIGURE 3
weird graph! best understood by reading along the x axis from right to left.
URBAN GREEN’S
who, what is urban green? how is it funded?
Millions of metric tons of CO2e b
note these staggering units
Strong advisory board
what makes it strong?
some affordable housing to choose low-cost energy-saving
insulation, e.g.?
enewable energy credits and/or
how do these work?
than 25,000 square feet
my 6 story prewar apt. bldg with 52 units I estimate is 2.5X this size
No extensive areas of this sort are found. Part of the answer might lie in the generation of new continental material at a rate equivalent to eruption of new water.
continents are presumed to be growing in modern lit
Gravity measurements during the past half century have shown that the concept of isostasy is valid—in other words that a balance does exist.
george, can you explain this?
hile this would remove three of my most serious difficulties in dealing with the evolution of ocean basins, I hesitate to accept this easy way out. First of all, it is philosophically rather un- satisfying, in much the same way as were the older hypotheses of continental drift, in that there is no apparent mechanism within the Earth to cause a sudden (and exponential according to Carey) increase in the radius of the Earth. Second, it requires the addition of an enormous amount of water to the sea in just the right amount to maintain the axiomatic relationship between sea level-land surface and depth to the M discontinuity under continents, which is discussed
Does the speculation of expansion, which sounds so implausible to me today, have anything to do with the lack of space exploration at the time? Why wasn't expansion excluded on the basis of uniformitarianism?
islands.
all of the previous estimation shows that neither radiometric nor magnetic reversal dates were available at the time of Hess' writing.
‘The seismic velocity of layer 3 is highly variable; it ranges from 6.0 to 6.9 km/sec and averages near 6.7 km/sec, which would represent peridotite 70 per cent serpen-
what about the classic description of ophiolites with the sequence pillow lavas, sheeted dikes, gabbro, peridotite?
The oceanic column is in isostatic equilibrium with the continental column. The upper surface of continents approaches equilibrium with sea level by erosion. It is thus axiomatic that the thickness of continents is dependent on the depth of the oceans.
Why axiomatic? Explicate, someone.
his could possibly be recognizable in the difference of tectonic pattern in very old terrains as compared to present continental structure.
I gather that our assumptions about Precambrian continents are based on geochemistry. I think I recall that Condie determined they were thicker, not thinner, than continents tody.
M discontinuity under continents vs. depth
depth to the Moho is a regular function of sea level
The relationship between depth of the oceans, sea level, and the depth to the M discontinuity under continents is an axiomatic one and is a potent tool in reasoning about the past history of the Earth’s surface and crust.
I could use some explication
If we multiply these various quantities, the volume of water leaving the mantle each year can be estimated at 0.4 km%.
can anybody reproduce this arithmetic?
this supplies the reason for uniform thick-
the 500 degree isotherm can't exist below 5 km depth
The topographic rise of the ridge must be attributed to the fact that a rising column of a mantle convection cell is warmed and hence less dense than normal or descending columns.
The expansion of the mantle carries the ocean floor upward with it.
Where are the Paleozoic and Precambrian mid-ocean ridges, or did the development of such features begin rather recently in the Earth’s history?
we expect he will say they have been eroded or subducted
Looking over the reported data on rates of sedimentation in the deep sea, rates somewhere between 2 cm and 5 mm/1000 yrs seem to be indicated.
useful factoid
he mid-ocean ridges could represent the traces of the rising limbs of convection cells, while the circum-Pacific belt of deformation and volcanism represents descending limbs.
the pattern is complete now
This could be most easily accomplished by a convecting mantle system which involves actual movement of the Earth’s surface passively riding on the upper part of the convecting cell.
an unobservable phenomenon, mantle convection, invoked to explain observable movement of continents, deduced from paleomagnetic data.
Remanent magnetism of old rocks shows that position of the magnetic poles has changed in a rather regular manner with time,
apparent polar wander
analyzed the spheri- cal harmonics of the Earth’s topography up to the thirty-first order.
???
Nevertheless, mantle convection is con- sidered a radical hypothesis not widely accepted by geologists and geophysicists.
and this is making me wonder how best to present the reasons why it is accepted today.
layer of uniform thickness could be formed would be if its bottom represented a present or past isotherm, at which temperature and pressure a reaction occurred.
not clear why he is emphasizing the uniform thickness of layer 3
So we shall assume that the other half was extruded during the catastrophe.
50% of continental landmass created in the "great catastrophe."
not sufficient to produce a molten Earth.
I need to check this out because my lecture emphasizes melting as the cause of differentiation, not whole Earth convection
gravitational energy into thermal energy
Dr Science, please explain. Is this because of friction?
primordial single continent (
is this covering the entire surface?
uniformitarian approach;
"the present is the key to the past," as they present it in textbooks. Lyell's formulation was more precise, wherein past events discernible in the geologic past could be explained by causes at work in the present time.
suggests an age for all the ocean floor of not more than several times 108 years.
100,000,000 My. Oldest Atlantic crust is ~200 Ma; little bit of Tethyan crust somehow still left in the Mediterranean, maybe ~280 Ma?
hydration of mantle material starting at a level 5 km below the sea floor.
not having seen ocean floor volcanism yet?
asymmetry.
continental vs oceanic crust
The early stage encompassed precipitation of sulfides, silica and/or circulation of highly acidic metal-rich hydrothermal solutions through faulted carbonate blocks. Dissolution and intensive oxidation of primary sulfides, Fe+2 and Mn+2 in oxic and supergenetic conditions resulted in the formation of polymetallic oxides that represent the late stage
So oxides are secondary.
Fe-Mn-Zn oxides, forming a stratiform and strata-bound ore bodies in the lower unit of the succession
these are the ones of interest
magnesite bed
evaporite?
rystal-chemicalparameter
not sure I want to know what these are~
β-factors are higher when the Zn-first neighbor bondlengths is smaller and charges on atoms involved in the bonding arehigher and vice versa
smaller bond lengths causes higher beta factors causing higher alphas (big deltas--fractionation factors)
.Infact,willemitemayhaveformedduring a hydrothermal event (Brugger et al., 2003)
think I read this in first batch of papers sent by William. Gives evidence for primary formation of willemite.
Hercynian orogeny
or Variscan, corresponds to Alleghenian (300 Ma)
Other experi-mentsonisotopefractionationassociatedwithsorptiononFe-andMn-oxyhydroxides (e.g.Balistrieri et al., 2008;Bryan et al., 2015;Juillotetal.,2008;Pokrovskyetal.,2005)haveshownthatheavyZnisotopesare preferentially adsorbed, generating a positive ∆66Zn between theadsorbing phase and the solution
This could be relevant to SH.
affinity constant
?
The main mechanisms causing Zn isotope fractionation at the Earth'ssurfaceareequilibriumisotopedistributionbetweendissolvedaqueousspecies (e.g. organic complexes) and equilibrium and kinetic effectscaused by interactions between solids and aqueous solutions (e.g.sorption, precipitation).
Ignoring melting
n terrestrialgeologicalsamples(i.e. sediments,igneous rocks and ores), δ66Zn values are clustered around +0.5‰,rangingfromca.−0.5‰to+2.5‰(
Was not aware of this very high positive limit-check source.
Strong negative isotopic shifts are almost only observed forlate crystallizing phases, such as those in vugs
Rayleigh effect
artialdissolutionofprimarysphaleriteisfollowedby precipitation of an initial secondary phase that preferentially incorporates heavy Zn isotopes
but most fractionation is positive in the oxides
(willemite - Zn2SiO4, smithsonite - ZnCO3, hemimorphite -Zn4(Si2O7)(OH)2·H2O,hydrozincite-Zn5(CO3)2(OH)6,andsauconite-Na0.3Zn3(Si,Al)4O10(OH)2·4H2O)
Smithsonite can't be primary at SH-see Peck? and/or Johnson and Skinner
Harland et al. (1990).
worth a brief glance
backstripping analysis
look this up Dong
intermediate and intermediate—felsic
arc-like? (subduction related)
neritic
near-shore or continental shelf
7000 m of clastic sediments
clastic means pieces of broken rock
Late Permian to late Tertiary
Write down this range in years.
polycyclic
usually means cycles of sea level rise and fall (transgression and regression) but something else in this case. Let's find out what.
Why no sand or boulders? Is it because of the softness of the underlying phyllite?
remobilization of the REEs by DIR-induced dissolution of Fe(III) oxyhydroxides produced the positive Eu anomalies and high Sm/Nd ratios that are characteristic of the low-εNd and -δ56Fe component
starting to make some sense
Export of Fe to the deep basin by a microbial Fe shuttle occurred at least initially through aqueous Fe(II) generated by DIR
The "export" or "shuttle" must be accomplished by currents
Oxidation of riverine Fe(II) could have occurred through either oxygenic photosynthesis or Fe(II)-oxidizing, anoxygenic phototrophs
Previous question answered
In the coastal region, Fe was sourced to continental runoff, and oxidation of aqueous Fe(II) produced Fe(III) oxyhydroxides that settled in a proximal continental shelf setting.
What is causing oxidation in an anoxic environment?
Importantly, Eu is preferentially mobilized during microbial diagenesis in marine sediments, producing positive Eu anomalies in pore fluids relative to bulk sediments (32, 40) and implying that the positive Eu anomaly may not be a unique indicator for a hydrothermal source for BIFs as previously thought
Yep, me included
Given the difficulty in producing the low-εNd and -δ56Fe end member through precipitation from a hydrothermal plume and direct oxidation of dissolved riverine runoffs, a process is required to actively pump low-δ56Fe Fe(II)aq into the Archean oceans from continental sources.
Here comes the pump!
The εNd–δ56Fe variations indicate that the continentally sourced Fe has near-zero to negative δ56Fe values down to −0.8‰, whereas the mantle/hydrothermally sourced Fe has slightly to strongly positive δ56Fe values.
Continental and mantle Fe isotopic signatures are distinct
The relative slopes of εNd–δ56Fe variations (Fig. 2) are a function of the partition coefficients (Kd) for the REEs in iron oxides (28, 29) as well as the contrast in Nd-isotope compositions of the hydrothermal plume relative to the ambient ocean that had a continental Nd-isotope signature
Thick comment, not sure I get it.
The key question, however, is whether there was coupling between Nd and Fe or whether there was two end-member mixing for Fe as well;
Occam's razor suggests coupling
The large range in εNd-values suggests mixing between a low-εNd continental source and a high-εNd mantle source for the REEs
ok
The observed εNd–Sm/Nd trend suggests mixing between an end member that has low εNd-values and high Sm/Nd, reflecting microbial iron cycling of continentally derived sediments, and an end member that has high εNd-values and low Sm/Nd, reflecting partial oxidation of hydrothermal fluids
Need to know more about Sm/Nd ratios as environmental signatures
finest scale banding (microbands) reflects annual or varve-like bands
an old idea, explaining the banding in BIF. Wonder if they talk about silica in this paper?
Overall, there is a broad positive correlation between the δ56Fe and εNd-values
Interesting. This is why?
Measured Fe- and Nd-isotope compositions reveal a large variation in both isotope systems: from −0.83‰ to +1.30‰ in δ56Fe and −2.2 to +3.0 in εNd
Results
The Dales Gorge member is ∼160- to 140-m thick
pretty damn thick!
leads us to a dual-source model for Fe in BIFs, including a hydrothermal component that has mantle-like Fe- and Nd-isotope signatures and a continental component that contains crustal Nd and isotopically light Fe derived from microbial iron shuttle.
Hoping to hear more about what this iron shuttle is
Difficulties in models that invoke partial oxidation of hydrothermal Fe(II) include the fact that only small quantities of Fe that has low-δ56Fe values are produced by such a process, which is problematic for explaining Fe-rich rocks, such as BIFs.
If there are large volumes of low delta 56 Fe BIF, oxidation is probably not the fractionating mechanism
More recent work, particularly the combination of Nd isotopes and REEs, suggests a more complex origin for REEs in BIFs, where a significant component is sourced to the continents
they will expand on this; don't need to check the reference now
Moreover, the Vancouver Island area accounts for a significant portion of local fishingand aquaculture.
Repetitious.
most fertile
Here and in many other places, citations are needed.
Indigenous
Logical leap. Paragraph needed
ideally cold winters,mild and rainy winters.
Incomprehensible. Winters cannot be ideally cold in one phrase, mild in the next.
The climate
An almost non-sequitor, or awkward flow at least. If Vancouver Island has Canada's mildest weather, is the climate truly variable?
Could be useful OER for science forward
Rich website with many offers to read more and link at the end to "Soil Biology Primer."
Read it. Who knew??
ydrologists, geomorphologists, biogeochemists, ecologists, and climatologists
what's wrong with geologists?!
topographically controlled groundwater systems
means what?
deep groundwater, recharged infirst‐order catchments, sub-sidizesflows to their parent watersheds
Huh? Does this mean that downstream groundwater recharges upstream areas?
mountainous regions
what about mountains makes groundwater reservoirs deeper?
Pleistocene meteoric recharge
wonder how this was determined, maybe delta 18O?
tritium
1/2 life is 12.5 years
three inches of mould had been prepared by the worms in the course of fifteen years
0.2"/yr
whole operation is due to the digestive process of the com-mon earth-worm.
Aha!
eparate in so short a time the fine from the coarse earth,
? Is there coarse earth on the surface?
fine particles of earth mixed with decayed vegetable matter
OK, a definition of vegetable mould
vegetable mould two inches and a hal
perhaps topsoil would be a better translation of vegetable mould?
burnt marl
historical substitute for lime, when rock crushing was not done at industrial scale
About three years ago cinders also had been spread on this field ; but when I examined it, they were buried at the depth of one inch
Further attesting to growth of soil from the bottom up.
At two inches and a half be-neath this, or about three from the surface, a layer of lime, or a row of small aggregated lumps of it, formed a well-marked white line around the holes.
Therefore 2.5" of soil had accumulated above the lime.
vegetable mould
presume he's referring to the O layer in soil?
For sheep, he says, learning how to effectively exploit their environment takes around 50 to 60 years. Moose need closer to a century.
If they are translocated and have no guidance, some random wandering that produces a worthwhile memory is exploited the next year. If the individual survives, it can train new members of the herd.
found that the whales favor areas with unusually low year-to-year variation
amazing
were strongly correlated with 10-year historical averages of chlorophyll.
whales as databases
measuring the concentrations of chlorophyll in different patches of ocean.
and at least say where the whales should go if they want food
licy. Most important, it is seldom realized that a pivotal goal is slowing the evolution of resistance and that, without this, all successful pest and disease control strate- gies are temp
Da-dam. Stop the pesticide and antibiotic arms race.
d, in every new case, human-mediated evolution tends to catch us by surprise, and strategies to reduce or stop it are invented from scratch. For example, cyclic selection has been invented at least three times (for control of insects, bacteria, and HIV), IPM at least three times (insects, weeds, and bacte- ria), and drug ove
are we approaching COVID-19 the same way? Can we explore some of the research directions underway?
ns, greatly re- ducing the number of offspring homozygous for the resistance allel
explicate?
69). If farmers plant a fraction of a field with non-toxin-producing crop varieties, and allow these to be con- sumed by insects, a large number of nonre- sistant pests are produc
Whoa! Let the bugs eat non-engineered plants so they can't develop resistance to the toxin, then let them mate with toxin-resistant bugs, reducing the possibility for inheriting resistance in offspring.
). Slow evolution can come from two sources. First, the multiple control mea- sures used in IPM reduce reliance on chem- ical treatments, thereby reducing selection for chemical resistance. Second, physical control of populations (e.g. through baiting, trapping, washing, or weeding) reduces the size of the population that is exposed to chemical con- trol. Smaller populations have a reduced chance of harboring a mutation, thereby slowing the evol
less use of chemicals means less ability for targets to adapt; physical reduction of populations does the same.
) do not use the same herbicide 2 years in a row on the same field, and (ii) when switching herbicides, use a new one that has a different mechanism of a
change what you use
). Similarly, farmers are advised to check their fields after pesticide treatment and then to change the chemical used in the next spraying if many resistant individuals are discover
make sure your treatment works
Screening for resistance before treatm
know your bug before you treat it
ing the most powerful drugs. The
limit use, limits ability of germs to adapt
t-obse
talk about low tech! make sure people take their medecine.
their use is limited by drug toxicity: ategies, often extreme doses can have physiological or eco- gh a combina- system side effec
the downside-side effects
e evolution of resistance. The evolutionary acluded in this biology hidden in this strategy is simple: a of HIV evolu- strong, multiple-drug dose leaves no virus able to reproduce, and so there is no geneti- in the United cally based variation in fitness among the or these exam- infecting viruses in this overwhelming drug exceeds $100 environment. Without fitness variation, there social price of is no e
strategy 1-drug overkill
Independent of their theoreti nings, the following exampl successful methods often sl for clear evolutionary reasi these approaches may be
OK, let's see what he's got teed up.
Thus, evolution expands the cl; that are medically manageable cally incurable.
poignant
s, evolution sparks an arms race be- tween human chemical control and pest or disease agent, dramatically increasing costs that are eventually paid by consumers (7, 11). For example, the new drugs linezolid and quinupristin-dalfopristin were recently approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Ad- ministration (FDA) for use on vancomycin- resistant infections (48). Previously, vanco- mycin had been used to overcome methi- cillin resistance (10), and methicillin was itself a response to the failure of penicillin treatment (13). This development cascade (Fig. 2
development cascade, arms race, various analogies for hopelessness of winning the battle
These efforts effectively increase the rate of generation of new traits-akin to in- creasing the rate of macromuta
Genetic engineering obviously shows human effect on evolution. Later comment about no widespread escape of engineered gene to the wild seems outdated. Canadian case where Monsanto sued farmer.
Partial treatment of infections with subopti- mal doses leads to partial control of the in- fecting cell population and creates a superb environment for the evolution of resistant bacter
we're vaccinating pathogens against our treatments
(30, 31). Rates of human- mediated evolutionary change sometimes ex- ceed rates of natural evolution by orders of magnitud
another interesting reference
ecies introduced by humans induce evolution in species around them
cascading evolution
6). The virus that causes AIDS, human immunodeficiency vi- rus-1, evolves so quickly that the infection within a single person becomes a quasi-spe- cies consisting of thousands of evolutionary variants (1
another reference worth following up
The Pace of Human-Induced Evolution
Now we get to the proofs
ce. The importance of human-induced evolutionary change can be measured economical
Still seems to be taking human-caused evolutionary change for granted, no need to demonstrate cause/effect
2). Some insects are tolerant of so many different insecticides that chemical control is usele
would be interesting to find out which
. Slowing and controlling arms races in disease and pest management have been successful in diverse ecological and economic s
Is it here? Ecology improves if we stop fighting pests?
ms. Such changes are apparent in antibiotic and human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) resis- tance to drugs, plant and insect resistance to pesticides, rapid changes in invasive species, life-history change in commercial fisheries, and pest adaptation to biological engineering produc
where will causality be shown?
we showed here that sucha cost actually occurs and leads to a rapid selection agains
again, i'm confused. Perhaps it's the use of the word cost? They've showed that C. sanctis has evolved in fragmented populations to produce more non-dispersing seeds. Are they defining cost as the relative preference for these seeds, the R factor?
First, dispersal ability was not estimated in the field butin a common greenhouse, which allows us to interpret popula-tion differentiation as the result of directional genetic selectionin fragmented patches.
Pretty cool experiment
The Breeder’s equation,Rh2S
simple model
qualitatively consisten
maybe this is acknowledgement of the logical leap?
Fig. 1.
demonstrates that propensity to create non-dispersing seeds is higher in fragmented populations
Given that suitable habitats are scarce in urban environ-ments (1% of the total area), this experiment demonstratesthat the cost of dispersal is high in urban fragmented popula-tions, compared with large unfragmented populations
Is there a logical leap or do I just not understand? Non-dispersing seeds are way more likely to stay on their patch than dispersing seeds. Dispersing seeds are likely to die, true. But how does experiment show this? Experiment shows that more dispersing than non-dispersing seeds exist in the patch.
To test this hypothesis, we first quantified the cost of dispersalin urban populations by using artificial patches mimicking urbanpatches. Second, we measured population differentiation fordispersal ability (R-ratio) in a greenhouse and showed a reduceddispersal rate in urban patchy populations. Last, we used quan-titative genetic modeling tools to validate the scenario of short-term reduction of dispersal caused by the cost of dispersal inurban patchy populations.
satisfying their criteria for proof, commented on above
R-ratio
First model input
trees on the sidewalk in the city of Montpellier (South ofFrance),
You can see a picture here: https://www.livescience.com/2341-cities-force-plants-evolve.html
allogamous
requires cross-pollination, male to female
An unequivocal demonstration
How can we prove that dispersal cost really drives selection?