6 Matching Annotations
  1. Sep 2022
    1. It is toward an elucidation ofthose metaphors, and a liberation from them, that Idedicate this inquiry

      I do not agree with this. Sometimes truth is too hard to accept as is. And hard truths can be better digested through metaphors. It allows people to understand something that scares them. Now this is not to say that I believe we should conceal the truth, but an experience of illness or cancer could be better explained through metaphors. It can allow other individuals to better understand illness and accept it as a fact of life. So as long as you do not create any misconceptions through metaphors, I do not see why they are a bad thing.

    2. The metaphors attached to TB and tocancer imply living processes of a particularly resonantand horrid kind.Throughout most of their history, the metaphoricuses of TB and cancer crisscross and overlap. The Ox-ford English Dictionary records "consumption" in useas a synonym for pulmonary tuberculosis as early as1398.* (John of Trevisa: "Whan the blode is madethynne, soo folowyth consumpcyon and wastyng.")But the pre-modern understanding of cancer also in-* Godefroy's Dictionnaire de Vancienne langue frangaise citesBernard de Gordon's Fratiqum (1495): "Tisis, c'est ung ulcere dupolmon qui consume tout le corp"

      Why are people more afraid of illnesses like Cancer and TB.

    3. there is nothing shameful about aheart attack.

      I don't really agree with this. I think it is shameful especially if you are a younger individual. People try to explain it as 'drugs' or 'unhealthy diet'.

    4. Any disease that is treated asa mystery and acutely enough feared will be felt to bemorally, if not literally, contagious

      Perhaps because of years of evolution the human brain learnt to avoid people who look different/ ill as a matter of survival. Maybe in the next couple of thousands of years of further evolution with the knowledge of medicine we could adapt to a stage where we do not fear those who are ill (or those who are different).

    5. Kafka's description of his TB as "thegerm of death itself

      Kafka has also done similarly in 'metamorphosis' where he shows the struggle of clearly mental illness through the unpleasantness of a cockroach. When George (I believe that was his name) wakes up to find out he has turned into a cockroach and further indicating that the cockroach is a metaphor we see the alienation from his family. They are afraid to get close to him and George slowly feels less and less like himself.