Throughout the paper text, add comments with specific critiques and takeaways from the paper. Some questions to consider: What is the gap in the literature? Are there related papers not included? Did you learn something useful from the way the problem was framed? What is the research question and how novel is it? Is the overall research design appropriate for the research questions? Are there specific limitations in the methods? What important assumptions are embedded in the results? What results did you find informative or surprising? Are there sections of text you think the authors didn't present clearly? Is each conclusion supported by the analysis? How do the key takeaways change the state-of-the-art in this field? What follow on studies would you like to see?

No highlighting without annotations, please!

Put comments with overall strengths, weaknesses, and takeaways in the abstract