31 Matching Annotations
  1. Nov 2017
    1. Whatever her view here, the nar-ratological “I” has a rhetorical power that depends upon the ability to select the best point of view from which to view an object or scene, to move freely enough within that scene to effect ironic distance and sympathetic access, and to exploit the wisdom that both nature and art provide.

      Austen shifts points of view to give her readers the opportunity to view something from the best/most appropriate perspective. This is similar to how a deserving viewer of the picturesque shifts viewpoints to see the scene in the best way

    2. She has abilities, however, as well as affections; and it is now a doubtful point whether his cunning, or hers, may finally carry the day.

      This is in Mrs. Clay's point of view

    3. regime of the picture.

      This is the second one, "regime of the picture." We already discussed the regime of the eye. The viewer sees or recognized a style/genre/etc, and that recognition gives the viewer something to identify with. What the viewer sees is not the thing itself, but the larger genre or movement that the scene recalls

    4. he novel commences with Sir Walter’s limited per-spective in order to satirize it, and both he and the book that monopolizes his attention are presented to us from a distance.

      Narrator includes info here that will get readers to get to know and dislike Sir Walter and Elizabeth

    5. Anne sees, feels, and reflects upon the growing regard mirrored in Wentworth’s twice-mentioned glance, and the result is a change in the way she sees herself

      Anne views herself as an object that Wentworth sees (regime of the eye) and uses his image of her to recall the old Anne that he loved (regime of the picture)

    6. The comparative modifiers highlight the self-ratifying nature of their views as well as their habitual framing of the environment, for the objects that claim their attention are only those associated with fashionable society

      The point of view in the description of Camden Place is Sir Elliot's. We know this by the objects that are pointed out, and the modifiers used since they make Elliot justify himself as an important figure

    7. -ated through a kind of pulsation between the regimes of the eye and the picture...allowing for visual recognitionof and identificationwith the object(s) in sight

      This is how sentimental looking functions

    8. Identified in the previous section as the perspective that guides our view of Lyme

      This is what Austen is doing by combining the regime of the eye and the regime of the picture. I think this point needs to be made sooner.

    9. the eye allows for an education that occurs in the act of looking itself,

      In the regime of the picture, the act of viewing itself is what opens the door for the viewer

    10. esituating the Gilpinian practices known to Austen, then by exploring how late eighteenth-century habits of visual perception are reflected in the characters’ views and movements, and, finally, by considering how those habits may have shaped the writer’s narrative practices

      Outlines the rest of the paper. I find this to be super helpful. I think there's a lot going on in the first half of this article and it has been sometimes hard to follow. Many working parts go into making up this argument. It may just be me, but I feel that the article could have been stronger if it was less ambition and instead spend more time explaining some of the concepts it discusses. Unless one is familiar with all of these concepts, the article can be rather difficult.

    11. I would like to argue that Austen’s strangely felt presence in the Lyme landscape is a function of the “sentimental look” with which she regards it

      Transition - Tegan sees Austen's presence in this passage as a good thing as it is a function of the sentimental look that is in the passage

    12. one may become rather unnerved by this glimpse of Austen—a sentimental “stranger

      If it is indeed Austen speaking in this passage, it is uncharacteristic from other parts in the novel because the voice is much more authoritative

    13. indeed, the only charac-ter who has warranted such trust thus far is Anne

      The narrative here then is in Anne's point of view, though it can be attributed to the entire group if the reader lacks the insight to arrive at this conclusion

    14. The next thing to be done was unquestionably to walk directly down to the sea

      This statement lacks an agent. It does not come from any one character but seems to show the desires of the group as a whole. This gives the narrator additional authority

    15. the perspectives of character and commentator are traversed quite freely in Austen’s work through focalization and free indirect style

      We've discussed this. Austen shifts points of view so often that it takes a careful reader to know who is really speaking

    16. Thus, the “deserving” picturesque viewer is one who also moves about freely, shifting his or her point of view as necessity, or art, demands.

      The narrator in Persuasion is a picturesque viewer and helps readers to become picturesque viewers by shifting point of view

    17. the tourist, wandering through unimproved country must both delight in its unspoiled condition and at the same time de-vote considerable effort to identifying the right viewpoint from which the land-scape may become Picturesque:

      Viewers must work to find the right viewpoint (point of view) for getting the most out of the landscape

    18. instruct these aliens on how best to see, appreciate, and horde up in memory a fleeting acquaintance with a scene that is not their own

      Austen uses Gilpin's instructions to guide her readers, allowing them to best view the landscape

    19. the writer could be recon-structing from memory a landscape she visited as much as eleven years earlier. Or, she may have had a sketch of Lyme in her possession as she wrote

      Speculation on Austen's inspiration while writing the Lyme passage

    20. Gilpin’s writings on picturesque travel and sketching were well known to the author,

      Establishes credibility. The footnotes include evidence that Austen knew Gilpin's works

    21. he shifts the emphasis from the content of the visual field to the techniques and practices of aesthetic appreciation

      de Bolla says it's not so much what is being seen but rather how it is being seen -> this ties back into Austen's narrative techniques and the point of view in the Lyme passage

    22. I will draw considerably upon the popular-ized picturesque theory of Reverend William Gilpin, as well as art historian Peter de Bolla’s The Education of the Eye: Painting, Landscape, and Architecture in Eighteenth-Century Britain

      Tegan's argument will be informed by these works

    23. This essay therefore seeks to italicize Austen’s persuasive use of focalization and free indirect discourse in Persuasion by considering the various spectatorial stances eighteenth-century seers might take, and what those stances suggest about knowledge, cultural authority, and feeling.

      Thesis

    24. attending closely to the techniques by which Austen authorizes certain points of view illuminates how the narrative’s form enacts its thematic content

      This is Tegan's end game. Examining the landscape representation in the passage about Lyme in reference to point of view shows us the persuasive power of Austen's form

    25. ewer arguments have explored the relationship be-tween landscape representation and narrative point of view

      Tegan will diverge from the norm by exploring how landscape representation and point of view are related. She's filling a gap in scholarship on the way landscape representation is viewed

    26. Critics considering the scenic element have focused largely on its role in developing character or advancing plot, high-lighting how it allows characters to demonstrate their aesthetic sensibility (or lack thereof), to expand their self-awareness and agency, and to test new dra-matic possibilities.

      This is how most critics view the role of scenic description. Perhaps Tegan is setting her article up to diverge from this?